Kishan Chand And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others
! ! " # $!% ! &' !
! # ()*'+,-+
! ' ! ! , .*!(+,( , ) +$!% + ! #*!/ 0+,,)+$!% * (' *!+,-+
!!' $1,
!"
#$ !!. 03* !! ,
4*! '/% ! '(#!!%+56 * !% (
0*7! '( #!!%+ 1!/ 8 '!7 + 6 !/% 7/% ' !* &0 9!7' 5! '! % : ,3* +& /(
&(7 ,+ ! !; ,;+ / 7 9*! ! '!%! / 7 ! 3* 0 < =
,
4*! > * * ! # < : ,3* ,+=>< ,6!
,
4*! = + 6 6 . *' ! ! 0+ (!
* ( ! ' ! *0 7 0 !%
!7 +6 ! '( ' !6*!!* /% !
'(+6 6!!-* #!
+)*!*0!7 5%+(!
* ( ! ' !
!7 !(! 6! '
+ (( 0 0 ** < ? : ,3* ,+=><+6!7/% *! = , '!*( @*07 6 ' ! ' (( 0 6* 5 !0!* 6 ( 6/ 03*! !! ('*!' ' !A/*(!
(!%!3* !0! :1 ! -!%'*!' (%+ 3* / 76 *''( 7 '( 3*!( 6*(/* !/%!- 0*! ('(6
! *0 '(. 7 ( 6! 7 5 ' 6!7/%/!- 0 ( / 3*!
!7*('('*!'(.77!(+! ( * ( >
'(6!'(
( !((7 +/** -(/(% ( +$!% 1!/ -('7 ,* !% / /(
!
'( ?(( B6 *! !/!- ' !A/*(! '*! ( ?
!* * # < : ,3* ,+ > ?
# ( / 3*! !'*/('*!' ! ( 0* '(+
!*(
/7 ?((+ ** < ?
,6!*' ( :!
#* ( ' ! (( 0 3* /% ( 0
<+(C,7!# 0 - # $!% + 6 6 ' /% *! - !!
=
/%! 0 $ !'! $6-!+ (76!@/% $0 6!77 >
0!* ''( / */7/% ' ! ! *' 77!( ( % 5 ! 6 !'! ! !( ! (!**!+6 6 ( 3* 6 / * !! (-% , !0!* !!@ 6 ( 6* !3* ( 6''( ! !3* 5 !!!@ 0 (7 ' !6 (( 0 ! !+
' 67-!! = /%/!- 0 ( 3* 63*!/% #
!'*/('*!' 6+ *! 47 !! ,
4*! +6 / ' !'! ( , ,'!*( !! 6 ' ! ! 7!'! !
!( !( < , -'. !! <
+ !7 + D ( 77*7D ( ,7 !!+$#"+)*!*0!7+!@ 5 /-!!6 (( 0/% ' !/% ( 0
5 ' 6 -*! $#" ,0 !!+ ' ! (#: <>= / !$ ;/( #*'!7*!+ 6 6 -! ''( -(,''(
- !!
+ ! 6 0- ''( B6 *! !/!- ' ( 6 -!$#"-&'&E 7 ?>
5 7* 7' * &
+> +
A+
< ' 3*
< > ?
+ / *! , (!F*0-(! = =
,'! '(
$#"+ ( 6/*(E !'(
-('7 #!
BB+)*!*0!7 5 ( 3* 6 (
! '*!' 3* 6 -!* ! '!- # ,+6 ! 3* C* -/(! ( G /!- + ' !6!@ '! +- 6%/. %! 6 6! ' (( 0 0 /- / 7- !!= + / /!- ?((*( /
! '( $ +*(% 3*!( 6 ! !*7 + / 3* 6 7 !'*/( '*!' & ! + 6+ /7 @*07
'/% *!
!"
#? B ' + ' !6!. ! !' !
! ! *+' *( 7'( ' -! ( 3* + ( /
!7 * *(E !'! -
%! 5 ' 6 7/%47 0 '!- # , ( 06 < > = 6/!-* C5 (7 ' ! (% 6 !0! !' 3* * < , !'(77 , , + < > =!.;,;*((* '!*!/ ((6/% )-!
' 0- /% 3*! 0'!7 ( 3*!* ! : ,3* ,* -/(! ( ! '*/('*!' !
6 / 3*! '!*! / (6 6 !/%
'!-'! 6 ( / 3*!+ 7. (7 !
% 0 3*! ( !-!+ $ %&' '$ ( )
%# *! 47 * ( ( )-!
+6 % ( * '! '( / 4! . '! 6 ( 3*! ,'!
'!- # , , + ( 6 !
7' /% '!- 0 (!
- ( ( 0 6 '%7 70+ %+!7 /% #)-!
5
< > =!.,(%6 '!*!/ ((6/% )-!
' !6 ( 6 !' 3* '! 0 !(!!* (( 0+ !
3* '! 0*' ( 6 (*'! 0
/!' /%. 0 # , 5 !@*07 6 (( 0/% ' !/%
( 0#:-( ?< +( *
%$ + ,
!" $6-!+ 76 7/%$ ;/( #*'!7*!-@*07 & ! 67 0- $ %&''$
!"
#-(,''( <
+6 ! 6/!- 6 /* *% #47 !(- !7*/(' 7%/ -+!0! 0( - 0/7* -/(! (! 5 ' #)-!
/'*/%( 6 ! !' B '! > @*07 ' ( *'!+$ ;/( #*'!7*!/!-* C> 5 *! $ %&''$ ( /* *% #47 !(- !7*/(' 7% /-!0! 0 ( - 0/7* -/(! (!
5 ' #)-!
+6 ! ( * -/(!
(
/'*/%( 6 ! !' 5 '! '( @*(!-6 7 !- (6 /% *! - ..%. /' 0'# >><?#?
!
? ((0(% 7.! 7* * ! !!(% (6 !0*( 7. 0'6! 7*0-
H!! (%
7(% /*!%* ! /( H '!*!(7'!'!% 5 *! (*
C>< 5 '! '(*/( !7 /-!
5 7!
! ' @*( !! 7 !-
5 *! *! ''(/*7!(%!-6 7
! 6 67 5 *! - 4'!!! 7 !- B !-6 7 !- '!7 6(( / */* 0 6 + 6 * !% 4'!6 ( 7%/ ((/( <5 !7
/' @*( !* %/* - ! !(7 ! !7((%'. 0+ ' !!6! !! /%'! 0 !*0 -!(! ! + * ! 7 3*(-(% /% 4'! 5 )-!
7* - !7 ! B !6!+
! '(% @ !% 7 !
7 !- /% * 0 7 !- ' ! !
3*7 !-' ! $6-!+ 7* (% / /% ''( /*!% '! '( ! /( (* 0 ! ' */-/* 7*/ ! !7!/!!
/%/!*/% 7( ?I* 0 7%7' -%7 !-/*! 7 ! ( ! /*04' *! J '! '(66((47 %77 * !!'! '(
5 (7 ''(( * # < / !@/% #)-!
> ?
5 6!' 0 !! 7
5 *+ '! ''( 7!(% 7' * /
' ( '!4! ! '*/( '*!' 3* ( !-('7 *(E ! (+77!( * (!+#! +)*!*0 6 )*!*0!7 5 *! $ %&''$ ( # ,
0--!0 ( 6 !. !-
*' + ( 3* 7*!*!
!6 ( 6 ! (% 5 #)-!
(/!%'* !! !
!( -*! ( 6 ! G '! +( - # 7/ 0*(E !((7 '( !-!+6 (7 0 !(!6!'
+6/!- ?'(6! (+6 *( /
! (( $ +.' 0 -6 @*07 '/%$ ;/( #*'!7*! ( *'!+ 7'*0 !! ,
4*! +6 !/% ,+ / !@+ !3*! % !
! /% *! &*( (%+ 0 7!+ '! ' 7 &B51J,$&B F1)8 ,#$ 1,&"8&,
F1)8 @'
KA
KA