High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/862/2004disposed of

Rajesh & ANR. v. State Of Haryana

2024-01-20Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary7 pages

! #$%"

&'()*)+,-)*.)-$$/"01234"

5678"9:";8<=>=9?@"-$A$#A-$-/"

'6B8>C"6?;"6?97C8D"

AE(FF8GG6?7>"

H8D>I>"

*7678"9:"J6DK6?6"

AAA'8>F9?;8?7"

L MN ! OOOOO PD8>8?7"@" "

3DA"(QC6K>C8D"*=?RCS"(;T9<678":9D"

3DA"(U6>C;88F"*=?RCS"(;T9<678"

:9D"7C8"6FF8GG6?7>A"

3DA"V6R;=>C"36?<C6?;6S"(;;GA"(WS"J6DK6?6A"

OOOOO ! XN #A"

&C6GG8?R8""

=?""

7C8""

FD8>8?7""

6FF86G""

=>""

79""

7C8""

BI;RY8?7Z9D;8D""

;678;"

#[A$/A-$$/S""

F6>>8;""

QK""

7C8""

G86D?8;""

*F8<=6G""

VI;R8S""

\6D;=6Q6;S""

]C8D8QK""

7C8"

6FF8GG6?7>""

]8D8""

<9?T=<78;""

6?;""

>8?78?<8;""

79""

I?;8DR9""

D=R9D9I>""

=YFD=>9?Y8?7""

:9D"

7]9""

K86D>""

6G9?R]=7C""

:=?8""

9:""

'>A#$S$$$Z)""

6?;""

=?""

;8:6IG7""

9:""

F6KY8?7""

9:""

7C8""

>6Y8S""

79"

:ID7C8D""

I?;8DR9""

D=R9D9I>""

=YFD=>9?Y8?7""

:9D""

>=^""

Y9?7C>""

:9D""

7C8""

9::8?<8""

I?;8D"

*8<7=9?"_"9:"7C8"`>>8?7=6G"&9YY9;=7=8>"(<7S"#a%%"0:9D">C9D7"b7C8"(<7c4A" -A"

.D=8:""

:6<7>""

9:""

7C8""

<6>8""

6D8""

7C67""

9?""

[$A##A#aa%"

S""

6""

D6=;""

]6>""

<9?;I<78;"

9?""

7C8""

FD8Y=>8>""

9:""

3Z>A""

'6B=T""

1=G""

&9YF6?K""

>=7I678;""

67""

367CID6""

'96;S""

\6D=;6Q6;"

QK""

&3d >""

\GK=?R""

*eI6;""

C86;8;""

QK""

5*P""

.6GB=7""

*=?RCA""

fC8""

6FF8GG6?7>""

6G9?R]=7C""

#,"

97C8D""

F8D>9?>""

]8D8""

:9I?;""

=?T9GT8;""

=?""

FD8F6D=?R""

>FID=9I>""

GIQD=<6?7""

9=G""

6?;""

:ID?6<8"

9=G""

]=7C""

7C8""

C8GF""

9:""

U8D9>8?8""

9=G"

S""

Q=7IY8?""

6?;""

]678D""

87<A""

DI<U>""

<9?76=?=?R""

]678DS"

#$%& '&(& $ ! *(+&! #,&(& &-& ( *$%* -

- ./ &%*#0 !($%- '&(& (&1 2&(&!

3 '

#, 2& 1&%& # # +-

3 4&! -

) #$%& 5 '#&( &#16 7%* &- '&(& #+& -& &!5 #,&(&)#&( -& # ( &4%

6 86 9)#&( %* &#

)

2&-# 3#

(&* (# $ !&( 7&1#

:;8 <(6=6<6 '- *(&-& #&!

#,& < $(# -# #,& 11$-&!>**&

#-6 3 *( % )1 & 1-&5 1,(3&- $ !&( 7&1#

;

) #,& 91# 7&1#

- ?:: ?/@ A=<5'&(&)(%&!3 -##,&%5# ', 1,#,&0* &!&! #3$

#0 !1

%&!#(

6 ?6 B,& *( -&1$#

(!&( *( 2&

#- 1-&5 &4% &! - % 0 - . '

# &--&-6 B,&(&)#&(5 #,& -##&%& #-

) #,& 11$-&!>**&

#- '&(& (&1 (!&! $ !&( 7&1#

8:8 <(6=6<6 ',&(&"0

1( 3 &2 !& 1& '- *$# #,&%5 ', 1, #,&0!& &! !* &!&!

1& 1&6A !&)& 1&5#,&0!

! # &! 0&2 !& 1&6 C6 B,& #(

< $(# 1%& #,& $-

#,# *( -&1$#

,- *( 2&!

#- 1-&5 !11 (!

01 1#&! !-& #& 1&!-%& #

&!"

2&6 D6 E& 1&5#,&*(&-& #1(

**& 6 ;6 F&( &! $ -& #,&

$#-&# -$"% #- #,# #,& **&

-, *(&-- #,& **&

%&( #- *(0- ( &4#& !

3 #,& "& &)

) *( "#

) #,& )1#- #,# #,&0 #, ,2& 1,

!(& 3&! *(& #-5 &41&*# #,&% #,&(&

& &( #,&

!G #,&

!& # *&(# - #,& 0&( :..CG (-# %& ))& !&(- ! &2&(% -$-&!#,&"

3( #&!# #,&%6 H6 F&( &! 7##& $ -& -$"% #- #,# #,& < $(# "&

' ,- 3,# 0 1#&! #,& 11$-&!>**&

#,& &2 !& 1& *( !$1&! "0 #,& *( -&1$#

6 '&2&(5

#,& 2&>-##&! 3( $ !-5 ,& ,-

"I&1#

) #,& *(0&( %!& "0 #,& &( &!1 $ -& ) (#,&**&

#- -

'&!6 .6 E&(!#,& &( &!1 $ -& & #,&(- !& !*&($-&!#,&(&1 (!6

!"#$% "& "'

(# )*+'" &( "&*'*+,&#$ -(.

! "&

!/ (! /(" ,*'

/(##$ ' /*' "&("

(!$ /(0 %

1 "& (//+0 *+2" "& , !+ ! ! 00 *1 "&

-34 "* 3567% "& $ /*+# &( (88# (! *2"( ! 1' 0& /*#*+' 8'

!" *+"0 "& ' *1% "&+0% "& $ /(!!*" 2 & (' "* '( 0 ( ,'

(!/

"&(" ' ,(' 9& .(,!

"+ *1 0+/& (+#" '("

*! *8 '("

*!0 &(0 "* 2

0+(# :

"& ,&" *1 "& 1(/" "&(" (0 .+/& (0 ;4< =9 *1 * 08("/& 1'*. =("&+'( > 1 ! '$ *1 ?!

(! @ )*'8*'("

*! 1*'

'$ "* AB C 9& '.(# 3*D ' A*+0 % E('

(2( D(0

'" "* "& 8 "'*# 8+.8

F+ 0"

*!% D& '

D(0 !, .

- "& "+. ! (! G '*0 ! "/ E+'"& '% (0 8 ' EBH ' 8*'"

-3A% "& 0(.8# 0 D ' 1*+! "* /*!"( .

-"+' *1 G '*0 ! (! ABI

"& 0"' !,"& .

- "& 0*. 2#(/G

0/*+0 .(" '

(# (! (#0* &( D(" ' /*!" !"0 9&+0% "& 0 )*+'" !0 !* 0/*8 1*'

!" '1 ' !/

"& !,0 ' /*' 2$ "& "'

(# )*+'"% (0 0+/&% "& /*!

*! *1 "& (88 ##(!"0 0(11 '. J0 ' ,('0 "& 8'($ ' 1*' 8'*2("

*! .( *! 2 &(#1 *1 "& (88 ##(!"0

0 /*!/ '! %

D*+# 2 (88*0 " "* .(G ( ' 1 ' !/ "* B /"

*! 4 *1 "& 3'*2("

*!*1@11 ! '0J/"%K<;%D& /&' (0"&+0L M

N OPQR OS OTRU UO RQVQWXQ YQRUWZ[ OSSQ[\QRX O[ ]RO^WUZO[OS_OO\YO[\TYUN `a b& ! (!$ 8 '0*!

0 1*+! ,+ #"$ *1 &(

!, /*..

"" (! *11 !/ !*" 8+!

0&(2# "& ("& *'

.8'

0*!. !" 1*' 1 (! "& )*+'" 2$ D& /& "& 8 '0*!

0 1*+! ,+ #"$

0 *1 *8 *! "&("% &(

!, ' ,(' "* "& / '/+.0"(!/ 0 *1 "& /(0

!/#+ !, "& !("+' *1 "& *11 !/ (! "& /&('(/" ' *1 "& *11 ! '%

0 -8 !" "* ' # (0 . *! 8'*2("

*! *1 ,** /*!+/"% "& !% !*"D "&0"(!

!, (!$"& !, /*!"( !

(!$ *"& ' #(D 1*' "& . !,

1*'/ % "& /*+'" .($%

!0" ( *1 0 !" !/ !, . (" *!/ "* (!$ 8+!

0&. !"

' /" "&(" & 2 ' # (0 *! 0 !" '

!"* ( 2*!% "& *' "&*+" 0+' "

0% "* (88 (' (! ' /

0 !" !/ D& ! /(## +8*! +'

!, 0+/& 8 '

*% !*" -/ !, "&' $ ('0% (0 "& )*+'" .($

' /"% (!

" !# $ % & '$ %"( )*+ ,*( $$

" -)* ."//

$ *# .)#" */. & && $* /..

. .

.& $

" && $* * . .)* 01

& 01 ". 2$ !/# & %$ * *')/* ##)!

" !/# (* 3"

" -)* 2*# .. 4)* .$

" && $*

. / /0

/ ( $)*

" !* $ &* 3"

#" "

"% $5 678 9&*

' 0 *$* $* .)%:.#

6;81

" #)* ."//

" *!* 1

& 01 &

" !*%

&& #*# #* $

"#.5 6<8 =" *$* $* .)%:.#

6;8

. $1

" #)* 01

. &

" && $* $ &

" !)%/

. 2!$

!.. .)!*( .

*$* $ *#

" && $* ."// *

" .)!*( .

& !*%

&& #*

" *$* $)*

' .)#" !* $1

' /..

0*1 . 0 % .!# $

1 $ 0

.)#" .)!*( .

*$*1

!. .)#" $

. .

#..*0 &*

" $) .)!*( .

" && $*5 6>8 ?" #)*

' .)!*( .

*$* $* .)%:.#

6<8 ."// *@) *

" && $*1 %&* "

. */.$1

") .)*

%.*(

" $

. .!# $

.)#" *$* $ .)#" $$

/ $

" *.!#

$ #1 %.

. * 0

* .

" #)* 01 "(

' *'*$

" !*

#)/* *#).

#.1 .

!. &* !*(

' *!

" . && # * # ..

"* && #.%0 "&& $*5 6A8 ?" #)*

' .)!*( .

*$* $* .)%:.#

6<8 ."// 2!/

" && $*

*. $ $

. &

" *$* $ ."// &* "3

&)*

#!0 &

" .)!*( .

*$*

#" &

" && $*.1

" .)*

& 01 $

" !*%

&& #*# #* $5B ;75 3)/$ % 3* "3"

*&*

" 4)$'

& DEDF GDH IJK EDEL MN OFPDQ RCS ;TUA V- >>>1 3"*%0 W X%/ ?" V)!* -)* 1 *'*$

" !)*!. $ %4# & Y?" ,*%

& Z&& $*. R# 1 ;TA[X "$ %.*($ $ "/$

" 1 \?" R#

. /.

" !*'*.. &

" $*

$ # ! "# ""'() * +

+, "#

-"' " "# !"- ".

- "# - $ / + $"

$ !0!, "##

&, +% %$) !( +

2- !+ ',+% + "##

+ "/ 34

+ "#

%"+

"##

+ /%"

',( "# 0 ' -"$$

"## - &, +% /%

% $& +" $ #"

%"+ /%"

',( "#

"## - ) 6% - + "# "##

+ /%"

"# 34

+", !+-

" + '0 -",

+ $

!$" " " " " "# '""! -" !,-5 +,.

- -" !" ! !"/

&& "&

"0+" "# 2-5 - + "# "##

+ "/

"# 34

., -" + ++, -", " +

- $ $& +" $ , ++ + + +# 0 '

- -,$+ - + "# - + 5 -,! '

"# "## -

"# "##

+5 + " +

/%% $, !

7+)8 !9"#% 2-): 48) ;" < =% 7,&

$ >", ?@ABAC ADEAF AFG FBH IDH @A@J KL ?MABN 2*O 3PPQ 7> 8Q895 "+

# "# " " -

R !

0+"

+ '

+ / 5

! 5 S T"

-+ ' &"/

/%-% + !+-

(5 >", + -" +!

- -,$+ - + "# - + 5

"# "## -

"# "##

) 6% -" +!

"# "## - 5 >", $,+

+- 0 / "# '

0( "# "## - 5 $& - /%-% "## - " 0-$) =%

--,+ , !

-" 9 "# V " " "# W##

+ 2- + +,.

- $ "

$"! "0+" +

X$ (X -

( !-

+ !+-

" ++ /% >", /%

+ "##

-+ "# &"/

+ , !

-" 8 9 "# V " " "# W##

+ 2- 0 '

"# "## -

"# "##

#$ %" "& '%" (#)"

!*" +"#! , #$ %" -#. #! #$ /$$"!*" 0 1"

)% %" 2# )%"! !3 (" #! $# !* 53 #$ %" #$$"!" #

"*6 !# ! % .5" )% *" % # ( #!

"! $# 5$"& '% (#)" ! ." "7" "* .3 %" 2# )%5" $!*!4 %" (" #! 53 !* $ %" 2# %!8 % % 1!4 "4 * %"

#$ %" "6 !5 *!4 %" " #$ %" #$$"!" !* %" % " #$ %" #$$"!*"6 ."!"$

%# 5* ." "7"!*"* %"

"*6 %" (#)" ! ." "7" "* .3 %" 2# "1"! %" (("55 " # "1 #! 5

4" !* .3 % 2# )%5" %" !4 ((" 5

!*" 05" 9:; #$ %" 2#!

#! #$ <!* &= 9,& 0 4 !$ 5 "$""!" ! ."

*" # >?@A>BB>CD> AEF G>GH IJ FFK LMNNOP 9N +22 ::N6 !* QDR?RSRT>? AEF G>GH IJ >D>?>EDG?>K LMN9UP V +22 ,99 6 )%""! %" "

("1"

"* )"" #!1"* !*

"!"!"*

!*" +"#! U #$ %" W

"! 5 2#

#*"

06 9VOO6 X#!Y.5" %" + ("

2# #!

*"!4 % %"3 )"" $ #$$"!*" !* 4% % 1" .""! 4 !"* %" ."!"$ !*"+"#!:;N2-26"5"

"*%"

#!(#. #!& 9O& X#!Y.5" %" + ("

2# ! Z>?>S [>GD \HED>?@ AF G>GH IJ ]HEG H^_>BK MNM:LMP ` ) X" 5* L+2P 9:V96 .3 #.

"1!4 % "1"! $

"!"!" (#1*"* ! %" W

"! 5 2#

#*"

06 9VOO6 %"

)55 !# ." *5" $# !1#8!4 %" ((5 .53 #$ (#1 #!

#$ %" -#. #! #$ /$$"!*" 06 9VOa !* "5"

"* %" (("55 ! #! (#. #!6 )%5" #!

*"!4 %" $ % %" #

#" % ! :U 3" !* %" !# !1#51"* ! !3 #%" #$$"!"& + 5 53 ! [>?HED \RT>? AEF G>GHK MNN9 +22 /!`!" b"5 OOU6 " "5 !4 #!1#!

!*" %" W

"! 5 2#

#*"

06 9VOO6 %"5* .3 %" X4% 2# % %"

"* *"

"1"* %" ."!"$ #$ (#. #!

!*" +"#! , #$ %" -#. #! #$ /$$"!*" 06 9VOa6 (" 553 ! 1") #$ %" $ % %" % *

!"#$% #

&!' '!&$" # !(# &) *

# $+ ,! # !

+ $&+!' $!

* $# -

)&# +#$)&+ !$ !'#

# $+ +#..&

(% &. ,!$##$ -$& !('

,& '& &.- &#$.

$/ 01/

&$"

!+ #

$ +! !

- !%

#$ !' #

!-- ''!$ & +#$+

3 & 4# +#$&

&$"

.&&"!&$" +& +.!$+ !$

5 ".

&$!(#) 3 &$ !

$ # 5&+ ,#'

3 &

$ & # - #(!&#$ # "## +#$ +/ 06/ 7 +#$ 8 $+

!(#) 3 -

$ + &.&$!' !-- !' &

&-#

# ,&

+&#$ !$ - #(!&#$

!-- ''!$ # -

&# # #$ 3 #$

#''#,&$" +#$ &&#$ !

$ &$

+&#$ #

#(!&#$ # ; $

7+30<=>? @0A % !''

+ (#$ # "## !)&# ,& ,# #') $

&$ . # 2/0D3DDDEF

!+ , &+ !''

&!' 4# ,& &$ -

&# # #$ .#$ #.# !%/ @GAB !& (#$ !''( &$# + # !-

&# ##$ % / @HA % !'' (5 +

)&&#$ #

#(!&#$ ;&+

!$ (5 +

+#$ &&#$ '!&

#,$ &$

#(!&#$ #; $

7+/ 0>/ I & +'!

! &$ +!

& !$%

!+ #

!& +#$ &&#$3

!-- ''!$ ,&'' # ,& !J $ &$# +# % !$ !'' !) # $

"# $ $+ !,!

# .(% &!'4# /

KLMN OLMPQ R R ! #J S

- !J&$"E

!#$

? T EU# S

-# !('

? T EU#