High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/144/2005dismissed

Som Nath v. State Of Punjab

2020-03-05Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!" #"$ #! &!'

!( & "$ )* +

&! *

)* !

& !$, "!, "!

) -)#"$ % ....

! $"0

%1 !2"0) "!)#

*+ ) "

*! "!3

! !"0

#1 ! "% )43 5 ! !!!! 6 7 *!! ) "!0 !0!" !!1 !

1 )

)

8 " !)"! !"!0!0!" !!+1 ! / "*9

"! 1

% ) "0$"0

* % % :"

!0 !

!1 ) ! !" !1 !

;

)< !2 5 ! !!!!

<*0 0=!8<=7)'=# !)#

0+ ! !

*0 * ( +1 % !0!0!

#> >3)+

(0 " ) + ! %" , ") + ! !* !!

"# $0

+!0 " * 0

( "!)

"! ?

"!2 ! # 3 > ( $ $ ( + ") 1"% "0 !

/ ! %0! %) <*0 0=!!":

# !)#

!!0!

?<' +! 0

! ) #57/ ! !)

!1 * !"! ! ('+*!) 1 * 0, ")

%00 ) +$ #( + !

%!0 * 0, ")+ !!% !0 !0!

# 3 >!*%1 "

0! * 0

( "!# $0 !0

!/ !+ !

! " ! +! ! < + ) ," !) #57)#

! ! 01 1 0 + -"/ # 1 0 @!

" !"# $0 0 % 052'=A7

#B ! ! % 0 !!%1

" 1+!! !!0 0 ! " !0 @!!& 0!

'+*!)% " #

! +

!)+ 0%1 " "1+/ ! #)% 0%0 %1 "# $0

+ ! + " "+!

0 @

! /+ 0 +!!

+ !!/ +! *!

! ! 0 "%0+0 "%43 (0<+ " %B + *!

! !

!+! + <*0 0 =!92

*0! 626

," !)

*0! 6,6

!1 + ( * !*!1 / <*0 0=!

*! +) 1)

%00 )+ ! ," !) #!

+ / ! 0+ !0!

! !

"+ ( * @"!/ "

!" !" 1 !8! 0 " ! !+!< :

& 0!

0 ! ! /

!*!1+

!-!" !! +!"! " +!

!0 ! / ! ! "

")+ !" !*!1"!!1 8 +!+ / +!

( * C ! " !

! "# $0 ) %

"!!1 ;

8+!!*!)+ +! ( *

!*!1=!"! ) !1 + + &'" = ;;

</ !A ( !1!

!"0 %!< :

& 0!

!0 !!% 0!!! & 0!

) !1 + ! + &'" ?A)#"$ %)

0 !"0 '?

! !!+ !* ! *0 ! ! )

% ")+ +! !! +

! "! = !

"!2"0)

"!)#

) "

"!"

% "! !*"! >!# A !2"0) "!)#

!0!

"!35%7 +

!0 " !01)+ ) 1 0"1 ! / + B! * !" / ! !) "# $0 $" % + ! ! ! 1 "

/ %!0 0" ") !" B 1 0 + ! %+ #C<<-

( ! !

0 *! < :

& 0!

) # # #C ' ?

( ?A)

0 '

"! *DB#

!* ! &' " 0 + + ?A) #"$ %)

0 >

#C# )!() /=)

! +

!0 !+! !*!!% !0 # 3 > ," ! * 0!& $!

)

! #C< !2 )<*0 0=! + !0 !

") !*!1 !

! ! !0"%1 #C # ," !

! !0 !0 ! #C;<'

!*!0 ) +!*!1

#C></ !A

!1%! & 0!

!!"

!*0 #C3'" )&

!!! &A,' +

; + !1+ !* (*+

!0 ! !1+

*0 % !+ ! C

!"* "

!!"! !#) + ! 0 !"

)+! " %" 0 0

% 1** ! (0

! " ;

"!0 *) "

B (," ! C

%00 C ! !0 !0") ! 2"0) "!) #

* "

)+ 00!*

* ! ! " !

" * ! * -!

! #"$ %00 !"0 !! A !"!

8 "

! *0 ! "% !

!*0 !0 ) + % "< !2

0 ?< ! *0 / !!) !0+!*

" :" '

!!!$"0

!0 ! A !"!

8 ""! !

% !! !*%1< !2 !"+!0 1+ 0 ! ! B

0! +0

!+ !* * " %"

"!" !" '

!!!$"0

!"# $

( )!

*&* *+$) + ! B"!

%!*

+ !

+ !*! % !! ) +*! !* +! + ) 1* ! %"+"!! !*!1 ! " * *

" A !"!

8 "

"! !

! "

,)+ !+ %!*

!" %" + "+ (B

%" * A !"!

"! !!!! $"0 - )

/$$)+ !+

+ ! !% 0

1 "( 01!*!! "+!

! ! (+ %" + ) !!) <*0 0 =! + !!% !"! %%*

% 0+!

"( !0 ! ! !"!

! *0 ! "% !

*0 !*0 " !1!!!%1

1+ ! 0 +

1 !$"+ " "! ! ! *0 !

%0 !!

" !

! *0 !0 ! " !1!!!%1 !"!

) B"!$"0

1 % %2 %3 +/

" ! + "%$ !!

!!:"! !

%1 !'6%2"0%" ! *++ B !

0* + !

"*0 )" ! ! 1% 0*"+0 0+ 0 *!!%"+" % 1 ! 0 1

! +"%* !

" !

/ *+ (&

A 6 5"

!* 0 !!

%1 !"!

" !!!!%1 "

! !)

* 1%! + %1 ! "! !

! ! +

%00 $+

!1 "0 B %1 !" !

%00 ! !

+ +#C< !2 0 ) <*0 0 =! + !*!1 #C; < '

!*!0

! !"!1 ! / ! 0!! +

<*0 0=!! !

+"0+!*!1

1 !*"1+

" ! %1+ 10

*!+ ! 1 " / ++

+ !

+"* ! !

! +)+

! !0 :"

1 !

!*! ! (0 ")"%*

"+!01*%*

" +!%** "!

#" " !

%1#C<<-

) ! !

*! %1</$# +!!

%1 < :

& 0!

) # #)

+ 1 !1

> + ! + ! !

" %+ +!*!10 ! ! ! %" "! " ! +! ! )

%!* !** !" ! "

!1"

0 #C # ," !

! ) - @=!

! !"!1 ! !1( * ! !! !!*!?A) "% " / "0$"0*

%1 !

"!+! )% "

! * !!!

! +/ !0 1!

!1 ! C !0 !

!)%!*

!"0 !

(0!0

!0!

!0) 1 #"$ %)+

!" *1"0 +

!"0 !! !1!

( 1" " !"0 ! B8(( / !"0 !

* ""1!1 %!"!1 1" +!0"

" 1 !% + !1 !1 1

1 % +

" !* %"! !"* !"! !"0!

(0/ !!) !0 :"

!*!) " 11 / ") $"0* !! "

+ !

"%+ " 1! !01

8 " %% 0!

%1 "!'% 2" & 0!

) #

!" !!+ !!

0 !! ( "!0 ! 0

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#