High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1840/2005allowed

Santosh Rani & ORS. v. State Of Pb.

2020-02-26Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan24 pages

! !"

##$$

'& () # '"

" '

*+ "!##$$

,"(-&"-!&" *.*'& () //// & ! *0 1 2!*,"-&" 3! 2!1"")4$"

0&2*2 "! & " 5 657' +(&2,

!41" +& " 5 7' +""

+ *!41" "

"# 5 7' 2"& ,#" , "2!4"

* 6! &$ !"* &"!" & "2 "2"&

,#" , " 4"!

8!& + 9 ! *0 1 2!* ,"-&" 3! 2!*1!"##$$ )"! &"

#"4!!##$)#*!,#&2 (&2, !"

+ ) !4):&! !"2",2

"$4 *! ! #"!#" &

"!,#$ -""-&"11,"3!* " $2! &),1" ,#$ "

&#" '$*2

** 2! !" 2"( 2!* 1! 1 "+ 2 '& () '$ ! ,, &&" 2! "+ 2 2!6

, !,$4

!,"

2;! )4 2!1 ",; 2!!$ )! $"

"1"! ) !4&$$4!"!

&!$"

4 $"; &!$"

2!!")& ! !! 1 ! *)"!" $10 1 2!* !" $1 3! 2! ,!" $1 ," -&" 8! ,#$ &"!" ! 2!!2,""1!

! )&!"4"

#""! ! !&#$! * ,$4*"( 2!; &) :& $4!"$

)1 ! &#$2 " * &! ! "" 2 !"

#" $!& !!$, # 2

2!; !!$ &), ##$ )"<,

$$*2;- !,"-&"*7 !"2*<, $$!,"

2!,",#", )& ; ! !2

5 2"( 2! = ", & #"

+"$ , ;

! !$ ,+ ##$ )"!#$ >"= 1

; &! 2!& )2 "" &!##$ ) 2 &),)4 ! . 2&"!" !,#$ *!,#$ ! !! ,

2! 2! ! !" ,$4 ,,)"

)& !, , ! ", 2!* !14* ! *!"!" 3! 2!*,!","-&" )"!"0 1 2!! ,#$$ 2!,, & $ 21!!1"

,#$ * ! ,#$ ! ! ! 1" $" 2!

"#!,#$ *!,"1 :&" )4#&4&#" '$*1! :&"4"#" "&#" '$*2 !"">73 ?

5 5

"! "

5 657'1

"2 "2

& ! *0 1 2!*,"-&"

3! 2! '$ 4* 2 & 1" "" ! ",#$ + 2 !"

",$ *!$$ 2

$$!& 1 #"#" $

!&"!0&$2 "*2 #" !$$ !&"!0&$ 2 "*2*! &##$# &, "$&#

!!$$ $$!& " #"+& "

@" ' 8! 2! & " 5 7'1

A$& +$4")$)4!&"

*$"

!0&$ 2 "*2 +! ""5

5,,! !&"$"

0&2*2 B"

0&2*2* 2! #", !"2 " ! & " 5 7' 1

$ 2

!& *!"2 !!," 2$4* 1!!*!4#$ 2&$4 $,"$ 8! 1 !

A"+ !#" &

8 )" 2 !, 2&$ ! & * ! #" &

A, , 4 + 1

, -""-&" '<* .&",( 2! '< * #.&# '<5*7- !,"-&"

'<*7+" 2! '< *7.&"# 2! '< &" " 2!9' '<@ 8!#" & $ "

+ &, CA 'CA '

<!!!#" & + $ , & 1"""& " 55 " ' * 1!! $$ ! ", 2 "&, ##" 2

!, 1" #& !, )& !4 ! $$2

2!!41"

!) ,#$ !

$ $4 )+ #$ 2

,#$ *& ! &"!"#$!!, !",""2:&1"41 2+ $& 2"

, )& 1 !)&$"& =" 2,)$" ! $$$! "$ "

, ;!!,

* 6",!"

!"#" )&!4 !1 )$4 4! &!, * ! ! ,!"2+!") !1 " $+!!&

! !1 $+ 2 >"=1!!"#" !&"!"#$! * ! $ ##$ "

" ' >"= 1!!

",, 1 2" ;! 2! +", !">"= ! !1 & &"$ )41

&$; "#"1 $2)4,#$ #"4#$

")41 "# ,",A, ! &"!" #$ ! ! !" ,$4 ,,)"

! ", ", 4 $$!", !"" & ,"-&"!$ = ! ,#$ + *!& A,

)$ &" "'$*$"= !'*2 <*6D

$)" 2!",'$B *2 < *- ! B$ <5* -&$# 2! < ,"#$*$"='C *>"=

" !" 2 "2&, * $

0&2* 2 + $$!& , &#"*

1!!$!,22"+ !4!+$!#" ##$ 7!+!"$"

$"!##$$ & + $"

#&4 + . "$ " ! '& ()) 2 2!"&2!!"" 8!" $#" #$ ", $(&" #"& "! !#" & ,& #"+ !"22

!& )4

!1" )$&) &! #"+2&$!& !!$ "4 !#" & +" ! 8! & A##"+! 1! ,A

"2"*1!1!!!#" & ":&"#"+2&$! & 8!& ":&"" " $4" )$ #$& )$A#$ *1!!,4 &) !, )&! "&!&$

! #" & "4 >&"!","* #" &"

(&" #"& *!& " 2&$4#"

,42 ")&+

!&$ )#& ! D" ! !#" & !) )$ #"+ !"22

!& $& +$4 ",+$4 3+"!$

!"$&")4, ##" $+ 1" "#" $1 + !& 8!""

+"$"

" 4 2 *1!!") 2 &," "

8!" 2"

$4 "#" 2!,"!#$ ,&! !! 2!!= #$ ! "+ 2 2!6

*1!" ! ,!"-""-&"

@ ,#$ ! &), 1" ,#$ '* 2

"#","! , ! 7 ,,

2 E)$ #",#$2 2"#"! #$ ")$ #"+ ! # & )$, !" +"

! <!!#

2,!! $&" +"

) 2 "& " & $)"

,&)!" >"!" * ! !$4 $", $ & $

#"#"$4A#$ D"

&!A#$ "!$4 , 2"! 8!#" &

"4 &"

+"($"!" $ $4*!" 2 + 2+ +$)$ ! "" !1 ! 2"( 2! !

&"$!",, & 3# ,",A,

!)4 2!1 #"",*1!!,2!!+ 2 !1 ! & ! ! ,$"$4 :& #" 1"""&)4!#$*1!! ",$$4

&"$! &!"#"*+$)$1&$!+ # & 1!!"!"1"&1" 4,#, !1! 2!!

&"$! 8!""*! !"

)2$1 !#" & 8!"$4* ! , !""!

* ! A4

1! 2!1 & ) ! )"!".&",( 2!!2"#"3 @

" '$B *2)&

# , 1!" ! ! !! )"!" 2!*1!!2 !"4

! !4,= 1)&! !

!,"

2 !! &"$! #4 !"#"!) #"+ CA )4!& .&",( 2!1! ##" '< &" 2!"$1 "

!"2" !!,!!!2 &!"#""" $$! "

2 !1!,$4 2!!

# "&)!!!,, &""!,"

! 1 ,,)"

!",$4!)! , 1

)& , !! & $4+"

1 ! 2 !,"

1 "#"!#$ 8!$$2$"

1" 2"( 2!!+ ) 2,#"1!! ,1" ", >"

B)""4 $"$4 !1!! #& 1" 2 !! 2! 7 ) &!

+ *'< .&",( 2! 2! &!$"

" ! 2! " $4) " 2 + 2+ .&",( 2!!)+& $4" !$"

" ! 2!)&)4! 4 2 &$$4 )$ ! ""! &!&, " ! 2! 3#$& )$ "4" " &!$"

>B"!#&"# ,#" , 2"!

'< .&",( 2!! ! 2!! " &$

? ! 2 2*1!!! "!"

, '<-""-&"9 ,#$ ! 1!" #$$4 C+ !

,#"+,

"! !$#!#" & "4* "!"2 2

)& 2!!,, & )4! 2 2*! ,"#"#$!1&$!+) !"* 1!! ! ! & " ! #&"# ! 2 2 " &$ ! 2 2*!) ! =)"= =2 $ 2 8! ! 1&$!+ $4"& # ,$4,,)"

! 4 !41&$ !+",! )41!&2 2# ,",A, &!"

1!&2 2! :& #" ""&)4!#$ !", &!! "4 )" C+ = !!"1 , #&)1

!& ) 1)&! " $4) = )), !#"1 "$4)& &!11 " 21!!"

#" *1!1"2+ 2!","$ , "4 &##" , !!41&$$ 2&$4), 7 !

& 2"( 2! )$ ! ! ""* ! $$2

!& 6##$$ !!4!)!

&#$

2 B"

$"!##$$ ! """+"&

&!" >"

) 2

1!" !#A&"

! ) "+!1! & !& ) 1 2! 1 $$" 2!"", = &"

2!"&!!& ;!! 2+ ) !" !&"

2! ! 1,, &*! 1 "&$4& " ?7' )& & " 5 7'1 ,& !

"#!$ # %& )4D F)$&#", &"!, 2), ##" 2 @7'1

A#$ *1!! "

#"! ! :&""$!= #$ )1 & !& ) ! " 8!& $! 2 8! ! ,, &

!"4:&""$ 71 ) "+!

)!$!

&1 "" &$:&""$)& !"1 &2!,

" ! =+" "$ 8!""*!!"2 ), 2

!& 1 :& ! # #

$ ' )4!#A&"$ 21! " 5 7'"$ 2 &)4)"1 ) "+ ! &" ! +, 1 !4#"

+ " "4 #&$ * " " , $:&,, ! 41!!!+,)$ 2 &!#&$ " " 1" A# & ,$"$4 "&, +&$ 2+ 4,, &*! &"

2++"2&$4 (

)* +,- ./0 %1!$$ 21! #), " @7'1 ) "+ "

! "

#$ %&

#$ % "

# $'& ( # $

# $ "

( % )

( 71 &"!") "+!1"&" 2"", 1!& 2!

:& &$$4 $$1*

) )

8!& *7 !!(&2, + ""

)4!&")$1" )$ 8! , " )414# ! ##$ 8!##$$

:&!!"2",2

!, 3

"4 , ) !:&"" "

"( &'

#(! )(* #+ , ()!

#-.

()!