High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/726/2004disposed of

Ram Niwas Etc v. State Of Haryana

2015-07-01Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik9 pages

! "#$%&'(')

* + " /////00 1!/

/////

!0",

'/ 2-

.! % % 0 .! * & 3 %%+ , !

4$,5* / 3 ..

.!." 7/2-

4$,5* !-$%,3 0.

5 8./* 9$* . "(,:

. !/ 8./8$" !- :- .* (!! !

% .&

* + !!"8 "5- ",+ ";9 !" $* . "5- - , 4$,5* ":

" ,

)/7/.

., ,3&-/8/ /8 -", .

" !! "!$,5 ( ",(3&+ & - !

%/ - !

, % . **

"5 0$" !- $", .

"7<= ",'",

%, >.!-.

? ?@

.*0%

" %( %

, !! "!$,5 ( ",- %,3 !5$ % &.**

"5 0$" !-

"7<= +-

!" . 0$" !-

"' + !* $ -$! &+ A$

$", .

"' / %!3!

,3&

, !! "!$,5

3!%$

%&" : , !-+

%**

"5 ..33 .&.

&3 %"5

"&!$-5 "5/ . $", .

"7<= (3

$", .5. 5.$! *0. !"* . . , &

0 "

-+ -, $% % .

! % C - !D

.C !- - %"5+ - %3 . "5-("!

43 . "5-("!

!- "5- ","!

& "+ 0.

.%,$ C "5. *

3$!!

",( 5$.

".*

+&$"53&!( .* ,+ - ? ",?C" ?(+

", "5

3$!!

",( "0$. " ., . % ", !"

!/" .

,( "3 00.

,/ - !B 0.

, "50 &/- %!.* 0!

( 5$.

( + 4 "

, " .

, "5 0 &/ ! + ! " 5- (

(" ", !!$%,3 4 "

, "50 &/ B %"5+ -0% %!.

,3$!!

",( "0$.3&

0. :

0 3 "5 ,. :

" 3& ,. :

. "!

43 . "5-/ "

- "5 3$!!

",( "0$. &!

+&$"5 3&!+

", "5 " * ,,% . ",+ : "5 C" ? ?! 5"

,. :

. !

0/2-

: !-

.,( !C "5

* + 00.

,. :

" 0 "

?C" ?

%% "5- *

- *!

%+ %%%

$0 !

0/!!$-(3 $%0.

+ .,!

0/ "

3&!- ""

0+ -?

$0 !

0 * $ / - !( ","!

0% &(3 &$"53&!- .$" &(,$

/+ .( &+ 00.

,3&B %"5+ 0% %!/- .!"+-+ !-%, "5 ? "- !- , !%!

,- !"

!+ ";9 !"$* . "5- 3& +-+ !-%, "5?C" ?, !%!

,- !"

* + !!" "5-/? ",?C" ? !E/ ",E/ + *

!$.

$5-!

0% "? ",?C" ?+ 0.

",(

" "

0% 0!!

!! ": , * */E/ ' /-

0% " !0 E/ + !0.

,/ $A E/ + !!

" . .

5 !

" +- $0" .* %

E/ B' + ! .

., ,/ , !

0% " !0 ! %! 5

,/ $!

, + ..

! + ! +

., ,/

.*0%

.& ":

"!( - !0$ " $.

", "5 0. *

$", .

"!7<= ",'

(3 ,+ - .5 !-

+- - &, ," 0%

5$ % &3$ % %/

C "50.!

: , (!

"7'7./ //+ ., ,(+- &,

0.!

",0%

. "" /- ., !

"%&

"" ",$.

%& *0%

- !

. -

. "5 3 - $"!

% . 0

00.

! "5 : , ", *

% * "5 " .

.,( -/ 8/ /8 -", .

" !! "!$,5 ( ",.

., 4$,5*

" "!

3 - ! . **

0$" !- $", .

"7<= ",!

* .5. 5.$! *0. !"* . . ,&

.! 0 "

(B ", " , $% 0 &* "

. $", .5 *0. !"* .*"

-!/+ .(! ! $", .

' !"

,( &+ A$

,/ -

.,%

,$"!

%. ",%

$"!

%(3 ! , 00.

! "5 *

%* "5".

.,/ "+- - * - "

.&+ !!

"* "

".*

", "5

3$!!

",( "0$. ",!- %%% ",!"

!! "53&:

!/ .*.

, "5 !+ %%

+ !("" , ! "!0 .

* ",

., "55 "$ "

!! "!

.&/!0 .B

.C !- - ", > 2)@( ":

"5 . ( - +

, "0% % "

, &/

,.*%

)#/8/ C

0+ -- *.*3$!!

",(% /!0 - *( !"%&"

."* "0%

"(%

!$ ., ."

, &/"

.% .0 - !.!!

* "

"(- ,

, &(- !"0

.%,$ & "

.$ !- : "5

0+- -+ !0. :

/ "

,. :

: "5!

".*

" - ! / C

3$ )# /8/ 3$ =#7 /8(-

,3$!!

",( 5$.

+- %3 . "5-

/ *

- */ -$! !

"5 . ! " "! !

+ - 3:

* "

,.*%

3$ )#/8/ "%& - !(

" "- ! * "

" "- (- ,

".*

"- 0.

, "50 4 " ",

!!3$ !" 5- ","3,&+ 4 " "

, "50 &/ $.

"5 ,0. :

3$!!

",( "0$./- !!-+!

.C !- - ..

"5 ,0. :

5$.

3$!!

".*

"/- !!

2) !"

* 3&- * "- !.!! * "

"/" E/ (

",!* "

0. :

03&+- -B

.C !--

,(+ !,. :

"3&"!

43 . "5-/$. "5 $.!

.!! * "

"( A$ "+ !0$ B

.C !-- > 2)@( +-+ !,. :

, !"

*3 +-+ ,. :

0/ !- 5-%& *0.3

. %.*

" / /"!

43 .

"5-

%%&,. :

0( ":

"5 .+$%,"

C"+- !"

/-$!3&" , !%! "5 "

,. :

0( "" 3 .

.*,$3 /

, $"!

% . ! "

0. :

0 .!" + ! ,. : "5

0( - $%, + %% 3 C !! - ! ", %+ !,. : "5

0( "+ !!+- %!*$!

C"+ "5 3$ - !"

!"!

!- "5-> 2@ %3 . "5-> 2@,

&," C"+ "

,. :

0D - !!-+!

( "

"A$ "

+- -+ !0. :

!" "5,. :

"3&0% %/-

!- "5-> 2@ 5 :

!, .&

0 "A$ "/!0 - !+ !!( &- ,5"

!0 3&0. :

03$ %!,

- ,* 0%

( 5$.

3&:

."*

0 %"5+ -,. :

","

- :

."*

0+ !3 "5,. :

"3&"!

43 . "5-/

.* !0 &- ,5"

"(% (%,5

%C$0 ",.* %"5+ -

0% 0!

( 5$.

",(

.( % 0!

( 5$.

3&:

."*

0/ $.!

- !+ !! .!

%&!

.* !0 &.

$."

( 5$.

'* ," 5-

3$ %

.".

% G "5 3$ %

: "5:

."*

( 5$.

( - **

%& $."

, .$", ", , , "

,* ""

./ !0 . %3 . "5-> 2@(.* !0 &- 5"

"(% ",(

.(-

$."

( 5$.

3$ B , ," * C+ -- *

5$.

/-$!

0 "

B C 5$.

"% 5$.

3&:

."*

+ " "".* &/

".*3$!!

",( 5$.

B + %.

,&- : "50. :

0/ 2),

".*

"- ..

"5 ,0. :

2" - !0 "

" !

2 ! "

!- "5-> 2@+- "- &!

0. :

+- - & 3 ., , + ! 0 .C ,

( ! "

&- . !

". ":

"5 .. ..

"5 "5 0. :

0/-$!3& .&*, ":

& 3& +- - 0% 0 & , !0 ! "

3% !- ," %

" .

.*,$3 !$.!

!0% %!

!"" %+ ! "

"! !

", "!0 .

" , " * ", $.

., "55$ % ,/ "+- -

! 0% %! " "! !

. "

.&/ "

&(4 " "5 ", !!0 $% .%& "

".*

" +$%, - , !%!

, 5 "$ "

0.!

",! "

" ", !!+ !4 "

"( "" 3 .

.* ,$3 / - 0%

+- !

".*

" .

, + 5$.

.%0$*0+ !"

/- !0 ! "0$.3$!

",/ ":

"5 . %! , ,

- , 4 "

+ !!/ - ! !-+!

", + ! +

3$ " 4 "

,3& ":

"5 ","

"3& ":

"5 "!

.!"!+-.

!+ !/ , ", !!"

%%(

&( ":

"5 .+$%,"

4 " ", !!/ %!- 5-%& *0.3

* !.

!+--

% +$%,3.

", !-?C" ? ",? "

",+$%,5 :

! 5"

% :

0/ "

* ""

.(",. :

. +$%,!

!A$

3: $!

3&!+-+ ! 5"

% "5

0 * !.

",+$%,** !* /"!$- % C %+ &! * !.

!5 00

"., % "5 .!.

0"!

"" 0 "

0"( &** .33 .&

.$*!

, !"

"!0 .

" , " * ", $.

., "5 !5 "$ "

"" 3 .

.*,$3

$"!

!"0 .!"

"* & %! / /":

"5 ",+ ",$.

!?C" ? ",+ :

,.*

0!!

!! "

!0 %( A$ "

. %!

*0%

" !" ",! "

$..

!,,

-$.!( ( "& ", !!+ !" 4 "

"!( .,%&* "&, - 3:

" %

$"!

% "

!$!

+ 3:

, !$!! "/ -$!(.

!"!.

., 3:

"- 0.:

!3 &",.

,$3 -

% !

4$,5* ":

)/7/ ",., .!

! , ",3& 5 : "53 ,$3 (3 A$

,/- .3 3",! ",!$.

&3",! , !- .5 ,/ ( "&0 ,( !., $", !/0& ., .3 $.

" #$"% !*.