High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1929/2006dismissed

Balwinder Singh v. State Of Pb.

2022-08-18Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!!"

#$ $ ""%&'

( $!%"

)

* +%" !!"$ #$ $ ""%&'

( $!%"

, -

./ !!"

#$ $ ""%&'

( $!%"

!" !#"## $

%&$ ! '!'!$ '$"0 $ 1#/2+%3"45% $ &%"!!"$ /% 2*2'

( 66666 !'!$ (!

7"$ /"28""%$!%$%&(%+/"%

"!!$$% "%&"$/ /"2!$$(79 2!3 % "29 8:% , " ;

&%%&&3 3"%-%&":3%"3< $'$73%"%!3 ($"3$3"2 =- &% $%" >" 3">2 $" " '%3 ""% ' 2 <"3"

92 2

(7!!"

2 )

(7* + :?/ -

(7./

&7$"""&3"$%&"3$2$!!%$3 "%$"%7 ""% ;

2!%3!"7&%/'%3""%' (7 8$!3"% :/ &% (+"7 @8A $ "+ %+/"*7!$7%!"%""$ $3"%%&%/ !"%$' B"+337"!%3!"7 3 ./%&#1!

2"5'C 3."% " /( !"%"&%"$2$$!%""3%/"+7$!B"$ $"%$"%!(7"!%3!"7B!$%%$"&$

/!% "&%/"" 3.7B $3$(78%/"%$"(:$B"" 3.$ (+(7* +33 $$:?/. / $"" (7 $ $B " /2 % !""$$+""$!%"B$%""!%3 !"7B " 33 $ !! " " $!%" /"% $ ! &%/(7"8""$ $!3"$%/3%"((3 "" 3."33 $""%""$33% "" !$3%&$%/*?""&&3%$""B""33 $

%!""%""$33% 3""!$3%&*?""&&3B //%$ "" DE ' "% ' !!B $ $ 3 " 8 $ //% 1/"2<'2 (<+$%' 2*?"" '%3&&3"%"$!%"(7$$$/$$B 1/" 2<'33%7+""$!%"B"% 3/$&"%" 33 $&%/"/""$*?""&&3"" " "% $3 " " 3.2 $3 " $ $ $!3" "% ( 37 3%"3"""33 $3% ""$33% 3"(7/%(7 $%/$""B""33 $!%$3%&3 1/"

2<'B"3%$"//%$""!!B"&"

$ !+$%$" 3"%$%& 1/"2<'2"(%7 %&"" 3.$$323$3%+""! B) ($ &% "%("2"%$($3%"!%!!7 $.B"%$/!$%&

- /$3&%/3%&) ($"$ !%!!7 $.%(3/"%(,=.3(B"$/!$" ($3%"$ !%!!7 $.3%+""%!3$ 7 $"$%&8+$3!"%@:A$%&<'+ $3!"% @19AB $/!$$/!$$%".%$!" !!B"8%+"$&" $"%!""$$% $ 1/"2<'"$$"/2&"

$B"&""3$!%!"7%""! " 3. "."%!%3!%$$$$%+3%+7//%DE '<""$"(7" "$$$B"33 $$""$3$B FDE '$$""% " !%3 $""% % " ($$ %& 3 &%/ 8 DE '4 $

3%B&%/"%$"%&"33 $$$""%" "+$B!$%$3%&""33 $$3% 3" $!"//%$""!!$DE 'G"%'9B% $" !%&!3%&3%+7$!!$DE ':B%" "%"!%3 $""%2"8!% 3"3$!%!"7%""33 $ "$$$(&%G"%$$" 3"%$2"3$!%!"7$ !%$""G%&"!%3$""%$33 $!

" %3. !B "3% $%&+$""%2$/!!3$$""% "%&&3%&/3DE/2'

($!!%"3+" &%/ DE '2 " $/! &% "% ( "" %& !%!!7

33 $$$%$" 3%/!"%%&+$""%%"&%/"$23 $""33 $$!!&"% "B%!$""% %& " 32 %3 /"$ !% " $ !! "% " 33 $&%&3%$"$ $!%+ 3"%

; ' 2 " &!/&33$23&%%&&3 3"%-%&" 3"$&/$""33 $2"%3"7!%" "7 3/" , < "3% $%&!%$3 "%+32"E/" &%%"$$$0 'HG'.1 / 'H 8C%32"$$%&3%+7!%$ ""%3%+7%&3%"(&%/"!%$$$$%%&"33 $ "/$%&"!%$3 "%$"%7

'H, $ / <+2 "% "% <C2 5 (% ""3%""%%$!%&"" 3.F $"% 'H)8$!3"%:/"8%&"$3$!%$ "+$""%3% 3"(7/""%3%+7 %&3%"(&%/!%$$$$%%&"33 $ 'H- 1/"2<'"$"&(% "$% 3%+7%&3%"(+( &&3" &%/!%$$$$%%&" 33 $3"737"" 3.%"&"& 7 'H G :$ $"" "" "&

""$!%"$3 $"%+$"'%3 ""%' "$%/!$%/!%$" 'H;%$"($1 /+$&&+"DE ' "$"&""%

2".$/!!3$"%"%&&3%& /3 DE/ " $$ "3" G$ &&+" $ ($37 " "%$&3 $"%7%&"$/!!3$ "!%"%$ /$!%$$$$% C!%$3 "% !%$+%3 /"$ H" ""2 "!%$3 "%+3%"3%3 ) ""/"$%&"33 $3% 3"%,, ' 2 3 " 3/" 33 /$"3$ !! !%$3 "%+3$""33 $!

""%"/( ""7 ""%$3%""""7%3"( &$7+%+"$3$ 33 $* + 3/ !"!"""7%"3%//""7%&&3

%3%+7$&&3"&%/"/ C7%".%"3%33 $ $:?/".!""%3%3"%"" " 3.F $"%"3$$(&$7!" !%/ C !". !(733 $./$""$3%.%& # %$""%"* 2&%""$% $!3. !&%/$% $%

"&"+%+ "$3$ - < 3% $ %& " &3 +32 " 33 $ E/ %&%&33 $./2$"<HI2% !%$""% =

$%" $( !$""%/2"!%3&%/'%3""%' 3/"%%.

$(7 "%%.!3%"$!3"(%&"+ "%!%3$""%%

;

( ""!%3!

""/ %&&$"""" $($F &%F 7( "$ ($F "7 $+%+&$3$ & "$"""" $($ 3%.%&# %%3$$"<7 %3%$"%$""!%3 <H <("$"&""33 $./ $3%.%&$+%

"$"$$% "&%&./%"!$%$+$"'' " "%!3. !%&./(7"!%3&%/%/ &" /"$2 + /!

/" "

2"&% 33 $3%+3"&%%&&3 3"%-%&"3""/$%&"%!$$%""+772

"&% 33 $$"3"% %%% $/!$%/"8 &%!%%& 7$3"%!7&%&$ .3B & "%&!7/"%&&2"% %& "8&%

7$3

+(7"$ /"%&"3%+3"% $"32"&% 33 $+!&"!$"!!$ 3+3%/ !&%% ;

8 + 5 % $ &% " !!"$433 $2 "" 3% $ ($$ % "% " 3% = C&$"% %&""3.(73% $&%"!!"$$ ""!" "$$ % " "!%3!"7/7% $%"E/$"$$(7"!%$3 "%B$E/"% $3$$7$3$!!%$3 "%$"%72$%&"8&" $ ( %+ "% /2 "&%2 $+ (% $ " "% " !%$3 "% $"%7 $%( % (" $$ " / (% "

" "& $$%&!%$3 "%$"%72"&%2(&"%&% ("$% ( +"%"33 $"7$% (3F ""%&"3&/ $""/ H$2 "" 3% $ $ $ (/"" "" % E/"%%&"!""$$%$%"&&3""3("7%& !%$3 "%$"%7 &""+3%""%$28&""$3" !$"3$2"$%""%$%"""%&&3"$$$7 !+% $/"7""33 $2!%/!"(73"7/"+

+%+"33 $"$3$%7 C&%2"$%$%"% % (" "!%$"%$%&%&&3"$$$%%.&%!" 3%%(%"%+ D+%"$2!"3%%(%"%$ %&! 3%"F /"%& 8&"E!"%%&"" 3% $"%(F "3%"3%+3 C"% "$$%"

""$$!3""$"/!

/"8%%"$7 $%"%+&&"+"/"" %" /"+3(73% $&%"!!"$ $""""7%&33 $ $%"$"($ (3 $"/$%&"!%$3 "%$"%72 /!%&&&%/" "

3. 7 G%+2 "" 3% $ """%%&"% ""%"$"/%7%&'H G:$$""""

G :$ % $ //( %& " !%3 !"7 $ 3F "" $!3&37$"""""& 33 $ C&%2"$%(3"%(73% $ &%"!!"$3.$/"

53% $&%"!!"$& "3%"""

"/$%&"!%$3 "%$"%72"3%"(3%+7$"&%/ %&!%!!7 $. ( "$ !!%"DE '3+ &%/"%&&3%& /3DE/2"$&% "%(""%&!%!!7$233"$ % ("(% "" "& $$%&"!%$3 "%$"%7 H$2""3% $&"%!:%

%&"/!

/" "$ $!3" $ ($3 $$ (7 %($+""!%!!7 $.2!%!!7$"3 $!"$%&%! /

!%!!7%(&"3(""%"33 $%"$$3%2$ $ (/"""""$$"F "E!"%"/""%$%"

3%$""

"% ("& 33 /$"3 8&"+".(7""% ""/""%$%"

3&%7$/""33 $3%""7(&"""

$3% 53% $&%"!!"$$!%"% "3" $3!3$$""/"$%&"$$$%&3%+7/7'H 8 C%3 2 'H) 8$!3"% :/ 2 'H- 1" 2 <'2 $"" "" $ 3 3%"3"%$ " !%$"%$ % ("& H$ "" 3% $ $ 3%" "" " $3!3$$%!%"% """%3%$F ""$%& "3"33% ($ "%&!$%&//%7%33% "%& !$$%&"/ &" " + 3%""%$2 8 & "" " $3!3$$%!%"% "(73% $&%"!!"$ /%$"7""%"/"" 3.$$$!%""B""/ %&+%&<'""$!%"B""/"!%3!"7%" 33 $3"!

%3$""%"3 2& "$!3"%& $"3("+% $!3$ 3"7!%&+"%$(% "% $ "%&&3!%%&%($+"%2//%?"%%&+"$ !3!"

"$$$" "& %""

"%%$%!%$!%".

"/%2$""/"$%&'H$3%"% "&" 3%$("/"$/""%&3%//%.%"" / //%7&$$""/E!$$ ""%&%"& $$$% C !%$"%$%&"$$$%&3%+73%"(% ("&%""$% C&%2"$3%""%%&3% $&%"!!"$%$%"

"73

8"$3$2""$$$%&3%+7(%+/"% +& 7$ !!%""!%$3 "%$"%7%/"$!3"$ C7 3%$$E/""%(&%&"33 $( ""7$"

3."%" $3% %"($""%7/"!%" $%($+ 2"$%/"%3%"%$%"""77!+% $ /"7""33 $&%$%%&3"7/"+/!3" "33 $"$3$&$7 8%%"$7$%"%$(+" !%$"%$ C !%$3 "% $ $ 33$$& 7 !%+ "" " 3$ !%!"7/$&3 $"%7"$%"/!%&$$ "!%2"3$!%!"7/!%$"/. $/!!3$"."%%&&3%&/3DE/&%!%$" "&%7$$ C+$""%"$3$$(3% 3" &/!"/ C+7&3""""3%"($( 35'" 3.3$%"!$$+3( ""$!%"

+3"&% 33 $"+""" 3.%$"%!%"

% ""%$"3%$3% $!%$$$$%%&"3%"( &% %& "/"%("."%(%"!%$$$$%%&"3%"( C7 3% %" 7 $%( % ! $( E!"% &% "

3%"(+(3%+&%/"" 3.3"7 "+ C7 "% ( ". $ 3%$3% $ !%$$$$% %& " 3%"(+%&3"%$,--)%&"3" 1!+" F ""7%&3%+7+%+2"""33$%&"$/ (!" !%"33 $ :% 3%+3 $% &% " &$ /!3"% 3%/$% ""%(""$%+(7"/%$%"3%/% ""% (3%+3%"7%&3 C!%$3 "%!%+"$ 3$""33 $(7%$%%&$%(% (" "&% 33 $"73%+3"$"3(7""% "

C"% "$(F """"33 $ // /!

$/" &%"%&&3 C$ % $3%!&%& " 3"% C&%2"!!$&% "%("% "/"" $/$/$$33%7 C33 $4!!"$%""3%3$$%%& $ $!$%%&$"3 "!37%&"!!$"/$%&" %!$$(7"$% "%"%$ (&%&9 3 $""29".&%/"%72&3 92% $$ "$%&$""%$3 "!$3$ "/"%"% %"/$"3 :3$$7"/"%( $""%"% "3%3"$

" # $

" &' # $