Jarnail Singh v. The St Of Hry
!"
"#$%$ '
&( )*
+
)& $, ///// 00",, &!
1%/ ! !"
)* & ///// "%0 &2"&!
/ 3."!.") "0 )!")%
, # , 0 0")% 4 * ,, 6"2
%""
7(2-4"&!8
/
"))"2
"0 )!")%
!8 9/ 3."!.") %.
(,2 )!"2
$-"%!8 )/ (,%. & . )4 + 2:
# !"
%/ .$4 + + )* & /
.$% 00" , 2$)"#!"2
&:$#!$ 2 !"2
9/;/
)2")
%"&!"&#"
2 !"2
;/;/ )"&2")"2 ./ /</ &2.$+ 22$!$ & , "%%$
(2-"+ !". 5 2+ 6.")"5*+ %"&!"&#"2
(&2")-
)$- (% $40)$% &4"&!
0")$
*" )%
0 *
$&"
%/ , #/ 2"
(,!
0 *4"&!
$&"
()!.") (&2")-
%$40,"
$40)$% &4"&!
0")$
!6
*" )%
44$!!$&-
"&#"
0(&$%. 5,"
#
)# !$#
)(-%
%*#.
!) 0$# (5%! &#"% #!+ =>+ .")"$&
# ,,"2 ?
#!?/ 0") # %"+
// @
, &-
!.")
$#$ ,% - $&-
)2 )"6 ,
A 2(6 % %$2"
&&"#!$ 0 !) , 2"!"#!$
#)$4"/ 4" &6.$,"+
)"#"$:"2 $&2(,-"% % ,"
0()#. %"
) $2+ .(-"
C( &!$!*
# & :")"2/
6)$!$&-
%"&$
$#")%/ $2$&- 0 )!*
)4"2 #""2"2 6 )2%
& 6 *+ .
6B$2 )+ 4"!
0 )!*
$&"2 $&:"%!$- !$
$2 &2(#!"2
3."& 0 )!* )" #."2
00",, &!D
%""$&- 0 )!*+ %! )!"2 - $&-
(!
!)$"2
) & 6 *
%0 5(!
00)"."&2"2 ,$#"/ & $&C($)*+ 2$%#, %"2 $2"&!$!*
)& $,
"7 $&-./ & %" )#.
!. + 4" &!
B""0$&-
22")+
,*$&- !.")"/ (%0"#!$&- 4"
&!) 5 &2 %"
5 -%+ !$#"
-$:$&- .$4
0!$
$
6 &!"2+ %" )#.
&2(#!"2 4"
E"!!"2
$#")
0)"%"&#"
-$%!) !"/ ##(%"2 "F")#$%"2
0!$
:
()
/ &:"%!$- !$&-
$#") # ,,"2
)"&2") !","0.
&$# ,,*/ & )" #.$&-
%0 !+ &:"%!$- !$&-
$#") 4 2"
.$4 #C( $&!"2
#!%
&
?% 2$)"#!$ &%+ &:"%!$- !$&-
$#") &2(#!"2 %" )#.
% 4"
&! $&"2 6
% 40,"%
-4%/ " #.
%"0 ) !"2
" #.
5 - 4 2"
0 )#", %" ,"2 %" ,
?
?/ "%$2("% 6"$-."2
9=/> B-% " #.
5 -/ #.
5 - %"0 ) !",* %" ,"2 %" ,
?
?/ &:"%!$- !$&-
$#") . &2"2
%" ,
9
)%. & 6.")" %
B"0!
%" , .$4%", / ,,
0 )#",% ! B"&
:$2"
:")* 4"4
F/ / (C F/
%! !$
)"-$%!) !$
6.")"(0
4 2"
"&2 )%"4"&!
)4 , F/
/ %$!"
0, &
%0 F/ 0)"0 )"2/ ! !"4"&!%
)4 ,,* ))"%!"2/ !")+
2(#"2 ##(%"2+ 0")!*
<)$%. &
A , G , &- F/
2$)"#!"2
. &2
0")!*
/ 2"0 %$!"2 0")!* , &- % 40,"
% 40,"
%" ,
%! !$ "0 A F/ / 40,"!$
$&:"%!$- !$ &+ #. ,, & 0(!
()!/
$&2$&-
0)$4
#$"
44$!!$&-
"&#"
0(&$%. 5,"
#. )-"
%.""!"2 ## )2$&-,*
6.$#.
0," 2"2 -($,!* 5(!
#, $4"2 !)$ ,/ ! B$&- ":$2"&#"+ %! !"4"&!
99 )/ // 6.")"$& 2"&$"2 " #.
,,"- !$ 0," 2"2 $&& #"&#"/ * 6 *
2"
"&#"+ 0," 2"2 $&& #"&!D 0"2
,%"
#!
:")*
"
"#!"2
(%"/ 2"
"&#"
"F 4$&"2 $&2"0"&2"&!
6$!&"%%
(0 . :$&-
##(%"2
3/ ." )$&-
0 )!$"%
00) $%$&- "&!$)"
4 !")$ , 4$&-
)2+ 22$!$ & ,
@ "%%$
(2-"
!". 5 2 .",2 -($,!*
44$!!$&-
"&#"
0(&$%. 5,"
#
. :"
." )2
! !"
(&%",+ . :"
- &"
!.)
$,"
!."$) %%$%! &#"/ !)$ ,
(2-"
- $&- 2""0
4 !!")
)2$&- 2"! $,"2 )" % 2$%#(%%$&- 2"! $,+ %! !"4"&!%
)"&2") 39+
)%. & 3@
3D
&:$#!$
$&2$&- %(##"%% (,,* :"2 5"*
)" % & 5,"
(5!/ .(%+
% B"
5)":$!*+ (,2 ,$B"
2$%#(%% %! !"4"&!%
- $&/ "
()!+
%$40,* ) $%"2
9 $&!%/ $)%!
,,+ 0")
)"#"$:"2
"
"#!
$&2(,-"% % ,"
0()#. %"
)2
%.
%",,$&-
0()#. %$&-
3 2"0 %"2
)& $, $&-. &":") ) $2"2/ %(#.+ 5",$": 5,"/
#!+
,%",* $40,$# !"2 !.$&- :")"2
&!"&2"2 $&:"%!$- !$
:$)!( ,,* $&# 40,"!"/ $-
$%.
&":") # (-.!/
!)("
!."%"
2 *% 2)(- 4"& #"
$!%
"F!)"4"/
3$!.
$40(&$!*
0"
0,"
$&2(,-$&-
2)(-
!)
$#B$&-/
"#"$0!
"&
%6$&-
#!$
)"-$%!) !$
:")*
.(%B+
,,"#!
)"- )2$&- #(%!
4")%+
%",,$&-
(!
0")% 2" ,$&- !) 2"
0()#. %$&- .(%
6 &!
":$2"&#"+
)",$"
# &
&"F!
$&2"0"&2"&!
6$!&"%%
"
2$2 %(00 "
":"& "F 4$&"2 "
(0 . :$&-
##(%"2/
"F 4$&"
.$4 ":"& $
B& !)("
%!
)*/ ##(%"2 00",, &!
. 2 ! B"& !) (5,"
"F 4$&"
.$4
3/ .$% 6$!&"%% # !"- )$# ,,* %! !"2
) $2 &2(#!"2
!.$&- :")"2
.$% 6$!&"%% .
6B$2 )
B& 6% ##(%"2/ B$&-
&%$2") !$ %! !"4"&!
3+ # && % $2
)""
(5!/
()%"+ $&2"0"&2"&!
6$!&"%%
5(!
2$2 %(00 "!
# && % $2 %$&#"
2$2 %(00 &+ !.")"
)"+ !"%!$4 &$"%
39+
3@
3
2$%# )2"2/
#!+ 0") %! !"4"&!%
) $2 &2(#!"2
"
0)"%"&!
(%"/ 3."& )" #."2 (%"+
- !"
:")"2
22")
(%"/ 0)"%"&#"
E"!!"2
$#")
) &B
+
0"&"2
%"
5 -%/ 40,"% 2(,*
2) 6&
" #.
5 -
%" ,"2 %" ,%
?
?/
3 <)$%. & A ,+
2"0 %"2
)% 2+ &:"%!$- !$&-
$#")+ 2(#"2
.$4 0")!*+
:")$ *$&-
#!%+ 0(!
%" , $40)"%%$
?<A?
% 4"/ ! !"4"&!
<(,6 &!
$&-.+ " 2 &%! 5"
3
. 5 4+ " 2 3 + :$"6
!."$)
$2 :$!% F/ F/
)"%0"#!$:",* %! !"4"&!
3
()!.") :$"6
A F/ + ,$&B %! &2% :"2
()!.") A F/ + %! &2% :"2 &!"&!%
% 40,"%
A $2"&!$ $"2 %!) 6 #.
%!
0 0 :") 4&$ ")(4 A/
)"+ $
2$2 "F 4$&"
##(%"2+
! ,
&"F!
$,"2
40,* :$%$
@
#!/
$&!$4 !$
$#") (!
)"#"$0!
&:"%!$- !$&-
$#")/ 0)"%"&!
%" )#./
)"2(#"
6)$!$&-
%"&2 % 4"
%"&$
$#")+
&2(#!$&- %" )#./ .(% &# 40,$ &#"
@
#!+
! ,
%(00
&!"&!$ #$!"2
:"
&!"&!$
; %(%! $& 5,"
:$"6
F/ / )"#"$0!
&+ % 4"
6)$!$&- 6.$#.
F/ % 4"
%"&$
$#")% !.)
,5$) $&-./
%! !"2
3+ &:"%!$- !$&-
$#")
.(% ,$-.!
) , 6",, #(4"&! )* ":$2"&#"+ # && % $2 :$%$
@
40,$"2 &"F!
!.")"
)2+
4+
22")+
6.")"
C("%!$ ,,"-"2,* :")"2+ 5", &-%/ 5%"&#"
$,"+
$,"2
:"
&%#$ (%
%(00
&!"&!$ #$!"2 !$!,"2 !"
# $ %
0)$&#$0,"
"F0 (&2"2
2$%0(!"2/ . &2 :")"2
!
!$4"
) $2+
0)"%"&!
(%"/ 0)"%"&#"
:")"2
22")
(%"/
$,"
%.
!.")"
&*
!.") 4 ,"
4"45") ,$:$&- (%"/ %(#.
%$&#"
6.")"
:")* "
"#!"2 5", &-%
##(%"2+ !.")"
)"+ % $2
&%#$ (%
:")"2
:"& 3 B& 6% ##(%"2/ .
6B$2 )
##(%"2/ !.$&-
)2
%.
6.")"
:")"2
##(0$"2 :! )
> $&-./ %(#.+ :"
&!"&!$
%(%! $& 5,"/
!.") ()-"2
4"/
)" % &%+
$&2$&-
4")$!
00" ,+
)2")"2
2$%4$%%"2/
5 $,+ 5 $, &2%+ %. ,, %! &2 # &#",,"2 ! B"& #(%!
2*
%"):$&- )"4 $&$&- 0")$
%"&!"&#"/ &#")&"2 .$"
(2$#$ , -$%!) !"+ %. ,, ! B"
%!"0%+
40,* 7(2-4"&!+ 2("
40!$!(2"+ B""0$&- :$"6 00,$# 5$,$!*
:$%$
@ >
)$4$& ,
#"2()"
2"+ %(54$!
40,$ &#"
)!+
()!+ 6$!.$&
0")$
!6
&!.%+
2 !"
)"#"$0!
0* !.")"
/
$%!)$#!
"%%$
(2-"+ !". 5 2+ %. ,, "&%()"
2$)"#!$ 40,$"2 6$!.+ 6$!.$& !$4"
) 4"+ 40,$ &#"
%(54$!!"2 $44"2$ !",* !.")"
!")/ "-$%!)* %. ,, B""0 !) #B
%(54$%%$
40,$ &#"
)!%+ 0(!
(0 0 0")% 6."!.") )!% )"#"$:"2
!+ 6$!.$& !$4"
) 4"+ $44"2$ !",*
"F0$)* !.")"
/
! "#
"#$% %4)$!$