← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8999/2017allowed

Hari Chand v. Panchayat Mohalla Soodan

2018-08-03Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu19 pages



           

  !"  "#$%$&' ( 

  )$* &+  "!$!$&") ,--  &#* . !* // -+ & "%0&+"&!

 ' 1 2- -3 2

 



         

-3 2 5   

 



!" #$%



& 

!" #'%  

" 

" * % +" 

"

, #&$$

 -)  

.

/ 0 

 '

!" #1%  #  



!" #$% "  0) )





0"

 



 3

!" #1%

7   

   "

 -)  

.

/  8 

 "

) 



 8  )   0 09

)  

) 0

"

) 

"

 8  " :

  ;

 



 8  )   0 

) " 09

)  

"

)

) 0 "

) "

<  "



" :

  ; 0 " 

( 

" 

" * % +" 

  

"   

8 " =" 4   

" "  



                        

                           

       

    

     !"!

 #$          %&&'#&%(           

        

      )* <  8   '

!" #1% 



" 8 

   8 "  $1

 

"

 (

"

  

( " "

 ) 0 

 "   )



" 8 3"   "0 ) > 

 

!" #$% ( )  3



 3  0 ) 



0

? "  

   8  )



  8 "

" 3

 0) ;

0    

 8 " 

0) )

3    

  (  +3 







? " 



  

 



   "0  

 0  $   ("   )    

 "0 3  3)  

   

? "      " 8 )     (    

  )     "0 3) 

  3   0 3  8

? 0  (9 " ) (   

) 

("    8 "  $1

  93 ) 

   

?  !" #1%

8 ) 

  

   3

   )    )     "0   3 



  

 

 

;

>   

!" #1% 0    

"

"    3

    

 !" #1%   "   " "  $1

   

& 

!" #'% 4 

!" #$%

& 

!" #'%

0"





"

 0  (     

" 3 0)    =" 0



 

"   ) " 3 



 " 00 " 6  " *

  1,"+ )7 %*-* )8 9%2 #*8$ * &+-* )8 1

($9$/:)! %"%6;51-* 8<: :!! =) 9% -* 7!$ =)  &+)%1

( 2;(51>% )</"+.=2!+,%>% &+$  ="&#.9!2!+1 ;(

 "/*$

51 %*? &$ &)+:#!% 9!2!+>-,%>%@)$%* &) +")%1

 26(  "  0) 3   0 

 (9 "0 

0"  0)

;

" " 

( "

?

" 

 3

 ( 

" ) "

0



2"      (   "

  2"   "  

 " ?

&    "    

    



?

   "(0   "  

'

0 )



" 8 (

"

  8 <

0"

 

 " "(2     '

8       "  # " ="   "0 )

  (

"0  " " -$ 7



     ) # < 

  ! 3

 (2



3"  ) (



   0

  #) A

0)       # )

0)       " 0  ) )    "  /

<    



 

(2



3"  ) ?  "     0) 

 

 "

"

3" 

.3 



 (2



3" 

)  (  <  ! 

"    0

" (2



3"  ) "

"

3"  <   "

 

 # +,    )             )           

    )    

   - +,    )                     +, )   . +,  

      +,    )  

 

       )  ) 

)               "0

,"&7 ! :<<$ * $+:9")%:%- *"// 00 & 

 -A;



)

3 "

   0) "   " )

 0    "   " )  3

 " =" " )  3 9  

"

6 !

,"&7 ! :<<$ * $+:1% "%

" " 

  

 

                        

     



 !" #  



     

 $  #  $  

$ !% $& # 

 

 &  $      

$    #   

  # &       '

   '!  ()       





  $    

#  $  #  !  *         $      

   

      $     

  



'

 #  

 



$  $!+ 

 

$



    $ 

  

 $!, < *



2=$%!$#% &),")%:%-*") &= * +*:) &)

-&/$&" "/ 

)

" "0

,"&7 ! :<<$ * $+:1% "%   0)  

( 

 

 3 (  

"    

0   )  30 "

 (

  "0 (  "

  (   ) 93 3 

( " )     

0 9

)  

< *

 

" 3 9   3

    0) 0  

3"  ( 02 )    " 2) 

)

 " )  0 

"

 9  "

 )

3 

 



0) 0

 



" 

6 !

2=$%!$#%1% "%

" " / 0      ) !  

   1  2$ #34 )#&&)  5             

  0             #/     #$6-0            

    ) ) !

  "  7 61   !

  "                              !

      1  6  ) $7  #&& ! 

 

   5     

       ) !

  "  

   8 99909   !"!     0  "       

   

   1      7 61    )    

 : )       

    +, )        +,  )   +,   

   "   )   5  ) 

   

  ; )

 ) "           )  

            

     

)  <   = 1   5  <  =   

)    )   )  1   5  )           )     )      

   5   )           

  

!  +, 8 99909   !"!5        

)  5  

!

  "    )     : )  !

      

!

      "     )       >  - 

   ?        "    ) 

           !           

 5  )    

      >  )   

   !    7  @ :  2

 !  +#&&&,( !!3/A70 #&&& ! & #

!  ?)1  BCC %300071+1 ,'/ 5       "          

             ) 

 

     

   

 

 

   5    ):



     !        :

)      0 !   :         



  )

  8 9909        "  

 )      )    )  

   

  :  )     !

     - 

       

   )       :                  !    )  )  5  !        

                    

      )    

  )5 !      :

      )5 !    : 

    - 

      5              



   8   99909      !"!         ) ! 7 8 99909   +, !"!

      

   )    

   

             )    )   )*!      

       )   )  ! )       )     

   ?          

      "       

  )  )

  8 99909

  !"!     ) ! 0   

       !        

      )

         ))                 )          

      5                !          6    1       )

      ?            0   "        :               

   

         )   )

  8 99909   !"!   

  "     

  8 99909   !"!    

)!  ## 4 )#&&  )   072 (3'#&&

  ) $ + 93 

*

%*? &$ &)+:#!%9! 2!+1% "%

)

" "0

,"&7 ! :<<$ * $+:1% "% 3

2=$%!$#%1% "% 

3 

( "

6 ! 0

" "  7        ! 

  

  

8 99909   !"!D7:D         ?      

8 99909   !"!    E

     )?           :   !   #/:    

  

8 99909

  !"! %:? 

:  !  

           

)   )     

? 

   )   )    

)   !    )       5 D:8 /F   -     &3&##&%#  :E       )   8 99909   !"!7

    



                   :  B               :  

   

5  



   

    - 

 )  

8 99909   !"! 38 99909   !"!  

  

                            

   )

   

)   

     )          )            )         )       

    )    

    )         )  

 

       (8 99909   !"!  )             

      ) +,     

                    ) + )         )   ,  +,     

    

))    '0          

   )  

 8 99909   !"! )  ) )    )  

       

    )           )          

   

         )

  * 1

 )

3

*

>% )</"+.=2!+1% "% >%&!")/$&7-")9$#"%9! 2!+9-*)$- &=") -/")05A;   2

5 2=$%!$#%1% "%

,"&7 ! :<<$ * $+:1% "%

     0)

0)

   0   (9 "0

0 ) (   (

0   &



3 ( "

("      (   "

 0 0 

;

+ 93  *

,"+ )7 %* -* )8 1% "% 



 0 "  "  

  0 3 0)

09 )  3 

"    0) 0   (" 0)  0

< *

,"+ )7 %*-* )8 1%  "% )

* 7 *

- 22!+9%*"

$8 / .  ):=5A    "/*$2 ?$8"% (



3 #

 



 

"   < *

 

  3 

"    0) 0 " % (%   (" 0)  0 0    0) 0 " % (% " 

"  "

     ) 3 ( )     0) 0) 0 " % (% 

.3 *

 

(  # 0 " % (%   "

( 0  "  

0  

 

& + 93 

-* 8<: :!! =) 1% "%  *

" 3

 ,"&7 ! :<<$ * $+:1% "%

2=$%!$#%1% "% 3

 )  

# 0  "

" 3

 "

="

  

    

 3 

6 !

-* 8<: :!! =) 1% "%

" " -.!*/ 

 $   $      $ 0#%  1!%!2!2 !  !*     $    $ #

( 

 #



333"3/4/ #       

# !* / &  & 

  #   

   

     $   

#   #   )      

 !/

 $&

5 #



#

$  5   #  $  !*  

  &  &





  $  !*   



$ / - !67!86--

$ #

!,

   "     " 4 

  !:)"0) $# )"

&# &),")%:%>% !:)8 ")< /9!2!+)%

  $9$/;

(

" 

$

"  "0 ) 

3" )      0

 

"



(3 00  



3) 





  )

"

< 4 

"

    *

>%&!")/$&7-")9$#"%9!2!+1% "% 

"   "

-*$9-* &7 )* +* "!#"!# 9")%:%:&$#$0 /)0) !$&  "/*$ &+!*")%5 ((-  &+ >%  )</"+.=2!+1% "%    3 0)      ! 

  0)

( 

.3

*

>%&!")/$&7-")9$#"%9!2!+1% "% ")  0)

0   ("    ( "   0)

0  '

< 4 

 "

*

 

3"  "0  

(" 0 ( " 0 "0

-*$9 -* &7 )* +* @ "%

< 4 



3  

 (  

 0 "  " )       3    ) " "  0 " 

3" ) 0"  " 3" ( 

  ) < 4 

"  "0

-*$9 @:8 )* +* 1% "%  

0)   

"   

0   ?  0

 4 

   "0

-*$9-* &7 )* +* 1% # %"%:0)   



 3 0)

" 0  

 



"   

0

  

 

-* / 

     # $

;

 $   

#       /$  $ /   





 $    !

"       /  &     



$&  / 

     

#



  /

&

 

  !* /     



   $       

'&             $      &       

#      

  #

        $             /!  + #    #  



#

$#



  !" / 

  &$   

 



 $       /!



  

  / 

   #  

' 

'

$       

   

   

!

"   &   



   

 # !"      & 



!

+ 



!9  ) 4 



   "  )

"

5 .3 4 

 9

 " "0

,"&7 ! :<<$ *  $+:1% "%  5

 2" 0  (   " *

2=$%!$#%1% "% 

& 5

5

%*? &$ &)+:#!%9!2!+1 "%  "

,"+ )7 %*-* )8 1%  "% *

    

,"&7 ! :<<$ * $+:1% "% "0

,"&7 ! :<<$ * $+:@ "%  =" ) 3 " 0)

"    0

  3 9   "



()  ) 6)

" 0  "0 " *

  2=$%!$#%1%  "%  (2

0) 



( 

 

 3 (  

"    

0   )  30 "

 (

  "0 (  "

  (   ) 93 3 

    

0 9

)  

*

" 

3 9   3

    0) 0 

3"  ( 0    " 2) 

)

 " )  0 

"

 9  "

3   0  



   )      0 93

3    )

 

 3 0 ( 0 (" 3   

0

0     =" 

 0) 0) 0

0



< *

   0) 0 

  ) !

) 3   3"  ) "  "

 (



?

 " 0)

0)   

 0 

)

"  

 ( 

#  3" 0) 

" !

)  0  

    

 3 

, )   ( 0   )  30 "

 (

  "0 ( 

 ("  0 



 "

 ( 

< 

"   



0)  0 "0    0   0 "

" 

 



"

"

3" 

<



! "  " 



<   0   

  (2



3"  ) <"

0  (  

"  )



   ( 

< *

-* 8<: :!!

=) 1%  "% 

"0

0 0)

0)  3 (  

    

 0  ) 

  0

    

) 0  ( $ %  "0

(  "



"  (   )

      " 

  8 (

  

0)  ( (   0

 

 )

   (  3

  

 0    #  

   # "  $1

  

"    

0   0 





 ()  # "" 0  =" 

  "  $1

   ) 



!" #$%   & 

!" #'% "

 ) 

  

<







.3  "

$ %  

"  3"

 

" :

 3 

(" ) 

" ) 

(  

<  





" $ %

09

  " # 0)

$ %   )

   3 0)

0)

 0 ")

"0  0

" $ % )

 

0 

(  () 

 " ) 

  "  

0 



"  3 

" "0 6  3 ( -3 2

:=:%! (5

   0% B 9 8 C8,

B ( C8,