High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/168/2006dismissed

Inderjit And ANR. v. State Of Hry

2022-08-02Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan12 pages

! "

##$$ % & ' (

# )

*& +"& ,+ "##$$

!"" -,*,' (

....

##$$ /& ! & )$0 1( $ 2&3,4"1 45 67

& 6/ 85 &3 )(" # &1 ,96 " : ,)$

,4"1 -!&3-

6,"(0 + " " & 6" +

6, "( 0 & 3 3 & -# - ( #( ,

&$" & " & 3-#$-# - # 7

- "

$(,""# # & +

7,#$# ("1(;"($-0 # $$ 3 <<&-+"$1 3 3 5 '

0"$0# <# ($=!1 , & 1 3 3 5 9 0#- 3 - "4"1>;"($-3 $$" #,"0+ , + " & 0 !1 # 0(>" 0"1("#$# ( 03## ?=- >" 01 3 + 1(& )$&, 0" !&0 3 " >0& " 13>;"($-&#"131 1 "1 &3"" "<# + @A ) @A )@, #+$(&# & )$ !,&# " , - 3"- 3 3" 3"1 3 " "# -*B 3 >1""&#3 " " & # -3B >" # 0 & 0 3+--@A )4 @A )*, #+$(> "0 3 1(" #+& 1("0

<" ;"($- %<-3"

$1 3",),'C& ,4"1 C& 3"--"# 3$("

$1 3",) ""#>"+ " -"& #$$ " 3"13

" " -;"($->"130 &

###( 0>;"($-=&0-#$###( 0

3- " -$$"" 13#& 3" # , # # 3# $ " 1 303"," - 3###( 0 "130& 179=3

3- >"0 $ + # $>$$"# $0 $0""$1 -# :;:;"($- $ $1 3",)"+ # : :

<"# $$ 30"" & 0 = #$# +--@A )'

<" &C0 "#$ , "10"" -$4@A )20 &3" #$ "#$ + (0# # - 0 0 &0 "

& "#$ ,"&$ 30"" # # (0 # &1 # /'

-5 ,0" + " -"& 0 ," "A" 0 $"+ 3-# :5: $$"# $ E

# /'

-5 ,;"($-#"# # ( 0"' #&"& "$=&# & 3"& +3 ,"-#$# $0 ""-$ @A- ,' ( # # " -""" -#$0 "###( 0 -#$ +3

" -$,"$$ 3 "&0# # $ " & 2, 4"1, 0" +

--""& " 03 "& $ 2&3,4"1

#" "& ,1 + 3"# - " 3 & 6"0$

3 "&, "(0 " 3" 3$(,0"", "(#$ 3&$( $- $

& 3"& + ,"# & A- "$$0 30

)F # - 5 # "

0"$"0#'

)$ ,4"1, " (;"($-"+ (#$ # &1""& $ 3 0" 0 " # # ( 1 "- & " &1-" # @A ) 3 3" &3"" # ," + " -"&0$$0 #&"$ 1 3-# :5: $$"# $ '& " "# " ,"# # (0#1(;"($-0"' &0 #&&# "$=&# * 3& " ,"0 "

7, -#$ +3 ,""# # " $ # & 87 ) "#& #$ 3 " &

)F ' ;&$# 3" )F8 @' " 3", -$0 + " +@A ) @A )E, #+$(

)F6"+! 3"""0 $ 0 1 3 3 5 9 ,0""""$& 3", &++@A ) "- "#-1 ,

'& " # +#"#("+"$ " ,0""$ "-& 3"@A )<

)F7 ;"($ -, 0 + (

+3 3 ,)FD3"1 3" )F $1 3", ),$$"-&## "# & ( - $# # &$ $(0" 3 + (# + 3+ &&-

F"""# & + 3 $&

- "&0 & 77 ) , 0""$$" - 3 &- ## 33 "-0 #&"-1&"( "$$3 3" "(

"1 $$( +$+ "

" + , " & A- " $$0 30

' $ ! 3"0A- F,0""1 &3" "$31= $ 3*(#(1 3 3 5 '

/ -

F $1 3""

7, #$# ( -"-<# "0 ! 0"" +3

' & " " " 30 + -"# ( "& "# "3 & 0 1 1$ = ## "#$

F7) " 3""&0 #=&# - +$$3!1 -""&*& 1! 3"1&0( $ 0 1("#$"= 3G="0 3"0"

0"-" $ &0

" 3 3&- ,$ $& + 1" " & - 1+, 0"" $ "- 33 + "("+$"# ##$,0""0= &#

0" 0- 3&$ " 3 + ( 0(& 3"# ("##$

##$ & 79 ) "+ 3 1 $ 1( " ##$$ /& &# " -# - & 3"# ( ##$,"-0$$0+

50""-&# 3&$ "

"+" $ & $ "##$$ H& +,$ * "' ( 13 3" &3""

<" 3 & = $ & $ " ##$$ 0"" 0 -#$ D "5) -&"" - 0 & 0 3 #(0 --&# ," 3 # !&0 &"&

'0+ , -&" " 3&- 1= "0" + ( "#$# ( "+ ( # - " - 3 " # ( 1 - ," "1 ##&1$ #$ "1&# $(," ," &$ 1 ( C& - 1 3 & 0 3 #( --&# 1 3 + ( 4& " - , 0" " &"#3" " &1(*B , %< -3 " 1 "

$1 3", ) 'C& , 4"1,0"" +"#," ," &$ 1 ( C& ( -#$ D " <"!&3-

1($ & $ "##$$

" # $%&

'( ) 3&"1$ ##$1$""# # ""," + ("1 -# + +"$# = #&1$ " 0 3 - 0 ' $ ( 1 +, 0 " + ( "#$# ( "+ (# - " 3 E " &- , " #$ 0 C& = --

4& " - ,# ""&" (," +"$0# = " ,0" " ," & 3 "+"$" #0(0" -- 0$$ #$+"$""" 1 &3" "$ <" ,"!&3- ##$1$"" # ' " "# + D 6

0 ##$1$0" # + D70 &$(-#$ 0"

<" 3&- + 1($ & $ " ##$$ 0"C& 0" 3 &# 0 #&"&& 77 ) ,0""+$ 76 6D"

3 ," - " 3&- 76" $0"# &-# &$#1$- $"&

'0+ ,"& =" """ &"- $ F" 6D " $ 0" # &-# # $$ $ # +" $& ",-(

1# &-,& $ & $" (# +,""&" -- & " #

( &3 #(" #&1 $$&1 >

1 (#&-###(,

1#$ #$ 3 0 3 ($ 0""""&$+>

(## &#$$(3 (3 &#& $#$$( # " - && ( &3 #(" # &1 $$&1 >

( - $ 0"" "+ & 3 ( # 0 " - && &3 #(" #&1 $$ &1 , ( &$"- $ -0"" ( &3 #(" # &1 $$ &1 " 1

- && , " # 0"" " $ & $( I 8

F"$A- 3"&& 77 ) ," & C& #&$$" - 3 &- ## 3 "& # & + "- 5 ( 3 " 1#&"& "& + $& 0"" "&0 &# " 1 " 0 #& 3C& &#$$( 0" 3 " &# 1 (

" 76 6D" + ($ " 3 " $& $( 0"# &-# 0" 3 A &$#1$- $"& <"1& "& # +""" &"- $,0"" " " &"+- 1$($ <" , 1$"

" " " & 0 & # "

) 1 " " & +$$ 3 " - 0"" " 1 0 + & "-,0"""("+ $ <" 13###("" 3D =3 ###( "0 + -" &" 13 C&1&$=( <" &0 A#$ "0&"13-1" "

0"""(0 +$$ $( " "-" # "#$"13 " "(0 0 " 1 3" 4 -"+ &1("# & -& "" " -& )$&,0" ! &0 3 " +0 76 6D ""& 1= 1 &# " 1 <" # -&1! ""-0 = 0 3$( &$( # 3 1 " -

=3 ###("

F" 3 "!&3- 1($ & $ "##$$ '*

" #,"-.&

'(,1( 3$2&3"& ,&" 1 C& + & 0""0" C& 0 - #&"& 3 3" &#

<" 0 "$ &$ 3 C&$"&, + "$ &$ 3- 1+," $ & $ "##$$ !

" 3&- #& 0 1($ & $ " ##$$ 0" 6 "0 -#$0" " -&" + (0# # "B 1 ,

" ,C& (# 3"+ 31 = 1(3 ( 3" " + ( <" 3&- + 1($ & $ "##$$ $+ (- <"# & "&&$$(# +" 1""&0 &# "&3C& (" 1 ""# # ( - &( 4& " -# 30""-#$# $"= #$& 3"# " - # G;'5 = ""-$ @A- ' ( <"1! $$(- + <"!&3- $&# 1($ & $ "##$$ / 0+

" #,"-.&

'( "$#&$"##$$ (-

<"& "0 "+& (# !& (-

- 3&- #& 0 1($ & $ " ##$$ 0"" $(D( 3"-#$4G

3 " -= & ( +& 1$ &- " & )##( 0 &"&1 ,0""& 3 ( " 3 # 0"#3-,$$$(0(

3"-#$""-$@A- -= ( - # &$ $(0" "# & "&&$$( # +" -# 30""# $"= #$& 3" + 3#

F" 3 " A- " # 0 $1 3"1("# & ,3 "1= +0 " # 1 &$# & C& -

$0 5# + $0# +" 1 # 1 , " + 3+ 1( " $ 0 1 ' 3 + 3 &$1A#$ 1( "&# -# 3"$0 #3 "-0"

3 " # <" # & " A- " # 0 " " ## 0 "&, 0""3"0"&"0 + $1 3" #1$( " ,"0 A- 1("# &

F"$## F ,$1 3""" + ("1 " # "3 & 0 1 1$ =## '- ( # ( 5# & - 0&$3 1$ =## 0 """&$1 + +$&1$&- 3" + $( $(1&"&01$ 0 + "0 ( "# & (

<"# & "&&$$(# +" 33 "&1( "0 1$&11(# & 3 &3"

3 , + 3 $1$+ <" $& " 3"$(- " $& " " 33 "& # + <" + ( +$+ " + ( &$ 3&"#1$( (#$ &"0"& ( "(-

5 +$ (- (# + $0&$1# &1( $ & $ "##$$ # " # + -" "-$@A- ,"-#$0 & 1" ###(" <"&0 3"$( +1(" $&

3 " # ,"&0

& 3 3 &-# - ( ",0"""- -&- + # -- $C& (" 1 <" # &

<"-#&3 !&3- + #1(" $& 0$$ ,1&# # # ## $ ## + # $0

<" $$3$( -("

<"!&3- +

&#"$0" "##$& 1 0"& (- "-- 3$(

##$$ ! & )$ 1 1$ 3 "-1("& <" 1$ $$ "2&$ 3 ,4"1 & 0 3"- -="-& 3" - 3

# $%&'

()%* $+!', &) % # *& $-.

&) %