← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/5126/2024allowed

Arun Singh Pundir And Others v. State Of Haryana And Another

2024-09-11Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel11 pages

  

   

   

 

%()*+,)-./.*0

!!

          34         %(     !  





 15     (     16  7

5   ( &   88888 

"!# $%&' 

 9 (  ( ) ) (        

   

     !   "    # #$% ''

 ''' .0

;/         (

  !!

!

':

:

; <': $  

   *

   + ,

  -   -   

 ) (  &  . /

 - 

    "

 (  

  

 ( 

''!   !

!  . 0 ;/ -



'!.0 ;

;!/   )  *1  *

 2  -     (  2 )  ;

 

        2 (  - -

) )  ( 

- -

   79 9 

   #$% (

  



  

   

-  



  

)   



9   (  .  "     #$%  " / - -

 

- -2  

<''!) 

 =  

 

  2 -  

 

  

               



    

    

   



       !     "  #     " 

      $   "   ) %  &     ! 9  (  )  ( -

 

- -  !'! )  

  =         2  -   

 

  '                !     "      

"     &     "   9    ((    ( )  ( ) (  "  

  #$%"   

     (  -  

!''  - (          (  & 

  

((   '!'   

  (  -2 ( (   ((   )     ( ) )

 ( & 9

( & 

(  < ?          (          

(./ /)- ( ; )

 ( & ;-- -

   >   ( ;  )   

   

"

 ./4  ./   (

  (     

 4

(

 

  '' 9   2  ( 

 4

(

 

 '

''     )-   (    (  &  . (  -   ) ((

0  ;/

 ;

 *    ! 

"                

      

   " +,(597,0=70   -   "   *  "  "  . ,,/////+57.8  '  "0  "

* *      

     1 2 "  

       

  

  

  "  

 "

1  "   

   "         "    "   3     "0

"

  "     *   . ,,/////+578   "0      5 0.

////+5 '  "*   "0  

 3 

  "

"6  

 

    0. ////+578  

"0  

  3        "       

      1 

  09 "  "    



 ": 



  

         "

  0*  "  

  >#$ 

  . ; # 2 < = "

 # 

        !            $  

    ;   #   2 <   "

 # 

$

 *                        "     

       

    "

        

   



           

"   " 

 

* 

                         /,=/        * 

"  " " "

     

"              "         

    

% *  "                   "      "      

  

       ! 

!                     ,    1 ,(7907,070 -

*   5    /% " 45/ /?5/, /,  

->@+  ?

      $ 



 .  ,//A /,B& / / /?

/,B@ 1 C(((%%4 4/ 4B?5 /  2#        #" D         

    

  ) $ ) ) 

 ( & ;-

2  

 ( ; ) 

 %''

 



 

?   

 )  (       2) 2  )- (   (

 ; )



  $

9 0+(     

 - -  ( 

 

)  ?    

    )     

   2  

 )   )   (

*  #



 ,

 & *

 ''!' 9  2 (    

 ;

 >  /4 /( /     "     

   

 <    

        

  5      /?

/,                   "       <"        "

   "    ,,    7 0   " 

 G ////+5    70       

  

/// ?4   ( /?

/,             

   .

/// /+5       "    , ,       "    

    

///?

(   ?

/ /   @1 

9 !E         



          "!  

   ,        "   "  +      +     

     :   

 . ,// / /?

/,B 1 4B?5  2#       " 

 "  "       $  



+  

    "         

  "    *        

   

 "   

  <

          2    

 "  "         " 

"       

   "

        "

"                    !



 

   "                        "     

" "    8                           "                 

 

 # $ "           ,/ , /,%

F 

    E 2  A  "

"    

     

  "  

    

    

"   ""     "  "  $ " "         2    

  "         /?

/,        "

2      

&      

"

    

        )

?        ( & ;-  -  

    ( )        2  "         "        (  #$%        4

(

 

    )-   (  

 - 2-    (  

  (

     9   

 )       #$%   "

 (  

  

2 )"    : ?     

    

(  )          (  ?           ) 

 (        4

(



 . 0 ;/-   

 )- ( 

( & % (

'!')- 

2  % 7  @ @

   +( ( 

  ,

  & ;$$

      )    

   2  ''!



(     !     ! .

/ -  ((   )  )    

(  

7 

 '! -     - 

   (  A (  -  ) (  



) 0

   $ 2       (  2(   

  $-

) ((     7   

  

          



 ''B 2  -  

 ;

?

*  1  4B?5          2# "  "  



   ,B?(     " <  

    

1 "< :      

1  4/  2#  

  "    "    

5    70 

"  *#    H  1  7 0              



 1 4B?5

 2#                I  !

     J       " !

  

" 

>        

  

"

 



 

 "   7 7   0 

         *        70:      "+ 

"        

     

" 

    

   

     

 

A  

           5       

  #70 8 #           

      !        

      

              * # 

      



  

          *    #:

  

   1 4?  # # ,B%(K  

 

   





 "   ?

,      "    

           +    5 

+   "           

        !

  "   

 . $ $  * J1 #    .

  7 0  - 1  7 0   : "    !  70=                                 "  $ "       

 "   "    

  

  + "    

<    "     

  < " "               5            

             "   <"<   5  "

2         "     K       

   ?

 *  $   :     # "  "  :

      1  4?  # #  $   .7  

 

 0      J1 #    #$ %&'" 7 0

   7 0 *      # 1 4?# # ,B%(  "     !"  7 0 *            #K       <     1  4?  # # K      "  * "  :         : :        "     #      <     $     "    #     

        ?

( *  J 1  #         %"    7 0    :

 

   #    "

"!   

 

          

   $ 

  .7    

 

          <                <     

  "    



"K # :    1  4?  # #   ,B%(K           )   :

  

   )    +        

 $   

  

C  70   . 

 

          

+            +

 =



$ " 5+    .7  





 0$   70    ! K

 

+ "5    70     +       + +   70    "

   "             

    70#

"  

  

+ 

   70      +             +      !        

 + = 

  

  !  +

 70 $    +

K #

 <  1 4?# # ,B%(  "   $ 

  + 

 70

  !

"  +      +:     " 5    "     $         # ":

:   1  4?# # ,B%(     +         )   (     (

)   (   



 4

(

 

' '-   )-   ( 

(     (    4

(

    (  ;-  2  

%''

 . -   

  4(



/ 

(  ; )  2 .

  

  /

 )(  )    #

 $     )     (  & ;-    (

 ) 

  

(

4   "

 2 .)-





/

 (    9  2    

0           (    (  #$%  )  )

( 

-  &   0(  -

)    (    (   (    ( # #$%

(    9   ( 

-  0   -      !

  )0(   J "     20   2    (./ ) (

      ( 

- -        -

)

0( 

      7 

    (  #$% .

  (   

 

/ "

    = ( -  7  (           

( & ;-0( 

 (

 ( 

-4     )  9 



 

)  )(  ) (      

 

(  ( 

-  4

(



)

2 )- 2

(  )     (./  8    (  &   ( ;- 2   ) 

 - -    -   

  )    2 

   + ' $2-   2    

- ./ 9  ( #$%& ''

'

'''.0

;/ 

   (   !!

!

':

 ;

 <':

 $  

   *

   + ,

  & -   -

  

  ) (   . /

 - 

   " 

 (   

   

   ( 

'' !   !   .0 ;/ -



 '!.0 ;!/(  )*1 *

2 -    (

 2) ; 

"    ./ 9  (  ;-  

-   

% ''

'

''4;-  

) (  )  -  * 

1   .*1/ , ,

 & *

-   -6

$         (  B *1  ,



 &  *

 

2  

 

         ?

  2  

 6

  $         (  ) ( & ;-  

B 

*1,

 & *

   

 +( ( 

   ,

  &  *

 -  

2   

  2

 

 (  & ;-  ) )

-   

 

 2  ( 

C       +( ( 

  ,

 & *



2 

) 

*1 ,

 & *

            ?

2 

 6



( ) ) *1  ,

  &  *



 +( 

   ,

 * *

     

 ./ %           (    7    (  & ;-B *1  ,

  &  *



 +( ( 

  ,

 & *

 "

  ( )

< "

 ((  ./   

 (   #



' 

    ' D  ( 64   ,4& ,4& D  (