← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/624/2013dismissed

Shyam Lal v. State Of Haryana

2022-11-15Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari14 pages

 

     

 

  

  

!

   ""##

$%    "

    

 

       &    '%# $

( 

""##  & "

& ) '

'

( *( +

----

 



""  



0

1 

%" 2    .

3



4

 2  6%/(   ( 0' '%/'

"

/ 0

 "% '

% 2



% 2 

8&( 



(

'%/'

"

 /  0  

6%/ 9"( %"(

5 

9" 9

0##



( 5%

' 





 %4 & 

 8 7  9" 8  & 



%#

"

,9

 28 2', ;

 8& ;

89" 9 !

4  , 

8& .' ,  

4 .' 9 ' 

##



9" 9

0  

% % #,( 5%

"  "

" 

% /



(

9

2 <

&( 

9" %5



9" 9 %"

59

// 

0 

5 

59

// 

0 

(

'%( #

%

"" 

%

 

  / 

"%

95 

"" 78

0' '

=:&

 /



' (

! 

$ .  

 # 9

 5, #, /  5 /

'

#  

9

( 28 '0 >%9 &?1

#/0 "# 

# ' /

 0' 2')

# &?< /



=:&7

 

+% 3  * 3

?

 3 ( . )'

#,( &# 



## 5/ '

/ %# %  .',

0 5 '

    .',

)

/

%# 

', 0 0'

#/0

 0

*9 .',

%"

'%

?   

*

/



" %#

' ""#, .',

)"

'%

 .',

)"



# # )  )# 



'% ?' ' '%





"9(

#(

'

% 2'% #/



&

 5# +

%

9 "

5# 0

/%

# .'  ' 9 %"

9  9 



' +

 /

// /

'%

 /

0 

 ?'

##0

)(

%

5, 9  /

 



"": 9

#,  ) ##

0  2% '  

#

0'

 0  / ,##0 %0

5# ) "

0' '

9

0 5#0

) 5,

0  /

' /') .' 

%

.' 

 #%

/

9

!

,  29 %)0 " #

)

% 

" %

9 9

 

 ,

  '  /

    ! 

 

 9"#

=:&7( 78 /   8

% 2842+  >%9  &' / "'

## 0' # )

"' / "'

" %/'

0##

# "#

"#

% 0

""

 8@%

" / 0 %  5,

> +"

#(  

" 9 9 "

#/

2'%( 5#

 '( 5#

  )#

/ #% "#

"

.

#  0

) " 

 "

#

2

0

72;

 '%5

 9 

  A 

9"#

2')

# /

 %""#9

 B

5 9%



2', ;

  >%

$ B , 

,(

% 2', ;

 0'

9

#9

#/0

  >%

$ B

99  

9% % 2', ;

/



 B % $ B

>% %#

 



 0   

  2 



 0 :#% #,

%

2 (

'%   99



A

6%

  / 

8

# (   ( 99

%



%

2   

 A "% 9 

,



%5@% #,(

"%5# "% # "%   

#%

"%

(

6%/ 0 " / % 2

&( 0' (

% "#  (

9

# 9"#

 +0(  

'

,        



 < %#

""  /

 ""##

 /%#,

/% 

%

 

%"  %9

 (

'%(

# 

6%/ %"

5  %"

'0  ( (

9 "# #  .

%59  ( %59

0 /

5 

0 /

, 99

5 

 (

%

%

'%/'

/9 "#,

 1 (

% %59

 

72;

#%  "  ( @%

5# /%"

5#

C % /

""

9(

(



"   .' (

/%

9



'%/'

#

99 '



#%

59 #

5# /%"

 .'%(

/%



(

5 

, 99

#

'   

 / +

% %59

 9"%/ B%/9  ( /  

/ 9  ""

 ""

  /9 

/ .' ( 

9"%/ B%/9

@% '(

      

%#

/%

9"%/ 

(

'0  %" (

9" %"

6%/ 9

0 ',(



%

,

, / 9  ""



""

,   /9 

/ .' ( 

9"%/ 

(

9

%  

              

     

2  78

0' '

=:&

 / ) #

( #,

5%

# 5,

5 / #

9 .'%( %#

 # #, (



'%"

9 ,

# 5,

9

%

% # ' / #% (

/ 0

59 /

9

5 / %



 % /

%

 5 /

78(

"%

%

"#  9  % /

%

5 / "%

"#  9

 /

%

0' '

=:&6

 / 

=:&6

5

' 

 

  

 

   



 

 

 

         

   

 



  



    

 ! "# # $% &   &

  &'  



(    " 

  "$$   # $& &   

 $)*$+$,-..        ' 

  $   

  '     $)*$+$,-..'

0$+-$$

 1    $'

 



 $1   



 

 2   



'21 

$1     '   (!$3

  2  $3'  

  2 4 

$  

  4  $    

    

  

'

  

         $!

 

  

     '

    

 



'

 '     $   '   (

 '    '   '  ''

  

   (

   (  '5/        ,&&' 5 '

    '    '  $  



   

 

   (  ''

   

 (



   $1 





       



 

   ' $  67 !

  67  (!



89    6:   6 !!

/ $*+;

    7) " $&'  #$; + ..$<

=:&6

 

 /

%

(

'  %

  ' / @%

%

 / /% #

5'  /  B

 )# (

' 

% " ) /

5%

 

'  /

9% / /(

5'  5,

 B

0'

# #

5%

) ##

'%

5 

' /

5%

'0 /

 )#

"#

%5

7% '9(

" ) /

' 

5%

5 #

% ,

##

5(

'  " "# 

'  /

)" /( / 

"#  5 / :#% #, ' 

)0#/

  

/% #

=:&6 0%#

#

 9"#  (

0%#

2 !

8 =  

'0   0

( 5%

'0   0  # #, (

'%"

 

/% #

=:&6

0%# 59 5

9  5# 5  #

! 2  "%% 

0 /

=:&6(

%

'%/'

, 99

0' '

=:&;(

 / %

%

,

'""

(

"" "

0' 

5% 

#

(

"" , "

=:&D .'%(

 

/% #



"# 

% /

) / "#  9 

59

#  9"#



%  "%#

2 !

8 =     #,(

'0 ,

"

 B

'%/'

=:&;( 

)

 

/% #

 "%#

  =:&6(

,

 

99  

 /

 



    

 

9 /

#% 

 

9

   

 

 # 

%

 /

%

=:&6  " /

 # 5 5 #

5#,



"" , 99

'%/'

% / /

 ( %//

 

(

'%/'

#

99(

"# /  ,(

'%/'

/9 "#,

9%'

( "

#

"# ( 5 / " 

) /

""  ( 5 /

)0

5 

  #, )" /

'(

9( ,

) /

"%" #,

99 0'%" 5 %#,  

#9

 /



A &" #,

)

5

 (

5%

#%(

#,

0 /

=:&6  # ( 5%

0 /

"" , 99  #  .'%( % 9

 

 /

=:&6(

'0  

'%/'

"" #, 0 , 99

< 8 % '##(

/ #, " =:&6

'0  

'%/'

=:&;(  

%

9  5#, #%(

'%/'

/ 0

59 /

%##, 

5# '

1 % /

%

 5 /

78(

%(

 # =:&(  0'

' 



 9 ( 5 



 )#

'%/'

% 0'

  #

)

 (

' 

' / %

5%

"# 0'

'0

"#

"



=:&

5 "

#(

%// 

%//

=:& %



,  

5 /  (

 

 .' ( % 9

 

 /

 /

=:& .'%(



% 

'%/'

9

  9/

 ""##    



 

 

  

 

        '    '  5/    

     '

      

  (

  (

    

 5/    

    

     



  $% 

         



   

'  $<  

  

  "

9 9 "

0

 "%% 

%

% ",

5,

( (

  =:&=4

% ",

5,

%

 ( 5%

#, 

'9   ''

""

 5:(

&?A(

0'

' "

:' 5

'%/'

% /

%

9 

 ' 

 /



=:&= 5



=:&=4

5

' 

   =6   1'

               



!  

'

$7    (  

  

'

       $   '

'

     $ "#$%"&$'&("&#)"* >  '  ( ?  

'%'    &  

? 

'$ '>3  '

    ?"/!#$  4@  @ ?$

>"   7 @  

 ? 

 

  (

  '

   $ >!' ?!' ?/!#"  ?"A   4 

 ? 

'A  ?" @

                    ?  "

       ?"



  

 $  ( ?"& ?

"

 '

.-



 $)  

  ?4  ?/!# ?"$<  

%

9 

5 "  =:&=4(

 

')

9'

/(

%#

9 9 B% (

)



9 9 B%  5 " 

%

  %

% 

' /

%

"

9 9 "

0' '

=:&=4

 /(

'%/'

"% 5

"

#

( %

 )# "

 B .'%( 5

=:&=( #

=:&6 5 

'%/'

5

(

#

'0  

'%/'

"" #, 0 , 99



 

  "

72;

95  =:&> 2  2  

( 0'

9 

# "

#(

' 9(

9 

( #% 

=:



 "":

9  / %

## 5# (

0 #( 5 

=:  / "#

%54.

#

 )

( 9

=:

9"  /

#%9"

#  "":

/9  5

5#

 '(  

'%/'( )

"  

5%

'%9 5#( 5 /

%

9( 5%

,

5

  #, "%(

'%9 5#

%

'(

""

 /

5# /%"

5# /%"

% (

"%

%#

9 

5#

%

=:



#,  #(

5#

: 

'

' /(

5# /%"

% 5#

( " ##, 0' "

'

2  2  

"%(

/ 

   /

5#

(

 

'( ' 5 /   5#

)

,

9

"" "    .' (

%#

 ""##

/%

#% 

"  (

2#/ 

5%

5# /%"

5#

% /

#

9( 



##

%

 / /

,  

 /

  ! +0(

%

B

/%9  5%

 9"# 9%'

(

% /

%

'# /

(

#

##

7.



%



 (

'9

#/



""

9

2#/ 

'%"

 #%  "   0%#

% @%#

)

## ( 9%'

" 7.



%(

(





, %

#% 

"  (

2#/ 

5%

5#

(

 

#

9 5#/(  5#/ /

5# /%"



5# /%"

%( 0' '

'0  %# (

## 

5

5 

##

59

' 9  #,

' 5%

"  

% 5#, @%

%(

'%"

#

/%9

%" 

%#

 ""##

%# %     

 

  /

%

'0  (  '# 99  

 /( %#

5#, ,  /

%

'(

"

 # 5

""  

'#  

 /(

( %#



% /

  %// (

 

"#

9%'

( "#, " 

) /

""  (

)" /



9

4"#  0'

', ( %5@% #,



8





  #% 

"  

2#/ 

5%

5# /%"

5#

(

%

9( 0%#

/ 

, # /

( %#   %/

'0 %//

#/

5#



9(

7.

 " #,

%(

 7% '9( 0'

'

"  

%

% 59 

 

 8 @%(

9"%/ 

(

'0 

(

59 " #, (

9"( %"

6%/ 

%

, / " ,(

5%

, / 9  ""

(



""

   8 @%(

9

"" #(

 9 

% #(

'%"

(

9" %" ' 9( %

'0 :%

6%/

'%/'

'0 0 / 99

 @%

' 9 A  "

/(

%

 

0 %"

5 #

"

0' '

=:&6

 /( 9 /  % $ B

>% (

"

 "

#

" %( ,

"#/ %

!

, 

# /



'9 @% #,(

2%"  

&#   

 

'0 %

:" % ) /



 %(

%

'  "% 

%

 (



6%/

 

'

'0 " / % 2 11

&(

 %

'

## % 9

"

#%

0%# 59   ' 9

'9 <  "" ,(

,(

  0( 5%

#,

:" ,

" 

# 9

# /

"" # 1 

0

'0 '

& / 9 ## %

""#

(

,(

(  "  

 

  !"!!#$##      %&'()&     &(%&(*)+(,-./01*(,)2/(34 ()12 &(%&(**(+2*%,5'( ()12