Kailo v. State Of Pb.
!"
#$"%%!
& #$ '(#)*'+ ,-"%"%.
/# .....
& (1( && #$ 123 .....
#4
&)*.*(+ 5+-40#'& -$#&+
&.
*(. 6(+6(+-- 123.
.
. 7 8 + &
+(3
$ 45(&&+ 2145 &#$ '#0'#4 #$( 4& 4 %!.%9."%%! (( 43:&+ 145 -
'#1&- 51-04 ;+'+&+
&+(3
'#0'& 14 '&# !#$&+ '#&'(15(4 (:'+#&# ' 13(&'
('&- 9<!=$#(+#&->&+ '&>?4( 4 5#5##1( (# $#
#4#$( :
(4&# :$ #$ (."!-%%%@ -4 $1& ;+ #$&#$1&+ 14 5#5##1( (# &$#
#4#$# :
.
&;($1&+ 4 '& 4&+&&+
#4#$4 & &# 4:14 5# 3:&+
&415&+ '#1( #$&-(+3 & #$$5(&&+ (13(&&0
#( 41 #+ . 7 "8 + 3 $$'&(#$&+ (&&'( &#&+ '&&+&# %.%9."%%A- 52& 5+#5;&+ (+ 5+4$ #;
#$$'(;
#0 &0 +' 35 5(&&##.
,"%94;
& &+ #;
+#1( #&+ 345 #$'.
4 5+(##$+5;& 5+ &&+ 4+ ;(2# 4&+
&:.&3#1&.%% ..-&+ &: '+ 4 &+ 345 #$ '#&+ #$05
4&+
&;(( #&& &+ 345 +05&;#+ 0:35(;&+#
#1&+4
(&'&13 #$# & ' '&::5 + . (
5&+
&:-&+
&& 4&#( ;:4;&+&+ (&65#$+ 5(-3#&+ 35(( 4#&+ 5#14.+ 0 +' ;((&#
44;&+&+ +
#$B 16+;&/1-&+
&;(
+ 44+ 4 &&:
;( 0 $ 4.+ 35( ;
'+ '6 4 4 &+ ( ;
$#14 &# 3
'#&5 #
:+1(6. #. ";(6 4#3#&+&+ 35(.;# ( (#$"!%5( '+;
& 4$# '+35. '+35-&+
5 #
:+1(6;
5+ 4"A/5(.!%%5('145&+ (&'
35(. &+ $#1( ( 4316 '
(;
4;&+&+ 5 ((#> >.
' ( ;(
44( $& 1( ;( +4 4#0 &# (+ 5+.+ '&5&' (;
&6 &# ((#04
& : #. 1C;( '#4 44 4( &'+ 4&#&+ (&&#-#&+ 3((;+ #$&+ $# ;( 5(& 4.
(#( '+#$&+
&;(5#&'#41'& 4&+#15+B 16+;&/1. '+5&+ (&&#-&+
&-;& (4 #
&:;
#41'
43 $# (
' 5+- $$'
'+5 &&#-;+#0 $ 4&+ $'&(#$&+ 4
1&+('#1& ( 3 5 ((#> >#&+ ( '
(4&+
' ( . 78 '# &##$&+ 0 (&5&#-'+;( 4 #1&. $' 14 '&# !#$&+ '&;(4 #1&&# ;+'+&+
& 4 4#&51&:4' 4&.
7A8 (1
#&#$&( 5&#(-&+ '1&#+( D 4(
:($0 ;& (- :- 52& 5+-;+#+4'#41'& 0 (&5&##$&+ - " (+ 5+-;+#;(&+
;& ((#$ :- B'++((-;+# &:'#41'& 0 (&5&##$&+ - A(
' 5+-;+#;( &&##1( $$'
#$ &&#/#&; 51&&+ 0&&
4 !1& 2 5+-;+#&##6&+ ( '
(&#&+ #$$'
+ 'D .+ '&5&' (;
&6 &# ((# 04 : # D+3&
. 1C D+3&
;( '#4 4-#&+
3((;+ D+3&
A;( 5(& 4.
(#( '+#$&+
&;(5#&'#41'& 404
(#( '+ # D+3&
!. (&;( '& 445#14(#$ (& D+3&
;
0 41 #+ .
D+3&
,(&+ (& 4
'&5&+ '
#$ :.D+3&
A &+ $$40&(#$#(&3 1& 2 5+ !4*/& 5+-
'&0 :-;&+ 54&#($ '1(:#$&+ #
&:.(
#&#$&+ + 'D D+3&
<-&+ '#& &(#$&+ (
'
(;
&+&#$ #
:+ 4. 7!8 + (&& &14 '&# .
..-&+
&+( 4&+ '# '& ((#$&+ '&5 04
55(&+ 4 4 4+ $( '&#.+ 4 $ 0 (# 1&$#&+(&#&+
'&&+&(+ ;(3#15+&$#+ +#1( #%!.%9."%%A4$& + 5 '#$ &- &+( $( '( +( 3
& 4 1 # + . +
(5&1 (#$B4:#(&3 ;
&6 &+ #36
( 4&+&#$&+ 0& ;& ((;
(##3& 4#36
($& '5+&+ (&&#.#;
-#4 $ 04 ;( 43:
&. 78 F4 &+ 15 4 2145 & #$ '#0'&# 4 #4 #$
-&+
&+(3
'#0'& 44( 4($# (4.
7,8 55 43:&+ $# (42145 &-&+ &
+(
$ 4.
7<8 +0 + 4 4'#1( $#&+ & (4
1( 4&+
'#4. E+ ((5&+ 2145 &#$&+ 4&-&+(
'#& 43: 4'#1( $#&+
&&+&&+ & #$ '1&# +5 ( 1 # &+ 4
#(&# #$ #$$' ;& ( #:.
4 5+- 13';& ((-;(2# 4&&+ & #$ :31&+
;( #& D 4 & &+ & #$ &. 1&+ # - &+ 4&#:
#0(#(#$ '&#!%#$&+ '&+0 #&3
'# 4;&+(&+
&;(#&
( 4#$+ 55+& &&+ '+'#41'& 4 #$5G && 4#$$'
#*5(&& .+ B4:#(&3 ;+# ;(((#'& 4415&+ '#1( #$0 (&5&#-+(#&3
D 415&.+ (4 :#$( 4:(( 45&+ ( '
(&# #$$'
+ 'D .*# #0 -&+ ('6#$& # '#4&# (&3(+&+&&+
&;('#('#1( ((##$&+
'#&344&+ 4('
' (&+ (&& &(#$&+ ;& ;+'+ (&+ '1&# 4#13&$14'#( C1 &:-
&( && 4&#'C1&&.
7 %8 &+ '#&:-;+ (1
#&5&+ 2145 &#$&+ &-&+(3
51 43:&+ 4 && '#1( &+&&+ '#& :3( &+ '#0'&##&+ (&& &(#$&+ #$$';& #:.* :3 '1( 4 5+- 13';& ((-;(2# 4&&+ &
#$ :4+(3
50 1 +053
;##0 3:&+
&-& '#&3 & 4 ''1(&'
(3 &+ 0 (##$&+
'1&#.+ #0(#(#$ '&#!%#$&+ '& #&&&'& 4&+
(&&'( .#
D&##$&+ B4:#(&3 4# (#& &+
(##$&+ '1&# 4#13&$1.+ ((1$$' && # '#4&# (&3(+&+&&+
&;('#('#1( ((##$&+
'#&34.+ 4('
' ( '#( C1 &4# (#(4
#1&&#& $ &+ ;
(# 42145 & (( 43:&+ 4& #1&.
7 8 &&+ & #$ :-4 5+- 13';& ((-;( 2# 431&415&+ '#1( #$&-+ ;(50 1 3 5;##0 3:&+
''1(
&. + & '( #$ &+ '1&# +5 ( 1 # &+
#(&# #$ #$$' ;& ( #:. + 4
#(&# #$ &+ #$$' ;& ('#&3 0 ;
4;&+4( &1(&#(1( '# :3 '1( #$ #$$'(&&1(-1 ((41&&+ '#5 &5#14(&+ $#.
+ (# #0(##$;;+'+ C1 (&+ #$4
;& ((&&+ & #$( '+#$&+ (1(
'&.+ '1&# '#&3 4('4 4 :#&+ 5#14&+
&;& ((;( 2# 4&&+ & #$ :4$2# 4-+(#&3
D 4415 '#1( #$&. 1&+ # -&+ :+(3
'& 4$#&+
'#('#1( ((##$&+
&-+ (&;( '& 4&&+ #&4 #
D&##$4
&;& ((#&+ ('# &+&+ +(3
;# #0 4# (#&& 4&#( :4#13&&+ 0 (##$&+ '1&#.:
#(& &'+#$5&#-&'3 (4&+&&+ '1&#( 3  4(3 4(# :#&+ ('# &+&&+5 (1 #&+ 4
#(&# #$#$$';& (#:.&3 (&-&'3 ''1(&'
-;+'+;'(& (&5 &41&:1 #&+ #1&&#('1&G &+ 04 ;&+# ' 4 '1&#.
!"
# #$"$%& '"( )*)*+,-
+ ! ".-/01 = 1 #1&?-&+(3
+ 4($##;()
H A.
1&+ - & ( '#& 4 3: 4 ( # '#1(
5$#&+
&&+
&;& ((;(
D 4- 4 & &+ $'& &+ : ;
03 . &+( 54-&( #&'
4$#&+ 4
#(&##$ 0B- 4 #(&3 = ?- 415 &+ '#1( #$ '#((
D&#- +( (&& 4 &+& $$#&( ;
4 &# 2# 4
&;& (-31&# ;
03 .+
$'&&+&&+ '1&#(3( 4#&+ 04
#$#$$';& (-4# (#& &+&( (+#14#&3
4. !.
+ 2145 &&+ #$
! 4 # 3: &+ '#1( $# &+ #4 && (# (1
#&( &+ '( #$ &+ '1&#. &+ $# (4 2145 &- &+( #1& +( + 4 &+& : 3 '1(
'1&# 44 #& D : 4
& ;& ((- ;#14#& '
((: 4&#'#'1(#&+&''1( 4;( $( : '& 4.+ 04 #$#$$';& ('#& 4(&1(& 444(3 4- :#''#1&#$&+ #$$'(&&1(.&+ #$ "
# $%
&'
(
(&;(+ 4(14 )
H& ( '+' #&# &+& '&#( #$ &+
$$'
-(+#143
#'+ 4;&+&4(&1(&.& (& #;&#(&& '5& (&&&1(&#&+
'&#(4&+ 4#'1 &(4 3:&+ .&:
& -&+ #1&('#&(&&;&+&+ (1 &#&+& '#4( 1&1(&;#&+:. (
(1 &##$;-&+ (1 &#;#143 &+
#&+ ;:#14.+ #$$''&(#$&+ +0
51:
$# 4 ( ;( ' #$
(1  '#5G 4 3:&+ B 5(&1 I.
7 "8
1&+ # - #
D&# #$ B4:#(&3 16+;&
/1'#&3 & 4 ''1(&'
&# &+
'1&# 4#13&$1.+ '#&34+(3
43: 52& 5+&+ #$ " (+ 5+.B4:#(&3
16+;&/1((#;& ((&#&+ :.
(#( '+#$&+
&;(5#&'#41'& 4&+#15++ .&(#&&+ C1&&:31&C1&:
#$ 04 &+&+( ##6 4&#&#( && &+ '#� (:.&+ (&& '( -&;#;& (#$&+ :4&+ #'
45('#41'& 4&&+
#&-+0 3
D 43:&+ '1#
D&##$B4:
#(&3 16+;&/14# (#&'(&:4 &&+ 5 1 ((#$ (##$&+ '1&#. 7 8 &((5$'&&##& &+&&('( #$'+'
:.+
&:;(##1& )&:-;+ &+
&;(( #&& #5;&+&;#35('#&5 #
:+1(6.+ 4&#: #0(#(#$
'&# !% #$ &+ '& '#$ 4 &#
(# ( '+ #: 4 #
'# '
(4 #0(#;#&: 0&& &+ :
&+ (&&'( .&+( 54- '
'3 '
41 #&+ 2145 #$&+ 1 #1&#$4$"$%& '"( # # ".' 23 " " %$3
)*)*+,-+ ! ".-/4+- ;+ &+(3
44#; ($##;5)
H( 54(
'3&:#$&+ C1 &(14 '&# !% #$&+ '& '#'
4-& ( ;
( && 4 &+&&+
4& #$ '&#!%#$&+ '&('#$ 4&#H
(# '+I4#&&#( '+#$0 +' #'#& #
( (.I 7 A8 4'#1( $#&+
&+(51 4&+&&+ (4 :
#$( 4:(( 45&+ ( '
(&#&+ #$$'
#$+ ' D ;+'+($&&#&+ '1&#'( .&:3 &# 4+
&+&&+ 4 :( 45&+ ( '
(&#&+ #$$'
#$+ ' D ; &+ '1&# 4#13&$1&+ & # '#44'& (&+&&+ #
&:;(&
4;&+# : 214'
+(3
'1( 4&#&+
&.&+( 54- $ ' 4  '(##$&+ 1 #1&#$4 "
5 23 # #$"$%& '"( )**4+6-+ ! ".-70-;+ &+(
+ 4&+&&+ 4 :#$A%4:(( 45&+ ( '
(;( '#( C1 & ( & +4 #& '1( 4 : 214'
&# &+ ''1( 4.
*# #0 -'(
#& 4(
&+ ;( "4:(4 :( 45&+ ( (#$'#&'
(13(&'
$#'+ ' D&#-&;(+ 4&+& 4 :( 45 ( '
($#'+ ' D&#;#14#&3 (1$$' 5#14&#'#'14 &+&&+ ( ;(&
4;&+.
7 !8 &+ +4-&+ ((1$$' &4 3 & &# 4'& &+& &+ ( ;( #& &
4 ;&+ & : #& #$ & .
$$40& D+3&
A #$ * /(+ 5+ +( 3
& 4
04 ;&+##32 '&##$&+
&. 1&+ # -&+ ;& ;+#+4+4 4&+ #
&:& (&$ 4&#&+ '&&+&&+ ( ;( #&&
4;&+415&+ & & 4&+ '1(:. &+
$##;54:#$ :-&+ #
&:;((# #41'
43 $# &+
#1&#$ 4+ $14'*5(&& 4
1(#$&+ #4 4& %,.%9."%%A4'& (&+&&+ (#&+ '
(;
$#14&'&.
0
#&#$&+ + 'D D+3&
<4'& (&+&&+ (# ( ( ;
&'& 4 5
4 ;&+ &+ (
' ( . &+
''1(&'
(-&'#&3 (4&+&&+ #
&:;(&
4;&+& : #&#$& 4# 214'
+(#''1 4&#&+
&#''#1& #$4 :#$( 4:(( 45&+ ( '
(&#&+ #$$'
#$ + 'D .
7 8 *1'+ +(( +( 3
4 3: 4 '#1( $# &+
&#&+ (
'&&+&&+ ('6#$(1$$' && '&
&+&&+
&;( '#('#1( ((##$&+ '#&34.+
&;($#14 &+ 35(4#(
5&+ &:-(+ & &#( ;:.&+( 54- $ '3 4 &#&+ 4 '(##$&+
#1& " " "." " %$3 # #$"$%&!"83".
" #3 )**9+6-+ ! ".,**+--;+ &+(3
4 4#;($##;5)
H '
((#( (&3(+ 4-&+
(#;+#'( &+&&;(#&'#('#1( ((#-+(&# (&3(+&- '1( +#;+ '  ((#(;&++(
'6#; . '&#!#$&+ '&50 ((&&1&#:
'#5&# #$ &+( #(&# 3 '1( #$ (1 &# 03 ;. (&+ #(&#& (#$ '&# !A;+ (# (1 &#(03  4;$#
((##$'&&' (.I 7 ,8 &+ (&&'( -#(
5&+ &:-&+
&+4 & 4&#( ;:. 5((&1'6;&+&+ 35(4 #
:+1(6( 4#1&.
& (&+&&+
&;('#('#1(#$&+ $'&&+& #
:+1(6;( 5' 4&+ 35(. 1&+ # -&+ (#&+5# '#4&#(155 (& &+& &+ ;( : #&+
(# & & &+ '
#$ :.
#( C1 &:-&+( ((1 4&+&&+
&;('#('#1(
((# #$ &+ 35( 4 ;( ; #$ &+ '#& &( #$ &+ 35(.
*# #0 -&+
&+( 1& $#&+'( #$&#&4 .+ (&& 14 '&# .
..- (+ +( 4 4 &+ $'& #$ : #$ '&5&' ($#+ ((#.&(#&&+
& &+&(+ ;(#'
&: & &+ 35(;&+#1&+05&+ 6#;
3#1&&+ '#&34.# ;-3(##(&:(4 #1&5(&&+
&3:&+ #$$'(4# (#(4 #1&$#+ $(
'&#.+ & # '#4 #0 (4 (&3(+ (&+ $'&&+&&+
&;($#14'#('#1( ((##$&;#35('#&5&+
'#&34. 7 <8 4'#1( $#&+
&+( #& 4#1&4('
'
5&+ (&& &(#$&+ ;& (. 52& 5++(50 & #$ (&#$&+
&(.%% ..4 05&+ #&(9.%%
.. +((#4
#( 4&+&&+ ;&5;#6;(4# ;+ (&&5&+
. &+ '#&:- " (+ 5++(50 &+ & #$ (& #$&+
&(<.% ..-4 05&+ #&( .%% .. +( $1&+ 4
#( 4 &+& &+ ;&5 ;#6 ;( 4# ;+ (&&5 # &+
0 & 14 &+ + 4 5+& #$ &+ 0 +' . + 4('
' (
'#( C1 &44##&: &+ '1&# &# 3 4#13&$1. $ ; # 4('
' ( 3#14 &#
&+
(&& &(#$&+ ;& (41 &# #$& .
(#(#&
'& 4&# 3 1& $'&(;&+&+ &''
&&:$& #$ & .*# #0 -&+ 4('
' (-( #& 4#1&- '#( C1 &4 4# (#&& 4&#$($:&+ 0 (##$&+ '1&#.
7 98 &+ (&&'( -&+ :+(3
'& 43: 52& 5+ &+ #$ " (+ 5+.#&+ &+
;& ( +0 50 4 & 4 4 (&($'&#: '#1& ;&+ 54 &# :4( C1 #$ &( 45&#&+ :#$'&5 &' ($#&+ ((##$&+
&.# ;-3(##(&:( 4 #1&5(&&+
&3:&+ #$$'(4# (#(4
#1&$#+ $( '&#.;& (&#&+ :+0 4
#( 4 $:(&($'&#: ;&+ 54&#&+ & (
'&(#$&+
'( .+ 4
#(&#( ('#$4 4$#(045#14$# $#145&+ '#0'&##$&+
&.# (#(4 #1&$#$(
'&##$&+
&.+ '1&#+((1''
(($1: #0 44
(&3(+ 4&+ 51&#$&+
&3 :#4&+ (+4#;#$: (#3
4#13&.+ &+( '#4 4&+ $45(#$'#0'&##&+ 3(( #$ 3 4(&($'&#: 04 (&3(+5&+ 51&#$&+
& :#4&+ (+4#;#$: (#3 4#13&.+ 2145 &#$'#0'&#- ( '#4 43:&+ 4&(#&+ 3((#$(&($'&#:4 3 04 4 &+ ( 4# ( #& (1$$ $# : 5&:# 51&:;+'+:'$#:& $ 3:&+(#1&.((1'+-&+
$45(#$'#0'&#-( '#4 43:&+ &- $$ 4. 7"%8 E&+ 54&#C1&1#$( -&:3 &# 4+
&+&&;#35('#&5'#&34;
5+5!%/5(.='145;
5+&#$ 35?;
4$#&+
&4((1'+&+ &'
&#&+ '#'1(#&+&C1&&:#$&+ '#&34 4$(&+
'& 5#:#$ ((&+'# 'C1&&:4'#( C1 &:-&+ $# (4 +(3
#( 4#+ .#;
-&+ #4 ;&+ 54&# (( 43:&+ 4&4'& (&+&&&+& #&#$& -
&;(#44:5 43#1&,%:
(.+ : '& 4( 3'6(&+ :
"%%A.+ C1&&:#$&+ '#&34 4$(
'& 5#:#$ ((&+'# ''& 5#:./
50 ;&+ &
''1(&'
( #$&+ -(# # ':'3 $$#4 4&#&+
&&+('( . ''#45:-&+ #( 41 #+ ( 41'
4##1( (# &$#
#4#$&+
:
(;&+$ #$
(.!-%%%@ 44 $1&#$ : &#$$ -&#$1&+ 14 5#5##1( (# & $#
#4 #$ &+
#&+(. #;
- &+
#4 #$ & &# 4: 14 5# 3: &+
& (+ 3 ( & #$$ &#;4( (13(&&0 #$ (# & #( 41 #+ . 7" 8 E&+ &+ $# (4 & #4$'&# &+ C1&1 #$ -&+
3 54 0#4#$ &((4((( 4. 7""8 +
&(#34 '
((:(&
(3 && 4$#
'&5+
(&(#&+&(+ :14 5#&+ #( 41 # + . "
83,0 )*)* + - :;