← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/807/2013dismissed

Rajender v. State Of Haryana

2022-06-02Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra17 pages

       

 !"#$"%&'&#( )



    

***  + , - -- + , -,,   ./0"123    ! "#$ # # 

 % & %  '

 **** ,,  4

  (" ")" 

 *   *

+

  ") $!"!    !     $!)   

"    ,- ./ ,.-01$ $)  ,0 ./ ,.-0*

 "

" "2$! 3"* " )"

 !$"



 ))"" $"* $ 

"04567# $!"!$") ")  "  " -.

...+"$

 ) " $  $!")

") ")  )  " 368 04,  -9 -. ,.-,$

"0,004567# 7  "$&$

%" "

3"* ,

  " " -9 -. ,.-, ": ;)  "

" "  ""  5-! !"#$ 0(6 2    

 0.7 &8-&(/9: ;;) <

!-9  $ # +66 )  )

" ;: 7,< !"   ;

$<  "!   *:$

$

"!"  ;4<! *$! * ")"  ) 

!"

* "!*

$ $ 

!  $*

:$ $

* !$   ) * *  "

!"

"!* "

 $ 

!   "  $"! ) !"

* "! *    "  $     *    $   

!     -, -. ,.-,    *$  -=0.   ;)""! <  !"  ))"

   $  $

")  *$! )

  ">)  ? *" 

! " 36;: 7-9<!"  " ":)"

+

!

:)" ""

 !   ;: 74< !" *

 & ) 3"

 "  *   "  7 ":    "+ !"

  :)" "       -9 -. ,.-,;: 79<""

"   "! " ) "



:")  * ! " *-5 -@"

)!"":) "

"  )  ":  "!$

"-59# 7 # ;: 7-A<  $!"

+

;: 7-5<



$   

$  -5 -. ,.-, )"

+ !

:)" ""

 !

  ;: 7@<  "

+

;: 7-.<



$ 

  # ""

     ./ -, ,.-,  ;: 75<    * "  ) 7"

' ) "  

" 3"*

" )"

 *"  ":    

 ,.

 -AAA  ) "

    

)

"" "! " "    "!$

"-40 # 7 # ;<  !" 

$" #$

3""!

 

$ !+ 

))""  $"* $

"0-, 0,0 045/.5 67#

"97

"#"

):$ ? 

,.-, ($* " "

  ":)"7B+-  # *  7B+,  ! 

 ! "#$

7B+0  ) 7B+9% 8  !!

"

?"

   

3"* 7B+/ )7  "

&"

(  ' ) "   

" 7B+5% )"

"

?"

 7B+4 % 7 7B+@# * $) 7B+A $)

% )  7B+-. # *     $) 7B+-- # *   ) # 7B+-, # * )

7B+-0 $*6

 "

"!

6 "! "!?"

 7B+-0)"

") ":;!

$)* 7B+-0* (" #$ <7B+-9 &'

 26#

3"*     !"

"!  $  )""!  "

  *"!  $ 

" 

* 7$* 7   /  

$ "  ) 

$ "! $  

"  0-0  # 7 #     " 

" ")" "!) "  ") *$ "

! "

!" ") 

$ ""  *  ")

" "  $   

""$ *

 " )"

":   "C$ "$ !"!"*

"* "))

=

" "

$""

"C)  ":! !"   !" ") 6" 

$  :)""" %B+-  % "

%B+, &)"! !   6$ " ?

" "  "

" "2$!



$ "$!) 

"  " )  "

* @ B   $   





    $  "

:)"   "

*    $ 

    

(" #$ "



" %B+- % "

;)  ":< !"

  "

"

 $*"!*

"* 

"

$! ;

":<   $!      )

"      !"  

! )"  

$ $!  ":$  "

"

 ")"

"

""

! 

" 

 

"";%B+- % "

<$  ": )":$ "

")"

))* 

$""

 "C)  ":! ")

"    $ $!  %B+, &)"! !6$ "

    

   )

    !"

    

")! 

  

 )"* "

 ))*")"

))* $  $! " 

 !"

")"

))*;

"! " $)*<      "!  "      )  

)) "  "

   1$"

< ") ** $  ))"



!  "

" $!  $ $!   

! "   ": :$

$

* ;

"<  !  "  ) * )$

")     )"

 !" ":)"

"!  "! "

          :$  $

  * 

  * 

": $ $! * "$)& 

":

* ) !" *       $*

    :$  $

  $   $!   "

" """ ) "   

"

"$

"")"

" $ "$

 "

 "

  ** $*  1$

$!) 

" 1$ $)  "* * "$



"

* 1$"

 !

!" ") -.

?             $    )

 !$ "  "

 !"

* "!

!  " "!  $ $! 7B+-0 ":



" "

*: !"

 "

"$ 7B+0);) " ":< 

)  $ B"

! ")7B+5% )"



 ""

$"!:)" ""

"

 "! "

 !    ": !"

 " ""

"*"

:$ "  $   ":   * $ $ $ $! " "! $!!

$ " * "!:$ 

"" )""

 !

  ;: 7@< $   $!)  ":

) ;%B+, % "

< )  $$*;

"<   ")""

  *!"

"! !  ) * "!

" * (" #$

* $

": $"! "

"* (" #$  !"

  $!  !"!)"   )  *$

" &

" $ $! " $ $  "$   " 

"

"

 * :$

$

"! "$!    & "!" " $ ))"

*

 *"!



 * (" #$ --  "! " $*)"")*  $

  "  $ $     

" "" " " !  "* 7B+-0 ":

" "

*:   *" ".0 -- -AA@ ;" # ""

 ./ -, ,.-, : 75 "$*7"

' ) "  

"

3"*  *" "    * ,.

 -AAA<*     ))"

  $  ")   "!

$     $-- !   :$

$

$ ))$&) ") $  ) ")$ :$

$

 $    " !!$ --+-,;!

   -- ,." ")"

< ! !  !   )  "

*  $     $-0 ! * "! $

"

*

    $   "?

* ,.-,  "$"!    $ !":$

*$*  $    $!*"!  $ "

 "*$  

"!

  "

&"!  )$

$"

 )"   "C  )  7B+0  ) )     "    ":

"

* "! ")7B+-0 ": !"

 ""

":" "$!  ":     ))"

"!!$  $!!  ;

":< & ! $ ;7B+0)<$  

": ""

     " "!

"

$   " $

$ *&"

 7B+0 ) ""

 ":    *"! " * "  ! 

"$

$

" " $  7B+5% )"

 $

)"

+

! :)" "  ":

 !"

 " "" "*"

:$ "  $  *$ $  (  )" ":"")  "  !"

8 "

"  7B+-0 ":7B+0)

"

+"

)"

!"

%B+- % "

;)  ":< *"! 

!$")"$! 

$  )  $ ":

  " 

  $

 ": " " "   "$$  ": $    $"!) $

    ! ( ":$

$

$  ":    )  " 



  !         )   ;%B+-     % " 

<     $

 "! $  )  $$* ;

$"< 

") ":

 ")""

" :$

$

*  !*$   )  $!$  ! *$     )"  -, 3)       "

*          "

 " 

  * " ") 

") ":

$     :

$"!"

  :

       )"

       "   "&"!    $

 "!     "D " ) "* )"

 "



*  "  8!"  

"!"

"  "$   "!:

")" " "$ 

$   !"    )$  !"    ""

"!

*   :

  ")"

 ) "& ) "  "D "*  "   -0 "



"

 

" * $      ")      ":     $     

)

"!&"! * " (  ":

") "*  "$"

 ( ")

")   :$  $

 "   $       )

"!    "

 "

&"! * " )

#$ $ """

"

"! ")

"):$ $





$ ")" " " " $ * "*  6 " 



"

  * "  "

"$"

"  "  ") ":" 1$")  *$ !$"  $ $!"

 " $)

;  )" "

"""!""

" ""  ) 

":$  *!$ "!$  " "* "  -9 6  

  

     ;  .&7&( 8 ;

>* $ )#$ " $ 

=+     

    

      

            

                        

   

    

          

          

         

               !

         "                   #            

   

 

     $

     

 

         %            

    

&!'"(       $    

    

           # 



   

 !)"*         +  *

 #    

      

      !,"*     !-"* 

  #     

        

  

    !."           



 

  

      

  

 !/"          

 

   !0"

%

       !1"

* 

 

             



  



        

     !2"%                  



    !'3"%  

    

   4              

 



    

 !''"%

               

           

!')"%   



         

 

 $

         #          5 -/ >* $ )#$ "       

 ;;) - =) 

"!* "=+ 6  

 $                 (              

   

 % 

           

     % 

           %                      

  

  

  

             

   

 

  

      

  

  

#     

 

    

     



  

     #

  

  

       7      



%         

       

       #                                   5 -5 !"! "

 !"

"" ;%B+- % "

<$  ": )":$ "

 "

)"

))* "$ !"!""))

" " !$ 

$ "

$""

 "C) ;7B+0)< ":! ")



"      "

 "  *   $!  ")   7B+0  )    "  "! ") ":;7B+-0<    * $  "));7B+0<   $!! "

    $"!  +:)" "  !"!  "  "$ !   "  ")) 

"   $ "

"! ":"

 

"    "  $!! "     " ") 

":;7B+-0<

" "

*:

$!

!"

  "    " $!! "  6  "   "  *   "

"" " 

 "!   -4 B"



!   )"

 7B+5 % )"

 $

)"

! :)" " ":



!"

  $!:)" " ":

!"

"  )"

     "! *$  "     ""  "*"

    :$

"  $  *$ $

 -@ 6  .&>9+'  "?!  ##>  #$  "1&% 8  0.&'@.01"(%"  (1 #?&%#8#/34"

** $=+   

 &     

     

        

           

      

   7       

       

                8 -A (  0.+'9" "( 8, A#$(1& 4) !9 1( ;<<B#84

/" )  "

"* $= 89   

  



     8 ,.

6 #1&+'  "?!  ##>  #$  "1&% 8  0.&'@.01"(%"  (1 #?&%#8#/3

'!1( /" ); 4"

** = 8%    

    

             



  

:       

                       

   

       7  

      

 7       

       

                8 ,- 6  38#.+'  .&(%&@8"'  (1  . %!&%"  #$  "1&% 8

0.&'@.01"(%" !@ /");

 ""$= 8(

      

   

    %

  

    

       #   

    

8 ,, 6 7 (  C07 .  B'  -! !"  #$   .3 ( 4  =      .&7&( 8;

<-   C* $ )#$ 

" "



1$ " " " $)    "$  

  * $=+  %    

    

                

  

:                         

  

 

    

  

   %      

    

   

 ,0/:8 ,0 >* $ )#$ "    ! " #

 ;;-) <4  +$

$)* "$ 

")> "

  * " ")$  

 ""

   ))"

 $  " !  $    ":

,9 6  231" 1238"/ 8."@."'"(! !&D"D'

-! !"  #$  C". 8 4 

 -0@."7"  #0.!   '"'  )

  C* $ )#$   "

* "$")&

"   ":) * ""

  

""

$ "

")" " 

$ 

 ) $   ,/ ($! "!$ &"

 !"!  " !"! )

" * ":$ !$)  *"* 



"

"* ) " "

"!  "  ") "     "    !$    $*      

":  !"

*$  *

   * $ )

"  !   )

 " " )

"   (

! "

= * $ " >

$ $ )E"

 $* )    ) ) "D"

 (  "

!"! )

" "$    "

""



""  6 -! !"B".'0'0.7""!-&(/94 ;;)-0@."7"

#0.!

;

4>* $ )#$ * $=+ 8%       #           

     ;6    

    

  

 



  

       

     

                   

   8 ,5 6  "    ": $*

   :$

) "* $"! !!$ 

)"  "$ ) $!$ &

! $ !$ 

  6 " "  "

"  "! )

  " ""!""

,4 6 " 

 " $)    "

*   "  ")

"

" "  ($   

$" "



   ))"

     $    ":       *

))"

"!$ !$ 

$ ")"$! "  ! 6 "  " ) "   " !

":

""

" ! $

 " )"



:") *! " *-5 -@"

)!" ":) "

"     -9 -. ,.-,;: 79< 

" $

$ "

" " $  7B+/)  "

( 

< ' ) "  

"  ":

$  $  ") *$!    ;: 75< "

)"

 *"  ": ,.

 -AAA $ "!"



 ":!  -9 -9 -. ,.-, ($!

 !"

")"

))*""!

")

)) " " $)    )&

" "") ** *

")!" " (

 $ * "" )$  "

!   "  ( "$

$

 * " ! !"

+ ))""   $"* $

"04567# 

"!

 $!) 

"  * (" #$ "$ ,@ B"

! 1$ $) "

"* 

:$ *$ "

" )"! "

$! !" $  " "! $")  :$

     "

"!      

 "  

$"  !"! 

$") *"



"

"    "

"

 "*>* $ )#$ " )

"!

 "$   6      # 

) .&7&( 8

;

"

* $=+ )3  <       



           

   + 

= 



 

        

(

     

   * 

     

   >   

)       ?     



                                      9        

                    %                

         ;    

  

   @           #                   '),3  (?                  

 +    

       

   



  A               

    )' <     

    7      

:     ? =B##!"  

  8  

  *   

                   

 8 ,A 6$ "

 &$$ !

 "

 )"

") ":

 " * "  7      :$     " "

  

 + "  "    

") "  6 ""  $ "  "!   "!*"! * )) "  "

   "

 $

 ("  $" " " "* :$   "

 ("  ":"    *   $    "  !     "

        *$



$*

 " "

*"!$!) 

 * 

  )" ( $) ":" *$ $ 

$ 

"*$ * " !

(  "    "!     "!   )   $   



) "   *

$ ) ":  )$ " "!  * "

$ *  )  "

) "

  * 0.

6 " * " $" " " "

 * (" #$ $  " 0-

1$ * " $"""!



*"!

 ")"

"")"  "6&(1".-&(/99&(1'  , 8&! !.   01/"

01/"

)

  B  &"! = F8 B   * = F8