← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1843/2005allowed

Paramjit Kumar v. State Of Punjab

2023-04-25Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat19 pages



   !"

!# "

$ 

% 

&



%



'  ( ( % ) *+( ( ,-

,!./-   

     ,-

0  ,!./-     

   

 + 123 /( $*4

((56     ! "  # $$%&'($)$*++,  - ! "  # $$%.'+$)$*++, )/!0 1!   -- ! " 2*(# $$%.'+$)$*++,    33! " 2*(# $$%&'($)$*++,

((56 $(  

   %

"5  "/  6"" 2*$)/  2($78  9 $*$(!"6

 *

  "        "$          /   "6 "/   "    /"" 9 $*:$(  - (

"/ 2*$ )/ 2($78 8"

9 $*$(  

  %

"5  "/

6"" 2*$78  2($)/  9 $%$*!"6 *

  "        "$          /   "6 "/   "    /"" 9 $%:$*  - (

"/ 2*$ 78 2($)/ 8"

9 $%$*        %

   -         /  "     # $$%&'($)$*++,# $$%.'+$)$*++,!/ 6   "

-     "   -   -    ""      

 "+&+;*++,!/ 6  ""  "(+<!(*'!(*(!%'&%'; =#> ?=#?@

""

  /" --  96 "(+<=#6 %!+++5$- 6 "%'&=# 6,++5$-/   !/    !6!   !  ! 

   0   1   #  /  "   -  -  96 "(+</ " %';=#6%+++5$"

-/    *

A= "/-  6 "$)/   "!

 <++*.+'*++*! /  )   !  / -->#

@!

 !   !   01 #    6 / = !78

 " 7- !1 # !""

9      - "- 6   6  !   " - 78   - -// -->#

@ -   - "

78 ! B/  - )/ 78  !

   --8/!/ "

 7 8  "8-  "

= !) 5

1"  ""

/6 -/

"/78 ! /  #B

"" )/ !"  !A=/6" "0-- ! =" " -/ "/" " "6-! "

/- ""

 "(+<=# ( " " "(+<=#/9" 66 # C -! "/" # 

C -!C # - "

- "(+<!(*'!(*(!%'&%';=#-  !/ "

 6- 6" ' = "

-- ! "

 9- /D$% 0- !D$*)/ $ "!D$(78 ! !D$'0C-- !D$, =  - !D$.0) !D$< =0- - D$& B#C--  ,  =  "  /   "!= -  -  # "" 6  " .

 6 !"      D$'0C-- D$.0 ) ! -!#B!C ! "  "(+<=# -  " 

   "  "$)/ 78 !

 ! 6   "      "  "! /    6   " "/   -   # "  "#E 6! - " "(+<=# ! 6 "  "   6 "E  <

9  !/   D$'0C-- D$.0) 

D$'0C-- !  "-6978 5 1# !   /-  $ 



  

      

                

             ! 

! " 



  "     

   !      ! #   "$

  %      &    '

  

        



  "(" )

    %      *

 

 )      #  ! 



  



      



 

     

+

0 &

D$'$0C-- ! /"" !  /%%+5<+B1  /;& 

 /// " = 62'/"!

/  2%!*(/8 7 "  -" -""#B!C ! 6 2(/"-  2%*/" = 2%!*(/" 6 /!/  6 2'/" 6 /7*.+'*++*!"6 ""!  "78  !    F905%!/ "

/-6  =  "$9!   /"" !/         - /   F9#B ;+  ! / #B!C  !   B    - - -- 62(-

- ! F /"    " 

"

  90 ) ! -!#B!C D$.B 

" " !6!78  / -

 /-  6"8> 62(  @ B  62(! /  

6- " > 6@

 6-  -  !    -"-- 2%!* '! / """   6-

7  " B" ""6F9A = "$9!   /""  

   !  -B    /6  "8  " 6- -    ; )  "-        "      !   /     "/   "  "(+<=#-  "  "!/  ""(+<=#!/ "

 /$ , #     !            )

- 

    - ! 

-  

!

- 

  

     

  !

   !

 -   

   . -  

!

  ! -  

 

 

             -       

        

  

+ %+

-"(+<=#! /--/  8 " "(+<=#$ >@ 

     ""

 "G>@  "// 8/-  "

""

"" 6 6 ""

8/86"     "

6 6 6"  / " "  !  ""

"  "

 6-" 8/ 6-   6

"   "

6 686"  G>@  ""

 9"

"

- 8" - "

  6 %%

  " "(+<=#!   /  ""6 ""

     FE 6! E !/  - ! "C  " 9"-6!*' F!-,,; "  6- /$ /    

 

    

  #         -   !! #  

   0  -       ) -    !

    -   

-  

 

   '

    #   ! ! 1    -    - ! 

     

 

    + %*

6"     "(+<=#" " "   96  D$'0C-- D$.0) ! " / "! "  - " "(+<=#/-  "=""  6"  "6""  " "(+< =# - / /--$

8 >@

  6 "D$ *)/ !/  / # /8 -!  ) G6 ""

 /  / A "       "

!    /            "

  E -

"

  ""  // 9"   ="! " "6 --   "

 """

"   >@ =" -! B? #   /   ""

 

       ""

  "    -       ""

"8!/ 6 ""

  ""!/ !/ "

6  6/" "

"

  -  "(+<=# "  -  ""

  "  "

6  !/ "

/"" -  "

"    

B/! "

"!                A=!  /!       "

!  /6  " - 6  / 6 ""

   

!      

 E !"  "

 !/ "

" " "(+<=#/- " >@= "

"  ""

"

8"/  6$ "



    6  "    "       -      ! ""

" 8"  !

/ 78  ! "

  >@F 6 "

/   /" 78  ! "-  ""

 - 6  !     B/!  "/-! /       "         "    "

 6  !/  ""  6"    >@6! "

"/ D$'0C-- D$.0)  FD$'0C--     -" -""#B!C D$.0) ! -FD$.0 ) ! -"6 9" 62(!     /     F   6  2(  -      - ! 

 %(

- /  "" "(+<=# "

"

     6" "/ " 6"   "   " # !/ 

""  "(+<=#!8-/ $6D$.0)   !

  -  /""  

   - B     /6  "8   " 6- -    

! - #  6 # /  %' =  6 #  H *3 9(  ) :;<  , -

(( ( ,4+43 - /$ "2 !

 #   

 !  

- #  3  *4256 

 2   -

  ) )  

  )- 



   3      /  7 #  8        

    !

  

#    3!-   #

-      

  !     2    -  53#3 5  $$&9":;6;96:

4- 

#

  <1

 =5,(  /  >?  3

#-    

      



!

 8 )3 !



  11   !@"-  

!  ! !      

      

  

  !     # 2 !@" 



5 3    !     -



A B3

2   

 

!

"#  $ %&    -=

 !C  

   #

 



!      

  

- - !

 ! 

   

 ) !     !

!

  !    #  3  *4 6

 #   !  

 !          

     !



!  

 !   

D!3 ** 2 5  6



   

3 "& = 

 # !#  

)  !  

   '!(

)* 

 

!

"# 

+, 

  -( .

)* 

- *.

)*#  $  0   

  -  

 # -2   

 

#



 *42 5 6

= %, B/! #  " 6    /96 "

 "

"

 9D$*$)/ !" "!/  

 "

" A=

6D$*)/

  6 6D$(78  ! )

  /  /   "    - 6  "$9!  /!   "" "   "6 -/ "

"   "6    /  6  

 "

  ""    "

/ 6 6 6D$'0C-- !/ 

6/  F9#"-F9#5%  !6!78  A  !D$.0)        -"    F9A         

  "

     9D$< =0-- !=--7" "!/   " "6-->#

@ :

! " -  "

!  - "  "(+<=#! / """  "(*.!(*'!

(*(!%'&!%';=# %.

"    ""   "!  "    

""

" 8"*.+'*++*  *%6- 

" /   6*++,5*++." ! 

  ""   !  /6-   /    ""

66-" 6 - 6F  "" 

 ")/  9 $* 7 8  9 $( )   /""6       6      "       A=    /       E  "-- " -  -""6  5  " "        "        "  "-  -  $

 ""/6E  " "    6""  -""= 6  "/  "$ ""! B- #  - 9" "

""  6!8- / ""

"  - "! /6/ "

 " /  -     "   ! #  8 " " ""

 "="!  # "/69" 9$6/ # !"

"'&*##"

  " "    -6 B? #   H +=>3  9(  ) /: ;<  , -

(( (

,4+43- ?

 4@$  < / "

 B?  #  /$ *    

     

       

         

 

-   

   

! 1>

'

 6   

 */ (0* 

$1

-(/

% 2(0 # + ,   

 < =9:    



3  ("

6

   C        

      1        

3 "* 6



 

##  !

!

# -  !             !

      #   #





   # . 9":3    

 

     ##

             

#!  ) 

-

- !- 3      #   #       !. 9:3!-    

 



  



  )  5 #  6

   

!

 #  ) ! 

C  

 !

    



 # 

 

. : 9%:,      

3  ("

6

C    

 

1        - #    #      !-         E 



 # 

 

-    F  6      

    

  



  

. 

 

-  !-   

    !

0    -  

       - = 9D   



:+      G1     H

  

! 



  

   

3 "*656-$4!    !

     -

     "*  656-  $4        #    I          !  

  3   "*  656-  $4    !   !    

     

        )    G     H  #

  !)

  1       @ #   -    

             )3 "*656- $4    #)     !

F6 #

 

3  ("656-$4  F 6 -)

# 

               3  ("656- $4  # 

  !6  E

     "  F6 -  -#    

      #  ! 

 

    #    !   

          

 -C    

    

7       

3  ("656-$4 # 

   1       F6 

 !

#         

!   !

 #

      

-

   !- #  

 

-  )  !B  # !         !   2

   

 ##1          !

#  -

 



#      !





   

  #  F     

              

#       3        

!    # !  ! 

   

 2   !-         )  1#- F 6         

-)

 #        

-       

#

- 

           -

 

  

-

    

      

   1 !   

3  ("656- $4 

       



       F6  

   #     

 



3  ("656-$4!   



  - #       -!

   #       - 

    #

 #

 

 - 

  

 

-   !

#

! 6   -(

(

)* % 2(0



 

!

"

% 2(0 # + ,     I@!93

:  2  -#        ##  

#      

    !##    



!-

 

 #

 

!-    #       !  D      C       !     !

!  



   

      

 -        G   H    

-    -  

! - 

 

   2    = 

! 

-

#

= %< = "! 6- F / "  - -A  " "!  / $ ""

" 8"    F9" !!  "         !  6!  7  8          !  

8 ""

" 8" /  6! - -" 6 =6 " -  "    6

"! ""- 6 # !/  9"-9$6 " "'&*##  "/  F "/   5""!/  66 "  #   

!6 9"- / "'&*##! / "  "!/  -6 B?  #   +=>3A ,*>-B"!   /

 - -""" +&+;*++, "E 

  "

- 66 "

6!E 6 " %& -"!6!!""-6 %; #6!6!/ !6 96 - !"""/ /

 " ""8

, ((B

- ( (  $"%

  8-5