← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/479/2016allowed

Naveen @ Bhanda v. State Of Haryana

2019-07-10Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu28 pages

  



 

     

 

!"" # $ %

"   

 



 &" !"" # $ %

"     





 &'



 !"" # $ %

"     !

 



 (  )* $ + !"" # $ %

"   !

 ! 



 ( , )- $ + !"" # $ %

"    "

# $ %&% ' ( $ %%% ( 

 # * $ ! ,

 & .

!/ !  ""   -!00120 03 

 " $ +! 

  '& 

!  ""   -!0010 03 -!001130 03 

  ""  -!00450 03 -!00320 03

 $6 $ +! ! * %

%%' $ '' 7  ,     

  ""   . "+ "6 '' /+'    8-' !""  6 6  "" 

+                 /+'         )1  3          !   $   +  $ "

   $    253 $    1,6  , +,   "  6 $ 1 ,$ 149(- 0

9  ( -: ;9(-;<  +,    = !"" 

   

,   +,    $ 2!'! 8 "" , 

     0

'- 0!"" $  

 

(  )* $ +

  &'

 

  &"

( , )- $ + 9'" '  $ 1  9(-      "

      )0  9'" '  $ 0  9(-      "

      2)0  

  9       "

'          +9 '  

   

+'" '     $ 2!'!

"

  )0 8  ,     !   6  ( '>    4  -' !""   -!0010 03-!001130 3-!00120 03-!00450 03 -!00320 3 6 6 &"

 &'



(  

 

( , " 8 "       3  !$9 $ +, " 9  +(($2$ "

 % , "  6    "",   '

   6 ' +  % ?  !  %  + ,  "   6   $ ), $ +  -   %0(0-@

 ! &'

+ ' :AB (!<  ,  20! 8, $ "

 "  +

, "   8 ,6, $  ,,   +6  6 ,  +, '  %  2$02% -$ "

   >   5&")

 $ +)

+   "."7     8, $ "

 ,60 0 ,&"   +  +     "  + $ "

- ,B 2 5   >  3   6 2!

$  '" +

 " ,., + + $02$ "

 

 %0(0-@ -'"   6  ' ,           %?!  >  $02  $ "

    , ' "" '       ,

>  + '

  '"  ! &'

 "  ,  6  6$ ,   +   6 ,     $+ ,"        %" &"   "   ++ +'' !$9 $ + 7 AB (C4)! 6 ,'

D9AB (C)!, +  3   12 ( 8 'D$= "+ ",  " >  "  6 6    " 6    , .  "  '' AB (   9 7" +AB (,    8   '   + , .  " ''AB (- 8 6 ,  "''B '  8 ,  8 '

 '  !'"  +   

, "    8" B '  '6,  "" 8 '   $ 11- ( - ,  '.   " 8   +  

+  ' "     8   6   '"  "   A      + , /  ' '"    14)1 $

! 1)15 149(- +  '"  ! 6(   $ : < 8'"  "  +6  !  $ + $ "

   -'"    6 (    +   +  '   ' ' 9      '   AB        

.0!   *          8 "" ,     

6 %  ""   C     "

 +  +/+'     (C!@ $ +   3 , " $9

 ( $  - =  $ "

   >     

     7 + -  6 ' ,  6 ,+'

D9AB (C)! %  " "+A%-$ 

 ,



 '

"

  (C !   &'

  :'"  <            6 $ ,   %,  +,. 6 ""   + ,  +   %  2$02 % +  - $ "

  +,  >   5 &" , $01$ "

  '   8, $ "

   7  9      60 0 ,    &"    =+   ,   "  +  +  +    6, 6 &"  >  3   6 2!

$ , + + -

 %0(0'  C    *, 

,' ""   ',"  .+  >    + '"   "  ,  6 6 $ ,   +   8,6 /   -'"  " " ' &"

  "  ," '6 %  6$ ,   +  6 "

 ",  " 8,  "+  +  '  , "

  !

  (    '6

  '  6,.,,   7  !

 (      = /  , ' +  6 ! ''" 

6  .'

 %' 6

&"(  

  /     

 "  '6$  %   -  % "   3 '"   "  .  "  6 "   ''AB ( (  .  "    %0 (0 '    / '

 AB (0 AB (0 ''AB (- %    ""

D9  1)5 $ 19(- 2!' !( $ -= $ "

AB (02 "

 ""    $ 4- ( - -    114 $  $  AB (03%



  9 0B '   '    '  6 " "  1( ,, + 6 '

    

  (      6  %,  '

"    ' ,    % '     '     (  

 =

/ '  6      67  '   '

%   + ,   B   6 %,,   '' /,

"   %6  .  +          +,6  %   . ' 

'"  , +6 6+  +  % ' B"&",  +  )"6,  6   %   ' ,  ",'   '   %  ++  6  ' ,'' '  +  +"" " '  '' 

'6  1 (C1(  &'

:6 <  ,  +, 6!   8, $ "

   + , "  $ , 6 %,  6  6 ,.6""   + ,  +

        % +     -    $02  $ "

   >   5&"   +,60 0 ,  

) '  +,  $ 

. !' + $ 

.&" 60 0 ,, "  !&"  +,60 0 ,    .'

  9    60 0 ,&" 6  / 6 ,&" ++ +  '

$  "

 ",$ "   6 ,.  $ "

,6' '  !$ " "

 '  6    $ " !

  ( 

'6  '  "   $ "   

  (      '  $ ",'   >  3   6 5 ) (

  (   '6    '  ,6  . $ "  4

  + 

'6    3   6 !

  +,6$ 

+ 8$ "

+ '   9  '"  (  

  &",  + &"

,  + (  

    .  '  ''6   ,. ?" (  

   &" ,.,6  

 ! :(C1<

 +,6 ' ! 6 !

6  '6 +'' +  +  %, + + ' 6 C    *, $ 2$ "

  ,6$ ,  +    %0(0  !  ,  +6   /  ,

   +  , ,6  %. ,6'

 ,   / ,6 !  + ' 6, 8 C  '

6 1(  ' + $  6 ' % ''   "  1 (  , 6  6,   +   % ,    6 $  6 '6    / ,, . +,  %   + "

 + 6  , ,   6:! +(6(6' , , "" + %70B ' (C1 ,  , < 2 9 0B '  6          ' AB (D  +, &"

 . "  $ 

.  '+ $ 

. &" 60 0 ,, "    %  "   +,6 '6 .  3 '8 %,   ,AB (D, ,    % " 6  ' 6 +''   !

 %,   , '  AB (D, ', '   % ' , + "  ,  > "    5 $ 159(-

  D9  4    $ 15113 9(- !'! ($  $ $ "

 %  ' 

 +,6!  $ ,   +' '"     $ 19(- %'

  " ' '

!+!"1  % ' 6! ,   " '            "   %  '        5    6 +

 '"    +     &"  6

"    %

'  6 &", + $ "

'  5    E  6    ,   6$  +  8  3  %   ', 8"  % ,    , ,. +8 6+ %  + 

' " %, + "

"+  +&,

 6$    3 (C4 %'

&'

   3  4 1(

  +,   -   "''B '    6 $ &'

), $ + 86 ,  6 $

" .

$)$.6$ + $ "$) / $ +  % , + /   

         

          



   

    



                    



 

!         

       " !   



       



! 

#   

  $%   

             

    

     

    

      

          !   

   $      5 8  , . ' +    /6 ( A  8 /, 0''        '

 9 / 6 +   6  (C2 !$9 + &'

      3   , " 

.

   %"   3    "

    +6   ,  $    "

    + ,  $    "

    +"

 + ,  $   "

    +"

 , # $   >  3   6 "" ,  D$=

6 

 -  2 2 3 +- $ "

 51, "'  '

> 2    "

    +"126 , "6  /6$ +!$9 ,  $  >   3         "

      +  "  , "6 $9 /"

 > 5  1 "

    +"126,  D$=

6 

 -  1 5  1+ !$9 $  $ + 44   8    ""  '

      "   '",  ,

  '", 

 (C5 A!$9 $  

 A%-   ( $ - =  $ "

"  +  +        "   "        

  3 ,



   (C- $ "

($  -= $ "

    AB (C)!+  + . + ""      "

    +" + ,  $   +, '"   "

    +6    $  "   "6   ,   $   +, '"   "

    + 6  "

  , #  +, '" D$=

6   3   (CA!$9% &   1  9> ' ""  AB (C0)!6' +  '

 "  +, + %""

"AB (C0) " ,  " +" . +,+ + ' + ",  +  ,  6  , +6 6    8 " F+   6   '

126" 0 "

   (C  $

 ( .

  "        3       6 $  , $ + "  1 (C$(G "

    , "   + $98$ $ "

 >  

  +                '      '

 9 "

   > 1   ' A!$9% &  ( = $ "

 8  +  ,  '

  4 (C9 "

"+  +""

 + "

AB (C0)!"   '

  !$9 $ + 2 (C1  %-  !   &'

  .  "+ "     3  AB (C1)AB (C01)  . +!$9 $ + 3 (C4!$9 $ +   3 , " 9  +(($02$ "

 %, "  6   ,  '. ,    + ""   %?!

>$02$ "

 %  +, , "    @ 6  +  %0(0, 8 6 

 +" ,    !''! &'

6     '      "    +       '   AB (!  %  "" +AB (C04)! 8 ',  "   +-  ' , +  D9 %  ' D$= "+ " " 8"+ ".",  AB (C01)AB (C01) % " 6   6   ,,  .  "  ''AB ( 8, 6    %. " 6    " ''AB ( ,,    H $; %  7" +AB ( %.  "   '   + ''AB (- % ""

 +" AB (C04)  8 "

  + 6 ,  .  "  ''AB (  8 "" , ",   "  

 5 >        ,   ,  $%>   '  &'

  , 

 

  ,  +   >  + 

+   2   ( $ -= $ "

  ' AB (C04)-  9 "  '  

 +'

 " %  1$01$ "

,   "  "'''

  AB (C04) !

  '

     "          ''  AB (C04)A   9 "  '  

 + " 126  +, +,, .  "   ''AB (C04)D 8  

  +     '  + )0,, .  "  ''AB (C04)%  ! "

, ",      '

 "126 %  6 + '",, + ' 

 ,, AB (C04)  9    B '             6  ,  , ' , 6   %  '  " +     , ' , , , "   8+ ,,   .   "   + 'D$= 1 (C3$ "   3  ' +. , $  , $ + 6 '    %?!>$ "

,   6 ,,   +   1 (C$9 $ +    , "

!

$981$ "

 >  

  (  &'

,  +  '

 '  9 "  '

 "  '

  ''AB (C0)!

>   (  ,  +   +    ' AB (C0) ,  '+ !'"   +   +   (  9 "  '&'

""

 "  $ 51- ( - ,+ 6 ' %    + 6 +6   1 (C$9$6 -   2  , " $98$ $ "

 >  

  

 

,  +   ' AB (C0)!

,  '+ !'"  +  7 

 9 "& ""

" $ 51- ( - ,, + 6 ' % +  (C$9$ 6$ +  2  , "

$98$ $ "

  >  

$9$6 -   + 



  "    '  AB (C0)!,  '+ (C$9(&'

  4  1, "

$98$ $ "

 >  

$9 /"

  ( , ,  + +   ' AB (C0)!  > 1     ,  + 6 $9 /"

 :(C <"   ' AB (C0)  "  ,+   '

"126,, .  "  ''AB (C0)- .

AB (C0) !  '

 "     '

   ''  AB (C0)A   -   ,   ""

  6  9 "

( "&'

 % +   ,.,'

-  , ""

 +     ( ,

(C!$9$ $ +    , " (($02$ "

 >  

!$9 ( .

 

&", + +   '  AB (C0)!,  '+ % +'

 "   '

  ''AB (C0) (C1$9 ( .

    , "

(($02$ "

  >  

  &",  + +   ' AB (C0)!, 

'+ % +'

 " , "  ,  ''AB (C0) !'"  +  7

&"9 ">'( .

""

" $ 51- ( -  (C4 !$9!

  $ +          , " $981$ "

 >  

(   '

  "  ''AB (C0)! %  +,%-$ 

'' >    (  ,  + 6   9>             '   AB (C0)  ! '"  +  9 "  '&'

""

    

1 (C2 '&'

    , " $%>-= $ "

 >  

 

 ,   >

 2   

 ,  +    ' AB (C04)- 9 " +'

 "  ,  "  %+   '

" ' $02,,  .  " '' AB (C04)D      .    AB (C04)%   !      + '

 "  ''AB (C04)A 8 '



 + )0'(  , , .  "  ''AB (C04)*  >    ""

  +   

 %    ""

  ""'     +      (     1  >  "

, ",      '

 "  +,  + %  6 + '" ,, +6 

 8"AB >)  +AB >) 1 (C3 9 ">'( .

     ""

" $ 51- ( -  +   &"

4 (C5& " $ +  1  , " 9 " 9)-$98$ "

>  

  ( ,

,   +        D9  4     1       $  3)121)159(- 2!'!( $ $ $ "

 !   ' AB (C5)! ( , "    ' AB (C5) , ' + 6"   !  "" +    "     '    8  ,   +     

) " $9 /"

,  "" +    '  4 (C9 " /"

   1  , " $9 $98$ "

 >  

   ( ,

, +  "   D9  4 1    $ 3)121)159(- 2!'!( $ $ $ "

6 & " $ +9 " !  '  AB (C5)! ( ,  ' AB (C5)

, '+ 6"   ! 

"" +  " '  % 

"" +   6  '  4 % 6  ( , , 6 '

    "        1    I  4  1  "   > 1     ' AB (C)  " ,+   '

"126 % ""

.AB (C)  !  +    "

,  .  "" ''AB (C)-  %

B  ;&$; "

  ! '

 "   ''AB (C)A  >  "

, ",     " AB ( %   ',, +6    % "

 6 ",  D$= +A!$9$  5  1 (C!$9$   5  1, " ($  - = $ "

 > 5  1!$9 + '

  "" J  "

    +  '

126  ,         H&$;   +  ,   '"        -   1    5  1 ""  " + ' D$=

6

> 5  1" ""  D$=

6  "

.

    '

8  "" '

  "    '", 

,

  '", (C1$(( "&'

  1  1, " $%> ( $ -= $ "

 >  

'"   +  ""

  +     = ( , ,6 +  8 " "'

  "  (C! &'

 (C1(  &'

 (C"   $ , 6  %,  6  6 ,. ""   + %,  +    2 $02% +  - $ "

  +,  >   5 &", + $01$ "  '   8, $ "

 !7 ." 6, ' ,60 0 ,&"   / 

    &"  ++ +  6 :       (C    (C1<   8  ,   +   6,  '

+  +    >  3   2!

        %0(0 C    *,  ,' ""   ' > 6 .

  $ 

 / 9''    + '

 (C  " + ' AB (!   (C  6$ ,   +  66  "

 ",  " 8,  "+  +  '  ,"

  !

  (    '6$ 

  '  6,.,,   7  !

 (      = /  ,     ' +             6  !     '   '"   6  .'

 %"  &"(  

  /     

 "  '6$  D'"  ". "  6

"6    ''AB ( 8

 %0(0 '    / '

 AB (0 AB (0, .  "  ''AB (- 8,  D$=  4 (C1  (   &'

  :    6       < " '   (C,+     5 ,60 0 , &"   &"

$ + ++ +    6:(C

(C1<6     +   , "  + 6, ' +  % "+  +"

 "

 6,$ "   66  "6,   "

 +  +''           B  6  

    (     

   66   7  %"  '    

  (   '6  3 :   

6  <  65 ) (    '  ,6  . $ "  4   + 

'6    3   6 !

  +,6$ 

+ 8$ "

+ '   9  '"  (  

  &",  + &"

,  + (  

    .  '  ''6   ,. ?" (  

   &" ,.,6  

 ! (C1  + ,6 ' ! 6 !

6  '6 +'' +  +  %, + + ' 6 C    *, $ 2$ "

  , 6$ ,  +    %0(0  !  ,  +6   /  ,   +  , ,6  (C1 '  . ,6'  ,   / ,6 !  +' 6, 8 C  '  6 1(  ' + $ 

6 ' %''   "  1 ( ,  6 6,   +   % ,    6$  6 '6   

/ ,,  . +,   2 ! 

  ,           % 

 ' AB (C4)-" ,   '

" 126, +, ''AB (C4)D 8" ,,   D $ = 6  !(  ,      !

 

,   2   &",      ( , ,   4  1    %,      ,     ' 

   '

!     ,       1     %  '

    ' AB (C00 " ," 126,  8,  D$=  2 !"D$="AB (F 126' . -) '  " 6 '

  '

 '  ,  66 '

  ,  +  + 

 , "6  2 !"D$="(F)  '

":- '6  12 +<  6 '  

=:'

. C)<,   '   !'!242 9  +' ',   ,. + 9 6 + %,   '  + 6+ 8 12    6  '

.    -)  :  '        <    6    '     '

   '  6      "  6'+  + .

+,  '

" '

. C) . '"

6    '

.  8    D$= "       6       .

6,  12"'  6  

    !  "  (C1       /   ,    ,      !

  /6   ,  6   6  ,  ( >  / ,    8

 6 "      

/   87     ,' $ , "   "  6 &"

 (     /   8 " "  "   ' (C (C1 8'&" /  "   6 ++ +        ';60 0 ,      5 ! + (  

  6+ $ ",,  "

 ",   66  8      6   7  8 

.' ' ,'6 "

  (C '  

 (      = / , ' +    (C1    3   6 !

  +,6$  + 8$ "

+

'  9 '" 

(  

  &",  + &",  +  (  

    .  ' ''

6   ,. ?" (  

  &"

,.,6  

 9 B '   

  (  

  &",  +   "

. +8 ! ')2 ,"

. 

" ,  +  8    (C (C1      + "   (C1 0B '  

'      5            6    + 

 '"    +     &"6

"  % '  6

&", + $ "

'  5     !"

'  ",&""       6  6"    "66  " ,"   6"

 "6"  ,   +''6"6   66/ "   2 % ;6    $"'  -        

      ' )  %

 .  ,+   "   , .  ,

9, 6  

 &   

    

      !            #  

     '  ' (%$) 

      

      

   *           

     

  *!(+,   

!                   !!!

!!!

!!!

        

                  

    ''' 

' (%$)     +     -   . '/ %       

 

  '   '                     

            #0

          &       

1%  &                                             

&  

   3  

4& +         -   $ 

      

        

     !   

    /   '   '                             '5      '  '6      

             % 



              

 -

      '  '6       

                  -  /  -  $5'2 

             

' $7+/   ' ,7$ (0              



 

     !!!

!!!

!!!

2 8&  %+- *+,-./ 0123%4*567,' 8,9050  

!

8 *1+,93,:;.<+"

1,8         

                         ' 0

. '9 '

 ( -2:

;<,' 0

= -!0

  > ? &   

                        !      +                 #  

 

      '   '  (%$)  

   

            

  *                    

  *!

(,  

           

     ?     (%87                

     

      

 (%87'        @  $   (%87      (%;)                          

  3 3 8 '/+' 

( %+ - 0;;.0/=6=8.0>3%;0;,*4  )  96?,+

"

1='          

    ! (%<5  (%$@  

 (%  ,  /     (%    ' 

  (   -               

     +

            .           



6                                %

              

            &

 

 ,7$A$7+/ 2(0% 

    

  ' 0

. ''

  ( -2:;<,'0=3 3  +   ' (C1  &"(  

   " ,    +(C1+  60$ +  +

  ' 8, '  +  " '     + 3  

  (   ' 6    '  ,6  .  $ "             6,  &" 

  (  8   /    8  "  6, &"

 (   /    '$  6      (C      

   (           =    /   ,  ' +      "  6, ''$  9 +    '     (C1(   

 (      =

/ , ' +    

  6    / 

) 6 + 6   6 '6 ' +       "  ,  

/ ' $  6'

 3 ! +     ""     ,   8  ""   

7       +   '  +    '  !"" 0

 

  ( ,   (    &"         8  6    ,  7 

  8   "" 0

 &'



 6 "   2  %6 6   6   +  &%  %%

   <52

'

 +

C$" . +)   G C" 6 G)