Arun @ Rana And ORS. v. State Of Haryana

   
      





!

"#$# %&'( (

      

 

    

     

 

   
)&

* + )( 




, * + )( 


--.

  

    !"# 

$ %&  !"   '

 (
)
* (+ ,
-

$ %&  !"  " '    '

  ),).

+ ,
-

 % / ( 

 '   !" "  



,

(/0
 +

& /  ## "

0   # ""    0 /'

 (
)
* (+ ,
-

0 0

1  ##"!

"  " 2,3'

 # " 
).3' "   

 #  '     ),).

+ ,
- 0 0   4  # 0"!

"  " 
53' "  / 

  " 63 7))*  2,5,
2  " 
)* 
). 2, 
, + 
53' " -  " /

  "   + #    "    2,5,
2 # "   $0   

0   + 8  #" 

/   

 09!

/   #

 .

2,:
, ,,  "   4   4+

#" / "" 4  /  ""  #  4+

#  : ;

  4  &    ;     (   :  /  4

0 "  % 4   63 0 # 8  ; 0  /#  4+

 4+%"  "  0"      8 < " /  8 #;# "!  / / 0# 0 

  0"/    (   4 +

  4 +%

3 "/         0

/   ;  4 %

    

  2 #  8  "- =    " ) =  "    "   #/" 63 # 

0   

4'  4+  ##      4 #   
,.,
2      

 # 

"         ""     # " 

  /#  !"

/ #"! 83 0     0  " # # "! 

"       4#   
,,.,
2  # "" 0 / ) ;  #  " 
)* 
). 2, 
, +  
53' " - " #"!

"   " 2,3' # " 
).3' " - "  "   - ;   "   1  
>  # 

     ""   /  5 ;    # 

 0 / $0   8"    

?
(%   " < " ? @3 $ ?2 3  $  ?-   ' 0 &&  /  ?5 $

 $ (% ?
,  ' 0 0  / ?
 0

 3 "  / ?
) A  8  0 3 "  ?
5   # B "   "  > ;    #               0     "  

  # 

"   $0 8?
3

 0'     

+ 

" # 

/0 0# / /"8%   !

/   # <.,5,
2 0.

2,:
, ,, ##" 

/   

  ""   " ""  /  ""   # 4;

 4 &     (   //4 0 "

  % /# 0# 4;

     ""    (  4+%4 =/      4  +    %%  4  A    4  '  # " /"  ""  " "  

0

 0   % /# 

0  0" /   /0 

0; (         "/      

 0      ""   4'  "%4 % 4A  

0 3  %

     

0 

0  #

   ""      ##   " !# < /



 (%  0   # " 

; %

0    + # #



0# "   ; ! "  @1  "/

 " ;"  

0

4+ # B  % "0# 4 +  ""   0"%    "" " /"   "  ""   

0 4+   ,),>,
2  !     "        "      ""  #     < 
,,.,
2   

  /#   #  !  "

/  #

"! "%""  

 " # "# % 

!

"!@1+%"@1' 

  #                 /  

/  "" /"! 

 

    
.,,
)   / /  "" 4 +%  

"   @1(  

 "

   ""   '1"""   ##   '  * ?(%   !

"

@1@# "  0//0

' !  " @16 ! 0 " 1   # "# "" #  B @1 "0"  @1  

  ! "     #     4+ " " !  @1< 

 "

/ 8  0  @1<+ # "# %0 /

4+ 

' . ?2@3 $  ,2,5,
2   /# '0  ' 0  #   !

/ #   /  #<A   " !   "

/ '

0"  /  !

/ <   "  !

/  "%#



0  0     + # #

 # " " 

 "  1      " #  ! 0

"  !  <A   # "# %



!

@1$
, ?-3$  
,.,
2   /# 3:<A   ' 0  #  0  + #  ! / "  #3:< " !

"  4' (   $  # 0  !

/ # <  " 0  !

/ #   / "  ""  0

%     "

  "/4'

(   $  3:<A  &  

    ! /     /  /     

"  

 @1 @17 @1< @1 " ! 

 ?5'&& /  
,,.,
2   /# 3  ' @30 / ' 0 &0  ' 0  &  /  !

/  #  ""  #  

! / 

"  #"  $0  !

/

4  # ;"" "  $0  #!

/  #

 ##  /;

  ;   #

3  " !  "   # !

/

  4 

!

/+

# 

  #"   4 

 /     0   "

  "/  ( / "  

 .

# "! %"

 @1'#    # %  "

!

"!@1+""  #   &   ! /   / /     

"      @1C    

  "  3   "  

"     4#   &  

! / ( / /   

"   @1 3  "

"   @1C "" /"! 

 2
-0 /# #"

/ 

  /

%"

 @1#   # %  

!

"!@1; 

 "  

,.,
2 "" %   # "!   "" &  " !

/#; "" &/ "  """"!

 " @1D 

  ! 

 . @1< 

 2
-0 /# #"

/ @1<+ # "# % 

"" 
 ?
,  (%         4  +  

"



#  /%   !

/ <.,5,
2 0.

2,:
, ,,  $0 #    # # " 

/

 

      /  4+

"0 % / 0 %    4 +

#    & 

  (   //" 

(   "!     0#     4+%  &   4+   / ' =% /  % 4  "% (  '"  "  

" ;# "!  0#  

  "!     /        (    4+   % 4 "% 4 +  '    % 

      ;

    #"  ;%  &  '

!

   + #  # " "  

0/    1   "" !

/ #   0      #

"! " 0 /   "" ;" #

  %  "

!

"!@1E

  ""   '
2 ?
'0  /  2,,5,
2   /# 3:<A  #  /  " !



    '      /    %   "   !

/  #    "  ;" %# &    0       + #

 "  B   "      + #     & 0 #              ;    "         

#$0  !  " @1 # "<A   

    !  /

 " /

 "  #     + #   # " "   1   "  """" A  < %0 

   %  

!

"!@1E
) ?
)3  /  
,,.,
2   /#    "   "

    "    $0   #    !

/ +

# """ 

" ; "  /0  #  4 "  

    "" 4  ##  0 #    " "

 <B  

"  

  4     / 

+%'  + # #

  &   ! /   / ! /  

"   @1C( /

   " 

 .  /# # !"

/ # " %"@1'

 #

  #% 

!

"!

 @1+  3   "   

"      @1C    ""   ""  4 + 0  / 

!

/+

 #     " 
53'(

"   @1  ""  # "  "' 0 &&  /  "    $0     '    $  3   "  

"    "" /"! 

  /# #

!"

/ 

 %"

 @1#      #  %    

  !

  "!    @1;  ;

" @1D ""!#  

 1  ""  # "#  "  #  "!    !

/  #  # "  #  %     " 

 /

  @13 ""!

      "!    ""   @1=  #     ""  

"  """"!

@1D
- ?
5A  8  03 "    ! / /.:2,,5,
2 #   3:< "    + # #   !

/ #  /       " !      "  

/      '   + #  0   /  "

    !

/   : #   <  

   /#  " "

 "    !

/   B  !

/

 # / % "!

/   #

   / % "  ;   

& # %    + # 

 ' 0    /   "       + #     #     "          + # #@3$

$ !    0   !

/ #      #  

"""# # 

0$0 0 #   

 

0   

 ; " !

/  # # "  $0 0

#  "  @1  

  @1
   "/'0  //

    "   ;    #          + #    / /  

0 /$ / /;

"" "     + # " 



0 ; " " B " /@13 $  #     / /     1    /  " @16; "  /

""  " "    0      % 

!

"! @1E  /

 @1 " """3 $ 

!    " " !  " < "  #% 

!

"!@1$  
,.,
2    / "" 4' (        / /    

"   

 @1 @17 @1< @1 " ! ; ""     4'    """"!

@12  
,
,,
2   ""   / /   

"   @1F        
.,,
)          / "" E/ 4  / /   

"  

@1(; "" E/ 4/ "   "    """  !

    @1)           "   ! / B"" E/ 4 

 " / ""      ' 

  #" @1<+ @1<'8# "#     "   # "#  1   @1<
5 A  "   /   /  /

 " 4+  4' 

"

 /  0    0#" !

/  "    

  #  "  "

" " # 0   # 

!0  " #"   %# 0 /

" !

/  ##

    "

1    

0 "   #   

 "# #" #

#   

" /! " 00   "  /

"" :  8

3 ( !

+"  

/

!

!

" %#4 # " /# ! 

B"! #   # "   "!   % "0#   (           /    "!     /  # "/    

 4  %

   

/

  0 "  :0&" # ""

 ! "!   "!  ! 0

!  

"   #  #   "

 0 " !

"0 /    !%# 

 #     "  :0&""0 0 !   0 /   #  

0 

" 04    / 
>  /

  4 "    "   

 0" 4

#   # " /

  # !  %# / 0 A "   /    ?
) 3  /   !

/+

#

2, 
,,.,
2 0
)- "%#0  "4  /+

#?"    4  %    4   0#      "  

!

"

#4  0   ! 

  !  !   !#%  "

" " "!

"  8 4 " 
53'# 0 / 
* ' /     /    (   !"     "   /"  ! /    

"

 0#     "  "  " /  "  "" /  "  /# "

"

/  "  ! # ! % 

  /

 4  

 "   "    !   0  >,  %     !

/  +

#    

 " #   4 #



/  4 !

/ 

 #  / "  4"  &  

"!

"  " 
53'
. 3"

    8   

1"4 !0 #  /

 !"  

4 8 ( !

+"    "   " "4'  4+ 

   0

  0   0   0  !    B"     """  !  "  ! %#  /4 # %   0 "    # !0  %    " # !"/  ## !"

"      # !  



  ;!" #  "!   # " 0"0

!  #   /   ; ! /  !"/   "

"   0#    / #   "

 /

 /0G ; #

0 /

"  ! "

" " / ! !   4 3

" #" "    # " /

  

 @!  "   %

   6

" 0  0  0  0 /  %# # !

/

 G3"

   #

B "0

/ ! 



"

0  / H!

9%#  / # " / 

   "% " %#  /;

0    1"4  , ' /# 4  #!

# !  

"" 4 #  /#  /  "     " 0 /  #!

/ 01  

  4  !

/  ! #  " !0  /0 "

" " # "

/ 

# "" !

/+

#   4   "  

(

 %#    8 4   "    G  7 !

"



"? !G

' 7!

"



" ' B  

"!

"  "0  
 ;    # # " #!  # 

4 A  "   /    3! / /< "8?
 #"     0 " ##   % 8   63 #   /   0 

   " # 

  0 

  !/



#  

""" #  1

//  4 %   # "0 "!

" "" 0  "

 /   ?!"

 / 0!  @!   ! !%#  /4

# " /# " 4 #

" /#  /   ## "0"%/  !     3 "

" " "      # "!    # "    /   "  0      0         %# ## /" % / 

 " "

! 0    0 "!    "     

"          4   6  "! 0  #  6A  / !

!0  0    "! 4 @! "

4

  "  0 

   !

#      "/ "  !

       # 

  ;  "      "   B    4   

 !   0

 0   # 0  0 "

"!

"  "   

  2 3 "

" "   0 4





#   0   #  ; # "  8 

" 63  0  #   

0 8 

" 63    0 0

0

"/  8

,

 ("0
5 ,
.

8--.

 -#5 $#5

 ? % /:  E :7 ? 0  E :7