Chander Shekhar v. The Central Bureau Of Investigation
!"#
"
%&'('
)## *
%+,*%-* ### %$'$'
%+ .%+(/( *%% $+ 0 /+% / .%($'1 ###%(2 $ ) 3 4# ,4,#
+%(% $) +# /$ 5"/$$6. & $%6
+$*%2%$'$'
%+ +#,/5%%$ %06. & $%6
+$*%+%(2 ### 4,6 #+ 0 (%*% +.'
.'% & %+% &'
1# 7$*'( 220'& 6$*%2%$'$'
%+'
$*% && 52
7'
12%$'$'
(%%-($ 20 &% +%& +& 2'%( $*% +%+(2 ((%87$*%$+'
0& /+$ 9##
##
%:/+%(
+%(2%&$'.%076;'$*$*%
&& 52
7'
12%$'$'
$'&%'
$*% 220'& +#,/5%%$ %06. & $%6 &&%2$( $'&%
(/85'$($* $ ('
&% 8.' /(07$*% +%+( +% 5 $$%+ </'&'
0+%& +6*% %( $ 22 (%$*% 220'&
(%=/% $076 $*% 220'& '( 00 ;%
$*%
' +%+( +% +%+%$ 8%$ -% +%& +
%:/+%(
+%(2%&$'.%07;'$*$*% && 52
7'
12%$'$'
>## 6 $*% 00 ;'
1 +%+ * 8%% 2 ((% 87 $*'( & /+$)
!"#$ %
$ &
$
!"
'
(")*)
+$ +,-$&
!"$. !$
$
/*+#*+# 0# &'
.
$1$
- .
2 &3#$ 4
*
$4
2 1 # 50 $
$ 6
7 '
$ $
$ '
4
$&
$ $ !"
.
2&31# 4
08
6 9& 6 4 2 6
'
4
$4 6
:
50 6 6
4 :
4 6 % 6
4
6 % &
$; 5
$!
<=$6 2 6 $ 4 4 . 6 $
66
6
' $
$4
4* 6
2 6 6 < 6
$4
'
!"
$ !"$&
$4
, 6
"
6
4$ $ !"$
2
> * /1* +%207 $*%+%(2 $ * (8%% (% $$ $*% % %+ $*'(& /+$.'% ?* (22 & 55/ '& 6'$* $8%% '0% $*%%1'($+72 (('807/%$ (* +$ 1% $'5%# %$* ('$5 76+# %060% %& / (%0 +$*%+%(2 $ 6+% %+($ $*% +%+ $*%$+'
0& /+$ $%9## (* (8%%
+%2+ /&%'
$*% +%+2 ((%87$* $& /+$ @## & 27
%:/+%
@;'$*$*%2%$'$'
6$ (/85'$$* $'
+%+(2 ((%$;'&%% +0'%+6'$;
/07 8(%+.%87$* $& /+$$* $$*% 07+%5 1;'$ %(( +$*%% % &% ;
%# #,* +5 6;'$* 8<%&$'
(* ;
$ 8%+ '(%87$*%& / (%0
+$*%2%$'$'
%+6$ $*%%
%&$$* $$*%+%;
(7%$
$*%+;'$ %((87$*%
5% #,#
;
+;* ;
0( $ 8%%:
5'
%# % $*%+% +% (/85'$( $* $ &$/ 007 %.% $*% ( ' ;'$ %(( #,#
;
+* 8%% 1'.% /2% +0'%+87$*%2%$'$'
%+(3& / (%0*'5(%0 $* /1*$*%+%'( +%+;*'&**%&
2+ /&% $$*%5 5% $(* ;'
1$* $
7($ $%5% $$ $* $%
%&$;
(5 %# % /+$*%+2 '
$($ $*%
&$$* $$*%& (%8% +%$*%$+'
0& /+$ '(2% '
1 +$*%2 ($A7% +(
$*%+% +%$*%$+'
0& /+$;
(.%+75/&* ;'$*'
'$( +'1*$ $ &$/ 007 &0 (% % % &% %.'% &%6 ;'$* *'5 /+$*%+ (/85'$$'
1 $* $ $'5%
6 '
'
%+% $ +%+(6 $*% $+'
0 & /+$ * +%'$%+ $%$* $'$;
($*%+%(2 ('8'0'$7 $*%2%$'$'
%+$ 2+ /&% ;'$ %((%($* $*%;'(*%$ %:
5'
%6 *'( ;
.'
1& ('%+%$*%5 $$%+6$* /1*0% %& / (%0 +$*% +%(2 $; /0 $*%+;'(%(%%5$ 8%& ++%&$6* ;%.%+;'$*$*%+%8%'
($ $%5% $(* ;
$ $*'(& /+$$* $$*%2%$'$'
%+(3& / (%0* &$/ 1'.%/2#,#
;
+ ;'$ %((
0% %& / (%0 +$*%2%$'$'
%+ * .'
1 0+% 7($ $% $*%0 ($ *% +'
1$* 07 % 22 +$/ '$7 8%1'.% $ $*%2%$'$'
%+$ 2+ /&%$*%
';'$ %((8% +%$*%$+'
& /+$6$*%2%$'$'
'( 00 ;%$ $*%%:$% $$* $$*%'52/1 % +%+ $% 9## 6&0 ('
1$*%% % &% $*%2%$'$'
%+6'(*%0'
8%7
&%6;'$* 0'8%+$71+
$%$ $*%2%$'$'
%+6 *'( ;
+%(2 ('8'0'$76$ 2+ /&%$*%
';'$ %((87 +&*6 6/2 $*%$+'
0& /+$'((/'
1(/55 $* $2/+2 (%$ 5 ++ ;'$(%0 '#%#$*% %:$ *% +'
18% +%$* $& /+$6 ;'$*$*%( ';'$ %(($ 8%2+ /&%% '$%07 ## # $'(5 % 8( 0/$%07&0% +$* $'
$*%
';'$ %(( +$*% % &%6'#%##,#
;
+6 %( 22% + ## $ $%($'
78% +%$*% 0% %,2%&'
0 /1%6 6
&*-/0 6$*%'52/1 % +%+;*'&*'(8%'
*%0'
8%7
&%$'00$*% 6;'00 2%+ + 5$* $ $%'$(%0
$*%% % &%
$*%2%$'$'
%+; /0($
&0 (%'
$%+5($*%+% 6* ;%.%+6$*%
';'$ %(( %( 22% + $* $ $%$ $%($'
76
$/+ 007$*% $*%'52/1 % +%+;'00($
(%$ ('%;'$*
22+ 2+'
$% +%+$ 8%2 ((%87$*%$+'
0& /+$
$%+*'($%($'5 7'( & &0/%6'
&0/'
1 8.' /(07*'(&+ ((%:
5'
87$*%+%(2 $ # $'( 0( $ 8% $'&%$* $+# %06/2 =/%+787$*'(& /+$6 (/85'$($* $$*% $*%+;'$ %((+% %++%$ '
$*% +%+ $%@## 6'#%# # #,* +5 6* 0+% 7$%($'
'%;'$**'($%($'5 7& &0/%# $'( 0( '+%&$%$* $('
&%6$ 5 ++ ;6(/55 +%$ 8% '((/%87$*%$+'
0& /+$ +$*%
';'$ %(($ $%($'
78% +%$* $& /+$
## +1/5% $( '
$*% 5 $$%+ ;'00 $ 8% *% + 87 $* $ & /+$ $ 5 ++ ;6 8/$
$/+ 0076 /2 $*% $%($'5 7 $*%
' ;'$ %(( & &0/'
16'55%'
$%07$*%+%
$%+ /+$*%+ +1/5% $( $*%% % &%;'008% *% +# $'(5 %&0% +$* $'$; /0 078% /+$*%+ +1/5% $(
+1/5% $(;'00 $($ +$ $*%( ';'$ %(( %( 22% + ## $* $ $%
'$(%0 +1/5% $( ; /0 & /% $ 8% +%((% 87 & / (%0 + $*% 2%$'$'
%+68% +%$*%$+'
0& /+$# ##
2- ?*%$*%+(2% -'
1B+% % !%(B ?*%$*%+%2 +$ 80% !%(B