← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1073/2013allowed

Kuldeep Singh v. State Of Haryana

2018-05-29Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi17 pages





      



    !"

#$

% &'()#  

*' 

+ !  , (

     

-  ./ )#$(.

0 # +  & '$(.

$  #    ((#  # 0  $ 1$+ !    



 2#   

'(4&'(  )#$  #   (  #     )  #5'() ( (6

 (7! # ( ((    8'()$ $.(0# ##0 

.

(  #

 '(

 9:- (0   (

'() )       ( .!  (

 !   6$

3;$ ( '  !

' # '() ) )  '    #  #  2# 

!$7$ %9

:,  &' -<6 .(  #   ) 0  # 



( ' () . ='  $   $ 2#

/ # ( ='  0 7 /  ( #   '(( (7 (! & . !) 



#7(  !7

$  ) $ 7



) 7 $

 7#  /

/ $# .):

"> 9%;>9 0 '(  # # 7$ ' (

$ 

)

 )$0 

.(  #  #  2#  $  8   &# 4

     #    (  ( & . )



((#

 ?@- )) #  ) # ( ')# & . 0   A( 0 # #   4&'($0# 0 /)  - $ 7 @!  ) : #  )$## (). '  ( 0!  $ '() ' 

  ) ($' '$

#$ 7(()$ 

 !

 (% $

3; #@ #   #  )$

#; 0 #( ')#  ( #50 ! & .  ( #

 !

 (  (( ()    '!    )$ #(  ( ) .7 #

 ) #(& . 0 ()0 ###'7 ( (

#;

; 0# /'   #) .

 ( :

0  )( #

'(;    (  #  

#  '( 

 #    #  (  (     

7))   9

$ ($7

# & . $ 

# '# /(#7

# (

 .(  

# 0

#0$ #!0 '(/# ( #.!@ (  %9

$ #

   

/ 0 #( ')# # ((( #   ( ) . ='   >  #7 

  

    ?@-$  B:,?@-30 

((2#:. ) ) ' ( :  #    - $  ) .  #

) #  -<%$  0#

/  # #

) # #

 ( #( (7 (! 8 )()#$: # )

        #(  # 

 ( 

(  #  :='



()?@-<630

('

(7!:, &' -<6 (

/

  

(;7

  $   ) ( 

/ # # .):

">  (  7  .    #

$.(  

.! ?@-<632#:. ) )   (  ')#   # 

.!?@-<63 2#  $ #( (7 (! #& . 0 # (( .

:'/#(.

)#    

('

)  

    @       (   



 )  '7# #  1' $  *( & ' (  # 

#'# 

('

( #

  @  & . $.(  ?@ -<>3 6  9

$

'(3   0  /   #    

/  '      ) $ 

'(3     (   ( '

 ?@-< 3$ #7  0# #( 0!  0

.( ( /

  $.(

.! ?@-<631 9

$

'(3    ( #( '

 ?@-<63+ ()



.(  #  ( 0!   $  0# #  0  /  

     .( 

.! ?@-<638, ')#   # 

.!?@ -< 30    ( 9   %

 :

  5 7  )#  -<  

/  

       )  (  ?@  -< 3$  .(  

.!    ?@ -< 32#

'(3   C

## /'   .0   (

"

2#  

).   #(  ($7

  

 ! ( # () 7



) 7 0

#

> ?@  $0# #'7

(   ?@-D   

?@ -$    .) ## ?@    $ #(  ( # ((7! '7# #1' (?@-  ' ( #0   2#  ' (  

$    @   7

/  (  + !   1 .

  (    

 

.(     #     #  # '    #

'(3    (

B    E 7 

! 

 

# (0 ) (  ( 

 #. ) $ #   0 '

7  #8:$ $0#



( # 

# '   %    

'($

' $

   # (

'      )  0 # #         (  (  '   7!  #   0'(

#$  # (

!='   

 -B  #'  (

'  (  # ) --  #

 (

'( $ # (((   8'() '('  ) '( ')

'(



(

  ( # )(#

()!$

0# ## ((

)' ! (

 (   "  . #)'

'($ #  @ (8  &# $

   -<;

$:( 5 2' , -<;$ ($ 7

# #(  (-<;$ '7# #1' $-<;>$,  &' $, ('7:

-<;6$ 7'#&' -<;9$:

'#&' -<;$: #  .-<;%$?+ #  - -<;"$ ?: (#', -<;

$, (#!#     -<;

$:



6  #  )#$  +  -<;

$  :

  5 7  )#  -<;

  ( :

3+'#- -<;

> (  ((# ?@    ?@-D (?@-F

   #  .( $

'(0 @ (7!  

'  (#

 0 

(('(

 # ( #  )  '   ) )  #  #  .( 0'

# (

 7#

@  # +((   '  ( ((#  

   

'(3    '7

(   #  #   7   !



( # +0 

( -   $ + ( #0& . '(

(     +

#0 ()    . )   )    +  0  0  

G     #      )+)

##)#('

 $  (

' 

(

 # )!+. ( !( ( ( 0!+ #;; 0# (

). !

 !



#+  ((



7'

 ' # 

! #  #0& . +0& . 0 

  (0  )

( '# 

;

'( #)# (') # '( (# ('(  7) #0   2#!

.(   # 

#  (  #  0       0  7 0  #  +  . ( (( !( 0! ( )  ( ( ( 0!  :# ( $

'(# @ (# ) #  <

  ) ) # ')# #.( $  ('

( (# )--  #

 ( # ((

' 

'($ # ( ((       8'() 

.

(  (    (  # 

'($ 

9  (

 :# .# ( (

' 7

# #(

 2#  #'

 )' 7! # (

'  #    #' (

?@ # 

7 ( (  (  '

@ :

 )'( #' (

  

 ! ' !$ ( ( ( 0! #  

'(7

7'

(

#  

#:

$ # (' (

# 7 (((7! #(  (

#  #( ( 0 !@#

) () #() ( 

0 # '  #:

 )'( # )( H ) I H 7  I 

 (

.

#   #'(

 9:-

> -

 $ (

'  ) 7#  #  ( 4

$  0#  ) 

#  .(    ('

(  7!  #   $'7 #)'

'( ( .(7!

(   7  ( '7  (  #  0   )# ! 

.

(  (    (     #  (   +' #'7   () #' (



 !

#   ## ('75

(#0

' ! ( '# #$0# #' (# /)# ( # $

#  ! )  ! (  (

6 2# H ' !I# 7@ (

>"%;:-$ 0# # H !0'

('

0# # '

#  ' /!

(. #0  

 ' ( 

') .5'! ( )

$ 7 #  #0# #  #!  #0  J #  

#0  0#'

##   0 # .0

 )#  !

   (

#

  !' 0'( (  !  !  . ' 7 ' ! 

'  '7!#  !  (

#

 '

#( (I$0# 

 9:- .(  !



 ' ($0# . 7

 '

#' ($ # 7'#(0 #   #(     0#  !@ (

! $ (#   7 7

 (

:- (H ) I

9 2#

$ )(  () #' (

$0# #

! '

 (

' # 

7 /

( $0 '( .    ' (

 (((7! #(  (

#( ')#  @)# . #    )#@  . #  ( ')# $ #(  ( 

( ## 

7 7



! #0#

'('  # ( .#0 #'  # #

'(

) '  # # # #$

# 7

#  &'(2#' (

 

( #

# 0 #0# #

'(# # ')#  (

'(  #( ' 7) (##  ! (  #  #

'(

7  (

'  #

 ' ( B' #  () #' (

0 '(  

# &'( )#$##'7 ($ (## ((  # ')# # (

 '(#

()

##'7 (7'

#. (

(  

0# #0  #/) 0# # 0 '(72#' (

 )    ( #!7

##'7 ( (0 (   #

#:

# (' (

$ #   

) &'()#$#

% #'7 ($    ( !)0 '(7# !

# . #'7 ( /##

'(

 $7) # '0$  #$ # # '(

 ?. ')# 

 # 7 (

 ('

#' (



!$ ( 

' ' # (' (

$ 0# #+(2# '   #  ( '( ;

                 

    

     

  

 

    

 

               

       

                     

               

 

 ! "     



  

 

     

    #

   

  

       

  

                 $   

           

 

%

  &     

   '      $

 

   



            & 



    

       

(



 

      

      )   

  

"

 

 

(       

      (      

*

   

      

  

               

 

        &

 

+ "  ,( ( 

                         

           

 -     

      

       सचा साथ    

        



   !                             

 

   

      .  

  

 

   .        ,  

     

 

        

           

              

      

 

/    &     %% "

   !               !   

         ! 0            

      

  

 ! & !  

    (    

        (    10    

 



!  , 

 

    &   

  

      

                           (  



     

                 

      



(       

 2   

     3 



4        "5,      

!    (   

 ! +





  & 



(    +

  

                ! 1       -  !     

!        

      

   

      6    

  &   ( 



           6   &

 

+  ""         7                             

 6     

  

  8      

  )9%!



$"

%  #  

7

.

('(

 9:-$ #



# 

7   ( ) () 7  $0# #

!) #  2#

 (   #' (

0 '(.  # (  (0 '# !0 #  ' ' '()## #

# .7((

' #

# (

    '(

(  #    '  (  #   2#  )    

 7) H'(

(I H .(I0  

7'

(

#   (

# #'7 (  2# (

 # (' (

#0 ! .



('

#   0# #

'(7 (  ' !   

   ) )  0# #  (  #  (  ( 

  ' (  2#   # (  7' ('(

>"%;:-0# ## # 7 ='

(7!  

' $ ) #7! #0  .( 

 7# ## (

 ( #(  (0 # ' !

" 

## ($  #(   ( ')#



7 0 #'7 ( (0  (#'# !:

   #0 '# ! ( ) #   #  /$ 0# #0 '(# .(

7

'

' '( #

 ' 7 (  

)   '(

 :- ( 7. ' 0$0 '(7 #) .   :

 !

"#$ %&$' !"! $ (%) %*%*  +

, &% $!-../(01,1.2$ #' ' # (

(   0 # 

   9  :-   0        H 7  I  .(('(

:-:



7#( #   #  !

 . )  ( #(.(' C ' ( 7 !

(( #'75

.@ 

   $  ( ;

 (.('  #  

 (7# .( ! ( '

# 

# 0 #

 ' 0# #

( #(  (

/ @  

7) (

#<#  # ()   7 (

# .



( ) #)$# 

 !

( #)   2# H ) I# 

7(( #:( -   (+ 0.$  /CE 0

 !H ) I  

) (

   

/ 



'B' #   @ (  ?)# 

 !  H ) I     7)  7      )  

(  #)  

(  #)  ! #)( H ) I #'

7



('

# )

0# #    '   . # (  (0 # @ 

 ' ( 2#@ '  

 !

 "#$   %&$  (!"&$, 0#  ( ) 0 #  #  

H 7  I (H ) I#( '( ;

:;, )

      

      

   

'        

  

 

  

(

   





   

'    

 

    

 $*

    )

  :<=  

  

   



     

 

     

         



 

 

    

 

      

 

           )

><?    @A ** ** ** :B,     )

       

  

    

 

 

 @       @  



C    ) (   %D & E@F  D 2F

   "     

  

             (       



  7    

        

     





 

  

         

  7          

         

7        

 

                      ! "!

        #    $

    ,

          7  



     

 :G    

 

   



  (      

                       

                   

  

  

H( 





)H@ I*$6

 "' (

     

  )HI*,  F +6

 /= $ ")    

       

(    7  (      

 > 

                      

         

    (        

 

,



%    " 



       



  







                     * 

     



    



 



       

 

H " 

( 

       

 

        

        

(     7  (   

'    "  

 

           (       

    

 

  #          

 



  !"3 $$4 ' !"! $ %* "46$7-.08 (0,  ( 4$+,

%$ #@ ' $0#( )0 #

 :-#( '( ;

;<,     7     



               %       

 

                            

  

     



 .  

 

  

  

  *   *



                0G ?  ) -        

    

 ;:)

><? @     



      H ,

   / 

       

             

  

*          

;;   

 

   



     

             

*   (*    



        

  

                      

    



   

 

         

   

 

    

,    

          

      

  E    

       

 

3     

          

      



   



)

><? @@       

       



 

   

  

 )

><? @  

    

      )

:<= @ 

 * 

 H :<=,

  /,   

/ 8 / 

   

' ) /$    

   

  





  

(

   





    

'

/     

    

 $*

  :  /  ,         



     

  

     

   

         

  

 $*

;/0  

  



  

    



   

    

     



 

       



> 2#5'() @ '  $4! $6' !"! $ %* $9$4$-..:(-,  ( 4$+,2; $5<$4$!' !"!$ $  $4=%

!-..8(>,  ( 4$+,;8" 4= ' !"! $

%* $9$4$  -..8  (0,     ( 4$+,  -;;   !

$45

 $45$+5

%!<$#  ' !"!   $  %*  "6$$  -../  (0,     ( 4$+,  /:8 $=$4% $4 ' !"! $ %*"6$$ $4=$4%

-.0.(:,

 ( 4$+,-.8 $) 4 $= $4' !"! $ %*

$43 $+ $4=$4%

-.0-(:,  ( 4$+,8-:$4= $$+$4=$4%

' !"! $ %* $6$!

$4-.08(-,  ( 4$+,;>/ # .#(

  7  7! ) ((' #  #  0#  7  (

'

0# #( 7! # 0#

7

( 6 2# $  0  .  ) 

# 

   #

    

(('(

 # (  -

(' (

  '

! #

( (7  () #' (

?@

$    #   ((

 ) #(  (



' (J #  ( !'

#  '  #(  (0 

0 #

# @ 

 ' (

 !$   

#(  (0 

# !0 ##$ ' (7!# # ' (  

  :  #  ' (  

$  #    

#) 

 ')) #    # .

/($ ( 

' )( #(  (

/ # @   /)# 02#)( 

 9:- 

(

0    

.

 9  =' !$ #    0(2#   #7!

='

( # ): #   

(!## 7 (  #0 #$'0  ( 

# :# 7 $#7 7 ( #  (( # )( $9-/

-.0;  ( 

, & #   <# # /)3 ( F