High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/395/2003dismissed

State Of Punjab v. Balkar Singh

2019-11-06Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan,Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

! "#!!

$#%&'('#!

!(! ) ) $'(*%&'('#

! "#!!

!(!

!! "

!# $

%&$ ' %&$ ' ' $

(

#$ %$&'

(

)$* #$ %$&'

(

++++ ' $ ( +!' ,'#!-%!#.%!'

0,#%&'12 #-'"% &('#%3 , 4'!% ,%!#%-0#%!# &5%''%!'#'%(#%&'( .&# #'# 5# ##%& '0 # .%& %!- 6#(5#'*% & 7''.'(#-'(#- %%-# # %

%&','.5#%#-( .--!( $#%&'!8# !

%&',*#%&',$'(*%&'!#%0%&',3%#%&', !!%&',$'(* %&', $#%&' !'-' %&', 3!'0%#%&',0%&'( %&'5'!#('# %& !!'0 #%&'(#!!--0.%&'%0!$( '0(!,',*#%&'&*$% 5'%(#%&'

'%%&'%0 !' (# $#%&'--!(%-$( #%-$ ('# (%'%(#%&','%%&'%0##%&'. $'(* %&'(!!%&' !%-$( #%-$ !#0'#'#5%& '!'%(#%&','%%&'%0'( 0%&'&*$%

5!#%&'

$#%&'&*(& 5'%%& #%&''%! #0 0%&'&*$% 5# %&''%%&'%0#%&'!' (#,5'#!, %&'&*(&

5'%%&'%0'%! & 3%#%&',3!'0%#%&'($'(* %&'$!(%&'#5'% !%&'%(#%&'('#!

('.%!%&('%#---!(-!% #%!'0 # #-%*%&% #%!,'%(#%&' -0-!-%!,' ' --!(#5.#0'! &5%''%##!-%*5! 4' % #(5#$6#9$*8!% ,0#%!#,5'#'. 5#(0%( #-%:!'% #( %-% :$,+#%&'#!'#;'+;#0'!%( %-!% 56#9$*8!% ,0#%!#(#-#((!0 % #(#%&'!12 7 < 8(('%!(#!0 !-'!0(!#=' %-!%,' !%!5'%-'

#0 >+12 1<5!#-#(( 4'+5'!(##( #&'!% ' -%-%(!12 6 8#-#((!0 3!'0%#%&' ! --!(5###!(%'%!-! $%5!

#-*#(#0'!!!!%--!(*#%&' 4'+##( #&'!$-''!%($%!12 8 7'--!( $#%&'5!

##!(,'5!( %!!!!%(&12 ,5'%-'5!

$%!!!!%,*%(0012 ?

(&5!#-*#(#0' !!!!% --!( %&', 5'%-' 5! !%@(, *%( 00 3 4'+- (#-#(!0'%(#%&'% #(, !%-!%( .'(-#,'5!%%-(%%0$' !0 '%(#%&''(!--0 ('% #%!!#( .'%0 %'%-%(

!!-',-(#-% + 5!(((( '--!(5####!( 4'0%*#' %-%(!!&&!( .'#!-%,5!' B0'!

# %#, $#%&'('%!#.0'(-!(% #%!# %&'#&#(%&5'%-'>+'( #&%!#(&%!'0 $# %&'('#!'(0 .(6# 2%&'!8#0%&', #!%(('#%%'*% &6#(5#5'%-'#%&'( '%!#.0'(

-(,!%-6# 2%&'(%(!!!!&( 0# -'#-# &&#%*( .','--!('(-!(% #%! '0 #-0 %%*!%&%('##0 %%!,' -' &%!--!(5!##((% (%'#+ = &%!0#%!# -'&%!#! %(-%!(-0!

# %(%'-' '--!(,#-!!!#*%(((# -% A# ('%(%&''-(#-% +#5'%-''--!('( $(5!2- !%* .#% .

'#!!%!,*%((% (-00%0#(#,-00%(' -!'#!!%!,#05'#,%5!!!%&(((

!!%!?(&('-,0#%!# >%(%& #%0 -% -!, -'#& # -! (# -%!)C, <)C, )<) , <) +5!#0(&%!' --!(,5'%-','. ((&% .(- %0(#% #%& ' -#! #!-% *%(-, % 20%( 7# ?

6#&%, 7 # "%$#0 % %&', 7 %!'% 0, #&'!0, 7) # . ' , 7 # %&', 7/ 3!'0%#%&',7A+6#0%%&',7C+#%&',7

# !'5%30#,7# '0,7+$#%&', 7 $#9'(7 # 6#0 %%

#'#!-%*%(-5!- !(,!0!' --!( 5# #-#(( (# -% # , % 5'%-' ' %-#%0%%&-%#-0!-!#%&&%!'--!(5# '0 '.(%('!0,-(%&''.#%-( '* ! .%* *(%'%!-!--#.-% %!0 #%&'%#(-*%(-,'--!(20%(# %&'!7(6 @#%&'!7

7#%&'!(' '(.--##-,'%(#%&'--0%( .!0#! '(-0'%# - %.#-*!!%&%--%5%'6#(5#

1 -%!

'%0,'%(#%&'5!-##.%&(&,# %&'12 #-'5!'*%&$%#,3!'0%#%&'5!#0(5%' &(!%, %#%&'5!#0(5%'$%,6#0%%&'(5%(# %&'5##0(5%'(&!

!-'#!!5(-!'%#*!

'-(%('%#-'%-5'%-''.#!(,'##,'. -!(% #%!'%0(6 @#%&'

7 6 @#%&' !(!('!*#. %! # '#%& #&0!, #( (( !!%! ?(& ('-0#%!#,(% -!#%&',!!-',--!( 5# % #'%#%(%*%( -!,!%-,%- ( !%(''# 5!# %&#.--#(-$5!0( .'0 +5!( ''#!-%'( #*&#%*!% #%! . 5!,'*%& -!('%(#%&'(-!( .$'(* %&'!''#%&'(!!%&'(--#(%& .,'.5# -*%-((#-%

+,5'#!,'#--!(5#-=%( (#-%!)C, <) , <) +( ''--!(5# !-((#&#%&#!%0#%!0#).#!(. %!

<(%( .0%,(#&#'#+ # 0'!,*%( (&0((A

+0. 0%( '# ' 5' ' (&0 5! #-(, $# %&' ! 8# !%&'(*#%&'!8# ' %&''(2%#(

''--!(<-*%-!&&#%*( . (&0'%# -*%-%(!-('*% ( #'%!#,%- 5'%-'5!%!!('(%'!%#-'#&'

, -! +0. 0%('#'''! !#-'('%! #(#-% AC # ##0%!!%% %& &&#%*( .'*#(%--=% %*#'#0%%&--!(

-' *5!&#((%-5!&%*'--!(<#!(! 5''*%#-'#&'-! 7'*'#( #(-! #'#%! !%(!&%& '#&''#-#(

4'#% #%' %&'-!(-%#-0!-!' -!, .!%!' & (- !%%,-0'-- !% ! 5!D 4''--##-$ -#- %%-# # %%&'

(!#-!'#!-%,*#%&'5!'*%&$% 5'#!'#--!('(%-$( #%-$ !

E(#' -%#-0!-!,%%!=%!!% '*#%&'5!-##.%& $%5%''%0!#%0# 4'!,%-0 # %&'5'# ''#%!5#&&#!!#!

+ #%! ' #! # %&' 7 #0%( #*((%%!0%(%'>+!5'%-'--!( '(-!(% #%!3!'0%#%&'

4'#'! !#*( ''0(%- *%(-#*('3!'0%#%&''(& '%0! 0(%- & .20%(#0#'!%2(.!,*%( :12 ('#%!*%(-!#'50.(.!, 3!'0%#%&''(#0%(' ( 4'##,!!% % %. 3!'0%# %&' !#%& % #%! ! &( . '

- #!-%- ( # ( 4'#% #'($'-''0(%- & 20%%'%(#%&'5!-(-(('%! ( '(%-$(5!#(-(%*%(- .'#!-%

4'!,'#5!(#%*(%0#%-*%(- !-#%!5''%(#%&'5!(0%(%' '!% ,5''5!0(%- & .20%((5'5! '#% #%!'%!#! 4'#!-%'( ! #*( % *%(- #&#!! ## 0(%- #0 '%(#%&'!12 5'%-'5!#*( .# !'5% 30#7 ( #'# % -0! #0 ' #-#( ' '%(#%&'5!(0%(%6#9$*8!% , 0#%!#

/ ) 0% 5%'%'##! '%0--##-(''(!#('(% #.%' 0%(( !$ ,! 5('#!-' !' (#('%!0'!5 !!5#( (%& 4 !-##!'5!0 % #-##05'%-'%- ( &'#( ' ' '( !#( &#%*! % #%! . 5 85*#,'!0#0##'%(#%&' #*( .# 6#0 % % 7) !'5! 0#0 % #%!,% #%!9 5#!#(0-' # #

6#0 %%5! &%*(%%-!('(' '(!('%5!#-%- .!!% -# ' % #%!5%''-!('

85*#,#0!!% % %.

. ('!#! -!=-!-'#0- ( # ( 4'%%#&#(%&('&%* . #(-#!%!

'-'!!% % %.('#! %&#0-- #% !#*%('#% #!-!=-'(% #.

- ( # (%'%!-!,5'%-'!#%&' . !#*( .

'#% #5!!#((%% 4'#% #'!#'# !#*(''%(#%&'5!

(%!-'#&(#06#9$*8!% ,0#%!#(' #0%( '%! #!%(- 8 '( $ #

'0, 5'5!!(8, !%(5''( !(''(-!(5!(0%( .'%0%''!% ( (%!-'#&(

/ 5' ' 5! ###( '%&'# 0(%- %!% 4'(-#- (#-' ('( %-$'%(#%&'

4'#!-%- (#*% *%(-'#0

/% ((''%(# %&'

A, ' '( #0%( (# . 0(%- #0 4'##,%#-- ( (#5''%(# %&''((%(--% #%!!#( .'%0%' %-%(''(!--!( 85! (0(''( #0%( -'%!#!%(-#-!%(# %0( ##0(%- #05!#*%(( 4'#!%&&%* .'#% #%!##%( -*%-%& 4' (&0--#% . #0( #*#!,

'*%&. 0# %##%!!#.*% %! ( (%-% #%-% !

+ !-' * %., %##- . '%! #, 5'% 2#-%!%& #%!(%-%,%#*%5%!- (# --!( !!%&'($'(*%&'5##%&' .-*%-(#-(# -%

+ 4'!-).#!%0#%!0%0!( '0%!-#% .''%&'#!%( 4'&', #(-! #' ! '! *'0 . #&( ' ' 0# '! !%- -0#0%!( 5'#%!F'. &'!0*% &F' %-%('($ - .#!&('.'( %* *( % . '# =## '##, '##, ' =0 !- #(-(( '. !-(%0#%!0 #(.

(#& .'0%'%!-!,5'%-'%!!( </0'! .

5#%- %(--'-%(#(-'!- #!-' %$#!!, !'!' (!(5#&0!!&%'!-%. %& %&' .#-00%%&!#%!-! 4'##,' % ( .--!(<-*%-! -$!0#%(%!(%!0%!!( !#!

% ( .'&%!-=% '#--!(,5(%( .&#(%##5%''*#(%-'#% #%'#&#( (-*#'-=% !-'--!(%-*%-%(!-

4'##,' % ( .'%! !(%!0%!!(

/ %

(01 $ 2

3$ / %$ "

2 3$