High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/818/2004disposed of

Roshan Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab

2016-09-02Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary6 pages

"# $

%%&& '$

#$%() * % + ,- &+./ +. %$ $# +0(

! 1"23 #$1 # + 2 $$.

161%() * + + 5 1"23 #$1 #

# 888

#5 6("$$4 !

"6(3

1 5 $ "$ 9 ( " "

1 5$$ # $" $3$

*$("$ $3# 1:;1::1:1: %' "$ )("!7$# ""$"

#$"1$"$$"*<# 3(#1

! 5 #

6("$$4 !

" 6(3

32 3#$"("$ $3# :;1::1:1:$ "5 # $3# :%1

$#$3$"7 = 7(74$ "><$ 5 # $15

"$9 (

15 $ ""

#$1$ 4$3# 2$<1

15$$ 3?( ##$" $3

!$ 1*<! 2 !# $7*$$ #"(*## $#$3$ 5$$"$$"

#(33($#< !! $2$"*<# $ 32 3# $#$3$1

7$<6("$$4 !

"6(3

14$$$"#

: > 1 #

#$$"# #$7$# .!

@%AB1$3"$"*<

@%A

$ *# $6(*

@%A B !5 #

7 <5

$ " !$

( $ +

04(

6(*

5$$$ !

*($

2 ! 3775

2 !

5 "# C $7

$"3 #(3# *<( !

# 3775 *(# %+16(*

!$## !# $3775 4

#$$"7

5 "$*<$!

! !$

#.!

@%A;B

"!$## ( $6(*

1 3$3# 5 # 7$ "7$ # 35044$

*$ ! 5

2 !

##(@ #:B3 7$

"$# #$$# #$" *( !6(*

# 5 $3("

#$# $3775 $$(41# $<

7$ #$3 # !

$1 $""$9 (1

" 74$

6("$$4 !

@ B3 7$# 4# $1

#0(#

2$#5*5 # *"7$, 1(4 $$# $!(" ##(15 5

7$"5 # 1!

2$#5 *5 # $* 30, 44$

# $

*5*$5# $ !

74 #, 74$

6("$$4 !

7$"5 # 1!

2$ *5# $$#

("$, 74

#.!

*# $6(*

3 7$ 5 "#$ 3($, 44$

2$ *5#6(*

" 74$

6("$$4 !

2$ *5# $$#

("$6(*

$3$ 4# )( $ 6(*

$# $!("33( $"

"$9 (

14$ $## 4#15$$

< !#

#374

("#*$ $"#$3 ! )( $ $"$" < 7# 4#5 # $ $ 4$3# 2$5$ 4 ( !# $! 44 !1

($$" )( $

" ( ! 2$ # !

# 1 #$7$# )($"6(*

$3"$",$4"(3$"*" $"3# 5*< )($"

, $# 7$33($3$15 5$$7 "$ # 4 3$ $4 3$1 #$"(< $"5 # *$ ! 74$

0$ #4

*<# $4 3$2 "$ $4 #$7$71 ##$ #$"*<# $5 #$

#$4 $4 3$33($3$5 # 3$3#7 !

#$ 5

4$4 $" > 1 # 5$$ $ #$" ( !

#$!

# 1

4"(3$" #$ 4$4 ! # 0$#3 1 # 5

0$ # 4 3$4

2 "$ $4 7$71 ##$ #$"*<# $5 #$

+1&("

#$7$# )($"

, 5

$3"$" #$374$# 2$ # !

# 13

!$ # $$3$ ("$ $3# :;1::1:1:1: %5$$ 7$"

$71#5 $<" "#4$ "!( #< 3 7$"# ; ( ! # 1 44 3 # ("$ $3# :

%1 72$"*<# $4 $3(# 1"$9 (

5$$ (77$"

# 3$# !5 # # $ 3$13

!$ # $3$ ("$ $3# 1:;1::1:1: %5$$ 7$"

$ 2$ $"1#5 $<" "#4$ "!( #< "3 7$"

(44# # 3

$1# $4 $3(# $= 7 $"

7 <

5 #$

# $ #$7$# $3"$"("$ $3# :

:%1#

$""$ $" $ 3 7 # !$2 "$3$ !

$7 # 4 $3(# $2 "$3$ $<4$ "$"# $ 3$3$ " $ 74 3 # # $ "$$3$1# $<$= 7 $" 7

A "+,) *

#$ !$ $""" # %(* 3% $3(## $ #

"$ $"1# 3(#5 $* $2 !#

4$ $3$ *# # $ "< $"1 7$< "$ 9 ( "

1 5

"(*#(1 3?( ##$"# $7,5$2$1 #5

$"#

$" )( $ #6(*

", 33" !<1# $< 5$$ 32 3#$" " $#$3$"1

" 3 #$" # $ $ $ 4 # #

)("!7$#

## $(# $#1$ (*7 ##$"#

" # 5 # # 3

$!$ # $ 74(!$" )("!7$# 32 3# 7$ # A $4 < !# 0 !$ $3< # $"$

$#$3$1 (*7 ##$"#

"7 7$#

": $# $<$ !7$7*$ $ $ 4$3# 2$ 7 $ $<

2$ ($$" #

2$ 3$"4# 3#$"# 7$#

><$ A $$$ !## $3( #"<3$# 3

1 5

2$ *$$ $" 3(# #"

< *< $ $" $4(#< "23 #$6$$ 1%() *1$ (*7 ##$"#

("$!$

< @ 3(" !# $4$ "

B 3#( $#$3$1 #

("$!$ 7# "

< 3#( $#$3$15

("$!$ 7#

";"

< 3#( $#$3$ $7 = 7(7 $#$3$ "$"##

("$ $3# :; % 2$ <$ !( 74 7$# *$ "$ $+$2$1 "" # ## $374$

# $ "< "$"#

#*<# $ 2 (#1$!

" !5 $=$3(# 44 3 # $"*<#

4$" !1# $$ "<#374$

$ )($"4$ #$7 7$<

# $# $

"1$

#2$< < (*7 ##$"#

*)$3# 1 # $4$ " $#$3$ "$"

## $"(3$"## $4$ " $ "<("$!$1 (*)$3## <7$#$

*$374$

# *<# $7##

: # # 3

$1 # $!$" 33($3$ #0 4 3$ $*( <1

#4 #< "# $$ !

*($ $ 374

*$$ "$" 374$

# *< # $ 2 (#1 $!

" ! 5 $=$3(# 44 3 # 4$" !

$ "< ("$!$ ( 3 $# 4$ " $#$3$ "

2$ 3$"

4# 3#$"# 7$#

><$ 9$$4 ! 2 $5 $ 3# $" !$

33$

$ $

#1 7# $3 "$$"2 $5#

$$"

)( # 3$5 *$ 7$#1 $#$3$ # $"(3$" # # $4$ " $ "< ("$!$1 (*)$3# # # $ 3" # #

# # $< 4 < >1D # # 374

374$

!$1# $4$ $# # $3(#1

"# $

7(#>1D 3(##$ 374

#1#*$4 "#, )($"#

"1$ $"

3( $$ 4"$#

(

$"$3$ 4#15 0$$3"#

3 $"#

*2$374$

# "" # ## $"$3$# 7(#

"$"##

#*<3 2 3(#1

#5 $=$3(# #$"

#*$4$" !

> $?($#<1 # $ 74(!$" )("!7$# 32 3# " #$"

(4 $" "# $"$ $#$3$"

#$"4

$"*< 3(# 7" $"## $$=#$##

$4$ " $#$3$ $"(3$"

## $$ $ "<("$!$*<#

44$ 33" !<1"

4 $" !"#

% & ' ( ") $# $ 4$ 0 !D$

E$ D $# $$4# *$ E$ D