High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1236/2015dismissed

Amarpreet Singh v. State Of Punjab

2019-10-16Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu28 pages

#$ %

& #$&

# ''(

)**

!"*

!"#

!"#$%% &

, ) #-. #/ 01 )

2* !.#/ 0.

) & )#.#/ 0

# ''(

)

1.#/ 0

) 3 .#/ 0

) * #%. #/ 01 ) )!.#/ 0# )

#1.#/ 0

0 +'

) -1.## - !"

5 / " # !

# #

# ##

( ## "%

& #. - # .

( 1"% .

# $ %. & # $ &

# )** 1 0# 1 # # 0 " # 0

. 6# # 7 86 89 # # + 0 5 10 /0## 0# #, !'# $%$"

##$ ( )$"% )"$ )** :;

' 6 6

# %

; # # %

% :;

% # %

; # # %

/ % # %

; # # %

6 <

# 0#/ :;

' 6.#1 0 '

# %

; # # %

% :;

% # %

; # # %

& # :;

' 6.#1 0 '

# %

; # # %

% 3 :;

' 6.

# 1 0 '

# %

; # # %

/ 0 1 ## 0 0 % 5 0

0 . . 0 1

# 0 !" . #0 1

1 * -# 4 . 3#/ 1*.

&# 4 #

# = / ;

- * ## 0 "0*

5 "

) 1

> 0# "

- * 1 *#/

. # / .

?". 0 &#.

# # 00

# 5% 1 <0 1 # 1

4 # / 6 . 00

# # $ %

/ / ##1

#& # # 0 3 # * 1 1 % 1 00

/ / # # "0*

- * - * 0

# 00

# 1% 4 1 - ".

1 "

" # *#/ - * /0 4

1 * % 4

"# !

4 # *#/ 1

# 1

0 5 / "# 0 1

0 # ## 0 )**. # 10

# 1

A6 @< ?; 1 # 6/ =0 1 0 1 % 4

. &# 4 # B 4

0 # 0# ## "

#% 4 ##

5 "

# 0

#0 # 1 "

10 1 <0# ## "

#% #

< .

1 *

5 1 /# 0

0 / 1 # 6/ 1 # 1

0 #

"#" $

$ !

$ ( )$(*+*,+ -+.#'/

#.+01 $

".- 11 $

(

".1 $

> # # 0 # 0#

< ## "

#% - * 4 0# 1 !

#0 #,

! "

# $

' '

( ''

'' '%'

) *

' '

' ' ' '

* ,

'%'

'% , * -

'' '%'

'% '

+ '* '('''

' '

' ' . ' '* ')''('

' '

/ 6!

( 1

" 1 1 !

1 # 1

0 0

# #% 0

5 "" #"1!

##1 11 # # "1 # #

1 1 (

= 0 0 @< @< . )#0

# 1

/ 0 5 0

0 1 # 0* # !

10 1

# #% 0

# / @< ; # 0

# = '

# # $ % 1 0# " #0 < 4 0#

, 0 ''

( # * ) )

' '

) 1

'% ' ' ' '/ 5 1

1 " "" # !

1 "

/ +

6 0

< . #

"% #0 # / "0 0 0

% 0

# " #

5 #0 # 0

# "

* 1

% 5 #0 # / ## 1 '

0/ !

% /# /# "

## "

#% 4 0 # 0# 0 "

#% >C /# #

# "

1 * "

#% #0 # "% 4

6 1

# "% 00 0 4

# !

1 # 1

0 0

#% 0

5 0

# 1 # 0* # !

10 1

0 0

# #% 0

6 0

< . ##

1 0###"

#% >' 2 . &@. #

# 1

# ) # 1. &# . 5 # 1 1

# 00% 2 #. :" @ 66. &# 6 1

/ 4 ## 0/ % 0 # 1 00%

)

( #% > .# /# @< '

> !" * #

# / ;

## 0 "0*

4 #

4 0# "

=80 0* "

" 4

- * 1 *#/

# #!

" 5 #

# 5% 1 # !

# $ % 0#/.

)** $ 0 )**. & # $ &

# 3 $ 0 3 # 00#

1 #

1 " <0# # $ %

/ / #" # # 0

- *

# 1

$ 0 3 # & # $ &

# * 00

/ / #" # # "0*

- * - * # 1 00

# 1% 4 1 *#/ # - " /#

% 4

0 > 0.

# 00

# 0# "% # # 1 * - " 1 1

" 4 0#

# 4

#0# ## 5

1 # 0# ## "

#% 6

< "% # 0

" 00

. #

# "0*

;

)

# 4 1

# " 4 1 6 / 0 4 ## 0

@< ? 1 % 1 0.

# 00

# 0# "% # # 1 * 1/.

# 0

% 4 ## 0 0 1

1 0 ## % 4

4 # # 0 00

# 0 # 0# #

>+ 4 ?*1# #

# 0 # 1

1 0# " /

. / / "

1 *

4 00*# / / 00% 6 1

# 1 * 0 # 1

0 6 1

# 1

? 5 / / 1 0# " "%6 0 * > *#/ #

# *1 !" 8

- * 5% 1 "

% * -# 4 ## * 1 1 00

# ## - *

4 1 *# 0 4 1 #0#

# 0

<# "% # "0

0 4 #

/ 1 # 0 +( * &# 4 *1 !" / %

- * 4 0/# !" "1 C

)

4 !" #% 0# 4 ## @< A# A; + > 3# 2 #

# 00

';);&?

' #

" " # / /

'+ #

( / " # 00 61 /# '

( > # #

# - 1

(+. ) 3. &# 4 # - "

;

) 0#

" 0/

6 1 "#% 5%

# #" + .

0 # #!

" 5 1 1 " # 1

D E 0 )** 1

% -** 1 / " "# 0% 5 # -** 1

1% #%

0 )** # % 1 -** 5. 0 )** # #" #

# # / / 1 4 *# "

# #

0/ #"

= < "

+ ;(

) % 0 / = (

# # - 1 &#

! "

# &#. *#

4##00

C >' 4 1! 5 # # /#0 "% #/ @< 4 /# #/ B 0# 1 #

1 0 ## % 4

&# 4 # 6 2 1 / 4

. &# 5% 0 # 0#

< . # 0 ## / 0

- * 0

5 "0* 0

! "0*

#1 0

. 1 0

0* .

"0* 0

# "0* 1 0 / "

# 1

4&. / 0 #0 - *

< . % 6 0 * . 4=.

. &#. )* 1*.

1 6 2 ## / 0

#0 # - * ## / "% # 0 0 # 0 / "

5 1 *

"% 4= * 5 1 #

# "% 1 )4 - * =

. )4 - ## / 0 "

< "

# .

# 1

"% *

)* 0 0 # .

1 0 00 ?"

%. ) 4 #

# 0

0 00 ?"

%. ) )4 - ## /

/ 0 #0 # - * 4 #

# 1 0 @<. 2 6 0

< . #

# 0 0 "

1 /

< "

# 6 2 ## / 0

6 0 )* 1*

> 4 - # /#0 "% #/ @< :

6 #/. # 0

#0 # 0 # 0 "

< 0 "

# 1 ## / "% 4= * 0 1

# 1 "% 4 1!

= '

4= * 6 0 # #

# 0 %.

* # 0 # " . 1

* =

# 0 0 "

< 0 "

# 1 *

* 0 0 # # 1 ## / 4 1! 5 #

1 0 00 ?"

%. ) 4 1! 5 #

# 0 0 "

< 0 "

# 1 A 0 00 ?"

%. )

6 0 * # #

# 1 * 0 0 "

< 0

/ /

'+ )2 A 23 :

1 % " 0 /# 00

# )** 1 . " . 0 0"

<0 "

/ / 0 /# 00

# # $ % 1 .

0 0 / 0#

# 1

. 1 "

0 #0 # - * 1 ## / 4 1! 5 " #

# 0

0 @<. 2 4 #

# 0

0 @<. 2.

(

/ 0 0 "

# 1

4& # 0

0 "

< 0 "

/ / # 1

/ 0 /# 00

# )** 1 1 *

* 0 0 # 5 1 ## / 4= * #

1 A 0 00 ?"

%. 0 . # =

4= * # #

# 0 / 0 "

# 0 0 "

< 0 "

/ / 1 A 0 00 ?"

%. #. 0 0 # = +

0 0 "

< 0 "

/ / 1

0 /# 00

# # $ % 1

## / 4= *

" 4#

0 ?. # = #%. 4= * . #

# 1 0 0 "

< "

/ / =

+ 6 - "

# 0 0 "

< 0 "

/ / # 1

A?. 4 A 0 00 ?"

%. 0 . # 5 0 # 1 3 1 #1 1#%"

#% 1 >+ " 2 " # ## / 0 6B)

>( 6 2 #

< . 0

#0 # # 0 0 "

1 / "% # 0 5 1 ## / 6 0 * > ) ! )# # 0# 0 #

C(' # "

C('

4 # /# 0 #

C(' @< : # C('

+ @< :; 4

/#00@< :; '

> #

/# 0 #

CC(('

# C((( ( ( ( /# @< :; # @< :;'

0#00@< :;

> 2 ) # /# 0 #

C +C

/# @< >; 5 00 # 0

@/#00 @< >;

> - " #

# 1 #"

# # %

) # 5 1. &# = / ;

1 #" 4 0

#" "

;

) = #%. 0

1 1 0 1 #" "

) 1 1 "

. % ) ! #

1 %

# #" > 0

. 1

# #" 1 # - * 4 1 !

# 0 #

# 1

4 1

0 0

> % . - * 0 1# "% # 5% 1 * %

. &# "

## 1% 4 % ) ! #

1 1 0

# 00 # 0

4 1 #0#

# 1 0

<# "% # "0

0 4 # ##

@< A; 4 ##

# 0 ##

@< A; / ;

) 0 * 1 "

% "% - * !" # 00 # !" # *#/ # - * /0 #

* % 4

. &# 4 1 # 1

@< A; 1/.

## 4 ##

- * 1 0 # 4 ##

B @< + >' * 1 6/ =0 4 0 ##

% *#/ @<

0 ##

% !" @< 00

1 # 5% 1 #0% <# 5% 1 # 0 / 1 # 4 # 0 1 0 1 0 /# # # 0

/ / "

1 * 0 0# "% 1

5 # 0

@< >';?

# # 0

/ / "

1 / 0# 1 * "% 0

4 # 0

@< >';) 00

# # 0 /# / / 1 +

/ 0# % # 0 # "# 5 / / @< + / 0# @< @< + ) " 1

4 # 0 0 /% 0

@< >';=

# 0 % 0 # 0

# "% # 0 /# / / "

# 1 / / 1 0 5 0 / /.

" # 00 1 *

@< >';G 6 0

< . #

# 0 0% 0 ## !" 0 @< ?

0% 0 ##

@< # @< A; 4

0% 0 ##

# @< @ 4

0% 0 ##

" @< # 6 2 @< @ 4

0 ##

)4 - # "

4 # * "

. / / #

# A?

4 0

# # "

A? 0 /%

/ / "0

* # 4 # # # 0* # "

# / / A?

4 ##

# 1 A? # " "0# "

1 0 /# "

#% #

4 0 0% #

# 0

< / / 1 1 / / 10 # 1 / *

/# @< >';G 4 ##

/ / 1 * 1 / "%) 10# 00

( > 0 ) # 0#

# 0 # 00 # 0 #. 00

( ++;);&# 1

"%).&#.101 /# (

(

C > # # "

C +C

# /?#.- !3.&#

>+ ! # "

0 # "

C('

>( #

# 1 0%

0 3 "

% 0 %

6 0

< .

## 0% 3 #" 0 1

/" A?

5 #" 0% 1 /" 6# # > * #

# # 1 0

"% "

%. 1 0

% "

# "

# ## "

#% "0

0 "

# # 0 # 1 / #

# # 1# # 1

> *! 2 #

# *1 # 4 1

0 4 # / #

+ "

; % .

# (

6 0

< . #

# ## " # "

# 4 0

1% # # / #

5 1 # 1 4 # / 0 " % % '

> * 2 #

# * 2 # . . &# 4 1 *# * /#

< ## "

#% - * 4

* "

* 5

< 1

# "0

0 / "% # 0

< .

#% 1 *

## "

#% 4 #

<0 "

## "

#% 4 1 "

# # 0 1 1 1 1 /

4 1 "

>' /# # # <# B # 1

*# G G 6

. B # 1 *# G G

C ##

F0 0 # ##

4 # / ##

@< >'; 6 0

< . ## 1 ## . . /1 0 # "

#% 1 G 1 %

10 0

. ' 6 . ' C 0 1 1 4

## 1 % ## . /1 # 1

0 # %

( F0 4

## "

#% 1

1 "% #

## 1

/1. . ## # 0

6 # "

#% @%

C 4

## 1 ## . .

/1 # #

# 0

0 0 # @%

## "

#% 1 # # 1 %

1 "% #

1 # * 6 1 0

B . ## 1 ## . 0

1 %

> 4 % 2 ## 0

< % 1 1 0 =/1 1

0 4#

* 1#"

% + >

# ! #

# # "

# 0 # # "

C'+

5 " " " 1! 5 6 1

5 " " C'+

# 0 0#

)

) 1 5 1. ) # 5 1. &# 6 0

< . ## 8 ##

1! 5 1 # A 5 " "

0 0 " 1 0 # 0# "% "

0 1 # 0 # ( >+

& # "

0 # . 1 0 0 # A "

C( CC A . " " 1 # ! 5 0 # 1

C @< >+;

6 0

< . #

# 0

# 1

# " "

# /# A @< >+; 4 # "

A @< >+; C >C # "

# 3. &# # 0 % 1 @< >C;

6 0

< . ## "

"% 1 # "% % %#1 %0#0 %

!# # 0# @< > ; /# 0 0

' > 3 # 0# @< >; 6 0

< . ## 1 # "% "

# # 0#/ 4 ## # % 0

# - #/0 # *

0 0# ' >' 4 #

# '

# ) # 5 1. &# 4 1 4B =0

. &# 5

% ! .

# . 2

/ "

/ # 00

# 0# / / 1 00 0 1 0 " 5 00 1

# 4 # 0 # " / / # 00 1 " / / 4 ##

/ / / # 00 6/ =0 * 6 0

< . #

# 0 * 1 00

# #

## /

#% %

## ! " % "!

)** 4 ## * 1 4 ## " '

= '

! 0

# / / / % # # /#

# / / / 1

* 1# 4 ## B 1

# /#

4 ## B "

#% # * 1

1 # 0 1 ! 4 # 0 0% #

# 0

< ## %

# # / / / "% ! #

# 0 0 #% 4 ## / / 1 1 ## / 4 ## # # % # # # / / /

6/ =0 * # % % # 0 #% ' > * # "

0 B

5 0 1 0/# "

00 1

5 0 1 ## / 0 6 0

< . ## # / # # 10 0 @< > ; 1 # 4 ## * 1 1 #1

> ! 2 #

# 0 1 /

0 0 / C

5 " * 1 1 # "%

6 0

< . ## * HH 1

## @< II; %

+ 1

% 1

## # .

# 0 1 # 1 # "

10 1 1 * 5 1 ' 00

"1 1

> # # 0# % ( !

#% #0 6!

( 1

" 1 !

1 5 0

# 1 # 0* # !

10 1

0 0

# #% 0

5 "" # "1 !

# # 1 1 1

4 # 0 0% #

# /# /# "

## "

#% >C /#

> # B !

1 0

# 1/. #

# #0 # 0

# * 0

# < 0 "

1 * "

#% "% 10 1

1 #"%00 0 @< 0 @< 00 # .

; 0 1 #0# 0

6. 66. 666. 6 J 00 # A? @< H.

0 # "

00 # A? @< H;. "

# <" 61 0 "

0 /# ## "

#% 00 # A? @< H;.

E / / 0# 1

% #

E )2 / / 6 1

# " 1 * #

E / / # "

*# ; 1 #

E / / )2 "

'+ *# 6 0

# / " #

% "0

1 #/# 00 0 *

@< 2

)* 0 1 - * # 0/# # "

# 1 # 5 @< ? 1

0 ##

% 1

0 ## /# @< 6 . # # 0

# # 1 # # 1 0# # 4 # #

% @< 0 /

1 1 # 0 1 0#

>' 2 0 0% #

# # 0/# % 0 # # 1 00% > # /# @< > !" * % 1

4 0 0% #

## 0 "0*

/ ;

4 1 = 1% 1

- * 1 *#/ 00

# # $ %

/ / #" # # 0

- *

# 1

# $ 0 3 # & # $ &

# * 00

# # # "0*

- * 4 1

*#/ # - " /#

>+ 4 ?*1# # # / / "

6 1

# # > *#/

1 #0#

#0 ## "

#% 0

@< A

1 B 4

@< A; > 3# 2 /# 00

# > # # # 0 / 00

4 ## 00

>' 4 1! 5 #

< . # 0 ## / 0

#0 # - * 1 / # 1

4& 6 2 ## / 0

#0 - * # / 0 "

6 0 * 4 # * 0 % A?. ) > 4 - # # /#0 "% #/ @< :

# 0 % 1 #

# 1 4 ## / 4 1!

4 # * 0 @<. 2 5 0 % 1

# 1 "% 4= * 4= * 1

## / / 0 0 "

4& 1 1

0 5 1 A?. # 1

" # >( 6 2

# >' 4 1! 5 0 % 1 ## / "% # 0 # ## / 6 0 * 0 # 0

# "

> - "

# 0

% "

# ## "

#% 1

#" 5 ## "

#% 1 /# "% 1 # 4 ##

B @< A; #

>' * 1 6/ =0 4

0 # 0# = "

# 0

. 00

# 0 /# 1

0 4

4 #

# 0 % * 4 0 ## #

0 1 *#/ '+ ?# 0

" . # $ %. & # $ &

)** / 0# 0 >'

4 1 #

# ! 0 00

. 2

/ 00

# # 0# / / 1 00 " 1/. >' 6 0 * 0 0% #

# / / 1 1 / / 10 1 *

/# @< >';G >' 4

## 0

< # # / / / "% ! #

1 # 0 #% 4 ## / / 1 1 ##

/ 4 ## % # # #

/ / / 6/ =0 * # % % # 0 #% >' 4 1 # /%

4 # "0 /#0 /

'( > # /# "

C +C

@< >; >+ !

/# 0

0 # "

C('

> ) ! )# /# 0 # #

C(' 4

/# 0 # /# @< : # @< :; > # /# 0 # @< :; # @< :;'

> 2 ) /# 0 # @< >; "

C +C

/# 00 @< >;

# 0

@/#00 'C > *! 2 # #0 4 0

1% # # / #

' % 1 1 0 #

> 4 2 ## 0

< 1

# 0

5 F0 1 # 0 *1 1

#1 1 # > * 2 #

# 1 "

# 0 1 1 1 1 /

6 0 # "

## / 62 62## /

* 5 1

0 < 5 "

1 0 /# "% >C /# 1

>' /# # 0#. ## 0

< 1 ## %

# %

C > 4 % 2 0

< ## 1

# 0 '

5 %

1 1 0 4 #

* 1# "

% >

# ! 0

< ## 0

# 1

# " / 0

1% " 1

0/ >+

& # "

A @< >+; >C

## 0

< 1 # "% 5 1 # 0 !

# 4 ## * 1 # 4

## 1

# "% % % 6 1

% 0# 0 % >

!# ## 0

< # # / %

0 0 # 4 # * %

% 0% /% # 0

% > 3 #

@< >; % "

> *

## 0

< # / # # 10 0 @< > ; 1 0/# 4

## 0

+ 1

% > ! 2

## 0

< @< II; %

+ 1

# %.

% 1

>( ## 0

< #" 0% 1 /" 6# # > *

# 0 6 0 " "/# "

0 /# "

#% 0

# " 0

# "% > * 5 0 # "% > * " * "

0 " /#"%)#0

0 6# 5 A? @< H; " # "% )

" <#

00*# "

0 0 "

6 1

0 % /#

- * "0* 6 /# 5 0# 1

"% > !" 5 # "% # 0 #0 4 * !

# "% > !" % 0 "

# "% #0 /#0 5 A? @< H; # % /# 1 0 /# 1

# 0

0 5 "

0 /# "

#% #0 # 1

A? < 5 "

# 1

# <" 6. 0 0. 1

# 0 0 5% 1 5 1

0 1 0 /# 0

0 % /# / 5

0 /# 0 # 0 ' 6 # 1 0 ' 6 % . # $ %. & # $ &

# )**.

# 0

0 )** # # # # 0 + 0 )**."% #

" !" *

# - * # # #% #0 " 1 # # 1 0# 1 1 " *# 5

!" #

1 > "

# @< ?

1 @< 0#.

> # . 0

< .

0 0% #

"% #0 # / "0

0 0

%. 0

# " #

# * 1

% 4 % / ## 1 ' 0 !

% % >C /# . 0

< . #

# #0 # 0

*0 "

00 #%. "

# ''( # #

. # $ % # & # $ &

" 5 " "

# #

% "

# 00# 5 0 #0#

* . # $ % # & #

( $ &

# 0

# "%

/# !

# # #

(

+' # #

* +) ,- * )) - $". &/

2 '3 > *;

# I ;3

> " I ;3