High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1475/2015allowed

Harish Kumar Verma v. State Of Punjab

2020-01-20Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu18 pages

#$%%&"'"(

)"%*+'

", ""-%"+"."

///

--"

,' #0'1" ///

0 /0"

'-" *% $"

--" /)//23"- % %"-/2/0'1"/ 444 !

/ 5*%"

"-*"% '

"6"% *1'6 " "

789/ !/

# *-"%&'6 :'*%""%% ";/< #

< 3*( *"

--" 3" %"$%$ # ##$'$ %<

=0" $ '6-%#%

" "( " #% # /

8 " % #"'- '6 %6'

% #"#' * %#7 */

5*$"# $'

%%"'

*--%

< %# %3"$%"

0-%$0 :"- +"-"0//"":'*%"" 6"%6"

*#0"3"0"(/ -%$ " (*"(= "-% %6* =$*"60/0/:"- +"-"3 "- :'*%"" 3* $

2% %."0"(6 $* *3"3.%6 ">%-?@$'

%%=0". %6

"("

:'*%""# *-"

9("/) *0"3"0"("6"'

7("3"3.%6"

". "$*"%%63% **/

< **"6 % "%$$ %3% * 3./* "( *%A") -/

*%6* % %678

<*$%" * $"-- # %- '

!!99<79 < # )"%* +'

" "-%" +"."

--" * %-'

!779

7</ )"%*, "%# * *"0"3"0"(*"6 *" - "%"60"-"$ :'*%"" "

"%"6# *%#%3*0"3"0"($"

'3--/)3" ". "-:'*%""3* *$ $-" *% "/ $%

# *%$"--$

-# #:'*%""" %$ -("$*%%-) "-/*B' " #" (#* *$'$ "% 3" $-"*3**"%/

*"%# 'B"3" 0-%$ %# ".%6 (%

*"%-(%"(6% /= "-%%6* "=B' /0

3"$'$

</5*%$"3" #""-(%

* ##%$ # * %$"- ?@"

%/ 9/

< $

2% %."

0"("-63% **'$-'* *"3"1 = " %6*" 6 $* *%# *#% -%# * * 0"3"0"(*"%' 6-%6$#)"%*, ""-%"+"."/ )"%*, "*" ".* * *" -"%"60"-"$"*" ##%. * */*' $ %'' "$ *" %@%*%%.$"'#3*%$** *%/*#' * "

" , " % # )"%*, " "-%"+"."*" 3.%63% * *$

7 *"-%*3" # 1/'

3 *"$."

", "*"$ **'# $

%6 "6% * "- " "- *"

# $

3% * % $B'$/ )"%* , " 3" '%*%6 "

6'6"6"% *$

"$$' "% "

" " 3*(*.%--* *0"3"0"(/ *% >=' $ %<

=03"6% "6"% )"%*, ""-%"+"."/

<#* %$"-?@"

%3"$%" 3*%$*$*- $

'6'

#%$ %$%3"#'% *%$"#0"3"0"(/ 5*"# * $ 3* $'$ @"

% 6" %% $"'#"

*% *%$"3"' $*-$

'6'

#%$ %$%3*%$*3'##%$% $"'"

*% *%"($'# "

'/ </ > -%$ % ". "( "$ % * $

-"% /%"

%#%3% * *%%"$ %* #%-$% %"-$

-"%

"6"% )"%*, "" *'$ %<

< !8<=0% ' #=--"B""6% "

:'*%""%-"

% *%$$'$/$$' 3"" </ !/

</*"--"3" </

</ / 5* $'

%@"

#3% %% '

5* # *"$$''$ %<</0//3"$/) *3% * *8#'#%*"6 "

"%"6#"

#%/ :%B'3""-% "%"6 " (/ )% #%3 %

%6 "-/0"3"0"("-63% * *( " $'

%6 "

3*%.("# * */= #*%".%6

*(% $'

%6"

3*%.(/0"3"0"(" *( 3"-$'

%6 *%6-%.2'

.""-63% * *%%./#

".%6 *8#'%. * *( '

# * %" %%"

/0"3"0"(#--3# *$*"%/)3% * **-

# * % ".$"#*% /5*"# 0"3"0"(3"

". "-($"--%6" "@%/)%# 2% %."0"( % #0"3"0"( - */*3"% % """$* * "-% %6/5* -%$3""- *"*

3"$( -%$/) *3"%$ /)*"

"(##$"*"#"--(%

-%$"

% *$"/

5* "

--" 3"$%$ " $"# "/)$ *%"

"-/ C*"*"-"$'-# " %"*"6

*'6* *1'6 "$/ 0C2% %."0"( **"3.%6">%- ?@$'

%%=0". %6"$*

"(/**"3%6/ *3""-% "

-*%/=

*"-63% ** *3"

"# :'*%""/

< * *" 6 % " % $$ %3% * *3.#$

"(/* "("

A") - ;" ' "/

9/<

*$%" - *%$$"--#

%-#* *0"3"0"(/*%# *% **" "("

% """.*% ".$"#*% -#/

*$%" *# %-#)"%*, ""-%" +"."/)*'%-(%# * **"'6* * * "

"%"6"

*" -""- *$% %#0"3"0"( '-( %"

/)3" ". "-:'*%""3** 3"$-""( *$ /* % $"-- *#* */)3 *3" /*%

-("6'

* -"-"(% *-*"-%" "% %B'%"'

* *0"3"

0"(/% *-*%# * ( "(%//

<)"%* , "*"$ 3% * ("

"*" ".0"3" 0"("-63% **% /5*"# *$

." "@%"'*

"- :'*%""/*"3"(#* *%

'"(/* %$ *3 %1'%*%(/5*( 3"3-- 3"#"-'%*$-'/*"- %$-" * %- " '

*/C**"$* ** "-)"%*, "3" * % $ "$ )"%*, ""*%% / *" %, " *% # )"%*, " *"

* * *(*"--"#

/5**3 **'"# *"-63% ** -"-"(% *-* ;""$*"" *3 *0-%$ %"

/)"%*3" "

* /=B' $%6 3 $'$ / * $ "$ * % ##%$

</ 5*"# -%$$* "

<?@/0"* "

<?@/0 *"%#3*%$*>=3"$/ C**"3 *"(% ** "- %- 6-$*"% 6- %6"$.#$"3 %%6/5* %%6 %- *#* * "% "

%"-# *"# *%"

*/ *.

%# %6 -%$'

3" "( -%$ "$ */ *'

-"% 20 20%

%%# 0-%$" *'

-%$ ""

% %6"

/ *"-#%-$% %"- %% *0'1"")"("")%6*' # %$3"%' 0'1" -%$3'6% "$ %" " *"$$'/*% %#% *"$$'%' / 9/ =$@"

%(-"$'-#"$$' *

**" - -%$

9/<

* **" . * */*"- **"6 $%* )"%**" - * * *"-63% ** * 0"3" 0"( *" 6 "

* "%"6 # *% #% 3* $% %# 0"3"0"(3/ *%

-("6'

* -"-"(3*%# * 0"3"0"(*"63% * )"%* +'

"" *("

/* %*#% * *" )"%*3" %-#"

*#* *"**"

".*% "-6 "%"6/* %* **"

%# *0-%$ 3**"$*%%-) "-:'*%""

* %$ "(#* *3"*"%6%1'%"-3" $ %6'

#*% %-"(*"$(%-'$-'/ *3" $# 3% * * ?D/ 3* * #"$ 3

%/* * *' ".-%B'/ !/ 0C /0" *%" %$"-##%$ %%-) "- :'*%""

<*3" "%$"-##%$ :'*%""/ "( *"-63% *" /E6*+*""

"/&"%+"'3*%$*3"$ '

(=$*"6/)"

%6*;"6% %%-) "- :'*%""$'$ @"

% *"(#0"3"0"(/5*"(3"'6* () 2'1 %6*0-%$ %"":'*%"""3"% %#%(+"

"-1%

%6*#/)""%6*";"%%6*#*"

"%6*/ 5*(3"'6* # *" -"%"60"-"$ "- :'*%""/ 5* ( 3" $% % * '"( "

</ "

</5* @"

% *"(3"$'$

</ *%# %#'%*( *0-%$ "

*$$'' % ".#-$*-/%6 %3"#'--(- "

"%%63" "$./?(" '

*3$-/

- "%%$*"6# *"6-# '

*-# %3" C"

(%$*"63" # * %-%%""' * %-/("%#"%-##%6" " '$' "# *-% 3" /:"(@" "$*"3$6 "$ "% %%6 # " %$-/ 5*#--3%6%1'%3#' "(

# 5*%$"# *$" 3" #$* %$"-""-(% ** %$"- ?@"

% 2 #0'1" +*""/5*%$"#$"3 "- *)"# *0"

*-6( "

2 %$"- --6 0"

%"-"#*% *-6%$"-@"

%/ / 5*$"'#"

*3" ' $*-$

'6'

# %$ %$%3*%$*3"'##%$% $"'"

*%"%"($'# "

'/5* "- 3%1'(""

*3".

%6"

*" @"

%3""'

*'/5*

$ (# 6% % ?@/0" %$ %"-%"6"

*3%6 *"

#%1'%%?@/08/ / =$@"

%* % 3"$$ " %# %6% ( *0-%$ "

*3"' % ".#"-$*-/

% )% .3%#"( 36"%6"

*#0"3"0"(3"

'-%*3*%% 3" % **"$'

@$%"-$*- 3% *'

/)$'- "(%#$*-$

'6'

#%$ %$% % ''"--( #' % # % -%. 6 "- '- #'% 3*%$* %$ %$%" "(/ 5* %%-% (#%1'% ;/" %// ""%"(%6$"'3*%--"%6"'-"%6(% *%$-$" '-'

/5*""%3 #"

"-"$"'#"

* % *%$"/ / 0C<;"%

% #9> +% $*-';"6":'*%""

*%#"

*)"% %

'" * 6"

*(* ( *"

5"6;"6" :'*%""/ 5*(' *%

-( $-%$. * 6"

*" " %##'$ %/

< *%

-('*" ""0%$*" "#

*#'$ %*-"

*" -"%"60"-"$/'%6% %6"

-%$*"6 "#"%#'$ %# *%* 3*%$***" *" = "-%%6*/ </ 0C)'.*%6*'6* *%6%"-$

-"% #%-# 2% %."0"("

/7/

</=$@"

% * "# %B'%( *$

-"% 3"#%-" " %% * / / 0C '* *"3"1 $

3" "'6* #*%3%#F */ 9/

<*"$$

"%* 0-%$3**6 $* ?@/0 / )% %#%*% %6"

'"% % / / 0C7 ) 2'1 %6* 6"%6 % # 3 "- "$-$ "%%6%$"" 3"-- % *##%$#

& * %$"-?@"

% +*""""1%") "- 0"

%"-" $ %-(/ 7/ 0C )".*+'

<*3"

")0//"":'*%""/ "( = "-%%6*#0/0/ :"- % 3% **% 3"- "$-" 3"-- / 9/

<**" *"- "$-""-- "-63% *"

-"- "-2'1 %6*# % %6 "$- "- % *##%$#* %$"-?@"

% +*"""" *

"$-"- % * "

#0"

*-6( "1%") "- 0"

%"-"/ "-2'1 %6*"# % %6 "$-"- % * $ %##%$*" *$%

*% / / 0C9= " %6* 9/

<*3"

" ) 0//"" :'*%""/ "( 2% %." 0"( $

6 $* ?@/0 /= 3"" *" *%6% "

%6% $$ /'* *"3"13*"$$

"% *"-%6 *"% />=?@/0+83"$ *"% #* /)%% -"$#$$'$" "'6*%

-"?@/0:"$ #3% /'%6% %6"

% * $--$ # "%"6% ?@/0/# $%

#%$"

?@/0>"$$'3"" /# $

- %#% %6"

%$*"--" 3" ""6"% "$$'/)% %#% *"$$'%' / 9/ = $ @"

% ( -" $'- # "$$' * "

" #$

*#0"3"0"( *"$$'3**"-63% * *3" % *"%"60"-"$ % "%"6#'$ %3**- - "3"

". "-:'*%""( *"$$'/) %?@/0

*%63""--6"6"% "((" % 3""%6( $

/ !/ 0C!= "-%%6*

<*3" "=$*"6 0/0/:"- 0-%$ %"" :'*%""/ "(* $%"'B"# %%-) "-:'*%"""'

'"-"

*# 0"3"0"(/)"-63% * * -%$##%%$"-3 "- :'*%""3*2% %."0"( "6 $*

?@/0/)$'$ %B' $%6/) "

-%$"

%?@/0? %%-) "- :'*%""#$'$ %6 @"

%# "(#0"3"0"(/# *"(#0"3" 0"(3"*" 2% %."0"(/ 5*%$"#$"3" * "-"

%"-""* %$"-?@"

+*""/)*"$-%$.

* 6"

*?@/0 ?@/07*% %- *$"

"/) '$

* 6"

*"# ""%6#) " %6* 0"" :'*%""/5* * 6"

*3 ".% %% ?@/00/ 3" ".% %% ?@/0/:"

% %6"

% 3" ".(= " %6*/

/ 0C *%*"." *3" "0*" "$% "

)- -%;/ 9 '-"$%$"

:'*%""/

<" * $"--3"$%# 9%$/5*(3". "$* *" - "%"60"-"$/)"-63% *2'%%6* %- # '-"$;/ "$*3% * '-"$" ."'$$%' # *" - 0"-"$"6 *% "

%%%-) "-:'*%""/

/ 0C " 2% %."0"("* *0"3" 0"(3 "(%6 %**'# *-" ("/2% %."0"(

*"3.%6"$* 6"

%"$

"(/0"3"0"( 3""-3.%6"

1% *$

"(/

9/ 8!/

)"%*"-63% * 38 * * $"

*% *'/0"3"0"($"--*"".* - *"*3" 6%63% * )"%*/ 0"3"0"(% '* %6* '</

8</ @ %6*$%" - *$"--# 2 %."

# % "3*%B'%"'

0"3"0"(/*0C%# 2% %." 0"3"0"(*"63% *)"%*"*" '/ 2% %."%# * 0"3"0"(*" ". "- :'*%"""$$' #*%%--*"

*/-"%6 *%*"-63% ** *'";"%%6*-# #%%-) "-:'*%""/ )"%*3"

*/5* "##%# * 0"3"0"(3"%% /* %$-"%1'( ". #0"3"0"( *% '

*""$./ 2% %." %# * **""-"(-#

% " " 3'- "$* :'*%""/ 5*( "( "

%%- ) "- :'*%""# *3*-"(/0-%$"$** "-"

8!/< "

/) *'"% %#%"(#0"3"0"(/

/ 0C "%6* !/

<*3 * " - "%"6 0"-"$ " " $"- % -" ?@/ 0G % '$ %" % %6'

#)" %6*/

</ 0C<+"

"-1% %6* 0"3"0"(" *% % 2% %."0"(*"%%6%*'#;"%%6*3*%$* 3"%*%%6*'*/)

<*% %#% "(#$"% '"(#%%-) "-:'*%""/ )% 3"$( -%$'$ % /0//

/ 0C)" %6* %("

<*3"3.%6 """6"

*" -"%"60"-"$ 0".*3"- " :'*%""/ 5*3"" "%"6#'$ %

<% *%6* / :%B'3" %6 6' "

#'$ %/'

6' 3 %

"%"6#'$ %/)3"%6 *#'$ %# "--"6-"*3"

""6# "%"6 "-"$/ "'8/<

*3 ". "'# "%"6 "-"$/C**"$*% *-"3# "%"6

-"$* %$ 3"-(%6%-"3/

3 "%6"'/) *'6* * %6* *"#"--' % ".#@$% -%B'/%B'%(# *( **"#"--"#

".%6-%B'/ # ".*% $"--"$ /) % $ "$

)- -%;/ 9# *% %- '

*3" /)"- %

$ "$ 6$('

3% *'

'$$/"3*%- #"

* #%$"

" .*% ""6 *$ (# "%"6/ # ""6%6 *$ * ' -"$3*"% 3"-(%6'

( **3" /5*3"% %# *% (*"

".% '-"$ 9/5*@ "( -%$$"

"%"6 "-"$ "$*% / )% .3 3**"#"-- 3 3*3 "'*% /

/ 5* -" 00 % %$ >: ?@/0> $ #3*%$*""' %"

% " '

() * +

(() *

((() * ! ($) *

# $) * , -% # " !# #

! # !

#! %

( '

# !

/01.2./.+.345 !

(( ((( ($ $4

7/ 5*$"%"$%$'

" %"-%$/5*$"3" 6% * #0C2% %."0"(3* * *0"3"0"(3"3.%6"". "$*"%%63% * */

< **"6 % "%$$ %3% * 3./* "( *%A") -/ "'

*%6*

% %6

<*$%" *$"--# %-#)"%* +'

""-%"+".""

--" * %- */)"%*+'

", %# * *"0"3"0"(*"6 *" - "%"6 0"-"$ :'*%"" "

"%"6# *%#%3*0"3"0"( $"

'3--/)3" ". "-:'*%""3* *$ $-"*% "/ $%

# *% $"-- * $

-# # :'*%"""%$ -("$*%%-) "-/*B'

3"$'$ "% 3" $-"*3**"%/# $%6*

'B"3" 0-%$ %/ (3" "% *"%-( %"(6% /0 3"$'$

</5*%$"

3" #""-(% *##%$#* %$"-?@"

%/ 9/

< $

2% %."0"( 6 $'

- "(

)"%*, "*" ".* * *" -/ *' $

%'' "$*" %@%*%%.$"'#3*%$** *%/*"- "

", "% #)"%*, "*" 3.%63% *$

7 *"-%*3" # 1/'

3 *"6"

", "*"$ **'# $

%6 "6% * "- " "- *"

3% * % $B'$/ )"%* , " 3" '%*%6 "

6'6"6"% *$

" "

" "3*(*.%-- * *0"3"0"(/

/ #* %$"-?@"

%$*-$

'6'

#%$ %$%3"#'% *%$"#0"3"0"(/5*"# $ 3*$'$ @"

%6" %% $"' #"

*% *%$"3"' $*-$

'6'

#%$ %$% 3*%$*3'##%$% $"'"

*% *%"($'#"

9/ 5*$"# *"$$'%*% '$ %<< /0//3" *"-63% * *8#'#%*"6 "

"%"6#"#%/:%B'3"% "%"6 " (/)%#% 3%

%6 "-/ 0"3"0"("-63% * *( " $'

%63*%.("

"# * */= #*%".%6

*(% $'

%6 *3*%.("

/0"3"0"(" *( 3 "-$'

%6 *%6-%.2'

.""-63% * *%

%./ # ".%6 *8#'%. * *( '

""-%"%%"

/0"3"0"(#--3# *$*"%/) 3% * **- # * % ".$"#*% /5*"# 0"3" 0"(3" ". "-($"--%6" "@%/)%# 2% %."

0"( *% #0"3"0"( - */)*" $

"( ##$"*"#"--(%

-%$"

% *$"/

!/ 5*' *"$$%6 *%# $'

%" #$

< *"$$'"-63% *0"3"0"($"*" 6 *" -0"-"$ "

"%"6# *%#%/

"%"6#'$ % *$"#--%--/ )3" ". "- 3* *$ $-"*% "/ < / 5*-(%6$% 3*"0C2 %."' $

%'' "$*" %@( *"

--" % *%.#

*$"'

" *"

--" *$""-63% **% * #% " %.%63*%.("

"# * */5*(3"- $'

%6 *%6 -%. 2'

." "-63% * *% %./ # ".%6

*8#'%. * *( '

# *%"%%"

/ 0"3"0"(#--3# *$*"%/ ) 3" ". %%- ) "-'

*%/ </ C*"

%%6%#%$" % (*" * "

--"

%@%6"(' "$%*%%./0C)" %6* *""6"

* " - 0"-"$ * 3" " "%"6 #'$ %

<% *%6* /:%B'3"%6 6' "

*#'$ %/ '

6' 3 % "%"6#'$ %/ "' 8/<

3**3" ".%6"'# "%"6 "-"$* %$

3"-(%6%-"3/

3 "%6"'*% %B'%( * **"#"--"# ".%6 -%B'/)3 -."# *""6 /C**$"

"$.

*3"% %# *% (*" ".% '-"$/ < = %$-" *3"-"6'

#6' %

"%"6 "-"$"-%B''3"#-(/= 3'-(%##%$'- # "( %@%$ %$%8 %'' "$3% * *%.# $"%'$*"$3 -"$/ "-- * *"#"--' @$%% ".#-%B'/; *" ' $ "( #'- -"(/ ; $ "% 3"

% 3*%$*

%'' "$$'-$"%3"$# "-"$/5*

%*" @"

%"( # "

6 * "

"-3* *$"3"%.%6 -('66 "$$' "(*" %@"( *%6% *%.# *$"/ <</ 5*$'$ # *"

--" %"- 3*%$*3'- "'"(' %$%/; *$"#--%--* .*% * "-/)"-%# *%% / 0C " *-"-"(3* 0C2 %."3" "(%6 %#% "

8</ "

<*$%" - *$"--# 2 %."# % "3* %# * 0"3"0"(*" ". "-:'*%""

"$$' #*%%--*"

*/-"%6 *% *"-63% ***'" ;"% %6* -# # %%- ) "- :'*%""/ )"%*"$$' 3"

*/ </ 5* % 1$ (0C%*'

- "(

"%* % %%' "- "

" $%$%6/

-($"' *% # *"$$'*"$3.3% *0C" **" # *1 3'- #'%*" 6'6* "# *"$$' $"' *"

*#* */0C*"

@ -"%%3*"

"$% (*%% 3"3.%63% **/ 5*% %$ %#"$ *% #"$$'3"3.%63% **/

*% %"

" *"% '$(0C"""# *'6* /; '$* %*""--6%*%% %"- ?@0/ < 0C*""- " "( %"-%

* %% %"- 3*%- %6%' /=$@"

%(-" $'- # "$$' * * *" - * -%$

9/<

* **" . * */*"- **"6 $%* )"%*"$$'*"

- ** *"-63% ** *0"3"0"(*"6

* "%"6 # *% #% 3* $% % # 0"3" 0"( 3/*%

-("6'

*-"-"(3*%# *

0"3"0"(*"63% *)"%*+'

"" *("

/* %*#% **" )"%*3" %- #"

*#* *"**" ".*% "-6 "%"6/* %* **" %# *0-%$ 3* *"$*%%-) "-:'*%""* %$ "(#* *3"*"%6%1'%"-3"$ %6'

#*% %-" (*"$(%-'$-'/ *3"$# 3% **

?D/3* *#"$ 3 %/ <7/ = "

" *"$$'3"#%-( 3% * $"/ ).3 %-'

# *$

3*%

% % # *$"/?*-"-"(.3*% "%$-"# * % %3** *"

--" "-63% * < * 3*"

*% .3*"$ **'"0"3"0"( *"63% * / < / >' * %#" ( *$

0C *"$$'*"

* *3'-'##$B'$"$$' # "-# *%% # *1 *3'-$ "%-(*"%$- *%#"$ $"3*3"-%%63% **"$"'

%*% "'

"$%"

%63% *

*$"/= % %*%6*-('

#'- *$"3'- *""$$

"% *"$$' "%"6 " (/ <9/ 5* $'

%*" "- *$""6"% "$$'(""-'

/ <!/ $$%6-( *"

"-%"--3/

--" )"%*+'

" , "H+"."%"$B'%

#"-- *$*"6#"

"6"% *% (6%%6 *% #% #'

/)-"# *3% * %# B'%%"( * $"/

' ( ' (

)*+),-

6%" C* * ".%68" E C* * "- E8;