Manoj v. State Of Haryana



 
   
   



!"#$%& &

% '( ")!

*+ +"#$ & &

%
 



 

   

 


 


   
 



 

 
  

  
  !"

 "#    $  "

    



%&&''&%(  

    )

* 

  +''&%, -  

 -"

- 

  "

 

  "

,&' .   /  0.12 "

'3 #"

%454$ 

 - "!"



"

 "

 

  "

,&'.  "

  '3     #  "

 %454   -  

"

     # #      %& &&&67 "

 

  "

,&'. 

 # 

   # #     - 

"

  # #       

5&&&67 "

 

  "

'3 #"

%454  

 # 

  # # 

 

#  ' $ "    "  

  %5&('&%'

  "

   "  "

"" "

$   8 --   

  )  9- 
-

 !

-      $ 

   - "       - -

 

- # $ # 

-8 - 



 9-# - 
 9 -



 

-

': ;%(&('&%'  "

!

"# #

 9   + -


  # # #  - 

 #

 ; %5&('&%'   - 8 --  !



%&,& 
 9    8 -     "  !

  "

-  
 < #


 # " 
  "#

  #
-   

 9 



   -   -

9

!



 %%,&
 8 -"#  # ""

   "


 '7,  #

 # - 

    8 -

-
   - 

 9

 

-  

$ <   -   $ -   #

# =#   $  #   ""

 -  9         $

"

 "

-   9    $- " 

, ,%5 -   9      > 

 - ? !

" 

-   9     ,
 





    

         

 

    

 


   







     

          

    !   " 
    #   
$%!& '

 ( 

 

)*+,**-   

  

   

  



  

  

     

 

+ .   



 

 

     

       

 

 

- .   



        / 

  **,,*+ ) .   



    



   / 

  **,,*+ 0 1

         

    / 





 

2
1(2 #3  $



  #4   

#4 !

   ( 

 

 

 #  

   

/ 5(
   

                        

              

  

    

      

        

             !  

    "

 # 

   $   

"

   

   

    %              

    

 &            

'     

    

 (  

 

     ) $ "  -"9 #

  !  

 -"-

#

# " "   "  $  

# 

-

  - -  -#



-

   7#

# =# - - '(  !

  7#

#  @=) 4 A7' #  

  %5&('&%' - 

  "

  $ #  "

!

<@=B  " >.  @=  .  *#      

  -   #   

  "

"  

,%5   - #



 # 

 "

"  - " 

,%5   - #





 

 "

"        - #



  #  

  "

"  "

   "

     - #

 

 "

-   >  

#  *# %& A75     -      -           

 9-# - "" ;%(&('&%'

  "

!

""

#

    

 -

 # # # -   #   -  8 -- -  

%5&('&%' %&,& 
 9  -  #  "

 -    

   #  <   #   ""   ""      #

$ 

 9 

# #-  



9



 #A 8 - "  

     "" ""  - #    8 -;     8 -     

-   



     ""   8 -      "

  "         

- " ! @=B."7 =#   

 #



-

#C  # 
 '&&&      "" "

 -      

-

  #  

""  

  ! ="

 - %% A7D  9    "

  

  A75   

  %(&('&%' #

""

  "

 - -

"" -  !

 ;%5&('&%'   8 -"# !

  "#   -

! 8 - #

 "

""    "" 9 

# #-    8 -"#     ""   ##

# ""  -  ;         . "7 =#       "

"

               !  

 ""  !

 9 #

    #



   



  # "" "

"" -#-



# .

 9-

#    %' A73     *#      ##    "

 # "

"

""  " "

"

- 

- # 
*## %, A74.


 

  %D&('&%' 9

"" #   "

"9  



#"" #

"

 

@=*

 ""

# "

"

  $ "

"

-   "!

! @=>    

 %( A7%&.*# 

   !

     /   "

2  9/

  "

2#

 -         " 

! @=B >.-



$    - 9  

-   8 -   7#

# =#  $ "" - "

  "   "" -"  "

"



  -  !

" 



-    $  ""   -  #

  

    #  .    "7

=#      "



-

 "

  $ # !

- 59 #

$ "  !

-" 

  "

  9 #

# "

"" "

$ ""     "

# "

 ,5E  " 

 9    %5 $ 

  "

#

-   

 

  9            -     # "C   %D 8A7%!*# "

##  "

"

0

!
1  >.+%&5

'5&5'&%&

     " @=8%-#   !

.

 

%&%''&%' 
" BE -" B         
  *#         #    # " "  %3 8A7'.    "



+'((6%%   "9

)   

  )    -  # "C  &'%%'&%%-"

&'&%'&%' %? 8A7,+     "" - 



8 "

 )

 * 

   >.  +,?  

  %5&('&%'  ;  %3&('&%'

"" -!  

.
 9 
"

;"

8 "

)

*   %4 8A7(  

                 " "" - 

  "

"

'4&4%4?4 -    !"

# " %D&('&&5!  

'&&5'&&5$   " # -#9 
98+ '& 8A75#  "" "" #

-  ## 

6  -# "



=#  - "

    !"

  "



B8"

 B8# .
 9    

-# !



  '&&D"" -

 # "

"# "  

    

  %'&('&%'  ""    

!

   

!

  "C   - 9       

*   - 

#   $ 

 .- -

"



   

77 -  "" -  9    ;%5&('&%'  ?&&
 9 8 - -        

  "" 
  9

% 8 -- # 9 9  "

# # -"

- 

   !"

 9  "" 

-- 

8 -" # .- - 

 


 /-  #2  .   # -

 8 -   "

 

""   ""       

  $  

       

"

  ""   # -    "     ""   -   ##  ."7 =#     

  
  '&&D #

'&%%      #

    ""          '6,  #  

  

 

 

-    " - ,' " '% 8A74.-    - 

 

 

  #



#"# #  5&&
  
-  # 

$   


#       

*  8"

  #   $  <

# ""# #      

  - #-

 %(%5&('&%' 

?&&6?,&
8 -   "


   "

 -   -  
 #   


  %'&('&%' '' 8A7%&*  "

 "#8 "

)

*  - 
-  .
 9"" # 

 "%'%''&%'8 9* 

# 

.
 9 ', 8A738


   %'&('&%'  
 *# 

(' "#      

*   -

/   ##" !

 "- 

!

 !

  #   

  ."7 =# 

         

       - 
8  /# " "  9-

   "      "

"



=#   $   -    ,&#

 '( 8A7?8+




   "  !

"


- 



 

"" # 
-   #"""C   '5 $ > "" "

 E  @=""

  

 # "#,%51

#9 A6%- -9  ,%51 " 

" #9 6%F6'-  #,%5

#9 A6% #  # !

#

#9 "  $ "

"

 

- "!

  "





 ""  >   @= 

 

 -  "# @= 7,/-2-  -   @= 7(/ = 7(/2 = 7("/ 2-

 -   $ 

  9  "

  -   # "

 %5&('&%'$    



# -  "  9  "

 %5&('&%'$ 



 9  

  8 -; 

              8 -  $  "       - "9    #

  !    -"-

#

      "   "         "      ""  8A75#   
  

-

'&&D '&%%"" "

 #9 
98+ 

 -  ##    #



  .
 9 "

 

%D&('&&5.

     

            -  "#

    #

 " "

  !"

   -  !"



   "

8  "" 

 -



 - #  # - 

"  $   -  ""  !

=

"

""# "

  " -   ! - "

 ?( .    'D ""  "

%&5 @! "

"

-     ""        "

      ! =

"

  ""# "

  " -   @="



.   -  " ="

  ""  '3 $     G

    

  

 !"" #!"$%&'
'(()!



 -  #  !

  

"

   



"  !

 -  # 

 #  "

   #  !

#

# ""

 "#  $   !



  

   

 









  ! "







 



 



 

  #$ 



 # 

"

# $

"

#

%



 !









 $  "

  "& '  %



     

 !

$ 

    

  

 ("

$

 !



)*

+,-.

/ 1- 

1-/ +30 ,-

4-1.

 0



 $

  6+.

  ! "

      

 # %  7 

!$ #" 

 

$$





+ .

     

#  

  #







8  "

  $  

  ! !



"



 

 

$    "

! $

+1.

9!   

 !"

  



!   

 

 "

    

 $





$



$  

 

  

% 

$  $ 

$

 $ ::

1

;  

   !

 #    

 



 



;



 

   

 <   



 !  

 (

(  (

=!

;



>"



 



   

 

 "

"

 (

(  (

=!

!

 #

#

%

"

   





 

#  $"

 "

  

?

    < #

 



 

!









  



'

 

;



0

=*

        $ #   

!  

@ "    # 

> 

   # 

= -

,-

 

=

;

-

(

A



# <   / @ =

"



        

> !   $  B<

; 

"



!

   



 



  $

  "

  # 



#  !"



$



  "

!

 

 $   

"

 $ ! "







 

!   ! #"

   # 

   

 #"

#

 



  



, ! "

  



; 



 #  $



 

'? $         E

        

!*   !"" #+,"*'--$.
/)0'0!





- ="

  "

?( .   "

#

  " -

 # "##  "

""   # -" 

9-

  "

    -  - " 

-$  ""

 "" # #  "##

 "

  #

  "

 "## "



!

    "

  -



 -



 

  $   !



 7 

  # <    





 

 

 #











 



 

 #$ 



$ #  # $

"

#

9 







  

  $ 

!  

$

#   $

 

B $

($ # 

"



  





$  



 123 
4,3 ** !"" #567" $%8(69 
6"$:8) 

6   

 *   

 

 

 



! $

 "

   



 



   ! "

       # %    ,,







 $  !   #" 





 





 ! $

   

$ 



 

  

 #$ 

 

# $  # $

"

#

 $ < 

  @4

9! 3 

!$ <

 $$  #  <  



   

 

D  @4

9! 3

 # 

6 6   

  $ 

  ! 

 $    

 !   <

 <  

$

 

 

 

 +  &.

"

 <

 

 

 # !       <

$     

   <

 

    

  "



:  :

     





 "

!

  

 

!  !

 

:  :

 # ! $  

!

 "



$    @4

9! 3

  "

    

*$ $





"

$

 

 "



    

*$ #   %   #  ,,







 *$     



% 

!  # ! 

! !"

$





 # $ 

# #"

 # ! 

   





  

"

'4 $     G

   6*, !"" #+'-$-.$-/

:0'!

  

  - # "     -



"

  #  # 9$ E$ " "



  

 "

! * $ 

'! 

    

 "

 !

!$  

 

  "

  $ 

$ "



 





"



 #

 

$ 



F  /

    

-   $ 

6   F 6

    = : = 5 

<  $"  #8   $ 

  F 





   

 

  #    "  "

# # !

  

 "

" 

 

  "

$

 $F  $   "

# !

   "



   



%  $  

   $"

   

  F 

! * "



   !  "

    " 

"

$







# $"

!



 



3 "

   # $$

 

 

  $ 





(     

 $"

"

 < 

  !   # 

 G 1 9

$ @//H   $"

> ! 

$



<  $   # 



   $ $ 

 

(

$  $! 

  #   

"  

"

# $ "

  $

 $ !"

 < #$

 

.

$     H 

    "

    "

 

> #!

 

$ 



"

#

   !

!  $!  #

 

 #  

 

 ,

 





  $F 

"

  8B 6?

$

 #   #



$ 



 



 

 #$ 



$ #  # $

"

#

1@

 

    





   ! ! 

 



 

 #$ 

  

  

 !

!  

 #$ $ #  # $

"

# C ,& $     G

     ,4 !"" #2;!'--0.$8/

$-%!



  "

?(  .   -

   " 

 #$     # .    !

- !

# 



=   <!

 $   !

 



!

  -#

   "

 =

# "#    $   !



  4

  " # $ 

 "



$  





% 

6 

6

 !

 #!

"

  <  %!

"

  6"6  

 

  

 !"$ $

  

!"



#

"



 



<  

  "



 # $ "

 "

  # $ "

#  "





 !  "

#  !

 @4

 9! 3

,/ +   I9! 3:.

   

!    # # $





$  $  

 ! $

+ (" !



)* 30 ,-

4-1.

 $ #  !

!$ 

"

   # 

# "



 ! %

"

$

 "



# "

$

!  



#

   

  

  

# !  "

!



   !

  

="   #8 6;     7 #    #  # 

 #  

  #  

$   

!

   #

  

  <   

3 

    $



#
#



*"

 

/ ;

   !      

    & 

    $

 # !  "



 

   #"  # 

# =" 

6 "6

-

D  

 <  

"

$ 

$ 

 

 



$ 

  

 #$ +.





+.

$ #  # $

"

#

 

"

#

 

"

 

 #$ 



 

#     # $

 "

#

 $ $  

 

>

 #!

  # # $ # $

!     "

#



 # # $ "

# !  $    # $



!$  





 # $ !$ !   "

"

!

 "

  !$

* 

 <  !  

   

    "

  

 

$!





 #!



$ $ !



  "



   

"

#



!

  

 !  

9!"

 

  %

 

"

!"

 





#

 

  

/

   

  #

"



 +

 .

+.

 7 + .

 

 +1.



 + .

 #



3 

 #

B "



 

  "

#   !7       #

  #"

 "

#

#

  





+ 3 :



$

9!



14 9

1B1 7 0

 = 

  9

J 

@47  >:



) # 1.

 

  <   

    #  

  

+  >

1@.



 #

   

"

    !

!$ !



+ 0

 9

J 



@17 >

1.

= 

E"

  

% "

 "

 "



     <

 #

      6 +    $   # $"

 .









   7  

  

 "



"

!

 # +  !

 .

,

  !  !

"

  ! 

$ 

  $   









  %"

 $

!    

  # $

"

#      







$ # 

    $!

 #

  

 $



!  

  

  $ 

 

"

 $ ! "









"

 

 # "

  $! 

  $ 

8 <  

  "

  I> "

 E#

9$

J



$ -- 

!   

 

 $    $ 

  

$  # #  



! "

 #  

   

 #$ " 

 

#  $F $   "

 

  # : 

 

   "



  # $

 #" 

 %

 

= 

! 

 # !     "

 



$ "

$  #  



  ; =  !



=8 +,/

E5 4 1 + ..

  

!   ! #"

   # 

 

 

 #"

#

 

   

 ! "

 



=  "



 

  

 ! ! 

"   

    #    %"



 ?$ 

,

"

9$

! 

      # #

5$

%  

> 



= ?$ :  +1.

 

+?.

/

! 



 %

!

"

! $  

 

!

  

 

!  

:  





  

  

 # $ 

"

 



 !

  "



!  " 

 

  



 "

  "

*$ 7  <   "

  

  

 



$ 

    

  

 #  

"

*$

  $   "



!  " 

   @



  #  $

"



    

 $

# $

   

    %  $

"   

#      #      #

    





$ 

"

   !

*

$$       $    ! 

 !  %

 

  

  C

, ,% $     G

     !, !""'-$$
'0$8!



 -



# -



"" 

    "

?(.   "  ""# "

   "



 

- "#

   <

   """# "

#   " 

! "

$   !



   

K

 

 ! #

# #

 

  "



  



  

   



 "

 

   $ $ ! !

 ; #

 "

"

 

   

"

  !$  

$

9%"

    

( #

!$ #   



 $$ "

 $   <    # $  



<! $

 

;1

J  $$     



!$  



  $

 

  "

# #           *   #  



    



#  $$        

  !





% !



 

 



! 

  # 

!  

%  #$ 

   <<< <<< <<<



;    

#   <  # $   #   

  

<   

 # !



$ 

 



 !

   "

 # % #   $ 

"





#  !  

$    

  # $ #  



 

 

  



 #    %"

      !

?

 !     

' "

<  !  $   

(



5 =90 %!

"

     

"

 "    #   "

$  



! $$$ "

 $

  



  # ! 

 !

"

 $$ "

 

 !    "

 !  

$  %

  



#

$

!    

 

 <  "

  # 

     

#  <

  

"



$"$ "

    $  

 !

 

?

B 

"

 #

 "

 

 ! 



 

!# # "

 

"



"

     

-

=

=

      

!   =F 9<

 

$     





>  =F 

 #$

 #

 :   # $$   

 $ ! !  

  *   # # 

"

    "

# !

       

#

  "

$

%

#

   #  

  

  #

 

*  $ 

"

  ! 

      @4

9! 3  $

>$

   "

        #

   

 $$!

 $   ,' $ 

 -" 

9-  "



 "    

"!  

 



    $ --



 !

  ## 

   



=

#"#    $ # " ! "

  



"    

$ # "  "%5&('&%'  

-  ##  

A75  A7D 9!



 "

 # " ! "

$ 



- =#  B8"

 .
 9

 !

- ##'(&('&%' %?&5'&%'

B   - 

 "" $

 9  

    

- 9         

 -    

       #      !

  

     

 

  ,&  #

$  "

 =#  # -  

" "  $

 9  

 -







!

    ,, ""

  #      

# #   01

  &1&23

  * 6

%& (! A A

 9 6  I 6+ A

 

I 6+