← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/156/2014allowed

Meena Devi v. State Of Haryana

2016-06-20Mrs. Justice Raj Rahul Garg,Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar20 pages



    

# $ %&'!"("

(!"

)* +($ ,&-& .$$ / +(( &0$  

     

  

&$' )(.1*.230*%$3 &450-& $2$( )()(.(.02-300$((3/(    2 $3 /3 ) * 6   

*03 &0$   *5 &&-02 03 &$%$ 21136&%250 %$$5 %-&27 -0.%$8"! $25$&$2$#(

$7-$!(8"98(""((0$2 *5&&-02 03 &2 %$$0 -0   2 & &2( ,0 1-05$ 0 0 0$0 9:( 83 0 .&&& -0532113%*%$02 $2 $0 %

;!< 0&$%02$-05&$  0$ /   &( 3"""9030 -$ /$  3 $ -05 5-& &$  $2 $2&( 2 0   0$$ 0/ -05 7/ 2 0-5 $2 *&$5$0$6&00$7&$ 5&$$2 &-7&$$*&$%600$2( %%05 $ $2 &%-$3 %$ .$73 $26 $2$3$.)1=-3 %253 % &$3&&-02#(

$:(""((3 00&$$$>(

$$2 %$$2$26&&0$   *5 &&-02 0(  20 $6 && 0  0-52$(    $2 6 0( 20 6& 2& 0 & 62 *0 6& $2 /-5(  -&0 $ &0 6$2 *03 62 20 $6 %203 &2 ?&@ 507-$: 9!/&0=2-&2?0-52$@507-$# /&(&26&&$-0/5!0.$00( $2$0/3$ 6&  20/3 75 .-0/( &2 $-0 2 $ 7-$ (8"((3 $5$$52&2%-$ $277( & 0-52$63 )3 $2 &$ $3 6& &$$2-&(&26$$2&$23626& &$  $2 &$ ( & $2 $2 6$ $ 52 ?$@ $A5% 0 05$2& $%A5 $22-&(7-$2-$3&2$-02( $ -%A5 $2 2-&3 &2 $0 0 0 $( .2 $2 6$ $ $2   $ &* $ $ &2( .2 &6 $2$

;8< &26&-%&%-&0/5$2& (.2%A0 2-07-52$206&$&(2$&$$0 %5 $2$ &2 20 00( )/   $2 527-20 %20 $2 &$(  &5 &$5 A -0$2%A &23$2%$6& $2*6 $2$&2207A07/&-0$ 0&7/ -$$5  &$5 -0 2& %A 0 -5 $2 &( 6*3$$2$$3$2/00$2*/0-7$5&$ / & $2/ 20  $/ 6$2 / &( 3 26*3B-&$0 $A55%$$2$$( & $2 &$$$ >(

 0 7/ %$ .$7 0&%&0 %&&    % -0 .%$ 8"!  3 . )1 =-3 0  0&$ >(

: 0 $2 $3&$$2&$$$$2-52&$760 $$2 %.$$ 5&$$ $2%&(%%05/3  $& 7&&3   >(

# % $ 7 5&$0 $ % .$$ .03 20-52 7/ . =&2 =-  #(

$:(8"(( -5 $2 *&$5$   $2 %&3 . )1 =-3 &%$0 $2 &$ 0 %0-%$0 B-&$ %05&-0.%$ :#( ((20070/6& &-71%$0$-$&/(2%$0$2$$20$26& 0-$&2/>%-&07/%&$%$ %%%5$2 %A9$%2(  C(

3 $2 $ 0 >$ 1-0%% &&7 )20D03>.%2

;#< 0  .52(  $ %05 $2 &$$$&3 $2 % &$0 $2 $3 62 0 0&%&- &$$$ >( 8 $2$ &2 20 %$$0 $2 -0   2 & 7/ &$5-$6$2$22 &% ?%2-@362%2&220 %%0  $2 7>   $2 70  2 2-& 0 70/ & 6& 6   $2 &( -&-$ $ 2 0&%&- &$$$3 &2 5$ %*0 $2 &%  ?>(

@(  $ %$ $2*&$5$0&$$ %2 607/%$$ $2%&$$2-$ .&&3 $2$6&%250-0.%$8"! $62%2 &200$5-$/0%0$( &-$ $&%&3$2&%-$>0

.$73 $26 $2$050 $2  0%&0&2($&$ 0$2$#(

$7-$

(8"9!(""((3$20%&020%7%A$$22-&  $  2%-$( $ $2$ $3 2 6& $ &$  $2 2-&($7-$ (

((3$2$ $ 52?$@  $7$5$22-&( $ $22-& 2&26 50(2$$-02$!(

((30  $-7$5 $2 03 6$-&$& $&* $ $ 2 &(6*32&6&/5-%&%-&(2$ 7-52$206&$&0&$$0%/5$2$&$25 20 20 $ 2 & &2(    $2 &$$ 5$20$2(&65$-A$2%A &2( 2 %$ 6& %03 62  $ >5 &2 &$$0

< $2$ 2 20 7 -00 7/ &$5-$(  & 0&0 $2$ $2 $  $2 &%   )203 >.%23  0/ &$73 62&  2 00 $ A63 0  ,1/ 2/ % &&0 $2$ $2 0$2   &2 20 $A % 0- $ 2 7-0( 2 $ &0-%05$-$((2-362%2&220 -&0 $ $2 $   &$5-$5 &2(  & 0&0 $2$ 0/&$$20$2 &23$26&& $%$7$62&& *00$) $*$$(%&0&220506$22& $2(  $ *0 20 &0 $2 $3 &2 &$$0$2$&26-0-2& /(26$&&% 0 $2 0 0-$0 $2 $$( 2 $ 20 %-&0 0$2 &2 $2 $0&(6*3$ $2$ $ 2& & *0 6& &$  $2 0 0 5$5$(

E!2$3 $26   $2 $ 0 50$2   $2 0%&03 0&0 $2$  #(

3&26&&$$$252(2$20 %20 $2 52 $ &* 00 $ $2 %$$ 7-$ A0 $-70 0 $-0 2 & $2 $( 2 $20 $$22-& $7$5$ -$&0(  2$-23$2$20-7$0$20( 2-&70.$76&$$22-& 50362&2 6&&$$$252(.2%*0$2 $7-$$2

< 0$2 250&&2( %2523&2 -0 / && &$ $2( .2 & 0&0 $2$ !98 0/&$$20$2 &23$%$20$A %7$6 *00)$*$$($ $2 $   $%$3 $2 $ 20 &$$0 $2$ &2 6-0 - $2 /   2 2-&70 *0( 2 $6&$05$5$$22-& 2$&3 7-$ $ 6& *03 62 20 &$0 2( 6*3 $2 0&-$6&&*0%7/(.200$A6&$62 20 %0$2$$%$$27-0(

E8 203  $&3 *0 &%0 &$  >( !3 62%2 2 20 0  ( (!"

!  $ *&$5$2% %%-%(

E#40/ &$7 3 $&$ 0 $2$  C(

3.)1=-3102$2*&$5$(  2 &%3 . )1 =-3 $5$0 $2 $3 62 0&%&0 $2$  $2 0/   %%-%3 622&&26&&$$5& $2 &$   22-&3&26022--02&%A0 -0 $2 0&   $2 &3 62%2 &-$0  2& 0$2( .2&0&%&0$2$&220&$20-52$=2-&2 $ $%2 $%2   6$( 2 $ $2 0 0&%&- &$$$ >( 8 -&-$ $ 62%2 &2 5$ %*0 2- >(

 -&0  $2 %&&   $2

;:< %3 62%2 6& $A $ &&&& 7/ $2 % *0 %*/>( #(

.-=-0&0$2$#(

. =&2=-20200*$2$2&%$ 62%2 2 20 0*0 $ $2 B )5&$$ $

("" (( 0 =-3 2$52 0&0 $2$  C(

3 2 6$ $ $2 2-&   %$ .$70$2&% )20320(( 505 $2 %*&$ 7$6 $2 $ 0 )20 0 200 * $2 & $ $2 %(  *0  >( : 0 &&$$ >(

3 62%2 6 200 *$$2%7/2(

E:)20 D 03 $&$ 0 $2$ 2 0.%2 *5&&-02 7-$!"/&( 6& 6$2$2$(7-$ $2&7%A3 2 5 6$2  .52 0 & $2 &&3 6& &$$2&2-&(226 .$7.523%$ 2& 2-& 0  0 $2$ .$7 20 %0 2 $ 2& 2-&(%%05/320.526$$$22-&  .$7362&A02$B- $)& $262&2000(2$0&%&0$2$2 2-&70 *0 -&0 $ 2&& 2 0 &2 6$0 $ %$&-%0(6*32&&220&A02$ $0&( $ 53&220-002&(.2

;C< &0&%&0$2$&22002$&$$2. 0 $022--02&%A0-07$2$20&  $22-(.27550 2(

EC( ,A .523 )0% %3  &$320-523$&$ 0$2$ (

$

( " ((320(27.5220%0-%$0-$&/ $20070/ &20$%0&-0' F 00 70/  

: %(( 0$/ 7-$ 0 0$/-&203657--&2$ 0 5/ $3 -$2 $/ 3 /& $/ 3 705  &$&3 % %/&0( 2 & 5$- A   "(C %((  60$2 0

 %((  5$2 %%5 $2 %A 52$&0 5 07$ $&0- $ $&$0%&&( 52$&0A&76 "(C%(( 52$5 07(2  &%$%2&97&& * %A  *(

5$&&$7&( .%3&A-0*$72$2/( )7&73&%02$2/( 2>-5& 0 $%2%5&$ &$( $2&$-%$-&2$2/( 70&$%2%$0 0$$3 -%&2$2/(

&$ $2&$-%$-2$2/(G

;H<   2& 3 $2 %-&   0$2 6& 0- $ &2/> %-&0 7/ %&$%$ % %%5 $2 %A9$%2 0 &- %$ $ %-& 0$2  -$ %-&  (21-&6$$$-(2 $7$61-&00$26&*7(

EH.

7 .52 0&0 $2$  8( (!"

!36226&&$0&7)2)A2 $ % .$$ .03 20-523 5 .523 )2 )A2 200 * $ 2  &0 % %$5 %2- ?&% @ $ 7 0&$0 

.43 )02-7(

"&%$,1/.520&0$2$26& &$0&. 3 %.$$.0320-520 %$ *&$5$ $2%&30$2$ -0.%$ :8?!@( ((

. =&2 =- $&$ 0 $2$ 2 20 5&$0   >(

#  %*5 -B >(

 62%2 7 0&$ >(

9   . )1 =-(  & &$ &% $& $ $2 B )5&$$ 0 & %  %&$2-52&$7.-=-(

!. 5 .52 0&0 $2$ 2 6& 6A5 & )2 )A23 % .$$ .03 20-523 0  C(

3 . )1 =-3 20 0&$06$22$2%&$/(&0&0$2$

"< 220&$$2%&$/$2-52. 7$ .43 )02-7(

8 *0 &   %$ .$73 $2   0%&0 &2 0 2-&70   $2 $ 0&0$2$25$0$$2$7-$ "9

/& 7%A( %&0 &2 6& 2& &( 7-$  0/&  $ $2 %%-%3  $%$ 20 $A % 7$6 2 0 2& 6  ?$)@ * & $* $$( 2 $ 6& &&$5  55 $ 2 $&I 2-&( 6*3 2& $2 &-00 2 $ $ 5( .2 00 $2 0   55 $ 2 $&I 2-&( 6*3 &2 20 $2$0 $2$ &2 6-0 - 2& /(  #(

3 2 6&  2& 0&  & 5%-$-6A(E2&$$232$$2$2&& &2 20 7 -00( & $& 6 & $ $2 52$$2$$( -&257%A232 -0&2 00( 2 00 70/ 6& /5  $2 &   $2 2-7(20070/6&&2 $0$&$3 20-52  -$&/(  0&0 $2$ $ 6& $2 $3 62 20 -00 &2 0 $ $2 $   %%-%3$2$00%&0&26&$  $2 2-&(  $ %$$5 $2 -03 $2 $ 207$0$22-7 -$&00 $ $252(  $-3 &2 -7$0 $2 0   2 2-&(  $ " -$&3 &2 &$$0 &5 %& $2$ & 20

< -00 2 & &2(  2& %&&>$3 $2& 6$&&&$$0$2$26&$&$$22-&$$2 $   %%-%(  00 $2$ 2 20 7$ $2 $$2$*552$ 89#(

(

# &2 $&$ 0 $2$  C(

 . )1 =- 20 $5$0 $2 $  $2 &% 0/&$7 (-5$5$3$2 $0&%&0$2$22-&702077$52  $2 &$  6A -0 $2  -%   B- 0 &-2( .2 & 0&%&0 $2$  0/  $ $2 %%-%3&220$022-&70$2$&26&55$ 2$2-&6$2$2%20(6*32 $2 6 20 &$0 2  *5 $2 2-&( 2-52 &200$20 55$2$&I2-&3/$&2 $0 2 2-&70 $2$   2 %$-0 $ 7$ 23 &2 6-0-2& /(2$&0&%&0$2$ $2 $*5 52$   89#(

3 *0 20 %20 2   7$0 %0$ 0 7-&0 2 03$2 $3&20-20$ &22& /( %%05/3  #(

3 62  $2 / 7& 66/3&27-52$2%20$2 &$  $2 2-&(  $ &05 2 0-52$ =2-&2 06&$&  $%25 6$3 &2 0 &2 $ &$  $2 &  0 &$5-$0 2 6$2 2- 0 $2 $3 &2 % 06&$&0%%0$22-$27> 70(

!< .2%-$ $22-&0 $7$5$2&  -$&0 $ $252( $$-5 $2523&2 -7$0$2006$-&$&0&2$2&$$0 &5 %&3 62%2 $$%$0 2 527-&( .2 $2 00&%&-&$$$>( 8-&-$$62%2&25$ %*0$22->(

3*0%*/>( #(

. )1 =- $&$ 0 $2$  #(

3 2 5 6$2 2& 6 %  %& 6& $5 $2  0 &$ $ &&-02 $-3 62 %$.$7$202%002&&$$$ >(

(  $ A5 0&$3 2 &$ $ $2-52 &$760.523 5&$$ $2%&( 5 6$2 $2 %  %& %20 $2 &$ 0 0 B-&$ $ >( H(  & %00 $2 &$$$&   $2 6$&&&(  20 0 %$ >( 0200*$2&$.$.525 6$2 B-&$ $  5$$5 -$&/ %0-%$0  $2 00 70/   &2(  20 0 $2 -52 &$  >(

C(2 .4$&%20$2&$00 $&$( *03 $2 0%&03.$7350 $2 02$350$2 $20%&03&-&%$0$2$ $ 6& $2 $3 62 20 -00 &2(  C(

3 2 5 6$2 0/ &$7 ) 20 %20 $2 7-& &$0   &&-023 62 2 -0 )20D00.52(2$6&6$2

8< $2( )20 D 0 0&%&0 $2$ ) 20 % &&07 2 2*5%$$0$2-0 2 & &2( %%05/3 2 &$0 2 0 $5$03 62 0&%&0 $2$  0/&  $ $2 %%-%3 2 2-&70 *0 20  B- 6$2 2( .2 & 0&%&0$2$ *0-&0$7$20&26$0$ *$2$2(6*32 $260 $26320B-&$02$$*$22-&($ $2$ $3 &2 20 $2$0 2 $2$   2 %$-0 $ 7$ 23 &2 6-0 - 2& /( 2 $ & 0&%&0$2$2&&220%7%A $2*5 2 %-$( .

2 $A 2 $ $2 &$    $2 2-& 0  $ &05 2 0-52$ =2-&2 06&$& $ $%2  5&& 6$3&202&&2$&$& 0 &$5-$0 2 6$2 %2- 0 &2 $2 % 06&$& 0 6$ $ 52 $ &* 00 $ $2 %$$ 02-$3&2$-020 $5 $3 6$ -&$& 0 &$$0 &5 %&( .2 20 & 0 0&%&- &$$$ >( 83 -&-$ $ 62%2 &2 5$%*0%2-*0%*/>( #( E2 >0 -0 .%$ 8 8 ( ((3 $2 $ &$$0 $2$ &2 6& %$ 0 &/ %$0  $2 %& 7/ $2 %( .

#< 0&%&-&$$$&5$%*0/%2-(2 &0%*/207$0-2( 20 %3$2$00$>/ 6$&&(  $250%-& $2$&0 55$2-52$2%03$2$-$0&7*0$2 %$-   %*/   %2- $ $2 &$%   $2 $( 6*3 62 /5 - $2 >$1-0% % &&07/27  E:)20D03$2 $ -$ %*%$0 $2 $ -0 .%$ 8"!   0&$%023&$07*( 40%-& $2$2&&-7$$0 $2$$2%*%$ $2$$2&$&$/ 

E:)20 D 0 7  62 $2 $ 6& &$$0 $ 2* 0 >$1-0% % &&3 %$ 7 0-&20$$0$2$26&*-&/A6$ %$.$7($&&&-7$$0$2$>$1-0% % &&&6A$/ *0%0%$70 $27&& %*%$(2 3$27%%$03 -501-05$ %*%$0&$%7&$&0 0$2$7%B-$$0 $2%255&$2(

%$30.$$%-&32&&-7$$0 $2$ / 7%-& $2 $ -$ 2& 0&7*0 $2 %*/  %2- $ $2 &$%  $2 $3 & $ &- %$$>$2 $2%25-0.%$8"!

<  3&%/62 E:)20D020$&$ 0 7  $2 $ -$ $2$ $2 $ 20 % $ 2 00%7&$ 25-$($&&&-7$$0$2$ $2 >$1-0% % && &  0&&7 %   *0%0%7-&0 %*%$&$2% && 6& *-$/3 $-$2 -3 $-&$6$2/ 0 && % 0%(

E:)20 D 0 20  > $ 50 7/ %5 -$ 6$2  & *&   $2 $ %25 2 0 % &&5 7-$ 2*5 -00 2&&2($&&&-7$$0$2$$2&$  $2 %0  62%2 $ %-0 7 0%$0 $2$ $2 % && 0 7/ $2 $ 6& $ *-$/3 $-$2 -3 $-&$6$2/ 0 $ &5 % 0%( / 2&%%05/70 -205$2%*%$0 &$% $2$0 0&&& 2( *5200%-& $2$&0  &%5 $2 *0% 6$2 $2 7 &&&$%3 $2& -$ 0& $2$ E:)20 D 03 62 20 0 .%2   $2 *5  7-$ !" /& 0 &/ A6 %$.

$73 20 $&$ 0 7  $2 $ -$ $2$ 7-$  $2& 7%A 62 2 6& &$ $ 2& 2-&3 26   %$ .$7 % $20$02$2$26&75%0$$22-&  %$.$7(  %%0 2 0 6$ $ $2 2-&   %$ .$7 62 .

< 2&0-52$6&$262&&22000($ $2&32&A0$2$$0&%&$2$-$2&$2$2 52$ 2 2(  2& &A5 &2 0&%&0 $2$ 2 2-&70 -&0 $ 2&& 2 03 $2 3 &2 6& $2A5   %$$5 &-%03 7-$ $ 6& 2 &3 62 &A0 2 $ $ 0 &( .2 & 0&%&0 $2$   $   53 &2 %$$0 $2 -0   2 &  $ A5 2 $ &$  $2 &  0 -$$5  %2- -0 2& %A3 62%2 &2 -0  $& 0&( .2 & 0&%&0 $2$$2& 6&/5$2$2 &$  $2 2-&( $% &&525-$3&27550 2(.

2 6& $2 200 * $ $2 %(  2& %&& >$3)20D0$&$ 0$2$2%-0$ $ $2 0$3 $2 0 $2 /   $2 %0$( 3 26*3 &$$0 $2$  $ %25 $2 2-& %$.

:< /J5$2&$$$  E:)20D 03 $ & 0 -$ $2$ 62 $2 $ 20 0 >$1-0%% &&7 23$$2$$3$2% 6& $ &$( $  %$.$73 E: )20 D 0 0   .523 20 & %%0 E:)20 D 0 $ $2 2-&   %$.

$73$ 0-$ 2&0-52$63& $ 26 2 & &2 20 00(  & &A0 2 $ 0&%&$2$-$2&$2$252$22($6&$2$ &&-% $2$ $2 $ 0&%&0 & $ 62$ 20 $02$%$$2-0(%%05$232 2-&70-&0$2&&20&26$0$02  7/%$$5&-%0(6*3$6&2&&2362 207&A52$$0&( $ 53&220 %$$0$2-0 2& $A52$&$ $2& 0-$$5$2%2--02&%A0$2 -5 7$2 0&   $2 %2-( 5 .%2   $2 *5 7-$!"

C< D 03 20 $25 $ 5 7/ %5 - 6$2  & *&3&-%2&$2$&-55&$6&-$$2&$ 62/ 2 6-0 7 0&5 &/ 5&$ $2 $( )&-55&$$2$2200&0 &/1-&$$2$2 %$ $/ & $ -52( *  2 &$$$ -0.%$8 8( ((3$2$&/&$$0$2$ &2 20 7 &/ %$0  $2 %& 7/ $2 %( -5 %&&>$

. )1 =- 6& $ -$ *  &5 B-&$ 7-$ $2 % &/ %$5 $2 $  $2 %&&   $2 %(  $2$2 203 $ 6& &-55&$0 $ 2 $2$ $2 %& 2075&$0$$2&$% %$.$7($ & $2 $25 $2$ &0 &-55&$ 20 7 00 7/ 2(  %$.$76&$ &/%$$2 $  $2 %&&   $2 %3 2 %-0 2* &$$02&$&$$$>(

7 .)1=- $2$ $2 $ 6& $2  62 20 A0 2 & &2(  $2 $2 203 2 &/ &$$0 $2$ $2/ 00 $2*/0-7$5&$/(

8 *03 2-&70 $2 $3 $&$ 0$2$7-$ 9:0/&$$2%%-%3& $%$20$A%7$6202&6  $$/ $$( 6*3 $2 $$ 6& &$0 -$  $2 &-&   2& $2 .$7(  %&&>$3 2

H< 0$$0$2$2&&$$$$$2%220&$$0 $2$  8(

3 2 20 %20 2 -0 $2  -% $>%$0%A0-B-6$22&6  )(  $2& %$3 $ & 0%27 $2$ $ 6& 0%&0 &23 62 $  */ /-5 5   : 9! /& 20 7 &&5 - 2 $ $ %$ &-%0 7%-&   $2 2&&$ $ $2 20&   2 2-&70

*0(  $2 $2 203   $   53 &2 20 $A$2&$ -$$5%2--0$2%A 2 &0-5$ $&$60&362%2&-$0$2 0$2 2&($6&>&& 562%26&  2 0 5&$ 2 2-&703 7-$ &26 $ 5$ &0%$0( .2 6& 75 2&&0 7/ 2 2-&703 62& 2 & &2 20 $ *00 2 6$2 / %-&$02& (.-%2&$2$ .$7&$$0 2&>$%2 $2$ 0/&$$20$2  &23 $2 6& & $%$ 7$6 $2 $ 022-&70$$/$$0$6&&2362 20506$22& $2( A5 $ %&0$ $2 $$$/   $2 %%-&$%&3$2&-$& $2*6$2$$2$ * $00 $ %$ $2 -0   2 & &2( 6*3 &2 $00 $ %$ $2  %   %-7 2%0$-$5$-0362%2A&27 %$$5$2 %-0.%$8"# $ (

;!"<

&-$$/3 $2 $ & %B-$$0   $2 %25 -0 .%$ 8"!   0 2 &$%     &$ 0   &( 3"""9 & &$ &0(&$03 &2 & %*%$0 -0 .%$ 8"# $   0 &$%0 $ -05 5-& &$  C /& 0$/   &( 3"""900 -$ /$   $ -$2 -05 5-& &$  $2 $2&( 2 0 0/ -05 7/ 2 0-5 $2 *&$5$0$ $2%&&27&$ 5&$$2 &-7&$$* &$%   &$ 75 600 $ 2( 2  &$0& $/ 60 $ $2 >$$ 0%$07*(                  

              !

         

 "##$"#%$ &