High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2483/2009disposed of

Baldev Singh v. State Of Haryana

2015-12-09Bench- 47 pages

!"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2 #, 3!

" # !

" $%%&

'%% ( )

) * # #

)

) ) )

)

# # ) )

# +(

% # # )( # # ,

# )

# # ( #

) ) ) #

# $ - ./ !

" )

$%%&

0%1 ) # # 2 ) ) # * '1 " 3 # # 2 # !

" !

( # # 2

# # !

" ) )

# 3 3 . 4 )

) ) / !

(

+ 56

# # ) 7 )

* 2

) # # # 8

9 #

) #

# +

3:1 1 , $$ ( )

) ( ) #

9 # #( , ) "

# ) )

& 4#4%+#(5-'+,#.400#4%1+)6-%$"#400#..4+$,,'/*1$$#($"4$+- 54,#74,*4(#-'$4,4)41+,$455',#('8"(#91+)":4%4*&1$1+)" --9#%$45$74,4$$%1/'$#($-"1* +,$1)4$1-+74,4$$%1/'$#($-"1*&',$$-

; %-0#"1*1+$"#54,#4,"#"4((#0-,#(1+$"#5-++#5$#(5%1*1+4.54,# .-()#(4)41+,$$"#5-*0.41+4+$04%$< =

#4%+#($4$#5-'+,#.%#6#%%1+)$-$"##91(#+5#-6!4+( !1+$"#/458)%-'+(-6*#(154.#91(#+5#,'/*1$,$"4$$"#0%-,#5'$1-+ "4,#,$4/.1,"#(/#<-+(%#4,-+4/.#(-'/$$"4$455',#('8"(#91+)": 4%4*&1$1+)"1+645$1+,$1)4$#($"#-$"#%455',#($-5-**1$$"#5%1*#4+( $"#%#6-%#$"#$%14. -'%$"4,%1)"$.<5-+915$#("1*4,7#..

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

$"4$455',#( '8"(#91+)""491+)4%%19#(4$$"#,5#+#-6-55'%%#+5#%41,#(.4.84%4$- ,"--$ '%/4?1+)" 55',#(4.(#91+)"7-'.("49#,1*0.<-0#+#(61%# 4,4.%#4(<0.4++#(71$""1,/%-$"#% #7-'.(+-$"49#%#@'1%#(4+< 1+,$1)4$1-+6%-*4+<@'4%$#%,4,"#7-'.("49#0%#0.4++#(71$""1,/%-$"#% "#%#6-%#1+*<5-+,1(#%#(91#71$.--8,@'1$#'++4$'%4.

A 4.(#91+)"-0#+#(61%#-+.<4$$"#1+,$1)4$1-+-6455',#('8"(#91+)" :4%4*&1$1+)"4$$"#,0-$ $1,6'%$"#%6-'+($"4$$"#%#"4(/##+4+4+1*-,1$</#$7##+$"# 04%$1#, +645$1$74,-+.<455',#('8"(#91+)":4%4*&1$1+)"7"- "4(61)'%#(4,4*4$#%14.71$+#,,1+$"#-$"#%5%1*1+4.54,#/--8#(4, 4)41+,$5-*0.41+4+$04%$< "#%#6-%#1+*<91#7$"#%#1,#9#%<%#4,-+$- %-0#1+ 455',#( '8"(#9 1+)" : 4%4*&1$ 1+)" (#,01$# "1, +-+ 1+9-.9#*#+$1+$"#5%1*# '%$"#%1$1,6-'+($"4$455',#('8"(#91+)":4%4*&1$ 1+)"74,,#%91+)1+ --0#%4$19#4+84$$"#$1*#-6-55'%%#+5# $1, @'1$# '+6-%$'+4$# $"4$ "# "4, /##+ 1+9-.9#( 1+ $"# 5%1*# 4..#)#(.< 5-**1$$#(/<"1,/%-$"#%455',#(4.(#91+)" -%4..$"#,#%#4,-+,61+( $"4$$"#0%-,#5'$1-+"4,*1,#%4/.<641.#($-#,$4/.1,"$"4$455',#('8"(#9 1+)":4%4*&1$1+)"%41,#(.4.84%44+(1+,$1)4$#(455',#(4.(#91+)" $--0#+61%#-+ '%/4?1+)" "#%#6-%#"-.($"4$455',#('8"(#9 1+)":4%4*&1$1+)"1,#+$1$.#($-45@'1$$4.

#4%+#(5-'+,#.400#4%1+)6-%400#..4+$4.(#91+)",'/*1$, $"4$455',#(4.(#91+)""4,/##+1*0.154$#(&',$/#54',#$"#%#74, #+*1$</#$7##+$"#04%$1#, $1,"1,6'%$"#%,'/*1,,1-+$"4$$"#*4$$#%74, 5-*0%-*1,#(/#$7##+$"#04%$1#,4+($"#%#6-%##9#+16$"#5-+915$1-+ %#5-%(#(/<$"#$%14. -'%$4)41+,$455',#(4.(#91+)"1,5-+61%*#("# *4</#,#+$#+5#($-$"#0#%1-(4.%#4(<'+(#%)-+#/<"1* ;

#4%+#($4$#5-'+,#.,'/*1$,$"4$$"##91(#+5#-64+1+&'%#( 71$+#,,4+("1,,-+1+$"#/458)%-'+(-6$"#*#(154.#91(#+5#5-*0.#$#.<

#,$4/.1,"#,$"#54,#-6$"#0%-,#5'$1-+ A ! '%/4? 1+)" 4+( ! "'01+(#% 1+)" ,-+ -6 '%/4?1+)""49#54$#)-%154..<(#0-,#($"4$1$74,-+.<455',#(4.(#9 1+)"7"--0#+#(61%#71$""1,(-'/.#/4%%#.)'+4+(54',#(1+&'%<-+$"# .#6$6-%#4%*-6 '%/4?1+)" "-')"$"#%#1,,-*##+*1$</#$7##+! '%/4?1+)"4+(455',#(4.(#91+)"$"#%#74,+-%#4,-+6-%!$- 1*0.154$#47%-+)0#%,-+16,-*#/-(<#.,#"4(54',#(,'5"61%#4%*1+&'%<

-+,1(#%1+)$"#+4$'%#-61+&'%<1$1,%'.#(-'$$"4$,'5"1+&'%<7-'.("49# /##+,#.61+6.15$#(

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

B 5-*0%-*1,#(##(7"15"(1,5.-,#($"4$$"#<"491+)/'%1#($"#"4$5"#$"49# ,$4%$#(.191+)0#45#6'..<1+$"#91..4)# >

65-'%,#$"# -'%$1,5-+,51-',-6$"#*1+1*'*,#+$#+5#-6; <#4%,0%#,5%1/#('+(#%#5$1-+=-6$"#%*,5$ "#-+C/.#'0%#*#

-'%$1+

4+($"1,

-'%$1+ !"

#$!% &!'

( 4+()"

* !"+

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

-'%$4,4)41+,$455',#(4.(#91+)",$4+(,5-+61%*#( '$$"# ,#+$#+5#1*0-,#(-+"1*1,%#('5#($-$"#0#%1-(4.%#4(<'+(#%)-+#/< "1* "#61+#4+($"#(#64'.$,#+$#+5#1*0-,#(/<$"#$%14. -'%$6-%$"# -66#+5#'+(#%#5$1-+;= 4+(#5$1-+=-6%*,5$,$4+(5-+61%*#( 6$"#61+#4*-'+$1,+-$041(71$"1+-+#*-+$"6%-*$"#(4$#-6$"1, &'()#*#+$ 455',#( 4.(#9 1+)" ,"4.. '+(#%)- $"# (#64'.

= 1*0-,#(/<$"#$%14. -'%$6-%$"#%#,0#5$19#-66#+5#, 55',#('8"(#91+)":4%4*&1$1+)"1,45@'1$$#(-6$"# 5"4%)#'+(#%#5$1-+;=%#4(71$"#5$1-+;A

-+,#@'#+$.< $"# 400#4. @'4 455',#( 4.(#9 1+)" ,$4+(, (1,*1,,#(1+$"#46-%#,41($#%*,4+($"#400#4.@'4455',#('8"(#91+)" 1,4..-7#( #5#*/#%

'.4$1 "#