High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/183/2005dismissed

Nirmal Singh Nimma v. State Of Punjab

2022-09-16Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan13 pages

"#$% &'"$$ ((%% )#

+* ,- ( +#

. /

0# 12'

# .*# 23 &'01 #'((%% # . '%% 0.0+* ,- ((%% 5* "#$% &'"$$2 #-6%# 7*&0(%*#0$# # 89" :

* # "##*& + 6'#(*-

0! '# #### ; 0+% 1 $# #0 '%%&

' :

( $ ' #.""< # 0 '& 2%0'2 *

(

&#$ $32'* 6% #(#$0'#-6 $$ (* '-% * # '

%* #%01,*&$ :

0'2 1#

' #2'''2 -3 #$ ##'1#6 0'2 * #&#&#* $(# $ #26#

(6 0

5 *%'#*#'#* #& #&#* $(# $ #(# =$ '

#%6 0 ' 0 (#'(# 1#

#' :

0(%(#6%-69'1# ' &'

'# #### '9 1 & &#592 (# '23 '& 2%0$# #

2'(#%*602'#' 9#1 # #$ ' $(#

2#$ &2'

# ## '& 2% & &2# 6 (3 2 % -#& ' # 0 ' ' (#

*% - ((#' % &2'' # ># &%6(32 %'#> 2(#

2# ('#02' &'(%(#6# *# -3>'62#((#' '- ( - ?*#-*0 *'(#

% ' $ "#$% &'

"$$ .*#$*3' &'0# 72 &'% 60 &#'0 $# #>'9 #$"#$% &'"$$'' ( $ #- (

'* 2 ##6*

#'> $ '/*$#'% ##1' ( '2 , 2''(%(#6>'9((# '* ' %&%#&'& ' #' * (# $&@##& #> '* (&' #'##* (# &@ #>$$ '#&#2 (#(# A= +>' + 6B99 B'$ <%0&@#2 #?* $' ( ' # &%6 > #' &' (0'&1' #* '

* %% &'$''2 &@# #$ & *'* '''%&%#&'&' #' * (# $ '#.@##& #>'* #(

+ 6B99B'$ <%0 &''' -, 0 #'

2 * ' (# >

$$A= + '#&#2

(#(# C'##0

+ 6B99B'$ <%0 '9 * #''* #$' (

$3 (% &%@((#2 #1#> &#$ 2 (#'##$ $(% - &2&'0'# *$*-

&#$

$3>' $(% '# *2# 1# (#(#%

%2'' %9'1 &

#( ;;>' ' $(%(#% -*%3(#%2#3 (%(

1#1#6$$ A= + :

* 2 ## ' D ,$% ' 2

*02''# *% #1#6*## 6

5#$ '$02''2#3 (%(

1$$A= + .#*

## 2#*# ''* $$ '# (2

(#(# A= +. C'9 #*?A= +A'(% ' - 2'' #$% 89 A= +A5 2 ## C' 9 1 & #(#(##*&' (% '(%#1#6 A= +8 ## $ 2

#*# ' (% 0 ' 9 1 & & # (#*'* % &2'' (#(#6 2

-# 9D#, # &'0D'(% 02'1#'

%' (#(#62'' %'1 &

#( ;D;>'## ' $(%(#% -*%3(#% %2'' % '1 &$(#

;; ;D;#$ * 69D#, # &'0D' (%

' =609D#, # &'(#*'* % &2'' (#(#6-#'9%%?& #$# #02' ' ' (#(#6 #*# '(% 0' (#(#62 & (* '*-%%3

09D#, # &'' 1# $(%(#%

-%%-&' &'#' (*#( 3 &8<0+* ,-0' &#'

-%%-&' &'

# &%63' $(%(#%% &2'3

*-6' + $# # $(% % $(#

'0 8<0 +* ,-0 ' &#'( &' #% '# #*# ' 1# #(9D#, # &' '1#66 #(#A= +7#$' 8<0+* ,-0' &#'2 #1'' $(%2

* ! :6%$#(' 02'' 1

$3 # $(% 1 & '# #$% '%% &

'* 2 (#(# % '*# #(' '*#0- #1 &'(#$ '#&# * # '2 % &

'* 0 '2 '#& '# &%602''0' (% &*%6 %$#% *# &'*# 1 0'(# =$ '%%2 &2

+F' '$ <%0+ 6B99

(#$ + ( #%$0$# #' *((#'(# #6 2'#&##1#6 #- #$'(

'* ' (# +F 9'1# ' &'0'9% *((#' '(# 2'#&#* '1 &- * (

&#$ $3 :

*# &1 &$ '# # '& 2%0$# #- ( &-*' #%2'#&# #' @*# 1 & ' 0(#1 &1#*

-%%-&' &'0#$%2

0'### ' $(%8<0+* ,-0' &#''#*&'' 1A= +D '*# &'(#' $(%(#%#$ ' * 6

'#'$(#'#2' #%%2 6 +F:9D#, # &'0D+% 1 $# #-#2'$' (#(#6% &2''* '-

(#*##1#6 2''(*' 2 %'1 &$(#

;D; ' (#(#60# &' (#(#6 ' (

' =6(#* &' $-#'9%%?& # '##& (% & *-%%3

$(%(#%'#*&'

-%%-&' &''8<0 +* ,-0 ' &#'0 ( #&# & ' (# 2' #&# * 6' (#(#6*# &'(#0' $#$ '

* 6 C' (# # 1 1#* *$

%* &#(#8<0+* ,-0' &#' A= +7 # % *# (# 1 0 $ ' * 2 ## * # # + 0 2'' %% ' #$ & #*$ ' (# 1 ((# &

*'* 2#(*'$-*' '%%&

&''2

' &2 #1##$'$ ''- 1%1 ' % %6 !

' 1 0'* =$ FD 1 # &'02''-#*&'#& #" ! '2 &'' (#(#6 #% & ' 2 ( :

#% " E5 !>2 3 *

2 #( '

$(%2 3 *

C' #% *# ' #$*% ' %%2 & ( # #$

#'# &#&*$ 0%# #%*# 1

'* $ -102''%'$&&#1 '' %'(# ((%02''2 3 *(

02' 2 $##&*%#'# & ((% * # !

# + '1 &- %-6'((%% 5* # (

$(# $ *# &'( 6((%0' $2

%%2 1 ##

#$ & ' ((%% 2 ( *# &'( 6'((% '2

$-%0 *-,' *# ' &(# % *#6- '

%# 75*6& #0$# #

"2'((%' $*(# %'# & 9'1'#%# *

%#'((%% B* 10 %#

1 . #% # ' +* ,- - & &'#*&''## :

D#-''2

#1#6 $%6+F+ 6 99'$ <%

(#$ + +F 9'1# ' &'

'*%%6 *((#'(# #62'#&#* '1 - *

* (

#- C'62##

=$ % &' -'%'* -*'6 *3'#&*

*% - '# 6$#%( "(#1* $6 -2 '$ '* B 1' - %%&#(#1 (#$(-62'''6$&''1 1%1'* ' 2# &%6 ( &

'$% %6 *#' 1 C' * &1 -6' +F $*-2#'6#% C'*&'

'6#%2

-*$#%6#'# 0'#(

- ( <# &%7*&' *#

!"#$"%&'#()

' - #1'2'##1#6 *((#-6'%2

%60'(# &#* #'# $ '' %6 #*%* ''# $ '*%-=$ 2'=## ## *2''#'6

(# #2#'6 #% 9 ' ##*%%6(#* &'(

' 2

0 9 6 # *- ' $0 #'# '6 #1-( #%*(

C'% 31 ' ' - (#1-6+F:9 D#, # &'0'* ' (#(#6# #'

@*# # (#* -#'9%%?& # # 0

2%% +F

-%%-&' &'0'###' $(%(#% '8<0+* ,-0' &#' (##$'8<0+* ,-0 ' &#'A= +7& '2'' $(%(#%'- #1 '#*%6 %2'2 % '1 &

#( ;; '#;D;

'#*&'

-%%-&' &' C'# $ ' '#2 6' &2# &2'' % = ' $(%(#%

(#'# *% %6 0' $(%2 * '1 ! : 6%$#(' 02'' 1 $3 <# *

%#'((%% ' # *% 2'

'$(*& ,*&$ #1#* #

D## &#* 3 2 '8<#$2 (#(#' (02''&1 # *--*'#*'*%

'(# #6 E # '' *# +, #

-"#$"%&'#()

# 2'# 2'% % &2'' (8<8#$ %% ' (02

- #1 ' '# #*% 1 # (#*#% #*% * # #$ %+#*##"+'1#6*$ $* - (#(#' (#1#6 D ;-%*(#$*# ((% #%

% .

!"#$/ %%&01 - #1'%2 '( 1#6 %#'1 '# 6 #(#*#%%%&%6 * ' #' @*#0'1 %%'#-62%% -$

2 $

-% '*#2*%

#%%'#*$ *2''# 6 #* (#,*'- * '* 9'

#' @*#2 $(% '%2 (#*# '#2 6(

-%6'1 %%%3%6'1-

$(#2'# #(%*# &'*# *' #'# @*#0 ' 0*%- ''1 %-%-$

1 !

C' 2 ''#'- %6 6 &' $(%8<0+* ,-0' &#'

C'(=*# '#1 3

!"#$"%&4$56)

# 22'%% &2' #% &#1#6 E3& (*$2' $(% 2# '$%=$ # # :

6 #1#60'21#0'#2 1 ' $(% 2# $(#2'# 6(#,*2 * '* 0'%62

'%-%'

C' (%6 &' $(%' '$%A=$ #2 % *

!"#$ " %& 4$56

'% & ' 2' '

$(% 2# ''$%A=$ #2' E

'*# 0'(# 1

-1 '&#*

'#2 ((#1 ' '#&# '

&## '# (2# %6'&*% #&*% #%'# # %2#3 &"# #% *#* <# *

%#'((%% '*#'# ' $ '/*$#0 ( 2

2 =$

%'*&' ( 2

$%6$ '/*$# 2 , 2''(%(#602'2 '21# =$ *# '#%-*' '#-%6'(# 1#

<# %+ + -6$3 & $ '*#

'&1 *($ '/*$##'# '1 &- 2 1#-6 ' * C'* 0?* =(% ' - # # # =$ $ ' /*$# "1#'%

=$ $ '/*$# (# 2

?* 9

*(#02'' 2' ( 2

'- , *# &' #' #1#6 #- >'' ((# 2

#' &'' & *# 2# (#*# -% 3 ((# 2' ' ' 1 '(%

#* 3 02 - #1' *' 2 ( *#'#'% &'

--%1' *$#* & *#

1#* ((# '1 &# 2# $#%*%- & -6 2

-% 3((# C' $ 6'2

2 '%- #%-% 2 # 9 ' 1#6 ,*&$ 0 #-%6 %5(%2

# 2 - #1'2'

'# %%& 6 $6&

'(%% % %6 $(%'((%% '#2 # #'$( &

'((%% 0'#%*#'#&'%6 %*' =$ ( 2

#' #1#6- &2

1#-6'* # 6*- '(#

<# *

%#'((%% '*#'##&*'

# #$ #1-6'92 #* 2# &

#(# $$% *(##0 '26 :

2''

$ #6 *#2 1%1 &' #' @*# ' ((%% %-?*#'# 9 *((#'# *'

0 ' ' ### ,*&$ 9 #*-""# 4#1 :

#*6 # 4#1 !"#$ " %&

# #;)

# ;<;;

-6'(=*# D21#09 %%$# ' #(

# #$ 0'(%(#6'%(3 6%6 ' $# *% '1 # *% ' * $ & & ( 8*#'#$#0#& &( #$'* 0' '$ <%0+0 &@#'- *$$ ' ( 2' (#

#' @*#'- ##* C'##0

- - $(% :

'0* & 6(#,* '* 8*#'#$#0#' #' @*#0 #*?-

'(% 0#$%89'- ## '##

(% #(# ' '&'# (% # 2%% 9%%? & # C'##0'#&*$ -6%# *

%#'((%% 2'*$# C',*&$ 9 #*-""#4#1:9 #*6 # 4#1!"#$"%&

##;

*(# ((%

*# #*$ ' = 2'' *'

- #1

'- $ (#' ' 0'#2# 1#* '##

# &2'''* '- ?* %%6#'# $(% :

' 8# $%# #

0 ' '# ,*&$ ### -6 %# *

%#'((%% .* 5

:433$!"#$

"%&4$56)

2 7 " -6'(=*#0 =,#

!"#$"%&4$56)

2 # 22)3

4 !"#$"%&4$56)

# 2 -6 &% 7*&' *# >$11$.$*#!"#$?

""%&

2 4-61 '+ D&'*#0'

'%( ' ((%% 6 $

# * # #*$ ' = 2'' *'- #1

'- $

C'(# '(#1 '#&&

'* %* 1%6 #$1%6 C' * *% # # # -%#(%* -%=(% #' %%&% $(% # *%'* #(

' #- 2'* 6% # (#$ '#-6 '2 & ' ' 2

* (

' #-

#&# ' (#0' ((%% 5* # (* #6- ((%62'%1 '%'((%'# -6 $3 & '$ 3 & #*& C' #*& (%# '1

*%%6 #6' %-#*# 6 %6*'' 2# &*%(' *'6((#

-%2'#$%6

# %6 6$('6 - '2 '$% ' '*%(#1- * #(#*1 # *% # #*&#3 & C'##0'

2#'((%% 5* * - 1#6'&'

%%# 6#*

C'$(*& ,*&$ 1 ## (

-6'#%*##2%%# 0'$(*& ,*&$

- *( (#(#((# % ((# 1 ## #(# %2 C'# %%&%6# #$6'# C' ,*&$ 1 ## #*('%2'# ' ((% * -2'* 6$# ' $ $

# &%6

((%% "#$% &' "$$ - -% &# '$ -6 ' *# D -% %% ' 7*% & #0 $# # #

* ## 2## & '$ ## $3'$* #&'#$ & !

# $%&'

()%* $+!', &) % # *& $-.

&) %