High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1544/2014dismissed

Kulwinder Singh v. State Of Punjab

2019-05-30Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu11 pages

!"#"$%&%'()* !"#$#%&'#( ))!!*( $(*(+ ,*- )( + ,( '-./" +0&!%$" 1%234 +, '-./" +0&!%$" +%'#"+3%'543%#40 +( $"*.#"**/0*(/(&*))!!*( $ + $ .#*/#(#*!0*(1*!/+ ,*-

1%234 +, 6 .&)(*))*!&*-#(#( (*%*#(, %2(* *(

/ -3 !* #(#*! $# 4 %/ 5*(&%*&$*&#-/#$#* .

))!!*( !"# $#%&'#( *!%"#(&0*00 $ 1 )(*"*0&*%"#(&* (#(&0) #&*-! $0(#6/67 / / *"#(& $0(#6 8+ 00 !"#$#%&'#( "* 0#0(* (0 $0(#68+( %!##2)#2(*()*3 # /9*#* !()*32(#/( (& % #% #2)#2(#:2(& ;"**!0#0(*(0 $0(# 8+( %#% #2)#2(3* *()*3# /9*#* !()*32(#/( (& %#% #2)#2(#:2(& (&(&(0" ( 00 (!3 *00 $ 1 )(*"**0< #((

.&0*(&)0 (##* (&!!#(&*(1 )( $#%&0*"*(&". 0= ; 1

)(& 0(((&58/>: +/&&*2)!3 !"#$#%&*00 * &#&!) 8(&#%

/1 )($#%&!*&#( 0= "#(&#)#)*!(1 %*/#(&02)*3*00 !"# $#%& (&"*3/$ 1 )(**!2((&2 $ 1 )(***00 !"#$#%&&*(0&*0)#*03(=#!!1 )($#%&"#(&(& 2(#(*=#%*"*323*(#)(&( 0=*"!!*(&# )#) ?&(&3*0&#(&#0##(3*"** *0&#(&** $#&#/(&3*=1 )($#%&(()(&( 0= $ &!1 )( $#%&**00 !"#$#%&%**(*!-!"&#&*"#(&* (=#!!#%&#2/(&3(&"(&-3#(&0**! .&*(/(&3 (=(&( 0=("**&*# #%(&)!#0(&"*3/(&3 *-*(&( 0=#(&**#!!*%%*#) (&:(*3/ 0*@-(& !"#$#%&%(*(!)&#00*!!2+!

#0+(/ (*&**/*- ((&*#( 0=!3#%*-*#(&**#!!*% %*#) A (& 0#0 2(*0/ (& 58 "* %#( .& #(#%*(#"*##(#*(*0&*!!*"*) ( )*(02)!(#0*! 2*!#(# .&)0 (#:*2#*2*3* "#(# ))( (&0* .&(*(2((&*00 "*!0 $0(# 6 + 00#%((&2/(&3"*!!3#2)!#0*(#(&0* *00 $ 1 )(*"**0< #(( 00 !"#$#%&'#( "*0#0(*(0/*(#0*- ;0/(&)(*))*! B* 0 ! *))*#% -&*! (& *))!!*( &2(!3*% (&*((&)0 (#&**#!

6 0 !*))*#%(&$(*(&2(!3*% (&*((&)0 (#&* )#(0*-3**-! -(* ))((&, %2(* (&!* (-!" ?&*&*!*0 !(&)*(#*%(& %& (&, %2(*030* !!3 !"#$#%&#-(&0*1 )($#%& ;((##(&*(&#-(&1 )($#%&"*"( 0=-*#% ; 1

; (%( 0= ((*(#

*( *- ( + / 1 )( $#%& !( (& & *!% "#(& ( 0= 1 %* ;"(( **!** (*- (C + /1 )($#%& *!%"#(&*00 !"#$#%&!( **!**1 %**!% "#(&% (*- (&*!*& /1 )($#%&0(*0(&#2&# )& (2(#2/&(#(0(*0(1 )($#%&(!)&#0*!!3 - (&#2-#!)&"*"#(0&

*(*- (6 6+ /& 0#*)&0*!!2+!#0+(/(*/#(#0(&**#2#% &#2(&*(( 0="*!3#%*-* ;"((+!#0+(/(* ; 0&#(*(2(#>: + 00#%(&#2/&#-(&"* 2 -3*00 !"#$#%&

/&*!%"#(&)!#0 #0#*!"(((&)("&( 0="* #*-*0#(# .&)!#0!#((&-=)#0%!**-!2(&0! (0&/ -*=*#*((&( 0= .&"(*=#()#

/ *-3 0* 1 )( $#%& "* 0 2 4* #;*/*"** *0& .&*-3"*()(2(2 :*2#*(#(##!;)#(*!/+*(#*!* 8< ()(/>: +/"*))* ;#(##(&*-3 8&#0:*2#*(#/&)(&*( *00 !"#$#%&"*2)!3*&!)#(&( 0=-3&#

-(&1 )($#%&

*(*- (6 6+ /&"((+!#0 +(/(*/#(#0(&** ;*"#$#%&"#(#&# 0! .*3* +?;*"#$#%&((##(&*(

*(*- (C + /&"*)(*($*(*2&*-*/*#1-#%*& ;"*(*=#% # *"&#!1 )($#%&/&#)*(*! 0!*2!3$# *2/0*2(& ;"**002)*#-3*00 !"#$#%&* $ 1 )(* ((*=#%(*/(&3!((&&*-**(*- (C

+ #(& ( 0= .&( 0="*!*"#(&#)#) .&3"(("*$#&# #

/&0*2(="(&*((&( 0="* *-*# (&**#!!*%%*#) !*!%"#(&-=)#0%!*" *! #(&( 0= +?6&= 2**)!#&)(&*(&"*!* % +*(3 ;# "# *2*! *)!#& "* >: *# 1-#%*&

/&"*)(#&#& 00 !"# $#%&'#( 0*2(&#& ;"**!#="(&#2 00 !"#$#%&'#( (!&#2(&*(&="$ 1 )(**00 #0 0&#!& ;*$ 1 )(*"#%&- .&3 (##((& & *0&(& 00 !"#$#%&(!&#2(&*(1 )($#%& (%(1 %*( 0=!*"#(&%9#2*# 1-#%*& ;*! (%"#(&1 )($#%& ?&*00 !"#$#%&"("#(&1 )($#%&/& (%#23(&#2 1 )($#%&"*"(&( 0=*"*&*#%!(23 00 !"#$#%&*$ 1 )(*&*(0&*0)#*03(=#!! 1 )($#%&

/1 )($#%&2(*00 !"# $#%&*(! !"#$#%&(&*(&" !!*(&( 0=

.&3!(*#1-#%*&

1 )($#%&)*=&#( 0= * **!***(! !"#$#%&(&*((&3" !!* 1 %*#(&#% .&3(*(2*#1-#%*&1 %* $ 1 )(**!-*(&( 0=2 (**#1-#%*& .&3(*(2 $(*(1 %* .&3&*!(*($*(*2&*-** (=(* ?&(&3*0&**"** *0&/*00 !"# $#%&*$ 1 )(*(!&#2(()(&( 0= $ 1 )(*0* %&(&! 1 )($#%&2(&0=**00 !"#$#%&%* -!"&#) .&3(=(&( 0=("*!-#%("* $#&# 00 !"#$#%&"*##%(&( 0=*$ 1 )(* "*#((#%*,##%*( .&3)!*0*-31 )($#%& -*0=(&( 0= .&3())(&( 0=#(&2#!!-#%* (&"*"*3(&*-3#(&0**! .

&*(/(&3(=(&( 0= ("**&*# ,*+*3*!* ;"/=#%(&)!#0 *=*/(&3())(&( 0=*!((&)!*0 (**0*2((&# & ?&(&30*2(="(&*((&)!#0#*0&#%(&2/(& -(&*00 !((&#& 00 !"#$#%&(!&#2(&*(& &*%!*(#"#(&(&)!#0&& !) 0 !"#$#%& -(&)!#0 !"#$#%&(*((&*(&&*022#((*2#(*= ;) 0 !"

6 -(&)!#0 00 "**( ;"*#(%*( ;2*#0! (*(2(/ >: +/ (&*( & *!% "#(& $ 1 )(* &* (&" (& *-3 1 )($#%&# &*=&***!/*"** *0& .&3"(("*(& )!*0"&1 )($#%&"*2 8&#0:*2#*(#/& )(&*(&"*#2)!322-%+*(3 ;#"#"* 2(&3*6(C

7 $8.**,#($#%&((##(&*()("*#)0(-3 (&2 +&(%*)&"(*= =)#0%!*(*#"#(&-! *-!(*#*(&"!#(2(&)( 8(#%*(#%#0$8 4*"#$#%&#(%*(*00 !"#$#%& ;2*#0! (*(2(/(&-*#"&#0&*00 !"#$#%&%(0 ,*0=(*2*(&)(!) 2)&*#%*&+(! + 2)/1 . */2-3*,* #0! (*(2(#>: +D 00 $ 1 )(**!2*#0! (*(2(

E#*3 2*)(&*(&"*#(&- ## ;#%"#"*#( *(*!*&*$"*2#$*(*% &*"* ("* $#&# # (& *2 * (3! $# B*=&2# +#) 1"/ *# 1-#%*& ; "* )*( # (& - #

(

=%#)#)"(2%"#-#!!

(&)*$(!/66#!$(/;

4&**&"=/ 1 %*/#( 0= ; 1

;)(&0)3-#!!# >: +F ;*!- %&((&#%#*!0 +?C $*, 2* - %&( (& 22 0 ; )(&*(*)0/

#)#)"!*#(&( 0= 2$#B*=&2#+#)*#1-#%*&&)*$(!4&**&"=/ 1 %*

*-**$#%&)(&*(&"*+#(2*( 2*=( 6

$ 1 )(**00 0*2(&#2 ;"**!# ="(&#2 ;2*:(*, #0#*!0#-&#2(&*(&&* 022#(((&2 *!%"#(&*(&)

$8 4*"# $#%& "* (& 8(#%*(#% #0 00#%(&#2/*()!#2#*3#(%*(# !"#$#%&*00

"* *( #% #(#%*(#/ *00 !"# $#%& 2* #0! (*(2(((&0((&*(&*!%"#(&$ 1 )(*022#(( (&2 1 )($#%& ;%(2*0*((&)!*0"&&*!% "#(&&#0*00 022#(((&2 1 )($#%& 00 !"#$#%&*!2*#0! (*(2((&*(&&*00*! *,*0=(#(&**#!!*%2-3*,**9-*0=# &*#%*&#*+(!+ 2)1 . * ;##0! (*(2(#>: +D ;%(0*,*0=(2(&)(

$8;*=*2$#%&0-*((&(*(2(+?

$8 4*"#$#%&*(&2*#"&#0&(&*00 2*#0! (*(2(*2"&(&*,*0=("0

*!=* &* ) (&*( & "* (*)( -3 )# ;"*&*#%("( 0= 00 !"#$#%&2 (#2 (%*0 0(&#( 0=

*(*- ( * 2 *00 !"#$#%&0*2(&#& *&* *!!)*(*((&*(&& !!#(&*2($ 1 )(* ;"*#*& 3 ;#()(&*2*&*($ 1 )(* B*(/&0*2(="(&*( !"#$#%&*$ 1 )(* &*022#(((&2 1 )($#%& .&!)#

C$8 *!$#%&)(&*(#< ()(/>: +/ "*))* $(*(2(02)!*#*( !"#$#%&*$#*2 "0 .&-3"*()(2(2:*2#*(#(*,#* ;)#(*!/+*(#*!* 8&#0:*2#*(#/&)(&*(*-3"* 02)/&"/#("*#(##*-!2(&*0

1 #*!$#%&)(&*(&&*(*=.2)9 .*(*0(

/&0#)&0*!!2$&*B*!

C #((&0((&*(**-3&*-#& (2 &*=&*0**!

(-(*=(##!;)#(*!/*#1-#%*& ;"((4* #;* **!*(&*-3"*=)(#&#&#0!

+? ;*2*#!$#%&)(&*(&"*&*#%( 0= ; 1

/"&#0&"*%#(#(&*2&#*(&4**&$#%&

6/(&*#( 0="*!-3&#2($#*2/#(#!!*% **!#/#(#0(5*(&%*&$*&#- %2(((&#0("*))* #*#("**!%#-3&#*(&((&#0( +?$8*,$#%&)(&*(*00 $ 1 )(* 2*#0! (*(2(((&0(&&*=)(00*!-!*0= 0! "*!!(1 )($#%&0(*##%*&***!(( "#((-3*00 !"#$#%&#(&)((# *(&(&0!(&#(& 2&##(#*!& #0! (*(2(#>: +? ;%((& *20 .& (*(2( +? $8 *, $#%& "* !3 0-*(-3+?68)0(1 #<-*!$#%&< *03-!*0= 0! "*!!(*((&#(*0*00 $ 1 )(*

%%*"*! 0 0( (& )(2(2 :*2#*(#*-31 )($#%& ;(#0(&!!"#% #, 3

B*0*(" #H 0 2 :60 2 #%&( !*(*!*)0(0=:(#% )(-*0=*/- )/##!(*(#-!)(/)#%0*!)-*# "*#&!#< ## ;)(&)(2(2)(/>: +> 00#%(&#2/(&0* *(&"* (#, 30#-/"&#0&"**(2(2* #0#(( 0* *(&##*30 *( (&-3"*02)/#(

"*()#-!()(&#%(#) 8&#0:*2#*(#/& #(& %%(#(&*((&*0(&*-3"*((*!!3-3 0%#(# .&"*!3#, 3(&*-3 5$B)(#>: +I 00#%((& !(:*2#*(#/ *4*0=("(*#"#(&& 2*-! $#2#!*!3*)5$B )(/>: + /%!*)#0"(*#"#(&& 2*-! 6 !"# $#%& &* 0*(%#0*!!3 ) (&*( &# -(&1 )($#%&&*(*=*"*3(&( 0=

("* 1 %*2*#1-#%*& 00 !"#$#%&"*2)!3 *&!) ;&*(#(0(*0(&#-(&/- (&#2-#!)&"* "#(0&

*(*- (6 6+ /&0#*)&0*!! (&*(( 0="*!3#%*-* .&*(/&%((&)(!% .& *-3"*0

24* #;*/*"** *0& +(2(2"*0 0(

+?;*"#$#%&&*1 )($#%&#(&02)*3 *00 !"#$#%&*$ 1 )(*

00#%( &#2/*((*=#%(*/(&3!((&&*-**(*- (C

+ #(&( 0=

00 !"#$#%&'#( &*2*:(*, #0#*! 0#-+?6&= 2**)!#&***((&2*# "&#0& & &* 022#(( (& 2 1 )( $#%& -3 &*(0&#% 0)#*03"#(&$ 1 )(* .&"*)0*,*0=(" %(0-3*00 !"#$#%&'#( (&-*#&# #0! (*(2( 7 E#*3 2*&*)0##0*!!3)(&*(

(

=%#)#)"(2&#%"#-#!!

(&)*$(!66/#!$(/;

4&**&"=/1 %*/

#( 0= ; 1

;)(&0)3-#!!#>: +F

*-**$#%&)(&*(6

$ 1 )(* *00 &*2*:(*, #0#*!0#-&#2 C

$8 4*"# $#%& "* (& 8(#%*(#% #0 00#%(&#2/*00 !"#$#%&2*#0! (*(2( -&#2(&*(&*!%"#(&$ 1 )(*&*022#(((&2 1 )($#%& ;*!%(2*0*((&)!*0"&2 1 )( $#%&"*022#(( ;*!%(0*,*0=(

*!=*&*((##(&*(*00 !"# $#%& (%( 0=*0 0( 6 C$8 *!$#%&)(&*(*-31 )( $#%& "* 0 2 (& 0**! 8( "* ( )(2(2 :*2#*(# ( *,#*;)#(*!/ +*(#*!* 8 &# 0:*2#*(#/& *2#(((&*(*-3"*02)/&"/#("*#(##*-!2 (&*0

+? ;*2*#!$#%&)(&*(&!(&( 0=($#*2/ #(#!!*%**!#/#(#0(5*(&%*&$*&#- %2(((&# 0("*))*-3&#2 6 .&)0 (#0*# (&*(*))!!*( !"# $#%&' #( &*&*(0&0)#*03"#(&$ 1 )(*(=#!!1 )($#%& .&3 %((&( 0=())*%*-!"/&#&* (=#!!#%&#2/ (&3(&"(&*-3#(&0**! .&)!#0 #%#(#%*(#!#( )#0%!*(*#"#(&-! !"**!!#(2(&( 0=*! )5$B)(/& 2*-!"* %!*)#0** ,*0=(#5$B)(/>: +I*>: +

00#%(+?

%%*"*!/(&0* *(&"* (#, 3/"&#0&"**(2(2* #0#((0* *(&# #*30 *( ;#(&*((&*0(&*-3"* ((*!!3-30%#(# .&"*!3#, 3(&*-3

.&2(#(=#!!1 )($#%&"*(-&#2*( #)(&( 0=!*"#(&)#) .&*-3"*(&"#(& 0**! .&*))!!*(*(#%(&)!#0*=*/())(&( 0=*!( (&)!*0 (* .&# #0#(2*(#*!0(&*(0* 1 )($#%&&*2)!3*00 !"#$#%&*&!)

*))!!*( -3 **-! -( 00#%!3/(&#2#(#(&*))*! .&*2##2# *,#$&*2* 4 % 6

;*#$#%&$#& 4 % ?&(&)*=#%9* F9 ?&(&)(*-! F9