Banarsi Dass & ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS
!
"#$%&$&'
(# )* (+ + +
, )* (++ +, - , ! "#$#%&'# ()( ! ## *"#+%&'# ( , !!# *"% -%.#/ + +
, ./012 " -#$ #'"#1#% ++#* "#*2# #
(&'#*# #$( 2#3# #"# &' 2#'" &( '4(" .#/++#*5$$)#6*+#7'%896"#(( "'#++#":'(89:7"*"#'$#"#
,48; 6< =47% " 5++' ''
'("&'( "%($" +# #
#"#"#'$#=##+ /("'$
++#"1%"/1<=4"# #'>/*#''+&(' />+1%"'"+
&
-#$ #'"#1# ''% ' " $#3* ( <'("/*#''+&&'(&'6< =47"*"*#&' /("5++' '' , " +# 5++' ''% ' 2##( ("/1"&'(&'6<= 47/'$*''(++1#'$ ++1<'"#2## ( /'#$?@88@6<=;7"# </'$'"#++*/("5 ? "##$#1%#
#"#'"++2" ##/+/'##'/"#+((".*$ / " '$ + # (('#' <' ( " 2## ( 6 #7% " $#3*##
#+>#<=4%/("'$ #
++# #"1 " # #' # &#+ /1 < =% 2"/1 " .*$ /% " /( " 5
'##/.'#*#"<'#*#" '$/#%"("2##( %#"" *"#".*$/##"A &" +# @ "#/&*/'#$% %"52"+ '* 5B ,4@9 ( 8; #" '+* " '+##1+(&=#=&" +#>#"'"+= -#$#'"#1#''5>+1%2##*"#(+#'3 (+&*"-#$#'"#1#''%"/1/'$
%
#/+#(('#'<'/*$#(<= 4 9 &#+/1<=%"#/.'/'#$ $ # +#+1 #( $#+ ( " # /.'% # '"#++*"#/$#<= 4 "+#'+(" #*"#' "5"#5B,4@9(8;6<=@7%#/'#$ /("5%#"#'(" ' (" %"# '#+"''+1 $#&' '&+1/1"5++'#" '% #'"#1#%.
#/%2"/1#'+##1'/'#$#'' ># " +# &=#=& " -#$ #'"#1# '' 5>+1%#*"#"<' %#/'#$+# /("5++'''("/1<'67/*$#( < =4%2# " /1"'6 #7 6<=@7 # /'#$'/1"5 ; !%2""/1%&#++&&=#=&" +# " ' "+ -#$ #'"#1# '' C2&% " #/& $# /$ & ( $ # >/.' 8 " # ( .
'
#'"#1#''%($#3*'"$## %( *"#( (" +#%# /'#$"+/1"(#"&' %" /("5
!"
#$ %&
'
'
('
'
) ' &
&$*
"2#3("#+/1/'$*#*" -#$#'"#1#''%#
#"#"/1"/*# ''+&&'(&'%#/'#$/1"5++' ''6<=47%""'"+-#$#'"#1# ''%#<' %#%"#<'
%"2##( /'#$
$ #&+1%"2##( /'#$ ?@88@%#'"%"2##( /'#$% " '#/'#$$#/1"5,?88@% %5B ,4@9(8;6<=@7"*"<=@% " 5>#"*#*#"' '&+1'/1 "5++'%#%" '#'"#1#.#/%2"/1"1 #*" '+##"-#$#'"#1#%12" +/12#+( "-#$#'"#1#''%#3'" $# (*"#( ( " +#%2"'"2#"A+1"+/1" % " /("5
3
, 5>+1% " (+* ( " <' ( "/1*"'$ +#(('#'<'/*$# ( " &' ( &'% # # /1 " 5++' '' 6<=47%"'#/#/#'"#1#&#+$1 2"'"2#"'$ ++1"$#("&'' /1"56<=@7 ?
#
#"# " '("
#''*"5"*""(+*5B,4@9( 8;%"'("+(+1#'"#++*/*$#" &#+1("#''*(" '+##1'" -#$#'"#1#%"*" '&+1#2&'/1"5++' '' # " 5$$ ''% / " '"'"#++*<=4%"/1"$6 #7"
#(" '(" %#"'## '"#++*<=4% "/*##1"## #1 %""/1##$"#/#*2#&*" '"#++*<=4 5>+1"/1"/'#$
/>+1 "<'("2##( %#/'#$
"&'6<=47%#/'#$'/1"5% '#++12"+/1/'#$*#"'"+-#$ #'"#1# ''% " #''#' 2" +#2% " # ( ( " +# % ($ "
'(" #"$($ " @ !&%#+2""2##( "#&/
'$ ++1#''(++1<'%"(%"# /'$(' "104 0
5 ! 60 9
'>'% " 5 ( $ " 2
#'#$ 4 "2 #''*+1$ ; #' 8 ' " $# '# +( "# / '% "% #++
*#
+'#67%(#1%# (#'" /+ +
,2 /+, - ,2 $%&$&'
3#&*" B"" #3*D# ED B"" #/+ ED