High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/689/2004dismissed

Sucha Singh v. State Ofpb.

2015-01-08Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik10 pages

"#$

$%&'& ) "(*"+, -

*%/"

2"3"

44444 55$33"(# 6'4 #"#$

*(7"8 44444 $'5 (9$(#

4 :/$#/$+ $5 +#$+'

%"3 5"5$+'

;", "33 <$9

'$$ 7*90;$(#=

$++$9

$5 +#$+'

#= >4 :/$#/$+ 7*90;$(# '/ *39 +#$9 &0$'#= +4 44"(9/*- 9?

%"#$

"55$33"(#4 '4 &("@'/& ,"3- -

*(7"84

/&'

%+&;&("3 "55$"3 &('#&#*#$9 *%/"

2"3" "55$33"(#4 55$33"(#

@$9

;;&##&(0 "(

$(%$ 5*(&'/"83$ *(9$+ $%#& .

"+% #&% +*0'

',%/ #+ 5&% *8'#"(%$'

%#- .- /$+$&("

%"33$9 A %#A-

@$$5&(0 ''$''& @04

%/*++"

55, /$"9'

5$+;&#

3&%$('$4 *90$ 5$%&"3 *+#-

?&9$ 7*90;$(# 9"#$9 4>4 (?&%#$9

+$'"&9

$(%$ 5"''&(0

+9$+

'$(#$(%$

$?$( 9"#$- '$(#$(%$9

*(9$+0

+&0 *'

&;5+&'

(;$(#

,$"+'

5",

&($

.-B 9$ "*3# %3"*'$

*+#/$+ *(9$+0

+&0 *'

&;5+&'

(;$(#

&?$ (#/'4 '

5$+ '$%*#& %"'$-

44 - "0+*5 "3 (0

3&%$

&%&"3'

5+$'$(# "# 8*'

'#"(9 ?&33"0$ /"(+"

(($%#& %/$%@&(0

'*'5$%#$9 5$+'

('4

*8$0/ /"9 "%+ ''

#/$;

&($9 3&%$ 5"+#,4 :/&3$ #/$, <$+$ &(0

?&33"0$ C"(09 & @4;4 "/$"9

?&33"0$ /"(+"- '$$( ;&(0 '%

D- %"++,&(0 8"0

+$"+ '$"#

#$+4 ( '$$&(0 3&%$ 5"+#,- #+&$9

+$#+$"# 8*# "55+$/$(9$9

8"'&'

'*'5&%& (4 "0+*5 &(0/- /"?&(0 '*'5&%& ''$''&

("+% #&% '*8'#"(%$ "55+&'$9 /&;

"8 +&0/#

0$# '$"+%/ (9*%#$9

"E$##$9

&%$+

"0&'#+"#$-

$F$+%&'$9

5#&

"E$##$9

&%$+4 ('$(# ;$;

F4 5+$5"+$9 +$0"+94

+;"#& '$(#

/*5&(9$+7&# 6&+@-

#/+ *0/ <&+$3$''

+$"%/$9 '5 #4

9&'%3 '$9 &9$(#&#,

$+$9 /&;

'$"+%/

8"0 *39 (9*%#$9

#/$+ "E$##$9

&%$+

8*# '$9 &9$(%$

('$(# '#"#$;$(# F4 +9$9

$%#4 /$+$"

#$+-

9&+$%#& ('

- '$"+%/

8"0 (9*%#$9

"0+*5 55, /*'@

*(9 8"04 <

'";53$'

. 0+";'

$"%/ <$+$ #"@$(

?$+$9 55, /*'@- </$+$"'- +$;"&(9$+ <$&0/$9

> @0 . 0;'4 5*# '";$ 8"04 '";53$'

8"0 <$+$ '$5"+"#$3, '$"3$9 '$"3 AA

8$"+&(0 &;5+$''& 4 ";53$'

?$+$9 55, /*'@ <$+$ #"@$( &(#

''$''& ?&9$ ;$;

5$+'

("3 '$"+%/

"%%*'$9"55$33"(# B %*++$(%, #$'

<$+$ ?$+$9 '";$ <$+$ #"@$( &(#

''$''& ?&9$ ;$;

F4 *G"

F4 '$(#

3&%$

> '#"#&

+$0&'#+"#&

</$+$*5

+;"3

F4 B +9$9 *+9$$5 &(0/4 *0/ '&#$ 53"( F4

53"%$

5+$5"+$94 5$%&"3 +# H4 '$(#

'5 #4

( +$"%/&(0 3&%$ '#"#& (I 5$+#,- "%%*'$9

<$+$ 9*%$9

('5$%# $<"

&(0/- </

?$+& &$9

"%#'

&F$9 '$"3 8$"+&(0 &;5+$''& AA

5"+%$3'

#/$(

9&+$%#& "0+*5 9$5 '&#$9 5$+#,

3&%$ '#"#&

'$"3'

&(#"%#4 ( ($F# 9",- "0+*5

@ 5$+#,

"%%*'$9"55$33"(#I 9*%$9 '";$

33"G"

+$G*$'# F4 ?$+& &%"#&

'";53$'-

+9$+$9 5$+#, @$5# "3@/"("

3&%$ "# +$'5 ('&8&3&#,

(?$'#&0"#&(0

&%$+ 5"''&(0

+9$+ F4

B4 '";53$ '$(#

+$('&% %&$(%$ C"8 +"# +,

%/$;&%"3 $F";&("#& ?&9$ +# F4

*(9

%/*+"

55, /$"9'

;53$#&

&(?$'#&0"#& (- %/"33"(

&3$9 "0"&('# "55$33"(#4

&(9&(0 5+&;"

"%&$ "0"&('# "55$33"(#- %/"+0$ '/$$#$9 /4

446&+@- #/$( *90$- 5$%&"3 *+#-

?&9$

+9$+ 9"#$9 44

;;&##&(0 "(

$(%$ 5*(&'/"83$ *(9$+ $%#& .

9&9 53$"9 0*&3#, 8*# %3"&;$9 #+&"34 #"@&(0 '$%*#& $?&9$(%$- '#"#$;$(#

+9$9 *(9$+ $%#& >> +4 44 </$+$&( 9$(&$9 $"%/ '$%*#& "33$0"#& 53$"9$9 &(( %$(%$4 9$ $(%$- &# 53$"9$9

&(( %$(#I

"3'$ 8$$( 53"(#$9 *5 /&;

"++$'#&(0 /&;

?&33"0$I

"%#

$%#$9

/&;4 /$"+&(0 #/ '&9$'

"55+"&'&(0 $?&9$(%$ "?"&3"83$

&3$- *90$- 5$%&"3 *+#-

(?&%#$9

;;&##&(0 "(

$(%$ 5*(&'/"83$ *(9$+ $%#& .

%# "3'

'$(#$(%$9 /&;

*(9$+0

+&0 *'

&;5+&'

(;$(#

,$"+'

5",

&($

.-B4 9$ "*3#

5",;$(#

&($

*+#/$+ *(9$+0

+&0 *'

&;5+&'

(;$(#

&?$ (#/'

+$'"&9

$(%$4 0"&('# 7*90;$(#

(?&%#&

+9$+

'$(#$(%$- *5

*+#4 /"?$ /$"+9 *('$3

#"#$ *('$3- "55+"&'&(0 $(#&+$ ;"#$+&"3 $?&9$(%$ ;&(0

+94 C$"+($9 *('$3

"''"&3$9 &;5*0($9 7*90;$(#

(?&%#&

*+#

(3,

*(#'4

&+'#3,- 9$3", '$(9&(0 '";53$

C '$% (93,

*8$0/ &(9$5$(9$(# <&#($''

0&?$( *5 /"?&(0 8$$( <

?$+ #/*'

$F";&($94 (#$(9$9 *('$3

*8$0/ &($9 &(9$5$(9$(# <&#($''

8*# $F";&($9 <&#($''

*+#4 $ 0&?$( *5 /"?&(0 8$$( <

?$+ "''&0(&(0 ?"3&9 +$"'

(4 &;53$ '#"#$;$(#

*83&%

'$%*# +$0"+9 $( *0/4 (3,

*(% ++ +"#$9 '#"#$;$(#'

&%&"3 <&#($''$'-

(?&%#& %"( 8"'$94 "9 *8$0/ 8$$( $F";&($9 <&#($''- 0$(*&($($''

. '$%*#& < *39 /"?$ 8$% @( <(4 '

'*%/-

*(#- '$%*#& %"(( '"&9

+$$

*8# 8$($ &#

*8#

0&?$(

"%%*'$94 "8 ?$ (#$(#&

*('$3

'*'#"&("83$4 #+*$ +*3$

5+*9$(%$ 9$;"(9'

'/ *39 '

++ +"#& #/+ *0/ &(9$5$(9$(# '

*+%$

'#"#$;$(#'

&%&"3 <&#($''$'

8*# &

&(9$5$(9$(# <&#($''

#/ *0/ &($9 '$%*#& (- '/ *39 0&?$( *5 /"?&(0 8$$( <

?$+ "%%*'$9- < *39

"#"3

'$%*#& $?$(#*"3&#,- 3&"8&3&#,

"E$##$9

&%$+ < *39 "3<",'

$%#$9 (#$(9$9 #"#$ *('$3

$%#$9 - ''&8&3&#,

"3'$ &;53&%"#&

#/$+$4 /$+$

;"#$+&"3

&3$

'/ < (?$'#&0"#&(0

&%$+

#/$+ 3&%$

&%&"3 &(&;&%"3

"%%*'$9"55$33"(#4 '*55 +#

/$+ (#$(#& (- *('$3

#"#$ %&#$9 7*90;$(# #&#3$9

4 /$ "3'

%&#$9 7*90;$(# #&#3$9

!- &# 8$$( /$39

+*3$

3"< $?&9$(%$

3&%$

&%$+ %"(( "%%$5#$9 *(3$''

&# ++ +"#$9 5"(%/ <&#($''

3&%$

&%$+

#/$+<&'$ 9$5$(9"83$4 , %&#&(0 "( #/$+ 7*90;$(# #&#3$9 "#

$ % &# "+0*$9 #"#$ *('$3

+$%&#$9 7*90;$(#- &(9$5$(9$(# <&#($''

&($9 8*# $F";&($94 '

&# /$39 &# (

"#"34 %%*'$9 "3'

$F";&($9 '"&9 <&#($''

9$ $(%$4 (?&%#& %"( 8"'$9

$?&9$(%$

&%&"3'

<&#($''$'

</$( &(?$'#&0"#& / ($'#4 /*'-

"8 ?$ 9&'%*''& (- &# %"( '"

$3, (%3*9$9 (?&%#& %"( <$33 8"'$9

#$'#&;

(&$'

&%&"3 <&#($''$'

'";$ &('5&+$ &9$(%$ ;&(9

*+# +$0"+9&(0 0*&3#

"%%*'$9I &

'";$ "+$ ('&'#$(#- 0$(#- (?&(%&(0- +$3&"83$ #+*'#< +#/,4

"3'

'$##3$9 '&#&

3"< #$'#&;

(&$'

&%&"3 <&#($''$'

"+$ "# 5"+ #$'#&;

(&$'

(

&%&"3 <&#($''$'4

(3,

"%% *(#

($F";&("#&

&(9$5$(9$(# <&#($''$'

"%G*&##$9 #/$( +$3&"8&3&#,

'#"#$;$(#'

"E$##$9

&%$+ < *39 "3<",'

$%#$9- #/*'- &# %"(( '"&9 &

&(9$5$(9$(# <&#($''$'

"+$ $F";&($9 #/$( #$'#&;

(&$'

"E$##$9

&%$+

('&'#$(# '#"#$;$(#'

&%&"3 <&#($''$'

< *39 8$3&$?$94 /"(9- *('$3

"&3$9

&(#

$?$( '&(03$ 9&'%+$5"(%, '#"#$;$(#'

/*5&(9$+7&# 6&+@ :- "0+*5 : ('5$%# $<"

: 4 #$'#&;

(&$'

"+$ ('&'#$(#

&(# @04

55, /*'@ ?$+$9

8"0 %"++,&(0

+$"+ '$"#

8$"+&(0

: ?$9

+$'"&9 '%

<($9 "%%*'$9"55$33"(# *%/"

&(0/4 5,

44 F4 ?$9 +$0"+94

*90$ 5$%&"3 *+#-

+9$9 7*90;$(#

(?&%#&

8"'&'

#$'#&;

(&$'

&%&"3 <&#($''$'

($ "E$##$9

&%$+

+"(@

D *+#

&(9'

&33$0"3&#,4 ($F# "+0*$9 *('$3

%"'$- "33$0$9 $

$%#$9

44 </$+$"'

5$+

&9"?&#

44 *5&(9$+ F4 - '$(# '";53$ #/+ *0/ ('#"83$

"@&+ /"(9

#$'#

44 4

+$'"&9 '";53$ +$%$&?$9 8"%@ 44 *5&(9$+ :> '

87$%#& "(9- #/$+$"

#$+- '";$ '$(#

#$'#

D44 4 '

('&9$+"83$ 9$3", '$(9&(0 '";53$

#$'#4 '

5$+ '#"(9&(0 &('#+*%#& ('

"+% #&% (#+ *+$"*- $< $3/&- '";53$ +$G*&+$9

'$(#

%/$;&%"3 $F";&("#& <&#/&( / *+'4 ( "%% *(#

?& 3"#&

+$'"&9 &('#+*%#& ('- $(#&#3$9

"%G*&##"34 '*55 +#

(#$(#& (- %&#$9 7*90;$(#'

#&#3$9 #

&' (( )!! #

&' (($ $* ,

(() *)#-

(( !)*

"%#'

%&+%*;'#"(%$'

+$'"&9 7*90;$(#'

"+$ '&;&3"+

"%#'

5+$'$(# %"'$4 5+$'$(#

<&(0 9",

&4$4 44 - 5$+#, <$33 '";53$'

<$+$ 9*%$9

33"G"

?&9$ "553&%"#& F4

3"G"

"3'

5"''$9

+9$+ F4 B

C +# F4 2- %3$"+3, '/ <'

'$"3

'";53$ +$%$&?$9

C <$+$ &(#"%#4 ?$(

&9"?&#

4 *5&(9$+ &(0/- F4

"G*&+ /"(9 : .- F4 *53$9 '#"#$;$(#

"0+*5 :- ;53$#$ 3&(@ $?&9$(%$4

*+'$

44 </$( '";53$ '$(#

#$'#- &# +$#*+($9 '

87$%#& ('

8*# 3"#$+

+$;

?&(0

87$%#& '";53$ "0"&( '$(#

%/$;&%"3 $F";&("#&

D44 $?&9$(#

&9"?&#

4 *5&(9$+ &(0/- F4

*+'$ <&#($''$'

*39 #$33 "8

87$%#& '";53$ +$#*+($9- ,$# <$33 <&#/&( +&0/#'

0$# E(";%/"

(#"&($9 +$0&'#$+ - '*;;

*+#

@( <

87$%#& 8*# 9&9

#/"#4 "8'$(%$

'";$ &# %"(( '"&9

87$%#&

'";53$ ($?$+ #"@$(

44 4

'";53$ +$#*+($9

87$%#&

44 </$( 44*5&(9$+ :> %"#$0 +&%"33, 9$5 '$9 <",

&9"?&# F4 '";53$ +$#*+($9

/&;

9"#$ &4$4

44 '$"3'

&(#"%#

*+#/$+ '

(0 '";53$ +$;"&($9 %*'# 9, 9, #";5$+ '$"3'- &# %"(( '"&9 ''&8&3&#,

#";5$+&(0 '$"3'

'";53$'4

# ./ "

+$"'

9$3", '$(9&(0 '";53$ "''"&3$9 '$%*#&

9*$

9*#&$'A #/$(

$?&9$(%$ 3$9 '$%*#& +$0"+94 , . / " #/$ $?&9$(%$

&%&"3 <&#($''$'

*(+$3&"83$ *(#+*'#< +#/,

*+#/$+ $(#+,

#"@&(0 5$+#,

33"G"

#+&"3 *+# ;$(#& ($9 "3@/"("

+$0&'#$+

$F53"("#&

;"@&(0 $(#+,- </$+$"'

/"(9 '

'&#*"#& (4 - ./ "(?$'#&0"#&(0

&%$+

$F";&($9 9&$94 ?$( #<

$'%"5$9

'5 8*# "++$'#$9 3"#$+

&9$(#& &%"#& 5"+"9$

(9*%#$9- </$+$"'- /"(9- #$'#&;

(&$'

&%&"3 <&#($''$'

"+$ ('&'#$(#- #+*'#< +#/,

&('5&+$ &9$(%$ ;&(9

*+# +$0"+9&(0 0*&3#

$?$( 5$+#, 9*%$9

33"G"

'$"3'

&(#"%#

($F# 9",

8$($ &# %"( 0&?$(

"%% *(#

9$3", '$(9&(0 '";53$

#$'#4

#/$+ &(# *+0$9

;$4 / +#

+$5$#&#& (- *+#

&(9'

&33$0"3&#, 7*90;$(#

(?&%#&

+9$+

'$(#$(%$ +9$9 *90$ 5$%&"3 *+#-

'$%*#& '*%%$$9$9 8+&(0 / 0*&3# "0"&('#

@$$5&(0 ''$''& @0

55, /*'@ 5$+;&#

3&%$('$ #/$+$8, ;;&##&(0 "(

$(%$ 5*(&'/"83$ *(9$+ $%#& .

4 4 44%#4

+$'"&9 +$"'

(- "55$"3 8$&(0 ;$+&#-

+9$+$9

9&';&''$94

8"&38"&3 (9'- '/"33 '#"(9 %"(%$33$9 #"@$( %*'# 9,

'$+?&(0 +$;"&(&(0 5$+&

'$(#$(%$4 (%$+($9 /&$

*9&%&"3 "0&'#+"#$- '/"33 #"@$ ($%$''"+, '#$5'-

;53, 7*90;$(#- 9*$ ;5#&#*9$- @$$5&(0 ?&$< "553&%"8&3&#,

?&'& ('

$%#&

+&;&("3

%$9*+$ 9$- '*8;&# ;53&"(%$ +#-

*+#- <&#/&( 5$+&

(#/'-

9"#$

+$%$&5#

&'#+&%# $''& ('

*90$-

"#&"3"- '/"33 $('*+$ 9&+$%#& ('

"+$ ;53&$9 <&#/- <&#/&( #&;$

+";$-

;53&"(%$ +# '*8;&##$9 &;;$9&"#$3, #/$+$"

#$+4 $0&'#+, '/"33 @$$5 #+"%@

'*8;&''&

;53&"(%$ +#'- 5*# *5 5"5$+'

</$#/$+ +#'

"+$ +$%$&?$9

#- <&#/&( #&;$

+";$- &;;$9&"#$3, $F5&+,

#$%& ';+&#&