Joginder Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others
!
"#$ %& $'()(%* !
! !
+
!!!$#(#(%*$,
-$,).)
+
+
/$)0%*1$*#)
2 3 !
+ -
+!
!"
-
+!
3
# $ %&
' (
)" * (
* ) *
+ * * , , " *
% ! ) ' , &
, *,
, % + & $ *4.5"*$ %*1(#(%*) (*
6 ,()%*$,) 1"#$1
7! ! !!
%!
8 %& +
) -
"
" ( " " ,
" , ,
) ) ) - .
') +.*(:
"#,"
;)!
$:4(
15(*()#,"#(%*9
6
+ 66 /+.*(:
"#,"
0 ( ) + * ") * , + 1 & 2
* )"
!
#
! $%
&
"
"" " '$ 3 " ,
" " ", " & , , 4 5 66")
7 8. 9 !"& , + ,
,
) : " " ) *
, , ' ) ") "
,
, : ; , , < ,
). " 65=
" )
)
4>859 !". 5>>= ? @ " *
(
" ,
+ " ,
,
, < ,
)A
*
7 8. 9 !" & , * + ) ) * ) ") , % " ) ,*
" ,
, '
, ,
,*
*
" B ,
+
,
#
"%()* "
#
%()*
"
"
+
,
-
.
"
"
/ ,%-
"
! !
"
! !
!
!
!
0 ,$-
!
1
2
"
!
"
!
!
"
!
"
!
0 ,'-
!
"
!
!
0 ,*-
"
! !
3
.
"
!
!
"
!
"
4 "
"
" !
!! !
""
"
"
!
!
5 6""
3
7
#$
% &
'
&
" 7
!
!
!
!
!
!
!!
" !
"
!
."
"
$## ( '
)* "
&
3
,
-"
"
"
"
!
!
3 8
"
!
)
"
'
,%-#
! !
19)2
"
"
!
"
!
,$-3 3
"
! "
"
!
!
"
"
"
8
8
!
)
+ +! , - '
! 4
!
:
"
;
"
) . "/'
3 8
!2!
;;;;;;;;; ,(- "
"
"
"
0 ;;;;;;;;; ,%<-"
"
0 ;;;;;;;;; ,%(- "
"
"
!
$(0 000 000 000 12, 3, #4( 4* 5 '
' 6 ,%-
"
! ,-
,-
"
!
,-"
"
""
,-
, 7
3
! !
! " ! "
!
-
""
" "
!
&
"
! !
=
"
""
.
" !
. !
>
,$- ?
!
3
"
!!
!
;;; ;;; ;;; *)9 '
""
"
!
"
"
0
;
0 ;
!
!
*)@ #
"
"
! "
"
/ -5
"
=
;
- A
"
!
-B
!
!
6
B !! 3
"
3
!
!
-
"
!
-C
"
!
- #
7 B6?D#63
!
- !
""
"
! !
-C ; ;-3 ;
;-7 ""
;- !
;- ! ;
;- !
; -E
%/ ?
!
" !
!
"!
$/+
!
; '/ !!
3
= 3
5 6""
& "
6""
!
"
;;; ;;; ;;; *)) 7' +!'" '
3
$< #
%()*
; "
"
"
" ;
""
!
,-
!
!! "
B "3
!
!
!!
!
,-
!
,-
!
!
!
!
0 ,-
"
!
!
" 0 , -
"
"
!
"
B
F
B
/ D
! "
"
!
#
" #
! "
! ! "
"
;
;
"
"
"
"
""
! ;;; ;;; ;;; 9%G+
"
HA
BH "
H6 BH
""
# 3
! A
BH "
B "
7 5
: ! & "
""
# 3
B
3 8
"
"
"
"
!!
!
;;; ;;; ;;; )5 8" & " . / '9
+!
!
6,%-#
! !
"
"
"
!
!
"
,$- #
!
) ( &"
. +
'
6!
!
,D!
3
-
;&
" , & .
) ) , '
"
!
%
) ) , , " *
,
) ' " ) "! , , , " , ")%&
'
5 '
,
) " ,
, ,
% ) ,), * ) ,
* , C ( + " )+"
2*@" , D "
" " " , %!
66 %&
#(:#$1 ") < "=("
;$,).) +#"#$ %& .*="> "*1 %#4$,)< 1$'(1$1 %*
! !
, , , , ) ,
,
):
" * ) " ,
) , ) ") , , ,
) : "
")
) $ + 3 !
!
! ! ? !
F
%*%) $% B
"
3!
!
" !
;
!
3
!
. "
!
!
!
"
? !
F
!!
"
!
!
"
!
B
"
!
%*%) $% B
B
!
!
"&
!
" " !
'
3 &
" :;,
"
3 A ,-- 3
B "
"E
:
/ 4 .
!
I +< & '
, :;%=/
! " B
"
B
"
"
&
B
"" !
"
I ""J
I
J
;;;;;;;;;
9) #
3
!
;
"
:5
!
# ' ,.- "
!
; / ,.- 7
!
3
"
9@ #
%()*
! :3
!
9@ #
3
9@
"
/ 9@B
"
&
3
,
- "
"
"
"
!
!
8
3 8
"
! ;;;;;;;;;
"
"
"
"
$$
"
!
"
"
K ;;;;;;;;; D;
"
!
! ! "
!
"
"
3
"
"
. !
" ! "
;
"!
"
;
" !
!
'
3 :##;
"
"!
"
!
" !
!
!
;
1
!'
3 :##;23
!
!
!
"
"
!
" '
3 :#;
:##; " ! !
C
;
!
!
6
"
!
! " !
7
"
& '
& '
" !
" ""+
+ > .& ' '
. ' + ""
'? ?
' "
! . "!+ '
+!
'
+
!
!
"
"
!!
D
!
"
"
!!
"
!
;
"
!
!
!
! !
'
?
");(, +(*@4 "*1
*%#4$, ;$,).) +#"#$
%& .*="> "*1
#4$,)A >$",(*@ %!
7 %&
1$'(1$1 %*
! 7! , " , @ ,%(-
"
!
!
"
!
:
;
" !
B
!
"
B
8
$%
" "
! ,%)-
C
J 3
B 7 A 5 # L6 3 " # L6 ,%)<9- ' 3BB %(9
" " !
!
!
"
" " !
!
$% B
;;; ;;; ;;; ,$%-
!
13 A 7 !
L6 ,%)<(-*3BB *)* ,
3 A -2 E
:
"
"
"
!
"
!
"
" K
!
! #
>H, &!A -
!
!
B
"
!"
!
,$$- 3 A !
, A - !
!
3
!
!
!
"
;
! "
;
"
,$'- 3 A ! " " !
!
;
!
!
! " "
;
!
"
"
!
"!
!! "
!
!
3
; "
;
,$*-
!
!
3 A
"
"
"" "
!
!!
" " !
; "3
'G,$-
#
;
;
!
"! ,$9- 3 A 7 !
,%)(G- ' 3BB *((,
3 A -
! "
!
"
!
6
,-3
"
"
!
0 ,-
$% B
0 ,-3
" ! "
!0 , ->
"! "
0 , -A
"
0 , -
B
0 , -F " "7 5 ,$@-3 A
" ""
"
" !
"
!
/ M
"! "
0
! !
! " !
!
3 "
""
!
"!!
!
" %)
,$<-"
%)<'
4
B !!
I J
""
!
"! N IN
""
H
3 A
"
"
!
&
"
"! !
!
H
,$(-3
!
!
" ! "
3 A
B / "
!
!! "
!
;
"!;
"
""
!
,$)-
A
"
!
" ! ;
" "
"
!!
!
"
!
C
J 3
B 5 3 "# ,%)('-$3BB $<< ;;; ;;; ;;; ,'$- ?
B
5
!
+
" 7 ,%)(%- % 3BB @G( ;
;
! $%
; "
" !
"
!
B
!
!
!
" %*L$%,''-
!
J " ,- 3 "5 # # 3 F %)@@ 3B *$*0 ,- 3
A 3 " 5 ,%)('- $ 3BB )@0 ,- F!! 3 E ,%))<- $ 3BB @*$
! ;;; ;;; ;;; ,')-
+ 4
JA# "
!
"#
%))G ;
"
!
"
! " !
"
! +
" C! F
3
B
D
! B F
B
B # F 6
#
+ 4
;;; ;;; ;;; ,*<-
+33
B !
7 B
.
!
" !
O > B
!
"
#
" !
F
"
! D !
!
!
"
"
!
!
#
3
!
J"
"
! I!
J
B
!
. !
" !
N NB !
B
!
!
!
;;; ;;; ;;; ,(<-
;
! !
+
;
" !
!
# :5
"""
"
!
I
J
I !
J" $% B
" !
,((- :
!
!
! " "
! "
""
!
7 C B
!
"
! 4
" ""
. "
!
" !!
"
!!!
;
"
! !
" "
,()-
.
#C B 58A ,
- "
"
"
" !
!
" !
""
!
"
;
C
!
"
! B
!
:
B
;
! "
!!
"
!
" "
!
"
;
"B
,-
,-
"
" ""
;
3
"
""
!!
B ,)G-
"
;
!
!
!
,- ""
!!
""
0,-
"
""
!
0 ,-
0,-
0 , - ;
"
0, -
0 %< 2" & +#"#$ %&
!!
-)!
4"::"
"5B,()4*"
$11C
,)!
+ * @ " " , * , ! !) , , ") &
' , , , ") &
%+& !-!
-"#4$$)D","* ;!
+#"#$
%& "5(:
"1.
6 + 86 ,
5E5> 5 &
' " * ' 0$*1,"
"E( ;!
+#"#$ %& !!9
6
+ 69 & ,
< ,
, ,
, *
,
)
5 &
* , 1 &
) ) * * +
) "! " , * " *
*
"
) ,
,
) , " * "
" %
) % 4 5 66 + ")
"!
) ")
) , " * , % 4 5 66 ")
7 8. 9 !" ,) , " %
, " * " ,
) ( " , %
,) %;$5>$, 9
-
+!
<
4$#4$, )0$"B(*@F,$")%*$1
$)F%
4$#4$, ,$0%,#">:$
$)F%