Balbir Singh v. State Of Punjab
""""""
##$ % &'"
%%$ () * +
"""""""""
$'#( ,$ % -.
/ 0 -"
-0
"
# "
$ ! "
%
&'() * + & %(, *
* +- % -0 1 "
# !
) !( ' ( ,!( !.!/.
0
$1 +
( . !
%
( *23/ 4*40
! 4 !
5 67
! !
#
!
18 (96(:
% ( , !
; !)
& ! '
(.2<6:%5
%:-= .18 -+
4-
4 !!
. %,737)7$31 + '
( !( !.<
+
, ( !
, ) ( !
+ !5 % ( ) , > / 0*+( ! ( !
)! % '
%! =
) ! ( !?)! :
&! # % (
= @ > + ! # @.>77-722
! @ + !&
%
@ !
!# ! + + + # !
% +
!
+ # @ B + ! 7(:
45 C4 !'
(' 6(:
% ( , !!
@ !
( * $ # (:
/AD %* ' 0
*(% !( !%
C &
5 /A ! + !% + 0 9
&:'% ( ,
*(9- @( !:'* @ ( !
'
& = &
5
2 < # (:
(9- ( !
+ &
5
# @.>77-722@
+
+ ! @
, ( !?, ) ( !
+ !5 % ( ) , >
! ! @
!
@
!
D
! %7$(9- ( ! (% !( !%
@ !
! + !
-E &!
+
/AD %'0 (%
(9- ( ! B
!!
@ +
+
!
+ @ @ !
-(
@
+ + AD %(
D AD %-( +
!
-(
(
+ *(9 - @( !#
3 /AD %:0 +
9
- ( !(:
%(, !+
+ !
! : + !
-(
*&!
4
# +
&:'
@ @ 8 # + ! + !
(
1$' '
% 21$/ 4'%'40
'
+ ! !
8 !
! !
@ !
@ !
$@ !
!
# + ! !! ( C ) ! ( ! )!/ !
*+( !0
! ! !
) ! ( ! )! $31 1 *+( !
+ !
) ! ( ! )!
+ 3 *+( ! C
7 ) ! ( ! )! C ! +
4
2 #
!
! ! + %7
%7 (.% !
# !
D
' AD%* 5 C AD%, F95 AD%'
'
& AD %%: 5+ 6
%%< AD %A
%) ( %
AD %F
%= ) #
AD%- * AD%:
* +
!
! AD% ' 5 AD%= * + :')!
( ! AD%> % 5
AD %&G%H
18 AD%I
13 AD ) #
%7 9
- ( !
18 (:
%(, !
(9- ( ! , ( !
! !
-( * +
! + !
! !
# -( @
5
9 + ! !
*&!
7D
%7
$*&
!
# ! ++ -+
4# #+4: @
4F 4 / 0 !
!4:! 4/ 0 #
7D
7
@ + 8 *& : !!
# 7 + ! ! (9- ( ! %7$
D
7
7D
!
<*& ! ! -+
4-
4
(%
! :
%7$ $ 6$ $ *&:
9 + ! ! : @ ! +
@
#
7D
(% !( !%
!
(%
+ %7$
J !K
@/@ % + 0 #
!@
F95
+
!
( 8'%' @
: ) ! ( !:
+ ! #
7D
$<
! ! ! %7$ D + C
' !
:
+ &
J@
+ K+ > + %7<
: '
* @=
+ AD %: +
18(9- ( !(:
% ( ,
&:' !*&!
@ @ ! !!
6 -(6(6-( ! # + 28
+
@.5'<$ :')!
( ! ! *
' AD
* D
:')!
( ! ! *
' AD
*
D
@ $ %7/0 : '
* @( ! %(, 18
! !
! + ! )
& (9 - ( !
, ( !?,
@ !
@ !
*
%7$(9- ( ! ! ! ! @ !
! (:
- ( !/%(, !0 4+ + ! 4
7D
%7 /
0 +
!%(, 4' 4+ ! *(9- @( !
'
& = ; !&
$ *& : , ( !?, !
:
#
!
!
(9- ( !/
! 0 %7 '
/ ' 0 ! + .>7<7122/ ' 0
+ 4 4 :
@ ! ! !
!
9 + !
4@
+ 4 + #
D
7D
+ !
! !@: @ ! ! +
9 + ! ! @ 9 + ! ! %(, ! : ! +
@ > 9 + ! ! ) ! ( ! < # D
/!
! %70:')!
( !
+ AD %= + #
+
+ @
! @ ! !!
!
-(6(6-( &:'* @= %(, ! 28 @ *
' AD
*
.<$66
' AD
&:'* @ = %(, ! %78 5 % = '
4. 4 ; !)
%(, $8
!+ *+( ! = ( !
)! % '
%! =
) ! ( ! ?)! :
& ! #
>
' #
C
+ J!
K
18 ! , ( ! ,
! @ @ !!
. >7-722
, ( ! ,
!
!
@ %78 !
C
: +
7D
%78
%(, < %&
!4. 4+ ! @:
+ !
!
4. 4#
!
+
!
:
@ , ( !) ! ( ! ! ! +
) ! ( !
*+ ( ! @ F
7D
%78 ) ! ( ! /%780 :
+
:!+ +) ! ( !
*+( ! 2 $*&
%78 @ *+( !
%!
+ #
) ! ( ! '
!
/%80
!
!!
#
+
+ !
: ! !!
:
:
+
-+
4. 4
!! !
!
8 #
%71 (% !( !%
18 (%, !
+
(:
%(, (9- ( ! C &
! -+
4-
(9- ( ! !
4# @4 !.>77-722
! ! :
@
!
4% 4
!
J K # @ ! #
, ( !
/%710
!
@
! ! !
/(%0 &!
AD %' %71 (9- ( !
*(9- @( ! #
(9 - ( !/%7$0
: '
* @( !/%70
7D
%71 +
$ 6$ *& (9- ( !
$ <*&:
@
@ C +
2 : (:
/%7$0 @
! : D @ / 0
#
:
7D
(:
! ! !
!
! ! ! /4#@ 40:
+
!
: +
!9 + ! ! J
K+
+ %71
) ! ( !
@
! ) ! ( ! ! #(% @ !4. 45 %/%780 : @ ! %8
>
! +
!!
1
! + % %
+ 18 /AD %H0
13/AD %I0# AD %H 18
&!
/( 7 + &!
0
3
!
! !
J* !
!
! @ !
4-((-(4
(9
K # AD %I 13
)&9'.
/ )
180#
J5C ! + F95 .8< 18 C @ + : * !
!
C
! !
#
@ ! !2@!1!
!
+ !
*
' !
4%4
# (:
!! * +
45 + 4 +
( 7* .%( * 5!
!
++ .%(*
!
' -+
+ : 4: ! ' ! '
+
!
E !
+ *
!
+ (:
! '
*
# + @ ) &@
# ! '
! +
(
' D
+ D
!
K 3
( $$'%'
4 ! +
@
# ! +
:+
) !( '
%+ ' * (
' .$
3
<2 D AD * F95!
( %+ ' * % (
, !/ % ( F95
!
0 5 % .
' %<# +
'
5 %.
/%8 '
0 +
+
D
+
9
%8
AD <2 2 # '
! + C
7 ) ! ( !?)! !
@+ @
) ! ( !:
*+( !+ !
@ !!
.>7-722/ >7)722
' 0 + ' +
5 + 4-
4 ! @ 9
!( !%
(%/%10
(9 - ( !/%$0
- ( !
@
(% !( !%
(9- ( ! @ # ! ' + %/0:
'
* @( ! D
7
+
7D
C ! %
@
'
# ! '
' +
! ) ! ( !
C !
+
! C
@
+&)
+
7 @ >
@ !
9 !
7
, ##* , (%!$ '
7"
%%$ () 8 /
0$/<05'5/'
0<
'9 ,$
, (%!$
7"
%%$ () * +
$/05'5/'
0 1 &) D
!
+ + %$ (9 - ( !
!
+ : D
9 + ! ! /%$0
(% !( !%
/%10
@
!
7D
%$
(% !( !%
!F %1/ (%0 D
7 -+
4-
4(9- ( ! !
@ !!
.>7-722
! J, !% &
K $ & )
+ ! + (:
% (
% (
!
+
! ! @ (:
: @ !
+ ! @ 7 + '
!C ) !
6 ( !
/ 0*+( !: ! +
!! +
@ ! @
@ ! !
' + C
+ ' :
C
+ !
< &% ( ! , *
* + - %
!
+ ! ! @ ! ++
@ !
( + ) &!
18/AD%H6%&0
38/AD%I6%I60 ( (
' AD
+ ! + AD%)
E
@ @
> (
+ , ' 7"
%%$ () 8 $/0 5'5/'
03 ! (
! .632
-+
9
$8232 C
!
+
!
+ * > (
:+ !
+ !
+ ! ! !+ 9
! !
:+
!!
+ F
!!
+ + %8 18 ! F 4 C46 ! !
! + %8 (:
% ( , !
!!
F95 !
(% +
+ + ! !
4 C4 (:
! + (% !E
%8 '
+
( <* ( !
! + !
! @! + +
/
/ 0
/ 0
+ + , 7"
%%$ () 8 $/0 5'5 /'
0 3
)
( ! 4 9 (
!
$8232 @
!
: !
+ ! !
!
! 8 .
!!
&) ' + F
+
!4-
4
4' 464# #+4 +
+ 4-
4 + ! ! 7 7 (9- ( ! '
(
( !( !L
%:-= .L
4-
+ (%/%10
+ 4' 4 %/0:'* @( !
*(9- @( !
'
& =
/ ! 4# #+4 %9
-
( ! ! + 0 # 2 6
+
4-
4 !
! @
+ !7 ) ! ( !
*+( !
@ F ' !%1(% !( !%
%$(9- ( ! @
!%$
! +
7D
! ( 7 @ + 1 .D+ !
+
! (:
% ( !
% (
7 @
(:
% (
!
%$
! < *&
$ 6$ $*&%/0: '
* @( !
$ *&+ !
(9 - ( ! ! #
(9- ( !
$ *&A+ !D
!
+ ! + <*&(9- ( !
% (:
, !
% ( @ !@
$ *& # (% !( ! $ < *&%$(9- ( !
(%
!
7D
(% 9
+
+
!
% $/0
1
! @
!
6 @9
+ (%
$ <
+(9- ( !/ $
$ $ 0 +
/(%0 @
!
! # %/0:
'
* @( !
7D
+ !!
.>7<7122 : ! 7 ! + !
#
!
!
! +
!
% $
1 !
! #
!
@ + ! D + (%
@ ! ! $ +
! D @ !
9 @ C + ( 7 ! ) ! ( ! C
+ !
2 ' ( C 7 *+( !
C #C +
'
+ ' +
+ + ! +
@ + + + ! @ !!
.>7-722"# @ + !
+ '
' 9
!
! D @ !
@
7 + C + 3 .D ! ! ! @ ! + ! !
! + /
! + !+
0+
/AD%*0!
>7-722
%$
>7)722/ A !
% +
0 >7<7122
%/:'* @( !0/A !
% + 0
! >7-722
%19 ' 8 /JE
K0 ! + @ ( @!
>77<722
!
@
3 I
D
@ + + %/0:'* @( ! ' @ '
@ +
18 * ' % /0:'* @( !+ ! + ! @ '
' + JE
K 8
@/ ! @ ! !
.>77<7220 (#
+ +
'
:'* @( !/%/0 139
@ D ' :+
' ! /# 7 *+( !
!
) ! ( !
0 # !
C *+( !
!
! '
C
@
D
4 ' !
@ C '
%/0 C 9 F95 .2< !
% ( ( %! = 18 *&! ! !
( .%( * ! + <=! @
@ !!
.>7-722 +
! ,
%!
+
(:
% ( , *
! F95!
% ( ( %! 7 ) ! ( !
*+( ! +
@ + !
! + + ! @
( ! F95/F95.2< 18!
% ( ( %!0 +D '
7 ) ! ( !F
/
0
' !
! !
F95.2<% ( ( %!
18: + !
E + @ ' F95 # + +
@ +
5
7
!
@
! %/0 '
!
#+ ! (
2 #
( @ + +
) &!
+ 18
38/AD%H6%&
%I + 0 +
# C @ + 18
' #
D +
L +
+
! 4 @ 4
#C
*!
+ !
! + ! +
@
J !
K
4 @ 4 # ! ! !
+ + ! + +
+ +
+ ' (
+
+
!
! 4 @ 4+
% (
+ (
! .632
$8232 -+
9
&
F 5+ . ' , /
228
13$0 :
+ +
!
+ ! ,
+ !
'
+
! D
' $ : ! + !
C ! !
' + !
@!
@
+ !
( .%(* 23 '
C C
+
6
6 # $ * !
6
E
(
$8232/ 0
( 7** *
+
+ ! '
(-+
!
!
'
! +
* $ (
! '
C C
#'
D
!
!
+ !C !
+'
'
!
! + 2 (
! #: 4( ' ( ()
, 7"
-(! , (%!$ /0 1 ('' 1
' ( (
C
*D' ! 5!
- : !' *C
G(
) ! *
+) !
: !' ! E
# $1
+ + '
(
) ! /
*
+) !0
! '
/
C
0
!
!
C
+
6 '
C *
' ( 6% ( : -+
% + D !
!
+ ' 6%
! !
'
!
+
C
# +
' 6%
!* ! '
(%
! !
C
6 #5!
- '
! + (
+
(% !
C
(
$8232/
09
+ *
' ( 6% ( : -+
% D !
*
' ( 6% (
2 ' D +
! ! * ! + &%(, (
!(%
' ( * ! + 5!
- ' > !
:-0 ;