Jitender Kumar v. Shyam Sunder Purohit And Others
! "#$#%&'
# %! ()*+ ( , # #% ( - ($*$ ./0 +.*%! (*(/# %! / ($ , $1%! % $ & 23 4.
.53 ( $ % & 4(./ (+ 6!7"
( / 1 # #% ( 888
/ 99 %: #% / ( 7#$#% 1 # #% *%! ( ( #"9
; /
%$ # * #%%!# #$ (! (%% <*( =!
!
> $? 99 $ %% <*( = !
1 $$ ! @0 / 9 (% ! !!# #% #7#9 *!: A.( #7B6 (% *9 !#$+#$$#%: #% %% <*( =' !
; ( !!*"#%: !"*+ % $ #% ( @* 9 7#! %" $ ? 99 $
#%%% <*( =!
>(9 9 7#! %" (% !"*%$ 9"% %! ! / / 1 # #% (C19 #% #/ !#9 !
$*# $ D#%: ( 9# ! "9 ( #% $ ? 99 $ 1 (+ % % #%E*%" #% %! +7 ! #%%% <*( ='!
; %! (!"*+ % $ #% ( @* 9 % / :(*%! / @*(! % 1(7#%: #$$* ( :
(!#%: + #% #% @#9# 0 $? 99 $9#+# #%?
$% / ( $1%! % $C! %!
% $ %! / ( $1%! % $C! %!
% $/ 7#%: %! ( !79*+#%*$ 7#! %" #%( $1 " / ( 6 / 1 # #% (C19 #% # #% (! (6 ( @* $ #! 7#! %" 6 ?
% ! %! ( / ( + % #% ! !"*+ % $ $ / $ + ? ( % " $$ (0 ( /
1(1 ( !E*!#"
#% / "
$ @* / #%?
$?(%:90!#$+#$$ !@0 / 9 (% ! (# 9"*( ' / #% ?
$ 11$ ! @0 / ( $1%! % $C! %!
% $ % / :(*%! / / 1 # #% (C19 #% # / ! % (#:/ %! ( !"*+ % $ #% ( @* $!"*+ % $6 6'6 '6' %!? ( #(+ #7 #% % *( ?/#9 / ( + #%#%:!"*+ % $/ !%"%" (%?/ $ 7 (?# / / $*@E " + ( / $*# 6 / ( ( 6 $ #! !"*+ % $ ? ( #(( 9 7 % %! @ 0%! 19 !#%:$ 4( 7 (6 / $ + !#! % 1 ( #% / #$$* ?# / ( :
(! + #% #% @#9# 0 %!9#+# #% / 7 "%$#! ( ! / $*@+#$$#%$ 9 (% ! "*%$ 9 ( / 1 # #% ( % ( @* 9 7#! %" 6 1 # #% (C19 #% # "
% !!*" %90 / 7#! %" ?/#"// ?
% $ %! (#%(! ( ( @* / 7#! %" 9 !@0 / ( $1%! % $C! %!
% $ ( %" #% /#$ "% < "
% @ + ! / ! "#$#% #7#$#% %"/ /#$ *( #%"
$ # 9 ! $
9 7 % < ( " / $ + #$ ( 1(!*" ! $*%! (&=
!
"
"
#"
""
"
$ %#
" &
"
#
'
'
"
'
#
"
"(
) # ) *+,
# '
-
+ (
./ 0 +
*+, $ F "*+ % $ ?/#"/ / 1 # #% (C19 #% # ?
% ! %! ( @0 ?
0( @* 9 7#! %" ? ( "
:(#"
990/ 9!@0 / 9 (% ! (# *( @ #(+ #7 % *( #$% / $ %! / 1 # #% (C19 #% # / / !"*+ % $ ?/#"/ / ?
% ! %! ( @0 ?
0 ( @* 9 7#! %" / ?(%:90 @ % / 9! @ #(+ #7 #% % *( @0 / 9 (% ! (# *( $#! $6( 9 7 %" / !"*+ % $#%G* $ #%/ $% @ %$/?%@0 / (% !"*%$ 9( / 1 # #% (! $1# ( 1 !G* (0 $#! $61 (*$ 9 / #%(1(!*"#%:!"*+ % $@0 ?
0( @* 9 7#! %" ! $% ( 7 $ /? / 1 # #% (C19 #% # #% %! ! !#$1(7 / 7#! %" 9 !@0 / ( $1%! % $C! %! % $4 ( + % #%#%: / / !"*+ % $ ? ( % " $$ (0 ( "% (7 ( #%: / 7#! %" 9 !@0 / ( $1%! % $C! %!
% $% / #$$* + #% #% @#9# 0 $ ? 99 $9#+# #%?# /* :#7#%: / @ $#$ $ /?/ ?
% ! !#$1(7 / 7#! %" 9 !@0 / ( $1%! % $C! %!
% $?
$% %*:/( 99?#%: / !"*+ % $ @ 9 ! #% ( @* 9 7#! %" ?
$ $$ % # 9 ( / 1 # #% (C19 #% # 1(7 / % *( / !"*+ % $ $ 9$ $ /?/ ?
$ :#%: ( @* / 7#! %" / ( $1%! % $C! %! % $ @0 / !"*+ % $#%G* $ #% ? 7 (6%+ % #%?/ $ 7 (?
$+ ! #% /
#%@0 / 1 # #% (#%( $1 " / (
; % / "#("*+$ %" $6%:(*%!$?/ $ 7 ( <#$ ?
(( % #%: #% ( ( %" ?# / (! ( !
!
> !#$+#$$#%: / #% (
!!*"#%:!"*+ % $@0?
0( @* 9 7#! %" > $ ( :
(!$ (! ( %% <*( = !
6 9 (% ! "*%$ 9"% %! ! / / #%(9 9 7#! %" / @ %?(%:90!#$+#$$ !! $1# / !"*+ % $@ #%: $$ % # 9(! "#!#%: / "% (7 ($0 / 7 "%$#! ( ! / $*@+#$$#%$ 9 (% ! "*%$ 9 ( / 1 # #% (/ 9 (% ! (# *( !#$+#$$ ! / #%% / :(*%! / / #%( 9 7#! %" "*9!@ 99? !%90 1( 7 % +#$"
((# : E*$ #" %! + / %!$E*$ #" %! 1 ( 0"*9!% @ 99? ! #99 *1 / 9 "*% *%! ( / 1( < % #% ( 9 7#! %" 6 $1 "# 990 $#%" %?/ ( #% / #% # / !@ %$ !@0 / % C1 # #% ( $ ?/0/ "*9!% 1(!*" / !"*+ % $ / #+ /#$ 7#! %" %! / / !"*+ % $ ?/#"/ ? ( %?$*:/ @ 1(!*" !? ( % % ?!"*+ % $?/#"/? ( % ?# /#% / D%?9 !: / 1 # #% (C19 #% # / 9 (% ! (# *( *( / (@$ (7 ! / / 1 # #% (C19 #% #/ 9$% $1 "## ! $ /? / !"*+ % $$*:/ @ 1(!*" !@0?
0 9 7#! %" ?*9! + / %!$E*$ #" %!1( 7 % / @*$ 1(" $$9 ? % "%$#! (#%: % #% ( 9 9 7#! %" ?/ #$ $$ % # 9 #$ / / #% $/*9! @ @% #! %! /
9 7#! %" ?/#"/#$$*:/ @ 1(!*" !#$$*"/ $?*9! $$#$ / *( "9 (#0 / 7#! %" % / #$$* $6 / ( @0 $$#$ #%( %! (#%: E*$ #" %!*( / ( / %%=1(!*" #% (9# (?
$(7 9#! %!$*#"# % ( $%$ %!%90 / % / *( "
%1 (+# 9 7#! %" @ 9 ! ( %" #% /#$ "% < "
% @ + ! / ! "#$#% %2@9 /
F .*1( + *( #% ! "
#"$ % "& '"
( !) & (* '
("
' +
9 7 % < ( " / $ + #$( 1(!*" ! $*%! (&= 1,2 #"* ,
2 0 % 2 3 * , 3 +
4
0
"
# 5 6
#
+
4
!
7 8 '
#"
!
+
4
9
"
# " 3
"
# #
5
:
# "
"
0
;
#"
#
:
# ! " " #
" +
"
3 #
5
#
"
! "
#
" '
#
,! #
"
#3
"
#
" #
"
# #
3
#
"
"
#
#
# 0 #
#
" # "
"
" "
#
" < "
= 3
"
$
9 "
#
#
';
!
+
4
0
#
5# /
;
5#
"
#
# "
# " "
+
4
#
>, ""# #
"#
# !
;
" "
#
#
#
0#
# #
" #
'
#
& " #
#
"
?
# #
# #
#
0 #
"
#
# 0 # +
#
+
4
$ ? 7 (6 #% %% <*( = !
> ( 9 7#! %" ?
$+7 ! ( / #%%% <*( =' !
; ( 9 !#%: 7#! %" #% ( @* 9 ?
$ !#$+#$$ ! %
>@0+ % #%#%:#% / #%%% <*( =!
> / / 1 # #% (C19 #% # ?
% ! 1(!*" / $ + !"*+ % $ ?/#"/ / ! @ % ( *$ ! @ 1(!*" ! @0 ?
0 ( @* 9 7#! %" %! $ #! !"*+ % $? ( 7 (0 +*"/% " $$ (0 %! $$ % # 9 ! "#! / ( 9 7 % G* $ #% %!"% (7 ($0@ ? % / 1 ( # $1 ( (+ D#%:*1 / @ 9! / / !"*+ % $ ? ( % " $$ (0 ( / !E*!#"
#% / "% (7 ($06 % /#%: ?
$ $1 "## ! #% / #% $ /? / $ + ?*9! $$#$ / *( #% ! (+#%#%: / ( 9 G* $ #% #% "% (7 ($0
> $#! $6 / !"*+ % $ ? ( / D%?9 !: / 1 # #% (C19 #% # $#%" (9# ( %! / 1 # #% ($ #9 ! $ #$0 / %%=1(!*" #% / !"*+ % $$*:/ @ 1(!*" !%( "(!@0? 0 9 7#! %" "*9!% / 7 @ %1(!*" !(7 9#! %!$*#"# % ( $%$ (9# (% / "#("*+$ %" $6 ! % #%! %0 + (# 7 % ?# / ( :
(! / #+1*:% ! (! (1( 0#%:( 99?#%: / #%(9 9 7#! %" ""(!#%:906 #%!#%: % + (# #% / ( 7#$#% 1 # #% # / ( ?# / ( :
(! / "/ 99 %: / (! ( ( E " #%: / #% (
!!*"#%:!"*+ % $#%( @* 9 7#! %" (?# /( :
(! / #% (9 9 7#! %" 6 / ( 7#$#%1 # #%#$!#$+#$$ !#%9#+#% A.53B
'
+# 5/ / ($1 D#%:C( $% ! & $C
5/ / (( 1( @9 & $C