← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1002/2002dismissed

Ranjit Singh And ANR.(Jangir Kaur-Died v. State Of Punjab

2015-03-24Mr. Justice Gopal Das Khosla9 pages

  

       

    

   

      

  

 



  

    

    

           !"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2 #,    

 

 



 



  





33 

      

 



  



   

 33 

  

  

   

  

   !!



"   #    

        $ "  % "#        

 "&



$&

"% "# 

 '

   



 " " 

" () *+'

&

& "

  

 

"

*",

"   - 

  

 # 

"

 " "*".    

"  )/!*+'

&  

"  

 

"

*"(

"    -  

 # 

"

 " "*"

(               & "

 "

"

   "    ""

   

$ "% " 

 "   

    "

"

#  " "

"



 "/0#  1 $ "

% " 

 (   !!       

  "

 ""



   "      2 " "   



 $&

"  % "3  "   "



     

 ) *  "   "   

   $ "% "



 &"

# "



 "

$&

"% "# &  ""

 

  ///, "

  &$&

"% "&  

 

  "

   0 +4)"  &  " "



$&

"

% "5 



  ""

 

 &  "6 ///,5   '

   &"

 



""

    

& "

 "

 "  "

"

#

& "



&  &"

 '

 

 ""

7" "



   &  "

 & '

 

 ""

 

 

 "



   "





 $&

"  % " 

 6

  &"



55',#(6.,-%61,#(6(#*6+(-7.65,1+56," !061(6 ,'*-7.650%1-%$-$"#-55'%%#+5#  + 8896$ 0 * ! 6%6/&1$1+)"0%-5##(#(6.-+):1$"!

6$"61+)"$"#,-+-7/%-$"#%

; 1+.6:-7!$-$"#*6$%1*-+16."-',#-7"1,,1,$#%6,:1+(#%<6'% # 7-'+("1,,1,$#%/#1+)"6+)#(-+$"#)%1..

"#655',#(:#%#7-'+(56$5"1+) "-.(-7$"#(#5#6,#(/="#%.#), !"#+!6+(!

%61,#(6+6.6%*$"# 655',#(%6+6:6=7%-*$"#1%"-',# "#%#67$#%!.#6>1+)!

6$$"# ,5#+#-7-55'%%#+5#0%-5##(#($-$"#0-.15#,$6$1-+6+(,'77#%#(,$6$#*#+$ /#7-%#$"#0-.15#

!

 6$"6  1+)"  $"#  ,-+  -7  $"#  /%-$"#%1+.6:  -7  ! 5-*0.#$#.=,'00-%$#($"#>#%,1-+-7! #6.,-,0-?#6/-'$$"#(-:%= (#*6+(#(/=$"#655',#(6+()1>#+/=!$-$"#655',#($"#(#*6+(-7 .65,1+56,"6+($"#06=*#+$-7.65/=!$-$"#655',#(6+($"# '++6$'%6.(#6$":1$+#,,#(/=$"#*-+ 8896$6/-'$ 0 * 6$$"# *6$%1*-+16."-',#-76,:1+(#%<6'%

!  % 6%6*>1%  1+)"  <.61%  5-+('5$#(  0-,$  *-%$#* #@6*1+6$1-+-+$"#(#6(/-(=-76,:1+(#%<6'%-+ 8896$ ;0 *

#7-'+(%1)-%*-%$1,0%#,#+$1+6..$"#7-'%.1*/,  ,$%1+):6,7-'+( 6%-'+($"#+#5?6+($"#,6*#:6,6$$65"#($-601#5#-75"'++1 "#%#:6, +-#@$#%+6.*6%?-76+=1+&'%=#@5#0$.1)6$'%#*6%?6%-'+($"#+#5?-7$"# (#5#6,#(  "#  .1)6$'%#  *6%?  :6, :#..  (#71+#(  *#6,'%1+)  

 5*,  1+ /%#6($"

$-/.1A'#.=#+51%5.#($"#:"-.#-7$"#7%-+$-7$"#+#5?/#$:##+ .6%=+@6+(5"1+:1$"6+1%%#)'.6%1*0%#,,1-+-7?+-$6$$"#*6,$%-1(0%-5#,, /#"1+(.#7$#6%   +%#5#10$-7$"#%#0-%$7%-*$"#5"#*156.#@6*1+#%"# -01+#($"6$$"#56',#-7(#6$":6,6,0"=@16('#$-6+$#*-%$#*"6+)1+)

!36+-&0%->#($"#/1..,@  @ 6+(@ 1,,'#( 7-%$"#0%#06%6$1-+-7)-.(&#:#..#%=6$$"#6,?1+)-7!6%6/&1$1+)"-+

  884 !8*6%&1$,0-?#6/-'$$"#,6.#-706((=/=!6%6/&1$ 1+)"$-"1*7-%$"#>6.'#-7;;3;

('%1+)$"#0#%1-(7-%*9  884 $- 3  884  !  6+(  <1,"-%# 65.-$" *#%5"6+$ /= 0%-7#,,1-+ (#0-,#($"6$!0'%5"6,#(5.-$"#,6,0#%$"#/1..,@  B$-@  B41+ $"#*-+$"-76+'6%=889 !6%*1+(#%&1$1+)"(#0-,#(-+$"#/6,1, -7$"#-%1)1+6.655-'+$/--?,$"6$!,-.(06((=:-%$"; 48

6+(    ;-+

8896+(9 889 #6.,-,0-?#6/-'$$"#6/-># 06=*#+$*6(#/="1*-+8  8896+(9  889 !6.:6+$1+)"

,0-?#6/-'$$"#0'%5"6,#-7+#:6%'$1 6%355/=!1+$"#+6*#-7 655',#( 6+&1$1+)"

!46%*1+(#%&1$1+)":6,6 -**1,,1-+)#+$ 6$"6+6'.6 #,0-?#6/-'$$"#,6.#-75%-0,/=!-+9  8847-%$"# 0%15#-7;

; 9;



"#655',#(,#$'060.#61+"1,,$6$#*#+$'+(#%#5$1-+;;

% 

$"6$"#:6,1++-5#+$/'$:6,76.,#.=1*0.156$#(1+$"1,56,# 

"#$%16. -'%$"6>1+)6(>#%$#($-$"##>1(#+5#-+%#5-%(56*# $-$"#5-+5.',1-+$"6$$"#0%-,#5'$1-+"6,#,$6/.1,"#(/#=-+(%#6,-+6/.# (-'/$$"#-77#+5#'+(#%#5$1-+;6+(83



!  6%6/&1$  1+)"  :"-  :6,  $"#  /%-$"#%  -7  $"#  (#5#6,#( 6,:1+(#%<6'%"6,56$#)-%156..=(#0-,#($"6$,'77151#+$(-:%=:6,)1>#+6$ $"#$1*#-7*6%%16)# '$6,:1+(#%<6'%:6,*6.$%#6$#(6+("6%6,,#(/= $"#655',#((#*6+(1+)*-%#(-:%= #"6,6.,-(#0-,#($"6$6,'*-7 .656,(#*6+(#(/=$"#655',#(:6,061($-"1*&',$0%1-%$-$"#-55'%%#+5#

;

!

6$"61+)"$"#,-+-7$"#/%-$"#%1+.6:-7!"6, 5-*0.#$#.=5-%%-/-%6$#($"#$#,$1*-+=-7!-+6..*6$#%16.6,0#5$,

  

"#0%-,#5'$1-+5"-,#$-#@6*1+#!36+-&$-#,$6/.1,"$"# 765$$"6$)-.(&#:#..#%=6$$"#1+,$6+5#-7!"6(/##+*6(#6+(,'00.1#( /="1* "#/1..,@  @ 6+(@ 7-%$171#,$"#,$6+(-7!3 !8 *6%&1$!6%*1+(#%&1$1+)"6+(!46%*1+(#%&1$1+)""6># ,0-?#+6/-'$$"#,6.#-706((=/=!$-$"#*&',$0%1-%$-$"#*6%%16)#-7 6,:1+(#%<6'% $1,+-$-'$-70.65#$-*#+$1-+"#%#$"6$$"#*6%%16)#"6( $6?#+0.65#-+8  8896+($"#-55'%%#+5#$--?0.65#-+ 8891$,#.7

"#0%-,#5'$1-+6.,-#,$6/.1,"#(/=#@6*1+1+)!6.:6+$1+)"$"6$6 +#:6%'$156%-7889*-(#.:6,0'%5"6,#(/=!1+$"#+6*#-7$"# 655',#( "#,61(56%:6,%#5->#%#(6$$"#1+,$6+5#-7$"#655',#( "# #>1(#+5#  -7  !  6+(  !

  1+  $"#  /65?)%-'+(  -7  $"#  6/->#  %#7#%%#( #>1(#+5#-+%#5-%(:-'.()-$-,"-:$"6$655',#(600#..6+$ 6+&1$1+)" /#1+)+-$,6$1,71#(:1$"$"#(-:%=-%1)1+6..=)1>#+/=!$-655',#(

6+&1$1+)"6$$"#$1*#-7*6%%16)#(#*6+(#(*-%#(-:%=6+(656," 6*-'+$  -7   .65  &',$  0%1-%  $-  $"#  -55'%%#+5# "#  *6.$%#6$*#+$  6+( "6%6,,*#+$*#$#(-'$$-6,:1+(#%<6'%/=$"#655',#("6>#/##+,0-?#+ $-/=!6+(!



$1,$%'#$"6$!6+(!

:#%#%#.6$#($-(#5#6,#(6,:1+(#% <6'% 6,:1+(#%<6'%:-'.(+-$"6>#5-+71(#($-6$"1%(06%$=6,%#)6%(, $"#  1..$%#6$*#+$  6+(  "6%6,,*#+$  ,"#  765#(  6$  $"#  *6$%1*-+16.  "-',#

1)"$.=,"#"6(5-+71(#($-!6+(!

6,%#)6%(,$"#(#*6+(-7(-:%= 6+($"#*6.$%#6$*#+$6+("6%6,,*#+$*#$#(-'$$-"#% "#%#7-%#$"#%#1, +-%#6,-+$-%#&#5$$"##>1(#+5#-7!6+(!

4

#6%+#(5-'+,#.600#6%1+)7-%600#..6+$ 6+&1$1+)":-'.(

4 ,'/*1$$"6$!6+(!

:-'.(+-$"6>#/##+0%#,#+$6$$"#*6$%1*-+16. "-',#-76,:1+(#%<6'%6$$"#$1*#:"#+,"#5-**1$$#(,'151(#  #7#%%1+) $-$"#*#(156.#>1(#+5#"#:-'.(,'/*1$$"6$$"#(#6$"-76,:1+(#%<6'% "6($6?#+0.65#6/-'$9"-'%,0%1-%$-$"#6..#)#(>1,1$-7!6+(! $- $"#*6$%1*-+16."-',#-76,:1+(#%<6'%   .#6%+#(((.



 '+&6/:-'.(,'/*1$$"6$$"#(#6$":-'.("6>#$6?#+0.65#0%1-%$-$"# 6%%1>6.-7!6+(!

$-$"#"-',#-7655',#( 6+&1$1+)"/'$$"#1% 0%#,#+5#6$$"#"-',#-7655',#( 6+&1$1+)"56++-$/#(-'/$#(

9

! % 6%6*>1% 1+)" <.61%:"- 5-+('5$#( 0-,$  *-%$#* #@6*1+6$1-+"6,-75-'%,#,$6$#($"6$%1)-%*-%$1,:6,0%#,#+$1+6..$"# 7-'%.1*/, "#1+>#,$1)6$1+)-771516.:"-5-+('5$#(1+A'#,$"6,6.,-+-$#( (-:+$"#765$$"6$&-1+$,-7$"#(#6(/-(=:#%#7-'+(,$177

3

1)-%*-%$1,,#$,1+$"#(#6(/-(=:1$"1+6/-'$;"-'%,  $ $6?#,6/-'$"-'%,$-,#$1+5-*0.#$#.=-+$"#(#6(/-(= !6+(!

"6(:1$+#,,#($"#/-(="6+)1+)1+$"#"-',#-7655',#( 6+&1$1+)"-+  8896$6/-'$ 0 * "#0-,$*-%$#*:6,5-+('5$#(/=!-+ $"#,6*#(6=6$6/-'$ ;0 * "#%#7-%#6,:1+(#%<6'%:-'.(+-$"6># (1#(-+ 8896$6/-'$ 0 * 1+6,*'5"6,%1)-%*-%$1,"6(/##+ 5-*0.#$#.=  ,#$  1+  $"#  (#6(  /-(=  6$  $"#  $1*#  :"#+  $"#  0-,$  *-%$#* #@6*1+6$1-+:6,5-+('5$#(:1$"1+6/-'$;C"-'%,/=!

8

$1,$%'#$"6$!6+(!

"6>#(#0-,#($"6$6$$"#$1*#:"#+ $"#=#+$#%#(1+$-$"#"-',#-7655',#( 6+&1$1+)"$"#=7-'+(6,:1+(#% <6'%"6+)1+)7%-*$"#%--76+(655',#( 6+&1$1+)"6+(6+)1%<6'% 0'..1+)(-:+$"#.#),-76,:1+(#%<6'%

9 

!6+(!

"6>##>#%=%#6,-+$-,',0#5$$"#%-.#-7$"# 655',#( $*6=/#656,#:"#%#$"#655',#(*6(#6+6$$#*0$$-%#$%1#>#$"# (#6(/-(=-76,:1+(#%<6'%:"-"6(6.%#6(=5-**1$$#(,'151(# "# #+)6)#*#+$-7$"#655',#(1+$"#0%-5#,,-7%#$%1#>1+)$"#(#6(/-(="6( /##+:%-+).=0#%5#1>#(/=!6+(!

:"-"6(#>#%=%#6,-+$-,',0#5$ $"#1%%-.# $1,$-/#+-$#($"6$!6+(!

+#>#%,$6$#($"6$6,:1+(#% <6'%:6,71)"$1+)7-%.17#:"1.#"6+)1+)6+(6$$"6$0-1+$-7$1*#$"# 655',#(*6(#6+6$$#*0$$-5-*0.#$#$"#0%-5#,,-7?1..1+)/=0'..1+)"#% .#),(-:+  "#%#7-%#$"##>1(#+5#-7!6+(!

6,%#)6%(,$"# 0%#,#+5#-7$"#655',#(6$$"#,5#+#-75%1*#$-'5"1+)$"#7##$-7$"# (#5#6,#(56++-$6$6../#(-'/$#(



$:6,,'/*1$$#(/=.#6%+#(5-'+,#.600#6%1+)7-%$"#600#..6+$ $"6$! %10$6<61,"60:"-&-1+#($"#0-.15#06%$="#6(#(/=!8 +,0#5$-%  "1>  "6*/"'  6$"  "6,  ,$6$#(  $"6$  $"#  56%  :6,  0%-('5#( 6.-+):1$"$"#655',#(-+;

889:"#%#6,!8$"#1+>#,$1)6$1+) -7715#%1+$"1,56,#"6,,$6$#($"6$655',#( 6+&1$1+)":6,6%%#,$#(-+   8896.-+):1$"$"#56%



+656%#7'.0#%',6.-7$"#6%%#,$*#*-71+($"6$$"#6%%#,$ :6,#77#5$#(-+.=-+  8896,,'/*1$$#(/=!8+,0#5$-%"1> "6*/"'6$"

"#>#%=56,#-7$"#0%-,#5'$1-+1,$"6$$"#655',#(:6, 6%%#,$#(-+  8896.-+):1$"$"#56%56++-$/#%#&#5$#(-+$"#/6,1,-7 1+5-%%#5$1+7-%*6$1-+6)61+,$$"#%#5-%(,,0-?#+$-/=! :"-&',$ 655-*06+1#($"#+,0#5$-%:"-5-+('5$#($"#1+>#,$1)6$1-+

;

"#-55'%%#+5#"6($6?#+0.65#1+$"#*6$%1*-+16."-',#-7$"#

3 (#5#6,#( 6,:1+(#%<6'%"6((1#(:1$"1+6/-'$8C*-+$",7%-*$"#(6$# -7*6%%16)#1+$"#*6$%1*-+16."-',# 55',#( 6+&1$1+)"1,/-'+($- 0%->#$"#765$6,$-"-:6,:1+(#%<6'%(1#(1+"1,"-',# 55',#( 6+&1$ 1+)"761.#($-,0#6?6+=$"1+)6/-'$$"#(#6$"-76,:1+(#%<6'% ,0#% $"##>1(#+5#-7!6+(!

"#"6(%'+6:6=7%-*$"#"-',#-+,##1+) $"#* "#%#7-%#$"# -'%$:1.."6>#$-0%#,'*#$"6$655',#( 6+&1$1+)"

"6(  ,'00%#,,#(  $"#  765$  #,0#516..=  :1$"1+  "1,  ?+-:.#()# +  6(>#%,# 1+7#%#+5#:-'.(/#$"#-'$5-*#-7,'5"6,'00%#,,1-+*6(#/=655',#(

6+&1$1+)"

"#0%-,#5'$1-+"6,#,$6/.1,"#($"6$,--+/#7-%#$"#(#6$"-7 6,:1+(#%<6'%,"#"6(/##+,'/&#5$#($-"6%6,,*#+$1+5-++#5$1-+:1$" (#*6+(-7(-:%= "#"6(6.,-06,,#(6:6=:1$"1+8C*-+$",7%-*$"# (6$#-7*6%%16)# "# -'%$"6,$-0%#,'*#6,0#%#5$1-+;D/E-7$"# +(16+>1(#+5#5$39$"6$1$:6,656,#-7(-:%=(#6$"



"#-55'%%#+5#"6($6?#+0.65#:6=/65?1+$"#=#6%889 + *=5-+,1(#%#(>1#:6(#A'6$#,#+$#+5#"6,/##+6:6%(#($-$"#655',#(/= $"#$%16. -'%$  

+>1#:-7$"#6/->#$"#&'()#*#+$-75-+>15$1-+6+(,#+$#+5# 06,,#(/=$"#$%16. -'%$7-%$"#-77#+5#'+(#%#5$1-+;6+(83  6,6)61+,$655',#( 6+&1$1+)",$6+(,5-+71%*#(6+($"#600#6.1, (1,*1,,#( ,%#)6%(,

- 33-70%#7#%%#(/=5-*0.61+6+$ 6%6/&1$1+)"$"#,6*#6.,-,$6+(,(1,*1,,#(

4

"#655',#(600#..6+$ 6+&1$1+)"1,-+/61.

1,/61./-+( ,$6+(,56+5#..#( #,"6..,'%%#+(#%:1$"1+ (6=,7%-*$"#(6$#-7$"1, &'()#*#+$/#7-%#$"# "1#7'(1516.6)1,$%6$#6+)%'%  7"#761.,$-

8 ,'%%#+(#%$"#.#6%+#( "1#7'(1516.6)1,$%6$#6+)%'%,"6..$6?#5-#%51># ,$#0,$-,#5'%#"1,0%#,#+5#6+(,#+($-"1*$-&61.$-'+(#%)-$"#%#*61+1+) 06%$-7$"#,#+$#+5#

6%5"

   

'.6$1  !