← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/337/2018dismissed

Inderpal @ Sonu v. State Of Haryana

2019-07-03Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu15 pages

 

            

    

 !""#$%   

 &'%()$ ***''%% +$ ) ,  ***'     

  !

"  

    - *./0 ! 1''%%* *)1$21)"31 %*4 , * 555   !



/1"''%"""$3"1.$36

*

2 1""%)"#$3 0 ")"8*9

 

9012 1''%% 010!13 0"1"  !'$"12%$)!"



:;





  1&"-%"1<&-< 12!"! !$ 

      

&- &6'"6 ="  *

7 :;&- /  *

7  9&- >"  *

7

 &- &6'"6 ="  *9

7 &   $%    ' 6    "  1  ''%%  "    $3  $1 "6'"6 '"  */1!0$ !!$%

 

/1  1  !!!$  6%  %"'

 1$%  -$"   +".

(8.0!%.$"%1#$"%#$"!  "%* /1! 1'!$""$1%%"1

)6$"  3%" -1" -*)*/$$01-- "

/$$3!1"62 )&.*, 11"'10&6?1 )12?100@"3" )0" A"!3*8*,  9

02 1@?$676 -@1 B8*:

/$$*

**

9$9*

'6&6?1 '@1@?$6" 61"6111!"2@"3  ?1"%.1$311"'6""3*1@?$6% &6?11" 1'2@"31!0@01"611 6 3*,11"" 6"123"1"62 1@ ?$6*&6?1% "1"3*2$:*

'61!%%1"

$321)1"?1'1" 61"61103"3 ?1"%2@"30$%$1 * $&6?1" $ 1C0 *)6$"11$'!16 $@0'1@"''&6?16$1"6*  16>&$)!":;&-03"*/160 ""3*=1'%"!!"" 6"2$1'!  $!%"62 % "3"16$  , $ .1*/1"2

0"" "21 &6?1*&0@"!$ 2 1 , '%"! %",8$1 011'660 !$!* /1  !$)!"

&-01 60""3 $1*/1!!$0*/1 $  '"!%$6'$$01@"  1)0" A"!

 0"1$$62'% 2% $62'% 1!1"!% 0!*1%%0 "% !6'%"3%%1!% 6%""* ;* /1'!$"C6"$62 0"""$''* /16 1!!$$)!" *-**0!*, "1%%3"%%%3"1"6'%1" %"6'%"!"* ,0 1"% "!"1" !* 9* /1  ''%%  0  !"!    !        2*,! 1"''%* :* B11%!$% 1'"13 1$311.$36!* * -B  )6$"    1  1"  '10  &6      )1* )1206'% "2 1@ )1*6-@1 "  08*:

/$$)0" A"2"33""8*,  9



*9*

96$@0'!6&61"1 " 1"!% 3"3?1"%.1"6"3* &6$31'6"" 6101@01%%01"63* &6%'1"!%% " 61"21)1"?1110$% $1 2$0$%!61C *

&6"$1C 1 !1 1"6* ,"!%%'10 $0"!1 *,)6$"01'%"! 

**

9* ,"6DC*-B 70!01"!121" "3$*-%"!" 611 1!"" 6"2$ 2 % "3"6$  ,  $ .1*, %30"11" 21)12?11'%"!!1,  $*/1 "" " 2  &6*/1 &612!$*-%"!!6,

8$1  %3  0"1    2    &6*  -66  C6""  0

# !$!*-%"!3"!1"6*-%"!11 2  &616"66DC*-B 7 *&!C6""1 6"111'%@0%3 1"%6 1 !!$"1'!*

-B )1211"&606'% " 1@ )1*6-@1" 08*: /$$ )0"

A"2"33""8*,  9

*

*9*

6$@0 '!6&61"11"!% 3"3?1"%.1 "6"3*&603'6""2 10 3*&60?1"%*,%'1"!%% " 61"21)1" ?1110$%$1 2$0$%!61C

* &6"$1C !106 1"6* ,"!%%'10 $0"!1 *,"21)6$"01 '%"!

9%31'*-%"!" 61611

1!"" 6"2$2 % "3"6$  , $ .1*)12%30"11"21)6$"1'%"! !1,  $*/1 "" "2  &6*/1 &6 12!$*-%"!!6, 8$1%30"12  &6

01'66C6""  2  &6 0!$!* -%"!!1"6*/12  &601 16"66DC*-B 7 *

-B  6   "    "%%3  4$0  /1"%   ""!0"1

1$%-$"6!%%1"6 @2$1"012$*,'%"1101"1$*1$% -$"@1"6!6 $)4$00111$%-$"0$%

$ 20""3*  6!11 $11$%-$"0 "3.!01"!%$!*1$%-$"@1"6'@1 1"!%"1"6<1$113#"'$*1$%-$"0 !!6'"2  0'2$1!$%16*,10" 311"!%'@"1"1$$"%2"%"  '' '!*/1 1$%-$"00 1!*,!"!%% 6 1$%-$"1"62"%'18*  :

: :*,@01$%-$" 1 10@31"'*  ,11!$%%% 0111!!$'"1$1!!6'"1$%-$"*, %!$%%%16@3""$62 01"!%$!* 1E$ 1-$2%"!-!$10!%1"%%%0 2!C6"*,"1"36 61'%"!*

* -B;1@?$611@0&6 "*

**

9&61@1"!2"33""8*,  9

  011$*/1  1"@0 1"32$1"!*, 0!%1"%%%02!C6"*

-B9  '"  ,."  16    1    ;*

9  1 ."""3"0"1)&.)"31&!13'%"!'/$$ 0    1  '*  -%"!  %"   2%  "  1  6  1  '   !""'!%0"11% < )<01"!10@"'" 1&**"! 66DC*-B97*16 1&**% %" %"''1''% 01"!10!"'!%@" '""! 66DC*-B97 */16602

1"6)12$""30"*

;* -B:,-0?$61!1 :



910

% '-%"!)"/$$2%*1 &'!1@ 1"

 "3  !!$+".   1$%*/1  $   "!%$ 6DC*-B:7DC*-B:7 "1"'!*,"" "1 !!$"1$*,%11"60!2 1 &"3"3 "!*

9* -B 2%. ?$61

*9*

910 '-%"!)"/$$*  ?"1,11"6 %'!%"8* 

*9*

9'"16">)= 1$2*,'"1"'!%"1 "! >)=1$2 2$

16 11!"',  $*

:* -B 2%"%1 **

910' 2%"-%"!)"/$$*/1 !!$&'% +".

1$% -$""%"'-%0"32 ),1@?$6* $"3 "3"1 6"1"%""!%$62!!* /1  &  1  10  1  !%%  "%    1"  2"%  '1  2"3 8* :



 16* "!%$6 &'%"DC*-B 7* !!$  +".  0  %  "3*  $"3  "3"  1  $  "!%$  6  DC*-B 7 *    ,  6"  1"  %"  "!%$ 62!!!%%"% 1"2"%8*

 ;

0 101"6*!!$1$%-$"$ "!%$6DC*-B 7 6""31"%""!%$62!!!%%"% 1" 2"%8*  :;;

;

0101"6*!!$"%"'-%$  "!%$6DC*-B 76""31"%""!%$6 2!!!%%"% 1"62"%8*  9;;

 010 1"6*,!2%). 12"66*



* -B

*"%?$61

91!$! 1'66C6"" !&6*/1!'  -"DC-B

7*&1"'""1!$ 1016131!@$ !$"3 6.2%% 1!@01"!10$ "!"!$ 1"1" !$*,'"11$"20".$  100"1"6"$*$"201'660;  *

-B

2%). ?$61

**

910 '2%-%"!)"/$$*/1 !!$"%"'-%

&'%  +".    1$%  -$"  0  "3  2  1  ),*    "3" 1 $ 1""!%$6*!!$"%"'-% 3!@" 01"!10@"'""!

66  DC*-B

7*  /1  @!1    1  @"   0  ''  01"!1  " DC*-B

7*   )@!1    1  @"     !  DC*-B

7  0  % ''*!!$&'%3!)0" A"!01"!10@ "'""! 66DC*-B

7*!!$%"%"'-% &'%%36!1'%! !!$!"6!" 66DC*-B

7D*

*  **

!!$&'% +".

1$%-$""%"'

-%0"3*/1 $ "!%$6DC*-B 7 DC*-B 7'!"% */1"!%$602 1"6 !2%"%"30"6602 1"6 D)&#3"1"30"*,"" "1!!$'" $*

* -B

 , $  ?$6    1   

9  1  0 ' 2%%-8$1*/1 ''%"!" 2""31

  %%"%! 2"%8*

:

:: 6 *

9

9062 1), -*)*/$$* "%08%  "! + *'%  618% "!%30"10 !"*    /1  '"  $    1      2"%  8*

:

::  " DC*-B

7*, 01$311  $$'!$62 ;

:

99*,E$18% "! 1 62"% 8*;

:

99*,!""6"%*/1'"$ 1" DC*-B

7 *>61"1 $11$62; :

0$0"1"1 /$$



9*/1"$62 0$2 62"%'11"3&D&8$629:

;

 *, !%% 1! 2&D&$62*/1'"$ &D&$62 "DC*-B

7* &1 &D&$621 $10$62

:



    

 ;

 0  $*  ,  1  2"     

:



  

 ;

* /1$6''%"!" >6 1 $62 :



 " DC-B

7   " DC-B

7D*/1 " $620 $12$$

?1"% 2$

-1'%!0112 0 $*,%!" 1      62"%  $62  

 ;

 DC-B

7>*  /1  "  62"% $62  0  $  "  1  62"%  '1  2"3  &D&  $62 9:

;

 *

:*

962"%$62

 ;

6!%%   99;

  :;;

;

*,6"%18% "!"!% %"!66$"!" 1   99;

  :;;

;

/1'"$ 1"DC*-B

74DC*-B

7,*

-B ,#")"311 *

9!!$&'%   %"'  -%  0"3  2  ),7&*   "3" 1

$ 1""!%$6DC*-B 7DC*-B 7 01"!11

& "3"30"*,"6$)!" :

*-**0 !2 1&**,"" "!!$&'%"$*

* -B ;)&"1?$61 :*

91 !!$  &'%    %"'  -%  "    66  DC*-B ;7  DC*-B ;7 '!"% * *

91"3!!$&'% %"'01$ "!%$6DC*-B 7DC*-B 7 01"!102 ,#")"31"30"* 11!!$ "316"@ "!!*,"" "!!$&'% "$*

* -B 9&'!11?$61 :*

91 0  '    &'!  7),  -*)*  /$$*      !6'%"    1 ""3"1''1'$)!" *-**3"1 !!$  1$%  -$"

 +".

 %"'  -%    &'%  01"!1  2  1" "3$*

;* -B : )& %0 )"31  1  

9 10 '-*)*/$$* 0"2 .)"31)&0!" "-*)*/$$01"!113" 6%>&DC*-B :7*

9* -B

16'%1 9* 9*

910' )*-* "!0*1E$ )&.)"311""1' ''!%"'%DC*-B

7*

:* -B

)$2&'!.")"311

**

91 0'&!13 -%"!-/$$*6'%")6$"!6 1"6!1"6DC*-B 701"!102 1"6 6DC*-B

706"*  /1 "0 1$312%82")"31 3"" 1!*16  1%30"1!6'%"0 $.1 $1



 2 "11'"%''"E$'DC*-B

7 *

*  **

92 02$31,8$1*,6   ''%"!"  DC*-B

7    !$!"3  1  '66    ! &6?1* '6612 011" 6"%

662  "  !"'  DC*-B 7 *    '66  1  !"  '!% !""3!%1 1!01"!10@"'"" ! 66DC*-B

7*

 ;**

91""1'''$31"'% DC*-B

7*,%" 2%"1 61'!" '!% "C1% < )<01"!10@"'"" ! 66DC*-B97* ,%%" %"'' 61' !"'!%%0"11 $% < )<*&0@ "  '" "!  66  DC*-B97  01"!1  0    2

)12$"'",."16"30"*

* -B

&'!1@?$61 ;*

910 '&'!7),-*)*/$$* 1 12"1!%% "% "$$62&!"! !!$&'% 6@1 6"%!% 6  )!1%D$!",  "! 66 DC*-B

* , $?$6"3"3 0"$'166* 9*

1!!$1$%-$" +". "66DC*-B

7DF*-B

7 *  *  :*

!!$&'%()$ =%60   "  1"  !  "  66  DC*-B

7 2 )&  "1  ?$6* !!$+". 1$%-$"0"31 $ "!%$ 6DC*-B:7DC*-B:7 *2%-0?$6"3



 "3  0"*  &  '$$!    "!%$  6  1  !!$ 6!1'%! !!$!DC*-B

7*!!$3! 23 '2@ "% @ 66! 1!-8

/$$% 1"!%2"33""8*,  9

01"!1 0@"'""! 66DC*-B

7*,8'% "3"30"* &'$$! "!%$6!!$ +". (8.3!  2%$62'% 1"!% 2"33""8*,  9

 6"%%3110"01"!10 @"'""! 66DC*-B

7D*$31"'% 1'%! ! 0DC*-B

7>DC*-B

74*    *

9  1  )&  "1  ?$6  "3  1 !!$1 $ "!%$6DC*-B 7*!!$%"'

-%  $   "!%$  6  DC*-B 7 *  /1  6"  1" "%6 " 1'!* &'$$!   "!%$6 !!$%"'3!@" ?1$@"01"!10@ "  '"  "  !  66  -B

7*  /1   @!1    @"  DC*-B

7*   

9  "  '$$!    "!%$  6  

*

9!!$%1'%"!'  1'%! !!$! $  ""!  %0  .1*  6  ''  "  DC*-B

7D* /1  !!$%1'%"!' 1""%%3110"

 130 )"31% 0113!)0" A"0"1$$62'%* ="3""$620"" ",  9

01"!10 @"'""! 66DC*-B

7*)&#3"1 !2%). "3166"30"*,''$31 '% " ! DC*-B

7,*

  *   

 !!$  $   "!%$  6 DC*-B 7*2%). ?$62%"%"3"3 0"$'166*!!$&'%"3$'166"@  !!*,"" "!!$&'%'"$* ;* /1  !  "  2    !"!$6"%  "!*  >6  1 "!!""!%11!&6?100@"3 ")0" A"02 -B;1@?$6*/1" !12 !%% '2 )16$"-B )12-B 1$!% 1'!"%  1!* 1-B -B 1

!1 

9&61!"2@"33?1"%.1 112'6" 32 1@?$6*  ,1%'1"!%%

" 61"21)1"1103"3?1"%.1 2@"30$%!6161 2$0$%!61C /1$311@?$610 1)0" A""$''1 '!$"! 1"'"2$11!1



91 !1@1"!2"33""8*,  9

 61"6* !"$ 1C0 1"62"%'10 % $0"!1 -B )6$"%3'0"11'%"! 201"!1>&$)!":;&-03"-)8$1*= 1'%"!!"" 6"2$$"" "2 % "3"1 6$  , $.1*/12 0"" "1 &6?1* 9* /1  !!$      $   "!%$  6*  /1 "!%$6 !!$&'%"DC-B 7 1 +". "DC -B  1$%-$""DC-B 7 "%"'-%"-B 7*!!$ %"'-%&'%%36!1'%! !!$!'

  6!"66-B

7D*-B

)&.")"31%" 2%" 1 61'01"!10@"'""! 66DC -B97* :* -$$    1  "!%$  6  !!$  %"'  3 !    @"       ?1$@"  01"!1  0  @  "  '"* !!$+". 3!  2%$62'% 1"!% 1"33""8*,  9

 6"%%3110"*!!$ &'%3!)0" A" 6 130)"31!% "1" "%%3110"*'1>)='2%0!211 @"12%"1* * /1&"3"3 "!!%%!1!%%"%! 1 62"%'1$2 1!!$*2"%'18* :



 01"!1 6  1  $6  ''%"!"  >6  DC*-B

7  0  "" "   2%3"3!!$&'%0 $12$ $ ?1"%2$

-01"!1"!%1'%!0112  &6?112!*&"1'% 1!!$11 62"%'1"2%31"6 1"0"1"'"1 "12%6"'%!*&12!  $!1C'%"1 =*/"%$"31% 1%11"2%"11'! !!$ 1! !"6011 $%0*/1"%!$1"! 11!%%"%!101' 66 !!$&'% 2"3!%1'%! !!$!*/11"6'%"@"1 !1""11! 21 "!%$6 !!$ &'% 1)0" A"! 6"  1"1$"1""%%3 110"*  /1  2.!"  1  1  !%%  "%  !  %"    2  1

 # '!$"0"6""2%""!1 0!!6'"2

!" "!'1'"" )!":9 ; 1D"!! 0%"31% .!2 1/"%$2 % "3'()

+,+- '.

,/0,(,!

2

 $  01" "121%1" $!1 2.!""@1"6 6@"31!$6C1"2"" !$%2'6"2@%3*8$!12.!"1 2@1"6 C1"2""31!$6*  /1%2" 1,<2%)$'6!$ $       

                   !

"

#

   $ 

   

    %  

&'()*+,"     #      #

         

  

    $ 

   -     "

. 

  

.    !  

  $   "/       .   #

  $ 

 

 $      .

   !

!  

        "             !  #      #

  

 

  

              $  !         

"  /  

   

                     $           

        

   "    

  

 #

.   $ 

.       

" #

   

     $   

  . 

         "

    ! 

 $    



        

0&0 1 .0234  -     

      

   

            !

"

    

 

  "

5       #

 

 

   !



     

&'()*+,     

  

  #

       

"6 ;

>612""!%% 2%"111!!$1 %%  "  1  )0"   A"  !  "  2  &6  ?1  !  

901"!1121"2@.1*,0' 1' 011!01 "66"% 2  1* /1""2%"12 1!%%"%!*/1)0" A"! "2 1!0! 61  11$ 1 !!$"110"*  ,1 $"1C'%"3"31  " !* /1!"!$6!!%% 2%"11110 !$"!E$! 1! 1!!$1"!!6'%"!* ;

/1"" 0"110%%.$36  1%0$*E$% 1"6""1''%1 6""6"*

1 2 1  2  

 )30 !

& 3" B11)'@"37 G B11'2% G78