Subhash Chander And ORS. v. State Of Punjab




    
  


     !" #!

$%&'' ( '( ))**  +(% $ % ,&

)  
   !"#

$% &'
#"'

('""

( 

- . ,/%(01( -( - $ $'%01 ('))**  - $'1*00 % ,& ))) "'

('""

 *$   ))** 2$%&'' (0 ,0 ,/%3( '%) .''1)(((')( ))*'** . '( 1 (' )% '&*% 4!#
   (.(%3)( 3 ('(5(& 
!!62' %('((.(%3)( 3 ('(3 '

%*    )53        3)  %)  '3  1  3)%.

 ,%.3      ((    # #!!8  )  &5  '  *(   *$ %.0 (9%(0 (:)%(

(% ; 3  (%<= 

& .  &5$
(' $ .'((.(   $
(' $ .'

(1*'';)( '&% 1**.$)) ;* * .;'$
( , $ .'0$
.($ .'0$
$%( .'

'()** $( (3 ;(1&5'3

''**'%(%* .;' '()( (3 ;'((3 '(;) ;()(  (9'

'($ >* '5' 3(%(;''3 '5 ;()()( .335  ( %'5 %*&))(' ;'*(.<% 5;)  5  &1  (3*  #80=  #;(.(.  '%  $
(' $ .' %'()(0 ' &5  '30   '(  &5 $
 .(  $ .'     '(  '  &5 $
$%( .' '5('*)* '(1**. $ ;* %$%&'' (  ,/%3(;(%  )(  '(3;'( , '%) .'( (% ;5 %$%&'' (  ,/%3(;((( &5')*)(5'&5$
(' $ .'  ,  '%) .';(((&5$
.($ .' $
$%( ( $ .';'*(5 .*   '% ;

%%

) . 

#  &(  % (5 3  )*  ;  **.*5 (1( (3(.'%&?@%$%&'' (&5$
('

$ .' '(*1((.;((1((3'(.')9 '(%(  '( #&(% (53)** .;'1*1 ((.;((1((3% ,&5$
.( $ .'0;'';9  133=  A  (3' % ,/%3( ( '95;()) -( *%( *';(1(0;'';9  133=

4 -(%( B42888)(9%'(9'

+ ;9  133=  * .;'(.(

( ' 3*(3'(% ,/%3(  9(';(1((3'%) .'&5$
$%( ($ .'0 ;'';9  133= 

! $)* =  "

')*%(( ;)()( 

 #4# !# #!!#;(.()(*5 . $%&'' (% #'(3 

 ## !# #!!#;(.(% ('(3.  '  ))**      , '5 ;(  (  )(*5 (  '      '(.    '  )(     ;  (3  .   ' %% 8CC04!#

  (% =3 1 ; )(1. '% **'%

'(  3   % (  $  8 8  (   ;'*   5  (3  .  1   )%    '3  )*  

      * 3)* '( )     ;  '    '  *     ' *.*13&*5'*  &(%(5#!!#'5' %))( '     ;'  %*3*5 ;     '  ('(  %))(  ' ))   '5  ;(  **5  3)*    '    %    '  *%  **.(1('1& 3(3'3 ;(    
    >#  -'  B*  ;  =3   ;' )'9' <% &* .'3 ''&

( .'(   %'%(( **.9)*' )(3  &(%(50#!!#  B( (*%(  ( '1 

(( *%'')(% ')(1&5 

 ( &*%& **'%;( 1('  )% '&*% 8CC04!#   *&1  0')( ))* 
&(%.'' '%(' ' (.()(*5% ('(3.  '))** 2 $%&'  ' (        ,    %  '1     &

<% ';(* '1' $%)(   0   (*  *0  (:)%(    .  '  )(   %5  % (.   &5  '    ))**   '((0  ,%.3   " !4 #!

!)(  .  ## !# #!!#% ( $ #'(3;)* ((%*53)  &5 1')%5$%)(    *0$%&1

&'(0 :*9 
 (3&5*( % *('$'  3*((  .2% ,'*& <% &5'(*%( '(.(% ('(3  B( (*%( '% ('(3 (. .'(%.''1  *%'$%&'' (  ,( *'& %&')(%

; % &* )(1 (1(5  '  (3 (3 '3 
 1(&5*( % *(' $' ))*'&

)(((6 ( . ',%.3   '))**  ')( '1&  1 (' )% '&*% 4!#0;''(% ( D4!#  3&* .( )%() 33 .5 E >'1(0 53(') .'0'**&  1(3()( 3&*(')%() 33 .  50  '**  &  )% '  ;'  (.(%

, 3)( 3   (    (3  ;''  35  =     1

5(0 '***&*&*  F  (.(13 ')(% ;'' %;( *5;)  *% .((3 ;''  (*  '  '5  '  3&*  (  '  )%()   33 .5 (*%( ''% ''(. % 8CC
 %& &5'1  (( =)('1 .& **.*5%  '((3 '9(''( '(1  ((';'' %'.'((3&*()%()33 5 '( '(1  (( ' 3 
*3((('';)   ((3 '9(' ;( 1()(%&('(*%( '  
( (6'95**.*5  ,/%3(' * & )(%  '%'1& <%

'(.(. '3% ('(3()

'**.*(30%  ')(% * 3*' '( 1  ((,%5' 1

  '  %  % (  $  4!# 
    '  .1     (%3    <% *50  )(   ))*    **;  
3)%.

 ,%.3     ((    # #!!8  (         **  ' ))** (<%''(.. '3  "-(

%*5 0#!

$./0

(