High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1189/2015dismissed

Balwinder Kaur v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2016-02-09Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary10 pages

" # $ %&'( ')*

+,- %'.

(' /00+-1 2300%++ 4%'5(5 #2 2% (6 & 27%'5 / %50 %25 $! 89 # # :9 #

'%5%2$ ' #7+(, +- * 41 2%'27% 00+-1 2

* 00+-1 21+ -;-<7%'5%+2&% 02% (<72%' %1% 5% + %4#-<7-+% 00+-1 2-

227% 0+-1%27 27%' 02-4% 27%'7 5&%%=-++% &) ;--52%'-< 5;%0-5(55(&52 1%&)7%'1(5-5'%50 %25 > 2%' =%%0-< 7-; - ,'<(+ 1-%;%2 ' &(2 27'%% )% '5,-27 -2%22<'

&7-5+ ?(%520'1%% -<5( %' #%12- @ '

,%'% 1 (12% 7% 052 ;'2%; %A ;- 2- % & ) + %4#-<7, 5<21 (12% -5 4-51%'

, 5 5%2 2 27% 7%;-1 + A ;-%' #;% 0-5(55(&52 1%, 5( -27%4-51%'

# # ;

<'%%-< ,-27 '%0'2 # 9 =7 #-<7* '%1;;% %

'%<-52'

2- 1 5% ( %' #%12-5 >*> "*>* !

< -52'%50 %25 >#0%1- +4%52-< 2-<% ; , 5 152-2(2% 15-52-< #(0%'-2% %2 +-1% BCD* # B%2%12-4%D # * #-2)# ;

4- %' %' 2%

7%#0%1- +4%52-< 2-<% ;4- %-25'%0'2 2% " &5%'4% 27 25-1% + %4#-<77 -55(%'; 7-5,-%*57%&'(<72 +,- %'.

('* (<72%'7-55-52%'- + ,27-57(5% 2% %' <%#7%, 5&'(<72(0 7%' ;

''- <% 0%'';% ,-27 &- #-<7* ,7 +5 + 2%' &%1 ;%7 ' , -

;#-<7*27% 27%' %1% 5% + %4 #-<77 2'

5%''% &-<7 5+ 24-++ <%

2%7 6'-- 4('27%1;0+ - 2 +,- %'.

('4- %2,5 +% %% 5

2% " @ 7% %1% 5% + %4 #-<7

7-51(5-5* ;%+)*'%50 %25 >,%'%005% 2 27% 5 - 2'

12-

; #-<7 - 4(' 27% 1;0+ - 2 +,- %'.

('%1%*+-2-< 2-%5(% &%2,%% 27%; 27% 1;0+ - 2 7% #0%1- + 4%52-< 2-< % ; ( 27 227% ++%< 2-5=- 00-< + %4#-<7 7-5 ,-% &) '%50 %2 5 > ,%'% (2'(% (2 5-1% 27% 0-5, 5( -27%4-51%'

27% %1% 5% + %4#-<7

1;0+ - 2 +,- %'.

('7 +%4%++% ++%< 2-57-5 ;(' %' &) '%50 %2 5 >* 27%'%'%* 27% #0%1- + 4%52-< 2-<% ;'%1;;% % ''%<-52'

2-1 5%( %' #%12-> 11' -<+)*1 5%( %'

> &(2 (0 27% 1;0+ -21;0+ - 2*#%12-> , 514%'2% -2 #%12- > ('-< -4%52-< 2-* -2 , 5 ( 27 %1% 5% + %4 #-<7 7 2'

5%''% + ;% 5('-< &-<7 5+ - 4('('+ -%54- %'%<-52%'% 5 +% %%

2% @

(2,7;2,,%'%,-4%527%'%50 %2 5 > 27% '%;

--< 2, ,%'% 27%-' &'27%'5

#-<7 ;

#-<7 57,-< 5 +% 15- %'

! "#$% &'#(&! )$$#& (# &$ ) & $ # ( ! )$ $% $ # % ! ) $ *+ % ) , &% # - % (# $ % ) $ .)#% $# & $ (%$ / 0 % % 1# $ $ ($ $ #

) $$$& # &

2 334 "# / / 0%% #$'%(&%! ) $5+

2 ! "# # $ #&

2 1 $ $ $ #

- $$! )$4 # &4&% %

$.) $ ! ) $ $ $ $ & $ % $# $ # 4 $ 0 $ ) "$ $ 2* $ & 6( $ % % ! )$.%#$%$! )$$% 6#($"#$)&% &7$#( $#( % $ 8# $ % ) /$#

2* "$ $ $ ( $ % % 1$.%#$$ $%! )$$##$) $ # 4 $. ! "#$(#* -&$

E '&7 #-<7 %05% 27 2 + %4#-<7 7-5,-%('& .

('7 02% +,- %'.

(' 7

" 5+%;-F% 7%';

''- <%,-27&- #-<7%7 552 2% 27 '%50 %2 5 > 7 <2 %A%1(2% 5 +% %% '; %1% 5% + %4 #-<7 ,-27(2 );%2

) +% 15- %'

2-%1% 5% + %4#-<7, 5 %;

-<;%) ';27%; %50 %27 2 =% + %4#-<7227%-' 7(5% ,-27 7-5 15%2 2 4-++ <%

2%7 6'- ,%4%'* 7% 2 5 ) ,7%27%' %1% 5% + %4 #-<7 , 5 +-4-< 2 27% 7(5%'%50 %25 >,-277-5'%%,-++ 15%2 ', 5=%02&)27%; 227%-'7(5% < -527-5,-57%5% +5 2 2%++ ( %' ,7 2 1-'1(;52 1%5 27% % 27 %1% 5% + %4#-<77 2 =%0+ 1% #('6 #-<7 7 5 5-;0+) 2%52--% &(2 27% %05-227%1 5%0'0%'2),-277-; ('27%'5% -<-2 227%7%;-1 +A ;-%'

E@ # %, #-<7 %05% '%< ' -< ''%52 %

;6-2#-<7-27-51 5%,7, 5- ++)217 ++ % % %05% &(227% ''%52'%50 %25 >

E52 &+%# ;#-<70'4% 27%10) "@ 2%

* A E3 ( %' #%12-5 * "* @* *@ * ! 27%' 2%

( %'#%12-5* ! *A E3

E# '-20 +#-<7 %05% '%< ' -< -2- 5%12-> 27% ''%52'%50 %25 >

'& 5 #-<7 ,7-+% %05-< &(2 27%

02- 1;0+ - &) %1% 5% + %4 #-<7* 1''&'

2% 7%'2%52-;)-22

# '

&6-2#-<7-5 +5 ';

+,-2%55

&- #-<7* 7(5& 27% 1;0+ - +,- %'.

('*1''&'

2% 7%'52')-22

> 6-2#-<7# , 527%;%;&%'#0%1- + 4%52-< 2-< % ; 2 27% '%+%4 2 2-;% % 7 5 0'4% -25 '%0'227%& 5-5,7-171 5%, 5'%<-52%'%

- #-<7 " 50%12' 5,- %' #-<7 '%27%';

+,-2%55%57%)7 4% %05% &(227% 52%052 =% ('-<27%1('5%-4%52-< 2- #2 2%;%2 '%50 %2 5 > ( %' #%12- > > ' ,%'% '%1' % 0(22-< 27% %2-'% -1'-;- 2-<%4- %1%,7-177 1;%'%1' < -5227%; 2,7-1727%) %-% 0+% % +5%-;0+-1 2- %%1%* 27%) %A ;-% E #(=7 %4 #-<7* ;& '

'4-++ <%%7;

0('*,72%52--% &(20 55-< +%15- %'

2--27%7 5 + %4#-<7,7-+%%A%1(2-< 27% 5 +% %% @

- 4(' 27% ,-4%5 27% '%50 %25 2,27%'+ -%5%1 2%<'-1 ++)2%52--% 27 + %4 #-<7 7 %A%1(2% 27% 5 +% %% 5 4+(2 '-+) - 7-5 0'%5%1%E('& .

(',-%27% %1% 5% * %05% 257% 7%' %1% 5% 7(5& ,%'%+-4-<-27%7(5%

@ '%50 %25 >5-1%+ 52G)% '54+(2 '-+),-27(2

)(5%'1% < -5227%;%' %1% 5% 7(5& + %4 #-<77 5+ 27%+ 2(=72- '.

('%21' 15- %'

2- %)$ 9 # % $ # $ $ # :# % # ( # :#3! )$#*+ &%$'#% (&$+- %)#%$)% $ 7$% %#%% $ ($ $ # & ) $ % $ % 2 2* $ # $ # ( !

) $ $& & & $)%%$ %)#%$)3%$$ )%$$ #$8# $ % 2 334 "# / / 0%% $ :# %# $ % ! ) $ $% '7$ #$ # $ % 32 ('& .

(' ,-% + %4#-<7 E% 7 4% <-4% (' 27(<72(+ 15- %'

2- 2 27% 5(&;-55-5;

%&)+% '% 1(5%+'27% 00+-1 2

;-22% +)*27% 00+-1 2 +,- %'.

(', 5227% '% + (<72%' %1% 5% + %4#-<7 7-5,-%('& .

(' E 7'(<7(2* 57% -5 1+ -;-< 7%'5%+ 2 &% 27%

02% (<72%' + %4#-<7,%4%'*57%7 5;-5%'

&+) -+% 2 +% ) %4- %1% - 27-5 '%50%12 02- %% , 5 %4%' %A%1(2% ' '%<-52%'% * ' ) 1%'%;-%5 - 27-5 '%50%12,%'%0%'';% 2 7 5 +521;%27% '%1' 2 %1% 5% + %4 #-<7 ' 7-5 ,-% E ('& .

(' %4%' ;-22% ' 2'% 2% 27% 00+-1 5 27%-' 02%

(<72%',%4%'*-2-52 -50(2% 27 227 2 +,- %'.

(' -527% (<72%'27%5-52%'E('& .

(' , 5 &'(<72 (0 &) E ('& .

(' 7%' 7(5& %' ;

''- <% , 5 +5 5+%;-F% &) 27%; ,-27 &- #-<7*,7+ 2%'&%1 ;%7 ' , -50%', ;-55- 27% 00+-1 2* '%50 %2 5 > ,%'% 1(5-5 %1% 5% + %4 #-<7 2 7 5 +5 1;% '%1' 27 2 27%

00+-1 2<22'

5%''% &-<7 5+

;#-<7* 27%' 27% %1% 5% *4- %2,'%<-52%'% 5 +% %% 5 2% "

@ 7%5 - 12-

;#-<7, 52+-=% &) %1% 5% + %4#-<7 '%5(+2 2+)*7%17 ++%<% 275%5 +% %% 527 51;%'%1' 27

;#-<7 -% ,-27-2,;27527%%A%1(2-+ 525 +% %% &-<7 5 + - 4(' 27% 00+-1 2 @ ,-27-

&(25%4%;275%A%1(2--'525 +% %% &-<7 5

+ "- 4('27% 00+-1 227 5 +51;% '%1' 27 2 4 '-(5 1-4-+ 1'-;- + +-2-< 2-5 52 '2% - &%2,%% %1% 5% + %4#-<7 27% 00+-1 227 5 +5 1;%'%1' 27 2 %1% 5% , 55(%'-<';(&%'1(+5-5

!334 "# / $ % $ $ #%% % #$ % $ $ % % $ %%! )$$%$ # $ ') & $% ( & % $ %(&! )$( # # 32 6#($ "# % % ! ) $$ &$$$$$ %$$$$#( (&&.$#($# $ 7% &4% %05-2-,-%27% %1% 5% + %4 #-<7-527%1+-17%'27%,7+%12'4%'5)27 2'%50 %2 5 >7 '+%-7-5 % 27*&%1 (5%,;

,(+ %4%'2')251'%%27%=-++%'57%'7(5&

'; 27% &4% 12( + 05-2- 27%'%1' *-2-5 %4- %227 227% 00+-1 27 27-<2 ,-2727%,%++&%-< + %4#-<7',- ,6#($"#$# #%$&.#4) #$$ $$$ %$ $$&& 8#%$$6#($"#

7$#$ $ $ %)# (# 4 )%$%$$! )$$ #$ $ $ % ( $ #$ & ( $ & ;( $ $ %% % % $ 7$%%#(% (&! ) $$%326#($"#(& %) $$)#$(&$. $ ( (# 4 % ! )$6#($"#$)# &$# $)4$$$#

)%$%#% $ 4 ) $ :#%8# +* *(&$ 1# 7$ & $ B #D D

%&'( ')*