← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/4845/2020disposed of

Sanjiv Kumar Rana v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2023-03-02Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi18 pages



  

                  



"#$# %& ' (' ( 

   

        &  )* '

+ 

+

+

 

        

 ! "

  #### +

+

  '

$ %    &'() )

* +  ,&-((,-./0

1&2%3 !

+ 4)! 5 !6   7 +  87 %!  9--) )   ( $   / !2 + + :4  -999,,;(,-&  &,< &(, -(,1

 4)    !    =  5   +  

  

 7   !!+/ !2 +  !! ,.,;(,-97

 

/  92 ! 



+;>*?

 9 ,, ,,,@1  $

 (@ 7 +  &@  !+7 7+   A7



 

 9

 0 !  

/ 2      7 !       +         !%

 $ 

/ !1 2   

+ -,-,(,-9 

 

/  92  0 !%+  !!,.,;(,-9 0

1- 

             :4   -99   9,,;(,-&  &,< &(, -(,1 4)!=

  0 9  * !%     91

 

  +  !!7 !+(9,.(,-9 & $$ !+ +7     + $  +  7! ,9,;(,-. > 7!        !           

!6

   

 

8 !

+!    

!6 !

+      

  

    8          7   +   )!3 +/3 =2 5  < 4  

  !  +  !!(9,.(,-9 !  9--) ) 7 %+  !!(9,.(,-90 %

 91

 



 !+!

 9--) )-(,.(,-. 0

1( 19 !% ; $$ !)

 !!+ 

 +  7  ! 7 

   ! !  !

 %  +  ,&-((,-.0

1&  4  7  !!+  '  7 

    !  (& . $!  !  !!%  +  !!,.,;(,-9 7  91

 

  $!70 % -,-,(,-9  A7

 

  

  9  0   

+  !!

 !+(9,.(,-9$7!    

!% ! !

+7   +  !!,.,;(,-9 /0

1-2(9,.(,-9/ +  2$ ++

 +  !!* (9,.(,-97!     !%  7!%!+

 

 !+  !

 9--) )$! +   

    -, $!  !   -1    +!+   +  !!(9,.(,-9!     -- 4 !  !  

 -(

    +  



   7 !    !    0  9--) ) 7    





   



 

  





 

   



 

 

   

  





 

   



 

 " 



#



$ -9 $A8!  )

!7 

  4  +  - .$/

.0 -.$1$

/ +

 2/3

.

2$/ 

/.$ .#4#% 66

'

7 7  '

"#22 % ' ' ,7!  1 %&'





 ! 



$



 "  



  



'





! 



"

 







 

  



 

 " 



#



$(

 

 

"   

 

#



 





'





 !

   





"  ) #

 * 

+ , #, -

.   

 

 ! ,

/0)

  

1&1"

 3'



,

/0) 

"   

 

   "   



  

 

"

" "

 

" 



#

   

  4     

   

  

 

"      "  5 



 



! 6 

 

   6       

 

 

 

!! 



    



! 

!

"

    ! 





  

#

$

, 8 !     5 

  #

* 

  

   

  

 



" 

    



  

"  

 



9 

"

  

 !   "  "



    

 #

"



"   $9



"

1:'

 

" "  



" !5 

"#

  

!

   !  

   "

  



 #

     

 " 

 #

    

 

 "

"

 

 

 

  

      

" 

;



" 

"  5 "

   





" 



 



 



 

!  



#

 

 !   !  

!



 !

" 

!

  



 







 



$  ,    

        "

     ! 

 8

 <!,  =, 4*!'

+

7

#> # ?! !  ,   +

 +    ! ,  = 8#   +

!, 4* 8*+

! +



%@'

  

   

! 





"! 



 



 

   

 ! 

"



#



"!

" 

"   

   

  " 

  



  

#



  



   



 

$ %'







 '

      

"! 

"

 

,

 " !

"

      #

  '

   

 "  





 !



#

   

  '

   !    

 

"



  #

A



! 

 

  

!

 

B #



CCC CCC CCC 1D! 



  



  

"#





"    





 

E D !

 ! 



  " "



" 

,

 &9

F D""

 , 5 -/.!,  ?

# 

 



?

# 

'

G

!

7 9 G



 



"#

 "

        

         

     

"

 





" "



 

9

%1'

 

! 

  



 

  





'



"  



*

 

 5 



"

!"  ! " !  



 '

  !     

      " 

 

     

!   

 



9







 



   

              







   4

  !

 

 





 

 " 





7

  - 

 .

0)'











 %D !

+G *

 -

.  

8# 

 -

.

"











#

98# 

 -

.

  1G





" 





 5

   





'

!  

 





"

!





  

 " 

 

 "  

             

 

  

     

       



     

         

       

   

   

 

 



#







  



 "

$ - 

 .

9











  40







 " 



 



" "





 

 !  







 

"



 







" 











 #

'







      "    !  

  

   

"





0  ;       "

     

 "#

   





  



  '



! 

  ,>  -

. #

 * 







" 

"  " 

 '

,> 

-

."

2  9      

  



" !5

 

 

#

'

 "  



 !

"  





'



 ,

    !  

  

 

     

    

   



#

"

  "  



5





'



!

 "





! 



"  "

 %4

 ! "  

 " 5

  

 





" 

 

 #

"  , 

 



!  

 

! $ 9

 

 

 

 









 

  

"! 



5 

 







 

 ,

     

  '





 



"

5 H! "

%)%

 "

"  /+

%)%   



    







  8#

 >   ,         

 

 

  

  



H! "

%)%



0%'

!

"

     

,



 

   

   





 

 

 ! "



" '

  

F D""

D, 5 -

.   







 !

,

&    

  

     

      

 

,

  

 





0'

!  5 

   

'

  

"   

 " 

,



,

3/

(! 

 !







 





 "

!   





 '

 !  

  #





 

 !  

"



(! 



   

 

 

 

  

!    

 "#

!  

!

'

"



 



"  !

    

 



  '

 

"  

     

  "  "

     

"!



 







  '



 

 5  

  " 

 #

 



          

  

  

   



$ - 

 .

;

    F   D""

  , 5  -/.  -

. 

 

  

,



%@'

"#

,



 "  #



 

5  



"



! "  !



 !" 

 

 

    

 



     !    '

 



"  

  "    



  

 

    

 "







'



     

  

      

  



 

+



 



 



   

 "##   

    

 

   $                    %9  !

" "  





!

  







"



#











  #

 $ 0'

  

    

 + , #,-

.



"

,





 "  



 

2 00'



,

3/

(! 

     



,



'





 2-.!

 



  -.

  



 

  



 

" 



#



'

! 

    

 !

  



  

 

9+ !=9 

"

   

 

    "  



!



 



 

$ 

 $   





 

 $    

$     

$     

 

 

 



" 

      

D !



"! 

!









 

" !5

    #

    

 #

 





!



        



  

    

               !       

 

  

     

   &!    

        

          

   

   !

     '

  

 

 





  

 



 





"



"

! 

#

" 

9  

"#



 #

 

  

>  ,

!, + I !!, * 8* I !!, *  , !*

,



  ! 

  2 309  "

!

"  







"  "





 

"

 



!

    

    

 

    !  



J

  



 

 



"  "

! 

   9 " 

"



!







 

6    #

    

  '

   

   !

 #

  

 

  $ 00;

"!    !   

D



  

 

" 4 



 

  #

 

D



1 %)%%+

  H/@/% %)%  

, 

,

   <   "

5  H   <

 9

  H! "

%)%,

'

%%@%)3 

 

'

  "





 

  

 

 

 

  

         '

 ,



,

7

 < "

5 H <

9

,

'

H%%@%)3 "K

"

%)%% /  !2 4 .

.

$ -.$1$ +

#/ .,  7((

'''

.#4#%

:;

7!  1 %;



"! 

  

 



9--   

     

-9' 

 (!  

      

     !  " "  

.4





5

  

" L4

 "  

,



 #

 L ".'

 

 

9-- 

 

 #

 

   " 

   

  

! 

 ! 





"

 

#

 "   

.9 ! 

 

"



#



 

   



 



.  '

 

   

 ,

9--    

" 

   

"#

 

"

   





  #

.'

 

   " 

""









5  













#



 #

.  '

 

  

"  

#



 "

 .'







  !



   





 

  



!  #

.'

"#

,

9-- 

  









#

 .'

!

 

 "

 " 

"

 

#

 

"

"

  "  #

" 

#.(  

  

" 

 

   

 '

"  







 "  



  

 

 

   

  ! 

  "







 "  

    

 



5 " 

 5.'

" 









 " 







 





 

" 9

    "

   

   !   

 

 

   

  

  

 

 





"  #

'



"  

   



  

  

         

" 

.'

 ! 

" 

!

 





 



 .'

 

"  

5 

5  " 

 "  

!!

  



   "

 ! 



 .  '

 

 ,

9--   

 

 " !5





 

#



 !

 

  

 "  

 





'

"   



  









 

 





 "  

" 

  

 

B  !C -& $)

 E

, 

!

D  

-8++0@/%)1

&)%)%%.M !  1    

,

 

#

 



"



,

 

 





"

  " 

"

 





" "



N

 

NK



#

 

  

 









% " 5



 "





 



 ,

         %%)%)1 

    

, H-

.

<4/ 

!

   

 

9

  

 

   

 ,

    !



 

 

, - H."

 !



 '





, " 





   



,    

"

 

 

(! 





!  

! 







5 

" 

 " 

" 



K

 !

 !

" "



 " 

"#



 



'

;

 

 !

,

 

 

 

 " 

"

! 

 

N

  ! N

"

9

J



 ! 



 

 

 

J 

 " 

 



  "  



'

 

  "  

 



"

'







#



 #

$ ->  

!      9--  ) )  !+  7     +  /  2  7 !  ! !% !      !!7+     !  

9--) ) !!+ !   !  % )

8

!

 9--) ) !!%!% D! 

 +   !  !!%    !(-) 4   %)

!!7  @ !  

   %

@ +  $   



!       

   ! )

 !  !%

!   !   )

           +             !!%

!  % -< 4 1  +  !! (9,.(,-9  +  !  +  !!  ! 

   + 7   ! 

   7   !!7+!

 9--) ) !!+ !   7 !   %! +  !%  $ !!!$   !% 

  !%  !

+ + 7 !!   !   +  !+         

    *    E  7 

/+  !!(9,.(,-927   !   

 !!7 !  %  %7 !  % 10 77

 %

 -; 47     !!7  +  ,&-((,-./0

1&2% 3 !+  5  %1 %!!7+ !  9--) )/0

192

 %

  -' $$ !)

 !

$ !77

 00  +

+

 

  ."/

,  ('



  '  

(  )*+(  '   )* +(