Sukhdev Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab


 

     

   



     !!

    

 
   
     "#$%#$&%#$'()*$+$,%-#.(/)0$&$1.&%$)2,%#$)2*$-%3 $-



     



!!     !       
 



 

       





 !"

#$ 

 



% & '

#  (& 



 )   *



  

 $

 

,



** 

 &

-  - 

*

,  

, 

,%

 -

** 

)& &

**  

++



 !"

#$







) !!  

!!

   

!!

 - 

*

. 



, 

,% /
" 



+ 

 - 





 

/


 

++  &   



   -

 *

. 



, 

,%

+ 

* *

*

   

   ) 

&    0 & 

  -

 /

) 

   

&

 !



   ) + *

)





0 ,,1,2 )

3

* /



 

4*

/



* * 

-    



&

(

   * ) 

& 



(& 

+ * /
. 

  

*



+





 

++  &

     

 )



& 





(& *

&  + /
 -   

 



+   +&

   /
/ +  

0 , 1,2 )

 * . 

 )

- 

*

+ *

+ 

** 



)

   

 

** 

/



 ) 

-  

 )   

/


/

" 

, 1,2

    &  

-0  #



  

/

   ) &

- 



641 1 /% 7  $



 * 4* 

 ) &

-

, 1,2 )

 *

4


 -  

&4

   *  

++ 

 

&

  8 (



*

 

 *



$$ &  

  )

+

* 3 (  $

  





*

)  )&  

)

)

**  &   % /
" 

 +  /



 ) 

 

  



(

*    

*  *&

+ ) 

*  )

 2 /
" 

 /



 





  &  &     *& + 

 * (9

 

(



* *

& 

&

-

* &    

** 

 &



/
 / 
 (

64
:$ 



)

 

*



  ;!

<
      

  

 

      

       


   

 

  
   

      

5

            
       !  

"#        
 $

$       
!     %        

      &    



  



 =

 ( ) 

 )

 $ ) " 

4*

/

&

)

  

  


,

)*  

 

 )  

 

++ )  >  

+

)  

*  





&



)



    ?  ) 



)*

& * 

++  +  *

 

  +&    &

* 

 +

 + )



 $ ) " 

*

  

-0

  

#+

*  )

 

 

 . 

 )

 

  ) *  



>  

&

*



)   (+ 

)    &



* 

#$  60.7$  -(282)$  ,.%$  9.(/)  )2-8/.-$  %#6%  %#$  611$//6,%- #$&$2,8&($//:%&$6%$)6&'2,)$& 6(&  #$#6),.%9#2-1$&$)6,:%#2,* 60.(%%#$*&2$76,8$.;%#$611$//6,%-6-&$*6&)-/$--).9&:6&%28/$--#$ 0&.(*#%%.%#$+6%&2+.,26/#.(-$,.&#6--#$-%6%$)%#6%&$;&2*$&6%.&8../$& 6/+2&6#6,) -$%#6)0$$,0&.(*#%%.%#$+6%&2+.,26/#.(-$6-1$&%#$ )$+6,)+6)$0:%#$688(-$) #$1&.72-2.,+6)$0:%#$16&$,%-.;%#$ 0&2)$;.&#$&8.+;.&%60/$/272,*2,%#$+6%&2+.,26/#.(-$86,,.%0$%&$6%$) 6-6&%28/$-;(&,2-#$)0:%#$16&$,%-.;%#$)$8$6-$)1(&-(6,%%.%#$)$+6,) .;).9&:0:%#$688(-$)  "6,)"5#67$86%$*.&286//:-%6%$)%#6%%#$611$//6,%- 128<$)(16=(6&&$/92%#"6,)"52,%#$1&$-$,8$.;6&'2,)$& 6(& 9#$,%#$:0&.(*#%*6-8:/2,)$&6/.,*92%#-%.7$ %2-%#$2&7$&-2.,%#6% 6&'2,)$& 6(&9$,%2,-2)$%#$#.(-$6;%$&%#$611$//6,%-128<$)(16 =(6&&$/)$+6,)2,*6+.%.&8:8/$6-).9&:6&%28/$ %2-,.%6-2;%#6%)$+6,) .;).9&:96-+6)$-..,0$;.&$%#$)$6%#0$#2,)%#$068<.;6&'2,)$&

6(& %2-%#$86-$.;%#$1&.-$8(%2.,%#6%-(8#6)$+6,)96-+6)$.,/:2, %#$1&$-$,8$.;6&'2,)$& 6(&.,%#$1&$72.(-)6:.;.88(&&$,8$ ;%#$ 60.7$7$&-2.,.;"6,)"596-%&($6&'2,)$& 6(&9.(/)#67$ )$;2,2%$/:)$-8&20$)2,%#$-(282)$,.%$%#6%%#$&$96-6)$+6,).;).9&: 9#28#&$-(/%$)2,8&($/%:8.++2%%$)0:%#$688(-$) #$9.(/),.%#67$ ;62/$)%.&$;$&%.%#$)$+6,).;+.%.&8:8/$6-6).9&:0:%#$688(-$) 9#28#6-1$&%#$86-$.;%#$1&.-$8(%2.,#6)6)2&$8%,$>(-92%##$&-(282)$


?

&2%16/ 6(&@ 6'296-6%%&20(%$)92%#6)2-/2<2,*%.96&)- 6&'2,)$& 6(&6-%#$/6%%$&#6),.%128<$)(1%#$6&%.;-$92,*6,) $+0&.2)$&: #$-$8.,)611$//6,% 6&%6& 6(&96-6%%&20(%$)92%#60(,)/$ .;;6/-$#..)6,)%.&%(&$-#$8.++2%%$) 11$//6,%(<#)$72,*#6/-.966%%&20(%$)92%#%.&%(&$ #$:9$&$0&6,)$)6-8&($/1$.1/$0:%#$)$8$6-$) -%#$&$2-,.9#2-1$&2,)286%2,*6,:%&68$.;)$+6,).;).9&:0:%#$ 688(-$)2,%#$-(282)$,.%$/$;%0$#2,)0:6&2,)$& 6(&&$6//:).(0%%#$ $72)$,8$.;"6,)"5%#6%6&'2,)$& 6(&8.++2%%$)-(282)$.,/:)($ %.%#$)$+6,).;).9&:

A !$6&,$) ))/    (,'60  &$;$&&2,*  %. $8%2., 45
 

9.(/)-(0+2%%#6%$7$,2;%#$&$96-,.)$+6,).;).9&:+$&$8&($/%:.& #6&6--+$,%  8.++2%%$)  0: %#$  688(-$)  9.(/)  6%%&68%  %#$  .;;$,8$  (,)$& $8%2.,45


B ,+:8.,-2)$&$)72$9-(8#6,2,%$&1&$%6%2.,2-%#$&$-(/%.; +2-&$6)2,*.;$8%2.,45
 61%2.,*27$,;.&%#$1$,6/.;;$,8$ (,)$&  $8%2.,  45
    2-  C.9&:  $6%#C -  1$&  %#$  60.7$  1$,6/ 1&.72-2.,%#$)$6%#.;%#$9.+6,-#.(/)#67$%6<$,1/68$92%#2,?:$6&-.; %#$+6&&26*$ #$-#.(/)#67$0$$,-(0'$8%$)%.8&($/%:.&#6&6--+$,%-.., 0$;.&$#$&)$6%# (8#68&($/%:.&#6&6--+$,%-#.(/)0$2,8.,,$8%2.,92%# 6,:)$+6,).;).9&:  ,/:%#$,86,%#$)$6%#.;69.+6,0$8/6--2;2$)6D).9&:)$6%#E6-1$&%#$60.7$1$,6/1&.72-2.,  !$6&,$)))/  (,'609.(/)-(0+2%%#6%9#$,%#$)$6%# .;69.+6,)($%.8&($/%:96-$-%60/2-#$)).9&:)$6%#-#6//0$1&$-(+$) 6-1$&$8%2.,4
.;%#$,)26,72)$,8$8%A?

?


,686&$;(/&$6)2,*.;$8%2.,4
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

,)$&-(8#82&8(+-%6,8$-%#$=($-%2.,.;)&692,*6,:1&$-(+1%2.,(,)$& $8%2.,  4
  .;  %#$  ,)26,  72)$,8$ 8%  BA  ).$-  ,.%  6&2-$  ;.& 8.,-2)$&6%2., 4 ;2,)%#6%%#$1&.-$8(%2.,#6-+2-$&60/:;62/$)%.$-%60/2-#%#$ 8#6&*$(,)$&$8%2.,45
 6-6*62,-%%#$611$//6,%- "#$,%#$&$2-6 8/$6&$72)$,8$%#6%611$//6,%-#67$8.++2%%$)8&($/%:6-$>1/62,$)(,)$& $8%2.,5BA
 9#28##6))&27$,728%2+6&'2,)$& 6(&%.8.++2% -(282)$2,+:72$9%#$1&.-$8(%2.,#6-$-%60/2-#$)%#$/$--$&8#6&*$(,)$& $8%2.,5BA


5 ,72$9.;%#$60.7$%#$'()*$+$,%.;8.,728%2.,6,)-$,%$,8$ 16--$)0:%#$%&26/ .(&%(,)$&$8%2.,45
 -%6,)--$%6-2)$ ,-%$6) 6//%#$%#&$$611$//6,%-6&$8.,728%$)(,)$&$8%2.,5BA
 6,)6&$$68# -$,%$,8$)%.(,)$&*.%#&$$:$6&-.;&2*.&.(-2+1&2-.,+$,%9#28#1$&2.) %#$:#67$6/&$6):(,)$&*.,$6-1$&%#$8(-%.):8$&%2;286%$1&.)(8$)0: /$6&,$)))/  (,'60 #$:-#6//6/-.16:6;2,$.; 
F
$68#

A
;62/2,*9#28#%#$:-#6//$68#(,)$&*.6;(&%#$&1$&2.).;%#&$$+.,%#- &2*.&.(-2+1&2-.,+$,% ;%#$;2,$6+.(,%2-162)%#$:0$&$/$6-$);&.+'62/ 2,86-$%#$2&8(-%.):2-,.%&$=(2&$)2,8.,,$8%2.,92%#6,:.%#$&86-$ 

"2%#%#$60.7$+.)2;286%2.,2,%#$+6%%$&.;8.,728%2.,6,) -$,%$,8$%#$611$6/-%6,)-)2-+2--$)  6:

    (/6%2  !