Naveen @ Bhanda v. State Of Haryana
!"" # $ %
"
&" !"" # $ %
"
&'
!"" # $ %
" !
( )* $ + !"" # $ %
" !
!
( , )- $ + !"" # $ %
" "
# $ %&% ' ( $ %%% (
# * $ ! ,
& .
!/ ! "" -!00120 03
" $ +!
'&
! "" -!0010 03 -!001130 03
"" -!00450 03 -!00320 03
$6 $ +! ! * %
%%' $ '' 7 ,
"" . "+ "6 '' /+' 8-' !"" 6 6 ""
+ /+' )1 3 ! $ + $ "
$ 253 $ 1,6 , +, " 6 $ 1 ,$ 149(- 0
9 ( -: ;9(-;< +, = !""
, +, $ 2!'! 8 "" ,
0
'- 0!"" $
( )* $ +
&'
&"
( , )- $ + 9'" ' $ 1 9(- "
)0 9'" ' $ 0 9(- "
2)0
9 "
' +9 '
+'" ' $ 2!'!
"
)0 8 , ! 6 ( '> 4 -' !"" -!0010 03-!001130 3-!00120 03-!00450 03 -!00320 3 6 6 &"
&'
(
( , " 8 " 3 !$9 $ +, " 9 +(($2$ "
% , " 6 "", '
6 ' + % ? ! % + , " 6 $ ), $ + - %0(0-@
! &'
+ ' :AB (!< , 20! 8, $ "
" +
, " 8 ,6, $ ,, +6 6 , +, ' % 2$02% -$ "
> 5&")
$ +)
+ "."7 8, $ "
,60 0 ,&" + + " + $ "
- ,B 2 5 > 3 6 2!
$ '" +
" ,., + + $02$ "
%0(0-@ -'" 6 ' , %?! > $02 $ "
, ' "" ' ,
> + '
'" ! &'
" , 6 6$ , + 6 , $+ ," %" &" " ++ +'' !$9 $ + 7 AB (C4)! 6 ,'
D9AB (C)!, + 3 12 ( 8 'D$= "+ ", " > " 6 6 " 6 , . " '' AB ( 9 7" +AB (, 8 ' + , . " ''AB (- 8 6 , "''B ' 8 , 8 '
' !'" +
, " 8" B ' '6, "" 8 ' $ 11- ( - , '. " 8 +
+ ' " 8 6 '" " A + , / ' '" 14)1 $
! 1)15 149(- + '" ! 6( $ : < 8'" " +6 ! $ + $ "
-'" 6 ( + + ' ' ' 9 ' AB
.0! * 8 "" ,
6 % "" C "
+ +/+' (C!@ $ + 3 , " $9
( $ - = $ "
>
7 + - 6 ' , 6 ,+'
D9AB (C)! % " "+A%-$
,
'
"
(C ! &'
:'" < 6 $ , %, +,. 6 "" + , + % 2$02 % + - $ "
+, > 5 &" , $01$ "
' 8, $ "
7 9 60 0 , &" =+ , " + + + 6, 6 &" > 3 6 2!
$ , + + -
%0(0' C *,
,' "" '," .+ > + '" " , 6 6 $ , + 8,6 / -'" " " ' &"
" ," '6 % 6$ , + 6 "
", " 8, "+ + ' , "
!
( '6
' 6,.,, 7 !
( = / , ' + 6 ! ''"
6 .'
%' 6
&"(
/
" '6$ % - % " 3 '" " . " 6 " ''AB ( ( . " %0 (0 ' / '
AB (0 AB (0 ''AB (- % ""
D9 1)5 $ 19(- 2!' !( $ -= $ "
AB (02 "
"" $ 4- ( - - 114 $ $ AB (03%
9 0B ' ' ' 6 " " 1( ,, + 6 '
( 6 %, '
" ' , % ' ' (
=
/ ' 6 67 ' '
% + , B 6 %,, '' /,
" %6 . + +,6 % . '
'" , +6 6+ + % ' B"&", + )"6, 6 % ' , ",' ' % ++ 6 ' ,'' ' + +"" " ' ''
'6 1 (C1( &'
:6 < , +, 6! 8, $ "
+ , " $ , 6 %, 6 6 ,.6"" + , +
% + - $02 $ "
> 5&" +,60 0 ,
) ' +, $
. !' + $
.&" 60 0 ,, " !&" +,60 0 , .'
9 60 0 ,&" 6 / 6 ,&" ++ + '
$ "
",$ " 6 ,. $ "
,6' ' !$ " "
' 6 $ " !
(
'6 ' " $ "
( ' $ ",' > 3 6 5 ) (
( '6 ' ,6 . $ " 4
+
'6 3 6 !
+,6$
+ 8$ "
+ ' 9 '" (
&", + &"
, + (
. ' ''6 ,. ?" (
&" ,.,6
! :(C1<
+,6 ' ! 6 !
6 '6 +'' + + %, + + ' 6 C *, $ 2$ "
,6$ , + %0(0 ! , +6 / ,
+ , ,6 %. ,6'
, / ,6 ! + ' 6, 8 C '
6 1( ' + $ 6 ' % '' " 1 ( , 6 6, + % , 6 $ 6 '6 / ,, . +, % + "
+ 6 , , 6:! +(6(6' , , "" + %70B ' (C1 , , < 2 9 0B ' 6 ' AB (D +, &"
. " $
. '+ $
. &" 60 0 ,, " % " +,6 '6 . 3 '8 %, ,AB (D, , % " 6 ' 6 +'' !
%, , ' AB (D, ', ' % ' , + " , > " 5 $ 159(-
D9 4 $ 15113 9(- !'! ($ $ $ "
% '
+,6! $ , +' '" $ 19(- %'
" ' '
!+!"1 % ' 6! , " ' " % ' 5 6 +
'" + &" 6
" %
' 6 &", + $ "
' 5 E 6 , 6$ + 8 3 % ', 8" % , , ,. +8 6+ % +
' " %, + "
"+ +&,
6$ 3 (C4 %'
&'
3 4 1(
+, - "''B ' 6 $ &'
), $ + 86 , 6 $
" .
$)$.6$ + $ "$) / $ + % , + /
!
" !
!
#
$%
!
$ 5 8 , . ' + /6 ( A 8 /, 0'' '
9 / 6 + 6 (C2 !$9 + &'
3 , "
.
%" 3 "
+6 , $ "
+ , $ "
+"
+ , $ "
+"
, # $ > 3 6 "" , D$=
6
- 2 2 3 +- $ "
51, "' '
> 2 "
+"126 , "6 /6$ +!$9 , $ > 3 "
+ " , "6 $9 /"
> 5 1 "
+"126, D$=
6
- 1 5 1+ !$9 $ $ + 44 8 "" '
" '", ,
'",
(C5 A!$9 $
A%- ( $ - = $ "
" + + " "
3 ,
(C- $ "
($ -= $ "
AB (C)!+ + . + "" "
+" + , $ +, '" "
+6 $ " "6 , $ +, '" "
+ 6 "
, # +, '" D$=
6 3 (CA!$9% & 1 9> ' "" AB (C0)!6' + '
" +, + %""
"AB (C0) " , " +" . +,+ + ' + ", + , 6 , +6 6 8 " F+ 6 '
126" 0 "
(C $
( .
" 3 6 $ , $ + " 1 (C$(G "
, " + $98$ $ "
>
+ ' '
9 "
> 1 ' A!$9% & ( = $ "
8 + , '
4 (C9 "
"+ +""
+ "
AB (C0)!" '
!$9 $ + 2 (C1 %- ! &'
. "+ " 3 AB (C1)AB (C01) . +!$9 $ + 3 (C4!$9 $ + 3 , " 9 +(($02$ "
%, " 6 , '. , + "" %?!
>$02$ "
% +, , " @ 6 + %0(0, 8 6
+" , !''! &'
6 ' " + ' AB (! % "" +AB (C04)! 8 ', " +- ' , + D9 % ' D$= "+ " " 8"+ ".", AB (C01)AB (C01) % " 6 6 ,, . " ''AB ( 8, 6 %. " 6 " ''AB ( ,, H $; % 7" +AB ( %. " ' + ''AB (- % ""
+" AB (C04) 8 "
+ 6 , . " ''AB ( 8 "" , ", "
5 > , , $%> ' &'
,
, + > +
+ 2 ( $ -= $ "
' AB (C04)- 9 " '
+'
" % 1$01$ "
, " "'''
AB (C04) !
'
" '' AB (C04)A 9 " '
+ " 126 +, +,, . " ''AB (C04)D 8
+ ' + )0,, . " ''AB (C04)% ! "
, ", '
"126 % 6 + '",, + '
,, AB (C04) 9 B ' 6 , , ' , 6 % ' " + , ' , , , " 8+ ,, . " + 'D$= 1 (C3$ " 3 ' +. , $ , $ + 6 ' %?!>$ "
, 6 ,, + 1 (C$9 $ + , "
!
$981$ "
>
( &'
, + '
' 9 " '
" '
''AB (C0)!
> ( , + + ' AB (C0) , '+ !'" + + ( 9 " '&'
""
" $ 51- ( - ,+ 6 ' % + 6 +6 1 (C$9$6 - 2 , " $98$ $ "
>
, + ' AB (C0)!
, '+ !'" + 7
9 "& ""
" $ 51- ( - ,, + 6 ' % + (C$9$ 6$ + 2 , "
$98$ $ "
>
$9$6 - +
" ' AB (C0)!, '+ (C$9(&'
4 1, "
$98$ $ "
>
$9 /"
( , , + + ' AB (C0)! > 1 , + 6 $9 /"
:(C <" ' AB (C0) " ,+ '
"126,, . " ''AB (C0)- .
AB (C0) ! '
" '
'' AB (C0)A - , ""
6 9 "
( "&'
% + ,.,'
- , ""
+ ( ,
(C!$9$ $ + , " (($02$ "
>
!$9 ( .
&", + + ' AB (C0)!, '+ % +'
" '
''AB (C0) (C1$9 ( .
, "
(($02$ "
>
&", + + ' AB (C0)!,
'+ % +'
" , " , ''AB (C0) !'" + 7
&"9 ">'( .
""
" $ 51- ( - (C4 !$9!
$ + , " $981$ "
>
( '
" ''AB (C0)! % +,%-$
'' > ( , + 6 9> ' AB (C0) ! '" + 9 " '&'
""
1 (C2 '&'
, " $%>-= $ "
>
, >
2
, + ' AB (C04)- 9 " +'
" , " %+ '
" ' $02,, . " '' AB (C04)D . AB (C04)% ! + '
" ''AB (C04)A 8 '
+ )0'( , , . " ''AB (C04)* > ""
+
% ""
""' + ( 1 > "
, ", '
" +, + % 6 + '" ,, +6
8"AB >) +AB >) 1 (C3 9 ">'( .
""
" $ 51- ( - + &"
4 (C5& " $ + 1 , " 9 " 9)-$98$ "
>
( ,
, + D9 4 1 $ 3)121)159(- 2!'!( $ $ $ "
! ' AB (C5)! ( , " ' AB (C5) , ' + 6" ! "" + " ' 8 , +
) " $9 /"
, "" + ' 4 (C9 " /"
1 , " $9 $98$ "
>
( ,
, + " D9 4 1 $ 3)121)159(- 2!'!( $ $ $ "
6 & " $ +9 " ! ' AB (C5)! ( , ' AB (C5)
, '+ 6" !
"" + " ' %
"" + 6 ' 4 % 6 ( , , 6 '
" 1 I 4 1 " > 1 ' AB (C) " ,+ '
"126 % ""
.AB (C) ! + "
, . "" ''AB (C)- %
B ;&$; "
! '
" ''AB (C)A > "
, ", " AB ( % ',, +6 % "
6 ", D$= +A!$9$ 5 1 (C!$9$ 5 1, " ($ - = $ "
> 5 1!$9 + '
"" J "
+ '
126 , H&$; + , '" - 1 5 1 "" " + ' D$=
6
> 5 1" "" D$=
6 "
.
'
8 "" '
" '",
,
'", (C1$(( "&'
1 1, " $%> ( $ -= $ "
>
'" + ""
+ = ( , ,6 + 8 " "'
" (C! &'
(C1( &'
(C" $ , 6 %, 6 6 ,. "" + %, + 2 $02% + - $ "
+, > 5 &", + $01$ " ' 8, $ "
!7 ." 6, ' ,60 0 ,&" /
&" ++ + 6 : (C (C1< 8 , + 6, '
+ + > 3 2!
%0(0 C *, ,' "" ' > 6 .
$
/ 9'' + '
(C " + ' AB (! (C 6$ , + 66 "
", " 8, "+ + ' ,"
!
( '6$
' 6,.,, 7 !
( = / , ' + 6 ! ' '" 6 .'
%" &"(
/
" '6$ D'" ". " 6
"6 ''AB ( 8
%0(0 ' / '
AB (0 AB (0, . " ''AB (- 8, D$= 4 (C1 ( &'
: 6 < " ' (C,+ 5 ,60 0 , &" &"
$ + ++ + 6:(C
(C1<6 + , " + 6, ' + % "+ +"
"
6,$ " 66 "6, "
+ +'' B 6
(
66 7 %" '
( '6 3 :
6 < 65 ) ( ' ,6 . $ " 4 +
'6 3 6 !
+,6$
+ 8$ "
+ ' 9 '" (
&", + &"
, + (
. ' ''6 ,. ?" (
&" ,.,6
! (C1 + ,6 ' ! 6 !
6 '6 +'' + + %, + + ' 6 C *, $ 2$ "
, 6$ , + %0(0 ! , +6 / , + , ,6 (C1 ' . ,6' , / ,6 ! +' 6, 8 C ' 6 1( ' + $
6 ' %'' " 1 ( , 6 6, + % , 6$ 6 '6
/ ,, . +, 2 !
, %
' AB (C4)-" , '
" 126, +, ''AB (C4)D 8" ,, D $ = 6 !( , !
, 2 &", ( , , 4 1 %, , '
'
! , 1 % '
' AB (C00 " ," 126, 8, D$= 2 !"D$="AB (F 126' . -) ' " 6 '
'
' , 66 '
, + +
, "6 2 !"D$="(F) '
":- '6 12 +< 6 '
=:'
. C)<, ' !'!242 9 +' ', ,. + 9 6 + %, ' + 6+ 8 12 6 '
. -) : ' < 6 ' '
' 6 " 6'+ + .
+, '
" '
. C) . '"
6 '
. 8 D$= " 6 .
6, 12"' 6
! " (C1 / , , !
/6 , 6 6 , ( > / , 8
6 "
/ 87 ,' $ , " " 6 &"
( / 8 " " " ' (C (C1 8'&" / " 6 ++ + ';60 0 , 5 ! + (
6+ $ ",, "
", 66 8 6 7 8
.' ' ,'6 "
(C '
( = / , ' + (C1 3 6 !
+,6$ + 8$ "
+
' 9 '"
(
&", + &", + (
. ' ''
6 ,. ?" (
&"
,.,6
9 B '
(
&", + "
. +8 ! ')2 ,"
.
" , + 8 (C (C1 + " (C1 0B '
' 5 6 +
'" + &"6
" % ' 6
&", + $ "
' 5 !"
' ",&"" 6 6" "66 " ," 6"
"6" , +''6"6 66/ " 2 % ;6 $"' -
' ) %
. ,+ " , . ,
9, 6
&
! #
' ' (%$)
*
*!(+,
! !!!
!!!
!!!
'''
' (%$) + - . '/ %
' '
#0
&
1% &
&
3
4& + - $
!
/ ' ' '5 ' '6
%
-
' '6
- / - $5'2
' $7+/ ' ,7$ (0
!!!
!!!
!!!
2 8& %+- *+,-./ 0123%4*567,' 8,9050
!
8 *1+,93,:;.<+"
1,8
' 0
. '9 '
( -2:
;<,' 0
= -!0
> ? &
! + #
' ' (%$)
*
*!
(,
? (%87
(%87' @ $ (%87 (%;)
3 3 8 '/+'
( %+ - 0;;.0/=6=8.0>3%;0;,*4 ) 96?,+
"
1='
! (%<5 (%$@
(% , / (% '
( -
+
.
6 %
&
,7$A$7+/ 2(0%
' 0
. ''
( -2:;<,'0=3 3 + ' (C1 &"(
" , +(C1+ 60$ + +
' 8, ' + " ' + 3
( ' 6 ' ,6 . $ " 6, &"
( 8 / 8 " 6, &"
( / '$ 6 (C
( = / , ' + " 6, ''$ 9 + ' (C1(
( =
/ , ' +
6 /
) 6 + 6 6 '6 ' + " ,
/ ' $ 6'
3 ! + "" , 8 ""
7 + ' + ' !"" 0
( , ( &" 8 6 , 7
8 "" 0
&'
6 " 2 %6 6 6 + &% %%
<52
'
+
C$" . +) G C" 6 G)