National Fert. And ANR. v. State Of Punjab
! " # $
# %
%
!
!!
# & '' (% %
) *** + , -
+%"
%% +# """
#$ % &'( $ )
& & *** %% +#.
"%
( ' $
%& & %
( & %'& * & % (
+ * ,
-./0 -1/0&*()
(
'& .
2 --344-5-1667 ,
.81669
: ' * '
& (
//00 % -0' 1234 &
5 : *
&
(( 2 2
(3 .1 ; 2 (& .899<= (> + ?
* 2 .8
2 @
&.8A9' /
(B & & *
('(
(3 ( *#- (( C
(
& ' 5 $ 3;2( 0
1 9&666/- (
* ( $/
< ?& C& & ( (
'&
'
3;2( 0 9&666/- 0 (( -('(**
2
(( ('(
(D ( ( (
193.884& 5 ' &
: ( (( & ( @(
& * (
(
$/ & $ ) & * & % ( E
6
& ((
*
E
( & 5 ' '
( ,
)
E
( '
(
'
E
()
*( ()
(219F< ? (
$/
&< ?C&&*(
46 96 ) (
*
()
E 5 ' ()
9GE ()
( '
((
' G69.884E 5 '
& ( & -B
& ((
E* & ( @(
&* E ( -B* '
E
5 ' &
: ( & ( *
.G6
(
&
( (
(
E
(
* ,
' D *(* *
( &*
*
,
( .966)&*(*
&( ()
'
D ( &* &( ()
*
& ) E
& ( ( -B
&
' '
*
& ( @(
-BE ( -B*
& *
( * '
:/::/G/ 0E
E
: ( &
./%@<;? ( ( E * '
-B *
E 5 '
( 2 ( @(
E 5 '
( '
2 ( @(
)
E ( ./%@<;? *
H2
& & )'
143.884 & &*
( ( ( &*( *5 ' 0 ( 2 <:( ?&
H 2
& & )
( *
((&
&*- &*
& $/ I& $ ) & * & % (
((
*
(( ((
$/ (& * $ ) & * & % ( & ((
' &*
(( E
* (
$/
& < ?& C&5$&$
( ( *(
&*
((
' ( *
(( '
*(
J*
& (( & ( -
( '
' 2 .8
2 @
& .8A9 <
@
?(
(3 (& ( ( * 2 (B & @
( & ( B &
'
*
( ((
(3 ( (( 0 (( ( *
* ( (
(
( ((
(3 (*
(( &*(& ( % ( ' & ( , 5 '& ( @(
&
: ( K.& &5 ( 2 ( @(
& K1&* (2 )&B*&** 2 ( @(
' KG&* ( &
0 @(
&
' & ( @(
& * K7& * (( 5 '&
: ( K ' (/( (
(( *
(
(G.G2 2& *( ( ( ( ( ((( *
( *
(
''
( : '
&(( & $/
I& $ ) &* &% ( ) *
) &*
2 @
( *(
*
) & *
E
*
*
E *
( (
*
) ( *
$/ (E *
*
2 @
(
) * , E* *'
) * *) &* (( ' & $/
(&* &% )
*( *) *
( $/ (E(
*
( '
*
( (
(( $/
& < ?& C& & ( ( '&
(
)
(
& * H 2
(
E
*( *
(( ((&*
2 @
*
E
D -((
&
*
D
' ,(
( &
* (( ( * ' @
& * (( ( *
&
&
(
$/ && (
(( 5 $& $/ & * (
) (
2
*( * *
$/ I & $ ) & * & % (
193.884& ** ) ($
&( *
(( $/
(
2
E
*
2 17
2 @
E (
2 17 @
& '
((
2 '
* @(
&*
2 E(
& (
*( * *E *
(( $/ * ( (
*
*(
( : ' &(( , %K.& 5 %K1 J %KG
( ;,% &;,%J&;,%B&;,% K ' (( (( 0 2 *D
#-
! "" #$$
% $&'
()"%*"
*&+, * &+ - . ) "
$ ( )"% *"
$+ % $/ "% %%"%0 10)
)2 2 % $" 3 4 '
$ ( )"% *"
) 3 $ 4 $ $
$/"
$#3 32 %%$$ " 3"
$ 5 *"
$ &'
*"
)
) 2 3" $ $ 32 3" 4 $ $ /"
$ # 32 %%$$ " 3" $ 35 $ $ 4 %"$ " 32 &'
0 ( 0 6-"!3708020 "
32 &'
*"
)
) 2 0 * &+ - . ) " $ *"
32
$ /"
$ #
%% $$ " 3 " $
5 ' & &-"
$&'
0 ( 06-"!3708020 $
3
% 2 $ "
$ 3"
"
$ $ 4 $ 32 $ /"
$ # %%$$ " 3"
$ 5
( ' "
"
32 3"35
& 2 ( (( ( '
( <(( 1?& $/ & $ ) &* & % ( <(( .?& ' <(( 7?& $/ (&* &% ( <(( G?& $/
<(( 9?
(
( ' 5$<(( 4?
(3 ( *
('( '
&*( '
J*
& *
( (
$/ I & $ ) & * & % ( <(( .?$/ (& *
$ ) &* &% ( <(( G?((
*
5 ((
*
(D (
:'
( &
(
( K. 5 ' & (
@(
& ) 2193.884
* ( (
/
(
'
( E
( KGB*&2 (
@(
K1E (
D -((
&
*
D
' ,(
&*( &
*
J
KGB* ( - , 2
& (
J
D
K7 *
( (
* * )
('
J*
& ( ( '
* 2 ('(
' *
'( &: 2 .7 ( * ( ' ( (/( ( : .9& ( ( ((
: ( ) ( * '
' ( & , @
& *(& *) &* B &
& ( *)
, (
'
* ) &
( *
( & ( (( ( *
*
0 '
(
'
( -( ( ' ( ' (( * (
(
&
* ( ( ( (('
(
)( /
'
&
.4
(& *(*
(
& *
) ()
& (
*
& ( *) (
*
& (
&& (
'
'
( &(
) & &
&- B &
' *
' (
( ' B
( (
:
( & (
(( *( * *&
&
$/ I & $ ) & * & % (
0 ( *
( 2 ( (( (
B *
&;,J ( ( *
( (
( 3 ( - (
& (( *(& * *
( '
( ( : .A& ) ( *) (
(
( *&
(
.7
&.899(
( () (
'
(
) / ' ( (
:
' ') ( 2
(2 &
D &
*G76F
*' 176FE *
D
&
( ( & *
( *
* ' (& 2
D
&*(& * (
*
(2 & (
( - , : *
(
*'
( 2 * *- &
(( ( * ' * ( ( *
( *) & *( *
( ( &
( 16 2 &*(
(
# 9 "3%32 " $
"
0
: % +$%3 $ 2 ;$"
"3% % +$%$ 2 3 2 % % $%%"$ " % 2 3" $ /"
$ # 2 %% 2 $$
" 3 " $ ; "
9%$- 3 2
6
+$ $ 2 3 2 % % "
32%"$ "
% 2 % " % 2 32 (32
3 % < =9 -; $(32$3 %$- - 9%44 $ 4 " %
% + 2
$ >" >"
%23 /"
$# " 3 3"%"$ " < 93 4 $ $ 3" 3" 4 $ %"$ " %"$ " 4 $ $ /"
$#332 %%$$ " 3" $ ; 3 $ ( " $
% +$%$ 2 3 % $"3 4 3" "33 " 3 /"
$ # 3 %2
2 %+ "
9 /"
$#3$ ( " %+$ $
"
3 $$$ " 3" $ $% "3%
$ " $
"
3 "%%"
$ % !
( (
( 1. &*(
(
# </" $
"
")"% ?
$-"!3 6@7>/> @
" 3% $
"
"
$$ %%32 % 0"3 % +$%$ 2 3
;
% " $"
3 % % =9 -;$(32 "3
% 2 + < =9 -; $ (32 4 " $ -
3
2 8 "% "3 " 3% $
"
"
2 %% $$ " 3 " $ < $ $ $ "2 2 % "
3 % % < $ $ $ "23 " 3$%$ $ 3 $%32 " $
"
0
D 2 ( @(
*( * ( %
-
( & *
&
D * ( (
( (
11 0 * (*
2 2
( (
- * ((
-((
( ' (
) ' *
'
( ( (
-
,
* (( ( * '
(( ' (
5$<(( 4?*
(
$/
< ?& C&& ( ( <(( 9?& (
* 17&*(
(
# 9 "3% 32 " $
"
$ &
"
0 $
3&'
0 ( 0 6-"!37 0 8 02 0 %"$ " % 2
"
0
"
3"
% ; $" "3%
3$ % $# " /* /"
:$ # ;$" "3% " "% %32 "3 $ "
% >
! "# $ %& < "3%
$
" $
"
0
3 &'
0 ( 0 6-"!37 0 8 02 0 3"3" ""
/$ ""#$$ $% "
2 $ =9 -0 %
"*&&'
0( 0 . > > 2 $32. "2*& # /3 =9 -# :
$$ $ /$ ""#$$ % =9 -#'
"
0
A:
@
" - & 6-"
7 &'
0( 02 0 . > 32 /$ "" #$$ 4 "%4 > "2 " / # A 2 32 # /3 .2 *&$ % 2 =9 --
:
$320( & & 6-"
7 3 % 0 (% 02 0 " /"
: $ / # / #$$ 0 0('< ' BB'
:
. 67 & 2$ ""/4 ) 0 .
" " $ $% "
2 $ =9 -C @
" & & 6-"
7 0 ( 0206-"!37 > 2 32 & &6-"
7
< 2
32 & &6-"
7 $ 32 & & 6-"
7 -"
&$%"$ " % 2 32 %
3$$ $ % $
$/"
:$#3 02 =9 .= 2$ %%"%
"320 ( 0 8 6- . %7
& &6-"
7 % &6-"
732"
$$ $%
=9 . 2$#$$ #
" 32 * & 6 7 $ 0 (
& &8*"
$ - % +4$ -"
. % &6-"
7 *&6+ < 2 & & 6-"
7 $
3 % 2$ "
$ 3"
< % 2 %"$ " $ $ % <&6-"
7 " 23
34 $D"2
$ $ =9 .@' " 32 & &6-"
70 (
; - &6-"
7 % 4
3$$ ; 22 $ $ "%2 $ 3 =9 .* =9 .; =9 .E =9 .) $ $" "% %32 -"3 - "$ "
=9 .*
/% 2
#$$ 3 + $ & . '/$ -"
#$$ " / * =9 .; 2$0$/% 2 %$0 /$ -"
& $ * $
$ / * ; % $ /% 2 0' $ /% 2 0 /$-"
& 8 "% $% "% 3 =9 .E 2$ 32 /$
. $ "" -"!3 &'
( ; " < "% 0( 60 (%7
"
0
"
3 32
" $
"
$% "% =9 .) 2 $
( "
( < "% 0( 06-"!3708020
"
0
"
$% 3 32
" $
"
= $
"% &
#$$
3 $ % $ $ /"
:$# " /* %+
% / "3 /% 2 /* %3" $ %32$
3#$$ % "3 "2%
"$4 " ;%"$ "
) /% 2 2 /$ "" #$$ & &6-"
7
#$$ $ % $
$/"
:$#% "3$$ < /$ "" #$$ 3 % 32 %"$ " % 2
%$
3 #$$ & &6-"
7 "" 2
3$ "
$3"
$ % 2 & $
3 /% 2%$ "
$ 3"
"
22
"
0 '
( 19&*(
# >%%.
&-"
3" $/% 2 (32/% 2 2 % 2 " " " $ %"$ " ; =9 . =9 . =9 ./ $ 2 %
@B
@
; $"
$(32 " $"3$ 2 % 4 $ 22 ; " " $ 9%44 $% =9 .. 2 $ % @B
." " $
49% % * "
2 2 (32 $ 2 < %$>%%. $
"
2% <% " =9 -;$ 2 /% $"3
3 %
( ; $ 3 %"$ "
>" >" D" $% " 3$"3
% " $ % %$ >%%. 3 "
"
% & $
3
% 2$ "
$ 3"
"% 32 ) . 3
"
33 &
3$ "
$3"
$ % 2 < $ ) . "%2 $ 3
%$ &
3$
% $ $ /"
: $ # 2 2
$ 3 "
<$ ! $ 3
& - * &
( )* *--
( * * ( (
(( * (
'
0
( ( ( * '
2 &
& ' '
'
* : '
&
(*
) * * 0 ( ) ( (( 5 $ * $
< (? 184.884 ' ;,%; * '
(
(*
5$&'
14.883 <;,% ? ' ( & '
&$
< (?* '
($
( ('(* (
;, & *( 37.883& @ 2
& %
$
2 ( @(
-( -
C
@ .8A9& 5 $& $
< (?&
& < ?
&&
2 17 2@' ( (
/0 (/166/..8 .7.1.889
%
( <
?&$ (
2-
&
5*& *% &(*(
( :
&* ((( *
D (
*
( &: (
' * ('( 2
* *
&
( ' (
(
*0
J*
&
((
&( ( 5$ A6 '
49 )
E (
.884
1. '
( ) ' *
: ( &
( # '
#'
(
) # *++%, --' '
&& 2- 5 ( 2 *
* '
(( ('(
(3 (&*
*
' * (( ( ( ( (
&
*
& ' ( ( ( & ( /('( J*
&(
(
('
.884
1. '
( &
!"##$%&## ''() "
*
!"##$%%## ''() +
,
-
.
, K( ( &
5$< 12 --349-5-1667? ' < 12 --344-5-1667?
2 * 0
(( 2 B($ &
(
*
)
(
D
((
%% +# (% %
) " #
.K
L $
1K
)/
L $