High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1178/2015disposed of

Shankar @ Juddi v. State Of U.T. Chandigarh

2019-05-16Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu8 pages

!"## $ !

%& ' ()*# ++,, * %! !- . & #/ & + !

"#$% &'()*"+,-./* #0.123#"$# &'()*"+,-./*#".&4*"2.&532.43+ 0 !

&#!1 /2" !2!& ++,, ! 3 % !&200- . & #/ &

#0.123#"$#6

.& + ! ++ , # # !#!*! / # ! 4*/5 ! ! 6

2 78, #!# ,%# )*/2 & #/ &2 # %# $

++,, !

%& ' ()*#9 "& /9#!& !#!& "+* #& 7, * %"!# 6 6:0 ;9 " #"! "* %"!# 6:0!* /,##5+# 5 !+ 8# 2<

# *,!+ 85 !# 2!*!&* /#/*#5+# 5 !

!98 ;9 ," #"! "* %"!# 6 :0!* /#/*#5+# 5 ! 8 !& !& " 9!* " "* !,8

.&" !&+"*!# # *!&,,#!& ! 9& %: ,9# %# /& , /9#!&!&+,#"#"# ,9 + !, *!8# !& +*& 5, 82 9#,# 5 !# / # / ! 77# / # )&*//# $2 # , 82 +* & 5 , 829 "# %: ,9# %# /& "&!&+! .&# 4* 9 5 ! 01: .& +,#" + !8 "& !& &+#! , 9& "5+, #

9 !#"&! !5 ! ""# /!&2&9 ## /# ;* $2 #, 82 +*& 5, 82%"! $2& #/ &29#!&& 5#,8557 %&*!,,/! 7,#

1 # '!2%"!$2& #/ & 6 ! 7*!

2 9& &" 5*!&4&*//#! 9" ,, !* & " 5#!

"2 8*!&" 55!& !# !&!9 %*'& 7#/ ;" 5 & 57 "& =& &+!!2& +#"'*+ ! " *# 4*# & 5 &*, =& & # , 52&7!&# , 90 ++*29&9 ,+# /# !&4&*//# " 5!!&+! ;!#!+9!& ""*29&/ &#5' # 7,9!9 !&,!#&#"&!9#!&!&# !'#,,&#5 ; 7!&# , 9 ,, 9 * ! !& # 4*# "# .& +,#" 9 5 .&# 4*9 5!!&&+#! , 0 ++*# .& 789 !+!5!5> 5# !1 ,;+#! ,2%"! $2 & #/ & :

!#/ !# 9 # #!# ! "& ,, 9 +*! *+ ! "5+,!# ,,!&" ,5 ,#!# .&+"*!# > 5# *579#!

# *++! !&" .&! !5 !!& ""*9 ,"* %"!# 6 0 ; #!& " !&+"*!# ;9 " #"! "2 !#" 7 ; "2!&+ ! ++ ,

6 ? "* , ++ # / 7& , !& ++,, !

&5 !,8 /*!& !!&+"*!# & #,!+#!" ? "* , ++ # /!&%! !&5 !,8 /*!& !!&+"*!# & +#!" 78 7,*7! *++!!&4*/5 !&, *!7,9 =& & , "* ,!&+ !# / !&*/& !&4*/5 "8" *,,8 $ 4 8@*5 " *"!!&+!5!5> 5#

;& !#"!&,,9# /# 4*# !& 780 ++*

%! 79* #B6> 6"5+ ! !& !!&"&! #+, " "57,9 *! !!&?! #++, .&9* #+, "7,#C*,89#!&!&

"*! /,+, " 7!&,,*! .

* /, .&! 79* #/# /7 "'9 *+9

5# ,,8 # ! !& "&! " #!8 !&*/& !& $!& !"! ,+ "# !!&+,* ," #!8 %! 79* #B6> 6"5+ ! !& !!&"&!!& #++, , !& *++& , .&9* #+, "7,#C*,89#!&!&#

"*! /,+, ",9!& !&*!7!* /, .& ,9#

/,#5/# /9#!&*++ /,# 4*8

6 .&! 79* #/# /7 "'9 *+9 5# ,,8# !!&"&!" #!8!&*/&!& # !"! , + " 4 " !!!&78!&! *52"*!!# /!& +#" #*5 !# /!&?! !#",!&& !

9&!&#5 # !&! 79* # "5> 6"5 7*!65, ,!!7,+ !# !&+#" # , " #!8 %! 79* #B6> 6"5+ ! !& !!&"&!!& #++, , !& ,9& , .&9* #+, "7,#C*,89#!&!&#

"*! /,+, ",9!& !&*!7!* /, 9&#"&#5/# /9#!&,9 /,# 4*8 .& ! 79* #/# /7 "'9 *+9 5# ,,8 !!&"&!" #!8 !# /!&*/&!& # !"! , + "2 "*!!# / !& +#" #*5 !# / !& ?!

D !#",!&& !9&!&#5 # !&! 7 9* # "5> 6"5 7*!65,",!!7, + !# !&+#" # ," #!8 E .&" * !&9 " # "!5+ *,!! 7# 4*8!!& "&! :

4*8 69*#"# !!" * !&# # 8"* !*# ##* ,,8 9,, ",,"!#,8 ,,!&# 4*#9 5!5# !* !& !*+7 7,9 + 9 # /, & + /9 + .&+7 7,!#57!9 # 4*8 !&9 " 7!9 !& +!5!59 7*! &* ;+*"!&+! 5!5+!2F> 0 $ :

&#"> 5# 2&+!& ! ,,!& !&# 4*#& !# !&"&!" #!8 %5! 9 !#!!##!& ! 6 ! 7*!

2&" 5*!&4&*//# 9 ! !*" ,, =& &9 !* / "& !&4&*//#2 ""*" 55!& !# " */&!&,& 57 "& %& # , 5 ""*/ 7#"'7,9 &&*, & # /"#2&7!&# , 90 ++* " 5*!!&4&*//# ""*,!& / '

#7,9!& 7!&# , 929&#"&&#!&#5 &#& ! ;,,9 ""*

9 85!&+! %5 " ,,!&+,#" .&# 4*9 5! !& &+#! , .& "! ", &#5 7*/&! : & " > 5# 2& 5#!!!& !9& !&# !""*2#!9 ' %& & / ! 9" ,, !* , !&, #9 ,+ ! !

!&#! =& !&# !""*2!&9 *#"# !,#/&! %&9 ! #!

" + "5!&4&*//# %! !5 !0= 9 !#9 *,8"7 !78&

0= 5@#& ;!!##!& !&9 ,+# /# !&4&*//# ;& "#&#5!& " 5*! ; 9!& !&#* ",9 /# /!9 &#5!& ;# !##!& ""*# !&*! ; 9!& ""* /## /'

#7,9!&#* ", ""* 9 8 %578" ,,!& +,#" .&# 4*9 5!!&&+#! , .&"!", &# * ",7*/&! ;# !##!& 78 :

&#"> 5# &+!& !& 9!& ""*/ ++,# /9#!&&#* ", ""*!'

*! '

# / 7,99#!&'

#!&#* ", !9&#"&& 9 8 ;"*, !# ! # !&#/&! !& ""*& , 8# ,#"!'

# 7,97&"*, "& 0=6%: ,9# %# /&& "!&! !5 !2F> 0 2 %5! 9 !#0= G:2F> 029 " G%?! 59 , " ,, !!&+! ""*9 ! ""*9 # !##780= 5@#& ""*5 #",*! !5 !2 !&7 #9&#"&& /!"!&7,! # 4 "'! '

#5!&7*&# !& 4* /, %"!$2& #/ & ;##",*! !5 !#F> 0

+"! '&%# /&++ !&'!"&'

#2F> 0 :

&#" > 5# 2 & # !& *//!# !& ! ""* %& ' & 7

,,8#5+,#" !

;%*4#!%# /&+!& !:

+"! '&%# /& +#!!9+ "," ! # /'

# 7,! # 4 "'!9#!&&#5 0=$ ; ; 9 %# /& + !& ! !& ""* 5 #",*! !5 !2F> 0 2 !&7 #9&#"&!&9 + "

$ '

# 7,! # 4 "'!9"5!&7*& 4* /, %"!$2& #/ &

+"! '&%# /&+!& !&& 5!& ++,#" !# 2F> 02" *"!# /+!5!5> 5# ;& /!

",#"'!&+&!/ +&!&+! .& 789 & ! 0= 5@#& .& ""*9 ! .& ""*5 #",* ! !5 !2F> 0 2 !&7 #9&#"&'

# 7,! # 4 "'!9 "5!&7*&

%* #! 2% #%"# !##"#"2> 5# !& !& + "," ! # /'

#279 ",*4 "'! #7, 5+,! ! !7,#!5!&+! ;*5 7,/*+9 !"!5F> 2 6 # 79 ",*4 "'!287, 5+, / *B! !!7 ,#!5!&+! 87, 5+," / *B+#" G%?

+!#F> 066 ""# /!G%?+!2&*5 7,9 !"!5 F> *7,7, '

#2&927,/*+9 !!"!52 F> 2*7,7, '

# .&# !& 7 9#!

780= %5! 9 !# 0= 5@#& 0= %5! 9 !#& !& ""*/## /'

# 7,9!&7!&# , 90 ++* 0= 5@#&& *,8"7 ! !&!!#5 8&5!&0= %5! 9 !# !&5

# 9&#"& '

#7,99 /# !!&" .&" * !&9 " # " !5+ *,!! 7# 4*8!!&"&! :

4*8 69 *#"# !!" * !&# # 8"* !*# ##* ,,8 9,, ",,"!#,8 .&# 4*#9 !5!5# !* !& !* +7 7,9 + 9 # /, & +/9 + .&7,! # 4 "'! '

#9" !&7 ##",*! !5 !2F> 0

5 78!& ""*5!&7*&!&4* /, %"!$2 & #/ &

:!9 ! +5#! ! "! ""# /!!&+"*!# %5! 9 !# # , 5 & # /"#2&7!&# , 9 0 ++* "&!&+! 0= %5! 9 !# 0= 5@#&& ,8 !& ""*/## / '

#7,9 !&78" 0 ++* :!& ,"5# !&! !5 !0= 5@#&!& !&& !&" !& ""*/ ++,# / ;"*, !# ! # !& #/&!2!&*/&&9 !&+! :!& ,"5# !&! !5 !0=

%5! 9 !#!& !!&, #9 ,+ ! !!&+!2&92 + !9#!

9 +*"78!&+"*!# ""# /!0=

%5! 9 !#2&9 ,# ,#"!# 4*#78!& ""*9#!& 7#"'

&&*,2&92 5#" ,> 5# 9 +*"!+ #! %&9 !5#",/ ,,8> 5# +&9 ! !5 ! ! ! 78&# &"> 5#

$ ? "* ,!& ++,, !& &5 !,8 /*!& !

!&+ !" # !"* %"!# 6:02 !& #!9*, 7"* %"!# 6 0 !:::0 = ! /9#!&!& /*5 !, "* ,!& ++,, !!& !!&" #"* %"!# 6 0 !:::02&92 "!!&5 !!#!& !#!# ! +5#! ! "! .& ++,, !# #!,8 & # !" * !&# " ++!5!5> 5# +!2 !&# 4*#9* !&+ !&" ""# /,82!& ++ ,#+ !,8 ,,9 .&" #"!# !& ++,, !#" !5 %"!# 6:0!%"!# 6 20 !::0 .&" #"!# " * !&"!# #5+78!&!# ,*!#*+&,

#9* ##"*# 2!& ++,, !##"!! 7+*"# *! !7& !&C* !*5 " 4#%& 5 )*/

; # %# /&%#&* )*/ =&!&+ '# /< 3< =&!&+! 7, 3<