High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1222/2015dismissed

Om Parkash v. State Of Haryana & ANR

2023-05-25Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra24 pages

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT

CHANDIGARH CRM411872015

!"#

$$% & '( $ CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE RITU BAHRI HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE MANISHA BATRA "

!) # $$%

"*+ % +%( ,,,

- $$$% .%.

$$%

!$%/%%$$%/01/!21% 34 5$'65 %

!/78645 3 9"%' '(1'343:

;:;9 438"

- /! / 3 9 !$%< =:!*

%; 1.!*!$% .'( "%''(%%// 1/ <6=:!*

%;* * % /!/!

1> 91%.1 * ( 1$ ./.1 1'938"*

/ . !$% 9 . ! / .

!$% // $ 1/ '

'1'$%$ .

'8 )! ! * 1 *

*# / !1 ' 39"*/* % *

/%* 1$ % 1 )11# . '

% (% )11# * !.11.21% 1 1$!

!/* / 1

$)%'

*#.# 1.

9 $% ! // !! 1.

!- $%$ 1 $* *

1 !$% ! * !$% ! ! / '

'1' * ! <6= 1! ! $11. (%% ! % * 1 .!!/$* //$!$!!/* *%/ 11% $! * % % . $%- !$%% 1*.

1/ $% . !1 '343:

;:;9 438"*8/ $/*"!!?!. !21$/*%/1&

. ! * ?! 1/ / 1*(*/1 %1!!/ %! 1.0 ! !$% /11%!% %% 1' 4"*$ 1% 1 $ %%*1$$% 1 - *!! 1' /$! !!1'43: ;:;39 38" 1 . / /% ( $%/1% /%!% 9 -1. $1?!!

*PW1'1.

$.1$$/% $%@?"

$%* 1 !!$1$ ! PW2 @ '8 ! 6 $ .1 0/ /$/

9.1/@?"

!! %1!1@?"!!!$% 1@?"9!!#/$ $ $ ?! /( (%1 PW " )1! * ( (% )11# $ .1

/@?"$ $ ?// //#/! %@?"3$ $

$ 1(%$.1/!!@?"9PW 4 1# )1! A1% / 7 % $ @?"4 $$%!.

'8)!./! !

1' 39"@?">!! 1' 39"@?"

5@?"

! PW5 @ '8'1.

$.10//

9.1/!!@?"

21%/*.

/!/ !$%.% ! 3 PW6 '1.8$)!$.11/ /* $1 $! 1!% $ $@?"

$$% ! .

!$% 3 9 @?"

78 @?"

!! 78@?"

9!!21#/ 1 ! 9@?"

!!21 / 1 ! 9@?"

3!!21 #/1 !1 @?"

41/ $% $%1@?"

>1/ # $%( (%@?"

5!!21#/ % / 1$ 1/ !%/%?! PW7.% !)1! @?"B4 $ .1 / $%/%%! $ 1 1 ! %# $/ !* 7'C)%PW8 !$%D E$ 1$$ %%/! !$%/%% %.

!*%% 1.21!@?"

9 PW9 D'E:! *

%;! !$ > 9 1/

/! 1* 1%%/ !/ .

$% 9 .1/ 1/ !

'1'!* .'

9 /&%%/"* .1% 1/.# 1 !.!/ !%%.%* % / - !/*!/1%!%%'

%% . %*!*/ $%'

1/ !!1.1 1"% 1! . 1/ '

! % 1$

%% $?!/ #%% %.1 PW10 '

# $ .1 1/ $!! ?! . !

9$$@?"

3(1 $ .11/!%/%?! 19

$@?"

@?"

4$$%!.

$% 1/$!!?!!%/%?! ! 1$% @?"

>!%/%$ 1 / !%?!$@?"

@?"

1 *$

?1$ 11!$$* *%1!1!$ $ ( %$.1 /1*$1. 1 $% !@?"

@?"

$% PW11 @(0)1!@?"B

9 $$ #$$%.%

.. *.$% %/ * $1. %/ * % / .

$ %# 1 / 1.21%

9 * .% ! $/ !* 7'C !%@?!)%(% $.1 /%$/ 1 !.% !

9 $1$ ?! PW12 8$A/.'/ $.1 1/$/ 1$$ $1 $! 1!% $ $ @?"

521$ $! %"1.%"1 7'C$@?"

$* */! 1!$*1.! /* */! !* * (*%%@/% %/1/@?"

$* !1% . $1. 1* 1@?"

@?"

!%?!$$* /!$1/1$ *1 % /. !!$% !* ! * $#$ $%.% ! $ *%% '!1*1' "* .01 /1%$%(* .1 3 $$/ $1 / .

%1%$6 1 % % 1 01/! 34 21

$6 /!/ ! 4 7%/// $$% .%.

$$% !$%< =#/$!/%/ 01/!21% $6 1 > '

! ) # % $$%

!$%/1 !$1/01/!21%*%.% . //.

%%1* 1.% %*- ** %!/ $ !*1.

$6 ?1% 1 % $! $! !/* .1.0$8*%$ .!%% !.

$6 '

*$ !!1$ .!!.

$ C%1!!/!#.%/ / %.%%.

$1 1 %.

!! %% % !* 1.0$ .

$6 .1* * * %$.% 1C%1 $$ $1$$!$6

! % $* ! ! 1' "C%1 !! / 21/ $ 6 $$% 011!B %%1/*1/ $$% /%.%%* 5 C % +%$6

' $$%%.

$$%

' $$% !$% 1/ % % $$%/ 01/!21%$6 . $/ 1 / /1! .

% 1% $$% *1% . $$ $%* /8*%%% * %/ $$%/%%$$%/ 21% 121#* 21* / %1*1%$.% */!% 1 !.% 11.%8 1*.21 /1 $! 1%./21% 1%.1.- $$%%1 1%%$**

$$ 1$* 21% 1 !% "1 $1

%!?1 $*(* $$%%1!1%.! 21% 1.%$1!$1 17% $1!$ %.% !1 1!%$$% !% 01$1 $ 1% . $1! . 1% $./1% .

!$1%*F % $ /1 21% $1!$ % *#.1 ! / .

% 1 8 * .% %1 $.% .%.% $$%%1 1%1. /21%.

# )$/ * $$% %* ! %1 21* $$%%.

$$% !$% .%%*G

- $1* > 9 ! <6= / !/ ! 1 $$%

!$% !!$% / 3 9 1'938"*/- $$%!!"%''( 1/ * / '

'1' $ 1 1$.

$1$$% / %/ * $% .1/ .# 1/ * *1$ * $* *%!. (! 1 ' 39 " * / 9

9* $$% / '

'1' '/ %$ !/! .

%* !<6= 1!!$11. 1 / .# / 1 1 1/ .8* %%%/.

$$% !$% * 1%.

! !C%1* % / !*$ 1 1 1!$ / $ $ 1 !$1/1$ .% $1 *$6 * .!!1.

! 21 ! /1'38"

- .% / 1 ' 3 8"

$1?!"B

# * 1 $ !!?! . ! $ . !%?!$@?"

1 !*$

?1$ 11!$$* *%1!1!$ $ - ! * /1.11 %%/ $ ! 11!$ /$ $ 1!$1/1$6* . * *$6 * . !! 1.

!* $6 . $% !!/$1$ $1?%/ $%1% 1 %$%*- !

<.!=1' 48"- ' 1

4 Abetment of a thing.-A person abets the doing of a thing, whoFirstly - Instigates any person to do that thing; or Secondly -Engages with one or more other person or persons in any conspiracy for the doing of that thing, if an act or illegal omission takes place in pursuance of that conspiracy, and in order to the doing of that thing; or Thirdly - Intentionally aids, by any act or illegal omission, the doing of that thing.

Explanation 1.-A person who, by wilful misrepresentation, or by wilful concealment of a material fact which he is bound to disclose, voluntarily causes or procures, or attempts to cause or procure, a thing to be done, is said to instigate the doing of that thing.

Explanation 2.-Whoever, either prior to or at the time of the commission of an act, does anything in order to facilitate the commission of that act, and thereby facilitate the commission thereof, is said to aid the doing of that act.

- !/.!1' 4 8" .?$%.

(/ 1

" $%&

$' ( )* ' :

;:!%;

3>4! $. / /F %

/ $ /F% //* ! $$ $ / /%%/%!#$%$11 $ / /F % %%

%%/%! / / %/%!/</= +$

)* ' 55!%C*A1%>5 (/

" % $/ * % 1//!1% ! .

!%/1/* # ! ?$% 11/!- * </=!/1/*$#1/ 1/ 8 +, % )*- :;:%;4 * %.

(/ 1 " *%1' 48" / 1% . !!?$% ' 4 * *

$ !!! / % !! . / 8

. % )*/ 8 54'

(=.% $?

1 % 1.! .!1. * %% !! ! $ !1% .!!* 1 $ %%/.1/ !$%* 21!'

4!% .1$!!1.

%/1% 1!%1 !!1!.

1 1../1% 1'3 8" 1 %&$ %

)*' >:

;:%;>3* %/ 21 1'38"/ . 1

D@ 1% 1% .!/ ! * 1!./.1 . !! 8 $ ! . $.

% // / !1 . 181!.1$ 8// $ /121$/1

!%. 1 !* . 1E

9 8 % )* 8 5>9'

(=.% $?1. !1! %.!%?$

.1%%%- $$!1! !1 !!* ?$.

$* #/ 1/ 1

8 %%/ .! . 1/$6 /' 4 8" / !!!1.

//% $!!/1.0/ !!?1%1*

! .

1/! - $1 !% 1$ ! "B> < = $$%

!$% !"B 5<'= ! ! 1%!%. ** * $ !.. 1//%.% $1$!/ %1 *$6 * . 1.

! "B >< = 1/ $ ! !! 1$6 1! //% $!!/!!$1$ .1* $! ! % ! $6 ?1%% .1 $!!/

1! ( 1%% /

..!.% $- ! !$ ! % $6 %% $?$!/!/

#%% !% !!. %.1 . % ! .1$

6 (**.

*%% ! % $6 ?1%% .1 '

% .1 ? ! * !! .1%/.

! % '

!$% 1/ %.1$6 ! * 1.#6 /. / ! !"B >"B 5 * * / $$6 21 !!1

3 71 1/ !1' "$6 11.% ! #* !.1*.

! * / % $*

% 1%# $ 011%%! $1 * ! %$* $6 > 9

* (% $ $1.1/ @?"

$ $ ? /!.

1 ( (%)11# $ * $6 /.#! . % > 9@?"

3$ $6

* *$.

!* . %> 9 "B ")1!!$% %$ $ 6 /.#! %*$ *

#*%/* $*8 ! @?"

>1' 39"!

* $6 %)11# - ! * * !! %

*.%.

!6 1%.$1.

$1$ !

* $6 ( %)11#

/!/! 1> 9(* 1! #/1! !* / * $6 !$!! * % 1%%. * $6 . 1.

// 6 !$ $6 $#/1 ! %1%! .. / $ !* *1% !!1- .!$1$ $* .1$ .

$* * %%/% . ' $1 % $1

/%.%!/$ / ! .

!#/.!!! 1.

. %%1 !! 21/ $ 6 / 1 '38" $!%%$$% /21%$6 1 ./

4 - $ 6 % . 21 / 1'9 48"* $$1 !!!/

/1'9 8"- % /!!$1 .%1 '

:; - 1%.11% 1! $.

/ ! :; :;- $ 1%.1% $$ $ $ %% $$ F :.;- $ 1%.%% 1/ ! /* *1%! *F :; 8.

:;:.; ! 1%. * 1%#% 1!/ ! $1. !$1$$

> $$% / ! / $1% 1! $* $ $$% %!#1// !

$! %%/ /.

%%1 21%$6 1 '- %%// $6 $$%.

//%$! ! !!$1$ 1%!% 1 $!!/* - !* *!0 %

1> 9 **%%/% '

1 $!$6 1 9- ! $* /

$6 1$!!/* 1/ . % 1 .% 1 %1$.

$1. ! %. .% . 1. 8 *%% % .*!. $!1%%%/%$!- 1 21 ?! % $! !/ .

1*!% / %* /* %% 1/ 121?1% 1%/.

!%- !1.21 * %!%/% 1 * #$/ $!! !8 %% .$ ! .1.0 $.

$6 (*1! ?1% 1 * !! . $ 6 * !%% * / 21%%/ !1 1 /!% * */'

$1!.1 !/!/ #$%- 1%!$1 $6 #*%/ ! 21!$ ! $!! 6 .$1 %1% $ $6 ! ! - 1 $ . / %%/<%$!!/= 1 %/ $ 6 /1% !! $1 .% 1

'9 48" .!1

5 ' %%/ / $ 6 !!/$1$ $1? $ 1'48"$* ! !!$ !%1:;:; / *%%* 1 * ..

$1/ $* ! $%.!!* !% 1 3 /1.%!!1* % *%1:;:; / .$1% '?$% 1%

?1%% $%%1 $8 !@?"

>1' 39" ! %%% %%//$6

!!$1$ %%8* % %! $!$!!/* 1.21% 1 B * 3 9 ! %/% ?!*/1 *!

1 $6 *1 /*

$* *%!.

. * $% / '

'1' !/#*.1 $ 1.- ( (% $ ! * $6 % > 9 1% * ! .

"B > *

# ! $6 !!$1$ ! $!!/* 1?$%/%% * ! #*.1 % 1 !*

1- !*$ 1 ! * !- ! "B 5./.1 1/%* ! . 1.0 $ .

$ 6 - 1 $ ! . * %$ $1 %% / $ 6 * $1 .%1'43:

;:;8"

-$ %%/%%%/$6

$1 % %1$ %/ 1.

!$ - $1 ! *101$ ! *! $1* %%% %%/!!/$1$ .

$6 (* !11 !"B 3'1.8$)! 8// "B >"B 5* $ !$ $/ ! 1*! $"B 3 1 . !.

!$%* $%1"B > * 1%.

!* !!

'1' / ! $%.1 "B 5 % .

/ $% %

1! $ $$ 1% !'

#*!

* 1 . 8 * ! * ! 1! $11. .% . 1 1 .

- $ $1 1%/ * / */ ! .7'C

1. $1$$/ */ * !C"1.%"1%!1 7'C$@?"

$* *!% */ ! */! 1* * /1 ./%%% % $ $* * 1 % * 8/% /%1 *$. %%1 %%1 % 1 . $1. 1* %// 1/ %1*

1%$/ !% /% 1.1 %.1#$ 8$$ %/ 1! . * %%11/ %$..% 1/%/ $ %!(*$ % 1 .$. 1. ! %

1%%71 $. 1.

1* */ !- .1 %! ./ */ !* %%$ . .

$ 8// / $/1/%- 1/ !!21#/ 11 .

$%.1 !!//#/ 1 $% . $%"B >"B 51/%* / */ ! 8// @ 8// 8 !1?$%!* * #1 .

$%- . * "B>"B51/ % 1% */ 1/ ! 1 !/ $@?"

%$ $1 * $ 1 21**.

!( !.# 1! .$.!.% * 81 1! .$. 1. ! % 1!#/%%//$ 6 / $% ./ 1 1 * !"B >"B 5 %$ /- //.

%%1 %/$6 /1% !! $1 .%1'43:

;:;8"**%% 1$ !21

%./ $$% %%/ /

71 $ %. / !!$1 .%1'38" %%/ .?/ ! // 1/ $1%% $$ %%/ ! . !%% ! .

$6 .$%%8 !@?" *%%/ $6 ? ! !%% ! @"B >!$%

*$ ! .!%%

$6 "B 5<'=$ !

% $6 #%% !% !!. % /.1 ! !7 $1$$/1'38" $1 *21$

1 !* 01

$$1$$

1* 1%!

F 1 !$! * *%/%% .1

- / 1'38" * 1$ ! $ 8 /% $ // ! 1 '.

$#*

.!11%$ **1*

$@!$ ! !% ! .!18 .$ * $1%! ! ! . .

$6 * * 1%*1.

! 1$ $'38"* $ . %%1 / %

21 $6 / /1 /$!%$$%/21%$6 1 ' .!1

9 -#/ . 1 1! * $ %%1 / % $$ $1!! 21/$6 /!%* $ /.

%% 1 !$%%/* 01/! /% % /1 .!1/% $$% $$%7/! $$% ! !

' $$% !$% % % !% $$%6

% 0.+ )* ' ) /01/!21%$ %/ $$$% * !% $$% $$% % 1!%% ! % %$ * 1 *

#$ .1%.

1 / % !- %1..#1 !$% (RITU BAHRI) ( MANISHA BATRA ) JUDGE JUDGE

$0 H6 Whether reportable : Yes/No