Pawan Kumar And ANR v. State Of Haryana
!"## $
% & '() !* ++,, ! ( -! !. / + !
!"#$ %&'() !*+,-.) "/-012"!#"
%&'() !*+,-.)"!-%3)!1-%421-32* % !
- -*0* & !1" !1!* ++,, ! -*(2* -# 3*1#!# ," !4 ,1. /
"/-012"!#"5 5*(3*!* ++,#" !# #,2/ ++,, ! % & '() & ,#!(+ # ! " 2(! &#!*!*" !, "( ,!*+ !#1!*) # ++ ,#!,& * )#!
5*+ ! ++ ,## !#!(! 3 # !!*6(3) ! !
!
1 2/#!# ,-# 8(31 & #1 # -# 5 79
1 # &*#"* !* ++,, !% & '() 4! #1&"* 3&#!* !# !* "+( #* 2,( -"!# 7 17
17 :% -"!#
!*%-"! 5*/&" #"! ! "( -"!#
7 :%!( 3#3(#)+# ) ! +# /
!+ /# 19 "* # (,!+ /) !# 1!
(!*( 3#)+# ) !!*) !* ""(% & '() & ," #"! ! "( -"!# 7
:%!( 3#3( #)+# ) ! +# / !+ /# 19 (,!+ /) !# 1!(!*( 3#)+# ) !!* ) !* 5*" !*+"(!# (!*,,#!* !")+, #
! 8 & !-# 3*3 !*!*" #, ")+, # !!!*-.1 %,#"-! !# 1* (* !!*"!!* !
7 ! 2(!
7% 1 * "# !,+* #" " ,, ) !* )!* !* " ) &#!**,!* !!*#"!#)* "))#!!(#"# 5* !1* "*!* *( . &!* !!*#"!#)& ,/# 3 !*"! 5*## "# !& !* (!")#,,#"#!, !# 2!& !*)!*!*" % &
'() ; !# )" <)!*#4! # =:1>? %@1& 3#! %!)!)? )# & " ("! -(#"# !1>? %%1 & , ") !*+! :!& ! !=-A1 *(2 ")+ # &#!*!** &#!# 3!*" %*!3 +*!*+!
& ,! 0 :
!#3 !# & ")+,! "* ,, & +(!(+ ! ")+,!# ,,!*" ,) ,#!# 5+#!" 1!*+"(!# ? )# &#!
5* ! !) !!* ""(& ,"( -"!# 7 7 % 5*/* #!*" !*+"(!# 5* ""(&" #"!
! "1 !#" 2 . "1!*+ ! ++ , A "( , ++ # 3 2* , !* ++,, ! *) !,/ 3(!* !!*+"(!# * #,!+#!" A "( , ++ # 3!*-! !*) !,/ 3(!* !!*+"(!# * +#!" 2/ 2,(2! (++!!*6(3) !
7 !*, (!2,& B* * , "( ,!*+ !# 3 !*(3* !*6(3) ! "/" (,,/ 8 & !-# 3** !!##!* !*"# +* " ,, )4! #&#- !#*'()
7 ! 2(!
7 !* !
*#3 (3*!* "))#!!(#"#2/* 3# 3 .# )!* +,#" . "*!*+! , 3&#!*!*+,#" &!* ! 2/ #"!#)& ,/# 3 !*"! 5*& #+(!2!& - !#*'() 4! # - !#*& ## 3&#!**#) 5*" (#+(!2!&
- !#*'() 4! #& !* !% & '() & ## 3&#!* 4! # . * ,+ #,,#"#! , !# &#!* 4! #
14! #* 3# &#!# 3!* !# (!(*&#,, !
(,3# !* "!##!# .&14! #" !# (,## 3&#!* % & '() -*# !) *& / 5*" (!,#&#!* 4! # 71!*#"!#)* ,!,*#) 2(!!* +
71!*#"!#)* ) !,+* #"" ,,!*#) 0!") !!*# " ."(, !3
71*"## ) !#
2(!(#"#"))#!!2/!*#"!#) :
*#"? )# 1*+ !* ! * ! "* 5* #! " 2!& !* %,#" -! !# * (* *(4! ## 2(!!&0#,)! .(!* +!* !
71% & ,# !#& !!**( 4! # - !#*'() #!* !*!*" .+ !* ! *# (3*! & !( ! 4 ) ! 4#, - # -" / -"*,1* (* . !2#!*&
$$ .#&#* ,+ #,,#"#!, !# &#!*% & '() .#, !# &#!*4! #&
! # .! !,## 3&#!**# !* ""(% & '() (! ,#&#!*4! # .& + !# *#*(&* *#2!*-( #, '() !,*#)!* !*# (3*!* "))#!!(#"# . "*!* +! .+!* !!*#"!#)* ")!!**(*#+ !
7 !,!* !*& 3# 2 !# 32/4! # % &
'() .* ! !,## 3+ !,/)*# !*# "")21
! "*1 $ %B7-( #,'() +!* !4! #* ! !,## &#!*% & '()
14! #* ( ! 0 !) * & / .* % & '() ")# 3(!!**(4! #
7 ! 2(! 9 % 5*#"!#)* "))#!!(#"# ! 2# 3 +2/% & '()
- 0 A ! 18( #A"!(14 ) !4#,- # -" /-"*,1* (* 1+!* !*& &0# 3 #"# !# %# "#+ , 5*+,#"* ) ++,#" !# 0# 3 !2#!*!* " -** 3# !2#!*!*"
$$ # ) !1>? %> -: 8#! '() + !* ! % & '() & !3 !# *#+ "2/!*:
!#3 !# 3#" .) #",( ! !) !1>? %4 ""# 3!*#)1!*:
!#3 !# 3#"* , ",,"! &*!1 >? %71 !* #"!#) * $!* ", ? )#
%B . )* * +!* !*& +! !%,#"-! !# 1* (*
7 !* ! /-:. + ,* +#! 1 ()1 0 # (#"# !# !* ) ,0*
%B$>.* )+ ,* ++ !*#!+,
A.-2* #+!* !!&#,!# &#!*!*3#!* +#",/# 3 !*2/ !*" &! 0 !+# -*# !##!* )# !* (!
% 0 6 C * )#" ,,/ ? )# ""( % & '() .+A+!1>? % .+!* !!*&
!*# 3 (33!# !* ! % & '() & ( " + 2, # 3 ?( , !"(
!( C * " ("! !* +! )!) ? )# !*2/!*#"!#) , 3&#!* % & 8 # % 0 * -* !#"!*,,&# 3# 6(# *2/ D>/" 3!" ("!#* )* 3+ ! 5 3( + ,1 ! 3( 2#!1 , )(" ,#+ "/ (#,&,#+ !" ! 5&2(# ?
") #3*!*(,12#!) 0,!# "01 2#!) 0#3*!# ")2,& #++, ? ") #E %- + ! 1 + !
!
*( A" ,? )# @ 3# )#!!&# 3,,/ (#+ !, 2# ) 6 )# ./) (+(!( ! <,"0+#!# $<,"0 +#!# -& 2&#!*2,! # 3# ,#"* 3) !& ,# & ++ ,, , ! ? )# F%5 3 !# ,, 2)# ,3 " 3! ) !+ 3
%
F!(* ,!*/ ) ,# #E +# # :
(+# # " ( !*# !*#" # +*/?# (!* 3# 3&*#"*# !)!)# !( (#"# ! ! " ( !* # # / "( ,# .&1 3# , "#" ,) 9& 2* 2
!!=-A1 *(2 + ") 1# /1 , 3 &#!* " < ( & # # 3 & (33!#?( , (,!
%2 2,!#)2!& 6(/ !*#,!* )# (! %2 2,( !# !#)2!& !* %># &#!*#
*( G +!*+# # !*"!1!*" ( !*& +*/?# (!* 3# 31&*#"*& !)!)# !( (#"# !! " ( !*# # /"(,# 5*!#), +2!& 6(/ !*& ,!* )# (! 5*!#), +2!& !* !* +! )!)? )# & &#!*#
*( %B
* ,!=-A +!1>? %H -(2:
+"!-(0*2#-# 3** ++ +!( -"!#
7 % :
*#"? )# *! !!* !*# !0 & !* !!*#"!#)* &#!! (#"# !) 3 & + #2, * !*
$
-: . + , -# 3* & !* :
!#3 !# 3 #" . "#+!)!)? )# +! .* 2! # &*! !*#"!#) . ! ""(% & '() .* , ! ""( 4! #
7
B* ! "
2 3 !* ) !* ! !) ! #"( *# 2#!* !!*#"!#)& 2
$$ -*& ,## 3&#!*
*)!*4! # .)!** #,,#"#!, !# &#!* ""(% &
'() 5*#"!#)< !*& ,## 3&#!**#+ ! 5*" !* +"(!# +"#,/#!* !% & '() * +!*#"!#) (! !*# 1*"))#!!(#"# ""# 3!+!)!)? )# +!1!*" ( !*& +*/?# (!* 3# 31&*#"*& !)!)# !( (#"# !!" ( !*# # /"(,# 5*+2 2,!#) 2!& 6(/ !*& ,!* )# (! 5*+#2#,#!/?( , (,!"(, !2(,(! 8 & !-# 3*#!*3 !*!*#"!#) %B
- !#*'() # !*!*#"!#) %B7-( #,'() #!* !* ")+, #
! .* % & '()
7")# 3(!!* *(4! ## !* /""( " % & '() * , ) #",(! !) ! 5*! !) !) 2/%B 8 & !-# 3*# (,/"2 !2/)#" ,# "# ",(# 3%1>? %1 =-A +!1>? %H
5* * &#!# 3 !* (#"# ! & ! ! = #"
-"# "A 2 !/1 *(2 1' , 5*+!#>? %I :!* ")#
!*+!!* !#!& !+#2,!?+ /+# # J(!# #3 !() 0K !* 2 "!
#3 !(!*+
" " :!& , !+#2,!?+ /+# # J(!# &#!# 3) 0K7 !*(++,# )#!!> 3,#*&#!# 3!*+
" " & !(#"# ! 5*+# # & !* !!*+ &*&! ", )#!!&#!# 3! )+ ) 0 ! ,&!!* ",J(!# &#!# 3#)#, ,/! )+ ) 0K 5* (#"# !* ! 5* )& ( !* 2/ 5*
+"(!# * (,/+!* !!*#"!#)& +2/% & '() !* !*"))#!!(#"# 5* ()(# 6(# !*2/ #"!#)* !2 ?+, # 2/!* ++,, !
!# 3!*) !!!!*+,#"2/!*3 !* !* !* " # " " 1 #! # ! ! , ! !* +"(!# " 2" (!*:
# "#!/!(+#!* !("*,#0) !! ,& /!#!2*(*(+ ! !** (!* )#,/ 5* #"!#)& )# !!*!#)&* !* "& "))#!! ,/!* !
) & !!"! !*",!*!*" #!"
!2 #!* !
!* +& !"))#!! %!)!)+! =-A+!1>? %H1 (,/(++!!*" !*+"(!# 5* , ! , !# !* (#"# !1 >? %%1 ( D: )* ++#,/"))#!!# 3(#"# !)/& : )!/# +)/,# )/ "0 !)/ !*!*/*(, !2 !!8 #, #!*4 !*1= !* F ",
3 )!*1)!*1( !# -"! ) / !2 ! ( !/F ",1 !*/* ! /!*# 3& !) *(,2 ! G
:!"
!22,#2/ /!!"*#) 3# !* ! / + &#,,"))#!(#"#* ++#,/ 5*# "# !*(#"# ! !* ! "!# 2 !! 0 3 # !3 !*1 !* )!*1*&1 !* )% & '() ;( !/"* "* ,# ) # !* (#"# ! ""(4! #* , !?+, # !*"#"()!
" ( &*#"** (3*!* "))#!!(#"# !*#"!#)& ## &#!**
$ :
#&( ##"(# 1!*# )#!# !* + ! ++ , ""# 3,/1!* ++ ,##)# .&1!* ! " #)+(+ ++,, !% & '() * ,,( " "( !,/ 5* ! " & ! ++,, ! 4! # & (+ # !
(# 3!*+ "/!*+ ! ++ , - #2 #,# 0 -*##"!!( 2!*!# ,(!!( 3* ) # 3 ! " 6#-* ) 8(3
$
. # -# 3*-#*( 8(3 B*!*+ 0# 39 C9 B*!*+! 2, C9