High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/735/2004disposed of

Sunder Singh & ANR. v. State Of Haryana

2016-08-27Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri11 pages

!"#

#$%&%'

(

)

+++ , - . ,

/#&#'"

" ## $$% %"

&'" ( #')

$ )

+++ 0

"% ## $ *% # ! +) ## $$% ' ,"

*,"%%$," (',-

./012003

!% .4012003

+)$ $ %% % 5', 6"* %% % 71 20.2200.+% % !

- # .34 2/08200. ,% $ +) ' !*" "" )9## $$%:* % %' ;< !1#

$'2%$"

'3#/ #$"%'

#'"#'$#

* ,"

./7 *"

13 !"

$ 9!

=>: , '%-#% - !

# !*

- "% 10? *"

13 , '% -#% - !

# ) % #)! !%2000@< !'$ !#)- !!

%"$$ !'" ' , , '%-#% - !

# !%A- "%

112 *"

13 , '%-#% - !

# !*

) % #)! !%.000@< !'$ ! #)- ! !

%"$$ !'" ' , , '%-#% - !

# !" - "% 132 *"

13 , '%-#% - !

# !%A - "% 181 *"

13 , '%-#% - !

# ) 382 *"

13 , '%-#% - !

# !" ) % #)! !%.000@< !'$ ! #)- ! !

%"$$ !'" ' , , '%-#% - !

# !" - "% 4'3#/ %'56 ./7 *"

13 ..3 , '%-#% - !

# !*

- "% 10? *"

13 ..3 , '% -#% - !

# ) % #)! !%2000@< !'$ !#)- !!

%"$$ !'" ' , , '%-#% - !

# !%A- "% 112 *"

13 ..3 , '%-#% - !

# !*

) % #)! !%.000@< !'$ ! #)- ! !

%"$$ !'" ' , , '%-#% - !

# !" - "% 132 *" 13 ..3 , '%-#% - !

# !%A - "% 181 *" 13 ..3 , '%-#% - !

# ) 382 *" 13 ..3 , '%-#% - !

# !" ) % #)! !%.000@< !'$ ! #)- ! !

%"$$ !'" ' , , '%-#% - !

# !" - "%

*% "$$" % %-#% - %"$$'

' $)

% A ! -"

" # ' % *%" 2/08200.'+%#

@ $ "

(,"$ ,*""%

!! $

-# %", $$, " +)- % !! $( # <.7 <038/ ! *" " %+$ ( '- *% " !

%, % + , .28 .403200.' % 121128 *" 13 $ !

B') "

% ! ##$ 224<8 2708200.9A:, +)'$%"*! !((,"+'

+ "* # % " "

'% " - - *," ' ,"9## $$%:*"

* %, "

!" "

((,"%# & $ '

"'$ %%((,"'$* % " )* '$ $$ *) " - -+ !" !-$) " "

'% C" '+%#

(," % " - & $*" "%' ,"%& *," ""-$ %% %# &,

" " "%" *"+ & &$$ "- *,"*" &$$"

(,"% # $, + &+% "- !*" "" "%" " " "%%"

'$ '% !" (')%'!! +)"

(,"" + - '

% '% *,"' ,"!$ *)! -" %# "

(,"*%%"! $

%#$"&" *" " *%-

$ ,$$) A- %% - A *%

+) (+," " +%% !*" "A @.*% ,% %, %

-- ## $$%* %

-#$ ! %%)!

-$ %* "$$

" ## $$%* ", <%" %'+( ! $

--%% #'%"+$ ' %./710?112132 181382 *" %13..3

%'+% " ", " # ' A- %-) % * %% %- $)C."

(,"C2 %+$ ' ,"C1 6 *$C3 %+$ 6$*," C8 '-!%-C7 %+$ ) ," C? %+$ 6"' %"C/'+%#

" C4'+%#

(+,"

! $ %' !" # ' " % -

' 1.1 !" !-$

' 9!

=>:" ## $$% " % !" # ' #$ "" )" + !$% $)-#$ " # % % " )!'" #$ ""

(,""$$ $ %*"-%" '% ! B' $) %" "

*" "" )"+ # %, "

)

' % ," -"

(,"*%), '*) " ',"" "'+ !((,"+'" ! $$ (' % *" %$ " -" -#$ " -!$% $) *%$ +)" ## $$%" !

$)D, " $+$

%'+-%% % - +) $ '+$ '

'% $ # % , " ## $$%<

'% $ $ '

% " ## $$%% +

$,,, +)" -#', (',-

./012003 !% .4012003#%% +)$

$ '" ## $$%# ! " %## $

" %'+-%% %- +)$

'% $ # % , " ## $$% %"

& '" ( $ #')

" )" + "

# '%

" ## $$% * ", <%" !

--%% !

#'%"+$ ' 10? *" 13..3 10?# %'$ %"=C"

%) *"%'

& *$ , ' %'

" '-% %"!" +)"

'% " " * '$ + ,'$) ! -' %"$$ + #'%" *"

-#% - ! " % # !

-*" "-) A ) % %"$$$% + $+$ ! E!"'% '% )# % +)%'

" !! %"$$+ $+$ " -#% - !

$! %'

#'%"- %%" + !

- C" )# % !! ,' "%% %' % !-#% - !

$! " -)!"'%

'% + #'%" *" ">

+ # '%$ ! 10?* '$ $"

" %% " " B'% & *$ , '% " " %% $, % " * % "

',"%'!! " )

'% !' '% "* '$

' "% !" %%) & *$ , #

'% %$ &, " #'# % !"% *"%- $ %" & *$ , "

% B' !" '$ " #'# % ), '" F F %% $$)-#$ % #'# % F -#F% '$ !!

- A ' !" #'# %

" !

-#!

#'# % % ! 10?%"

'$% -! -

)

%# !

---'

'% $!

" ## $$%

+)" # ' " % $ % % - ! - *" " ! !" & %, $'% %

! 100 + ! " (')%'!! +)C."

(,"*%

!" )# ! -*" " %%)! !" &# %'$ $'% < 1 ! 100 + ! + ,% ' 10?

*% %+$%" ! -" ! %#$ " $ +)"

# '

" $$ , !" # ' *%""

(,"

", $$, "

*" %, -$

% ,% ' .28 .403200.!

B')

##$ A , +) %" *! ! (( ," " ##$ -%""- " F" + " <<$* * ,"*"

%'- "%$$ ,$ ) " "+ $$,+ - % " '## +)' % %+*"

% "

'% %( ,

" "

'% " )"# $ % " "

'% % " '," *"

+ " " !

% B' % %"

'% # #$ %"

$ " % $!$ ,*"" "$ % "

'% F "

( ," % " *" " " " $$, $ ,*""% !! $

-# %" !%

" "

((,"'$+'+ "* $+$ " "

'% " %* *,"' ,"9## $$%:%, "

!((,"*"

%# & $ '

"'$ %%((," '$* % " )* '$ $$ *)- -+ !" !-$)

" "

'% C" " 9"

(,": $" - & $* " "%" ) A"

""-$ %% " *% % *% "- !*" """%" " " ""%%"

" ,%'!! (' %"

(,"*%&

%#$"&"*" " *%-

$ ,$$) A- +) C1 6 *$ %# " -

$ ,$ # A" !

$$ *, * (' %* !

' " # % !"

(,";<

! " #

& '

% "+ "" (' %* '% +)+$' * # "% # A, ##$ !" # $ + " (' %* $ %-#$ ' "%% - A *" "!

- " +%% !% !

- # A @. $% ', "% # % *" "

## " * %%+ A"

(,"% "*" " % " ## $$% & $*" "%' ," $ *,"

""-9"

(,":$ %% # $% % "- &$$"- +' + , %% A- " - "+ "" ## $$%*

& * "-# "

' $% - "*" "

% " " "

!((,"+ "" ## $$%* # % "

!" "

'% % "% % "" ## $$%* - *"

)* # " ) -# '% )"- "- ) " # % *" " *%&,% " !" "

'% *% "% % ""

## $$%"

-- ) !

*" "" *% %" - # "% * % *" " %*" ## $$% "

!" "

(

" ) $)%$ '

"'$ %%((,"'$* % " )* '$ $$ *) " - -+ !" !-$) " "

'% % #

" " ## $$% " ) & *$ , + ' "

##$ , +)-%",%" - "

(,"

!" ## $$%- $) *,"# $ % % !*" "" "

" !"

(,"" " " "%%"

'$ $)*

%-#$ (' %* %'!! +)"-',"

' C" "

## $$%" - '% (') "

(,"

" $% %'!! )F,

'%(')F*" %) !(') F, $! F ', "

' +

$' *"

" % "" %% $, % B'% & *$ ,

'% "* -%%, -"!

$$ *%"" #

% % 10?*

,$)" (',- !$ $ ' " A

!" ## $$%' 10?

*" 13..3%% % " ## $$% B' !" % ",

" %- ) !"

(,"*%"" ## $$% * # % "

!" "

!((,"*" " "

'% !'" % "*" " %& " ## $$% & $* " "%' ,", $-%& *," &$$"- 9" : +) ", "- *" % % !

%# &,

" !

$-,"-% $! + #

!$*C2 ' ," ) * %% !"

' % "*" "

(,"%

$-+," %%' ,"#

$- "" + ',"$ %% *$* *" " *,"" *+ &+ "-! -"

+ " % ! "

( ," ,, " * %

%# & +)' ," #! -" + ,%'+%

%% ) " % - !C."

(,"C2 ' ," %$% #

! -" % - %" " " ## $$% - * "

( ," $-+ "

! " '," %% ',"

- +)"-"%!%% - A +'',"% # % "

( ," % " " " % $-+, " %% *" "

## $$%# $ + &+% "- ," +)"" *%

'-% *" "

'$ #

" " ## $$% ) - * ,!'$$)

! "

(,"+ ,%

--%%

' 132%$% - '

" , B' " ## $$%' %10?132 " ! -%"! -" $)) # 2/08200.

A5#

+)C? 6"' %"%% %+$%" " "

$ ) 2/08200. "

( ," $ ,*" "% !! $

-# %", $$, " !

B') "

% ##$ 224<8 2708200. !%"*! !((," % $$, " !

%, % + , .28 .403200.' %121128 *" 13 "

' "

&#$ $$, " ',*" " "

(,"%'!! (' %+)" % %# $ +)## $$ * ," A"

+)' ,"! -"

!" "

!(( ," "

' *% +)"

(," $*" "

## " * %%+ A%C. % %- )*%

+ +) C2 ' ,"*"

* %% "

' '+% # '+)$

'% $!

" ## $$%C2 %+$ ' ,"% "*" " " " '% "

(,"

"$ )%'!! (' %*%+$ ,+'" , $$)% "*" " )* &," "

!((,"## $$% * ,"' ,"* # % "

!""

'% *" "

(,"%& " -

- *" ) A"

""- $ %% *,"" *+ &+! -"

!*" " '% (' %

(," " %- ) !C."

(,"C2 ' ,"%%

+ +)- $ '

+)C1 6 *$ $

%#$"&"*"

$ ,$$) A- (' "

(," "% $" "

%#$ -#$"

(,"*%# !

-,"%')

, %, -$ % "

-#$, +)%" %% <<$* !## $$ *," " !# $,% "

(," "-! -% ",,"% !! $') %%'

--%% +)" ## $$%' %382112181 ./7 *" 13%%'$)#

,$)"

(',- !$ $ ' " A

," ## $$%!

--%% ' %382112181./7 *"

13%'#" $ -, " B''- !% %* "*"$

"" % # % " ) 2003 " ## $$% ! ,# $!

" $%- ".2) % ## $$' ,"%, + '

33) %## $$ *,"%, + '8.) % % ,$$ ! % '-% % " % ! " ) % * "

## $$%' 382 *" 13% '

* ) %*"#)- !! !%.000@< % ! <#)- ! "

%"$$!'" ' , , '%-#% - !

" - "% " % !, '%-#% - !#)- ! * " ## $$%' %./7112181%"$$ -" %- $$" % %%"$$'

' $)

,$)" ## $%#$)$$ *

" ## $$% +$"% % " +$@%' )+ % %"$$% $$ % " ## $$%"

-#$ " %

% # " - ! - +

" ! 5' $ ,% %"$$, "

% %

--" - #% !

% ," -,# !% %"$$& %%)% #%

-#$)*"" (',- *"' # -#' & #, *"

##$ +$) ! " #

% % ! 32/ %'+-

-#$ # "% '*"# !* - "%! -"

! # !

#)" !

" ,%)%"$$& # & !" %'+-%%

-#$

# #''#" ## %*" " " # % *" " - !- -- $)! " A#)" ! 8 9

(

)

( C" " %# &,@ % ;

#& C" " # +$ ;