← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2030/2006dismissed

Simarnjit Singh And ANR. v. State Of Punjab

2022-08-31Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan15 pages

 

          



!

 "



$"% 



    & '



!

 "



$"%



  

 !"!

#$%&'&  ($  )*( & &&( "

)*  + ',

   * + ',

  %

* 

!

+   - $"%

....

&&(+& 

!

" + /



0

 #

 !  #

& ' + 

 1/ 2    3+ 3

2,, 4" $ (, , "% ,

,+

   # #  6,  +   $,

 0+ 0

 ,',

&"

, "+ "

"  5 

 ##

%7





 "

  

,

( #

++8

, #" #"  "

  



,



,', + 0

(

,,

+

 " " ,', 

 

,:"

,

#  



/ " 

,"  3+

,

( $,

 0+ 4 , "

/ ;

 # # 

/'

 <##, 8/< '

 -'

 ,

   2 $  *8=

 %

,

'

7 >" ,



, ,"

  ?

0 ,



'

*?

/'

 <##, 

,

?



'

+ 0 

 



,% , ?



  0( #



+ 0 +

 ?

  7 +

  0 '

 , 

 @ "

-"%  ?

,

   

! @ 7"

4 + 0



   , 

& ' @ &  " ?

 /'

 <##,  # " 





   

,

A"

%" ",

  '% ?

/'

 <##, , ,7

:"

?

#



, 

B,    ,

+ ",

0

,

 

,

A  ##,  *  ?



, ,",

A  ##, ?

 

 CB $+ & ' CB $ ! CB $+



,'



0

=

/'

 <##, ,,  2 >" + 4$ " 0

(  ?

#  

4$ 2 >"  , 

?

/'

 <##,

 

#,

?

# 4$ 2 >"   ,  (



, 

B,  

,

,",



,



 A  ##,  *  ?

0 +

,#

4$?

,  

+

,"

,'



0

?

 ", 4$ 2 >" +

/'

 <##, ,",

,

:"

+ " %

" 7 ,,  "?

/'

 <##,  0

3 

,

,

% ?

"

" 7

, % ,

"



3

= 7 ?

% , "

" 7

,'

 

,

/'

 <##, '  ,  ;?

,

 , 

7 , CB $D

#

  '

/ -"% + 4$ 2 >" 

"

,

'  ,  2$

, CB $D

# +



( 7 

,

 CB $5  / -"% / 4  

4$ 2 >" 

7 



 CB $



"

 :" 

,"

 

,   CB $+

 

,  & ' CB $ ! CB $

":

,

+

%  # 1/

/'

 <##,

"



,

 0

< "

,

+

/'

 <##,

"

,7

 

( *; -"

<

B (

 3+

/'

 <##, 7

( *; -"

",

&*+ "+ '

, CB $

 CB $ 8

/'

 <##, '



, CB $=

 

( ", 7 



+

(

  ", 7

4"

,"

'

+

,

##,

 , CB + $"%

 CB $= , '

#+ 

#"

" 7

# ,

 '

  # ,  

#

<



,+ ,

#

,  +

'  D  $ 

% '

 #,

,

 ##

3

,  ,  

+

,  

,,(+ 0,+

  "( , 

4"

,"

,"

B

#0 0

) $E / -"% + 0

,"  

$E ; -" + # 0



"( 0 ##' CB $=



#

," (

(  

 *;

,



$E ; -"%  +  # 0



"( 0 ##' CB $3

;

,

##,+ 0 7

,

##,

 , CB + $"% #   ,7  "

$+ "  

,





 7

,

$E= 4$ 2 >" + 0



," (  



E $E3 ;0 +  7+ 49< <##, $ %"

     ,

$ 

 ",7    2 $ F83=3D  





 -"%   ;"

2 3=+  2 + -"%B (+ $?

 "%

,

F$=C 5 $

 0 +   "%  #  

( CB $D

;

'



,

CB $5

$E

2 % +  7+ 49< <##, 1  % %"

"  ' ,

2

5=  

=  "



 , G*!

 ;*!

 ,

  

;

'

,

CB $E 8

$ED / ;

+

/'

 <##,

 ,%

'

 ,", 

' '"

,"

," #   ##' " >"+ 2A CB $= ,

,"





  $ 

, ,," ,



,"

 

" ", %" 

 , 

,

# ''

1"  

## , ?

%"

"

$?

#

,

0

  $,

 0 ##,

4$ "

,

'

# ''

,,"

& ' 

 %"

 0  ,(,

,

,(,

",7   ,

 

,,"

! 7

7 



4" #

B 4E /  + /, 0 %"

%7

 0









 3

 )

 

0  



4$ 2 >"   3

;

#"  

%7   2 >"  4$ ,



4E %

+ CB ,"'

 "( ## + ,

", + * %"

%

 %

2

5=5=5  ,

#'" $ + ;"

2 

8+ ,  

 3+

, 

,"  

;

#" 

,



/ ;



E

#

 ,



#  "  +

  ,',

 %'

#  #

 +

 "



<

, 5

 $ 

'

#

 8,,"

 

   "

 ,(

 +

0 

 8,,"

 "

 ,(



% #"   :"

% % 8 " ( %

 #,

&*+ "

=

20

'

,

# 

3

/ '



 ,"

 ,',+

   -



$"% 

 "



 ,"

 ,

,  /'

 <##, / ;

$ED+

 

 0

" 2 >" + 4$

B $E= %" ,  B # 

 

#,

,  B+ #

,"+ "% 

 %"

"#"

," ( '

# "%

+ "

,:"

,

#  

D

/ # "

(  ,, '

/

%

0

(+  (+ $E / -"% $ED / ;

'

#"(



," (  '

#" , ,"

,% 0" (

  ,

,  B 

 #

%" ",7 " ," 

 (  



2

'"

( 0

,', 

 

'

  '

''

0(

  #

,"

,',

,," '

$E ,

"

0( ,

 2 >"   

$E=+ , 

B  ,", 

# 

"% :"

(+

," # 

,   $ 

, 0

#,

,  B+

#

/  

   

," ,

% ,", ,  B 0

, 7

# 



#  $E=  7  ,  + 

%"

#

,"+

,%

, ,"

 "(

'

5

 

" # 

 ,"

 

     

 !"+

#,

 ##

, B

% '



'"

#,

 ,:"

 

     

    



   

 

       !"#$ !

    

       %            

  & 

       





;0 +  "

,



" #$  % &  '

(

  ) *



 '

 #8'

  0 # '

 # 0"  " "#

 %

'

+

" # '





 ,:"

 , 

"

#  + ,-!

.*.

7 ,( ' # ,

'

 ",

 ,:" 

 0

,#,( '

"



 "

" #0 #

 %7

,

 2 + 4$

",

  '

 " 0

' 2 + 4$ 



 4E / 



%7 , 4$





/ # "

(  ,, '

", %7

##, ,

4$ ,  '

 "  , (+    ", (

"  +    

'

 ,

   

,

#, ,%'

 :"

%" ,

0" " %" 

#

" , (

<(

'

",   0

 

E   

 0 ,

'   ,"  %'



#"

##, 0

  '

(

(

  '

#



   0(

,"

,',

C'

 0

  ##, 0





 0

1"  

 ,% "

"

 :" 0

/ 0

' ( "



 ,% "  %

#+

,"  , "(



 

, "     ,-*

 

..

% '



##, 0

,

( '"

(  0

 ,

 ,  ,," ##, 

=

<



"

" #0

 ,"

 , ,

3

,

 % ( ' ( 

0

 3

,

 

, (   0

/

   

  "

 

) % '

0 

## ,

%" "( % , , +

' 3

,

/ % '

3 3D

,

 ,( "

3

E  (



"   

 ,( ( 

,

,"  ",, #"(



% 

,

,

##,

 , CB + $"%

,

(  #

," ( #

A"

/'

 ##,



 /   %        ,-  !0

 

".

0



 7

" 0

, ,

B # = ( (+ 0 +



 (

",

,"

+

( 

#



 

% 1G #



 

 

*;+

 

,"

 #  , 12    %  3      4  

 

0!%( 

, 0 0



, 1G 1  #

+ % '

"



, " "

 $, "



 24$ ,

," " 





D

$E3 ;0 + 7+ 49< <##, $ %

'

:"

 





< 0

 

,%

 

% '

 "+



 ,





% '

,

(  " 0(

/ 0(+



,%

,

# ,,"

+

"  ,

0 3 3=

, ",

, ,"

 5

 ,"

 #  '"

 " +   #

,

' ## #, ,," ,

, B ", % '



"     4) /   

 # (

, ,

(

'  0 0 '

' "

,

A"



"            

,  +50!*   

 0





(  '

  ,"  %'



E  " &%,- !

*/ 0.+ " % ,( 

"  ,"

%

 

, ,



%"

'

,(

9 " 



,"

% '



3  3= 3

 ''

, =+   #" %" 

 %" %"   

( %"

;

, ,"

,%



  :"

'



 ,"

,"  0 ( ' ( (

' +  ,"



",

 8,,"



," 

'

,

 

,," '

##'

,"   (

=  %



" %

  #

 ,  ," ,,"

,% 0" ( ,



 0

, ,"

", ,%

/ %

(

'"

( 0

##, 0

  

'

,+ ", '( :"(  "

"

 %( #

 , 



,

   ,- / 0

3 % , 3 7

" 7

, %

,,,"

+ ", "

:"(

,% ,

,

0 ", + " 

#

 ,

 ",+ ,',

,,"





 

+

## , :"

"%  , 0

# , , :"(

 

:"



0

"

0

,," , 

   ," '

0

 "

  

,+

"

,% ,',

, , :"(

,%

C'

 0

 8,,"

,"( #

( '



7 , 7 "

"

 '

",, #"( (

, #%, " , (

("

0#"



", (

 

 #(

3 ( ( ( ,

0

'

,"

",'

" ,

" ##,7

0

 8,,"

 #"

 



 ( ",

=

 " " ,', 



  %

 

,

, ,   0

(  #(

 " ,', 

0

#"

0" ( 

  ,,(

3

/

 

,,

 



00



  5 

%

 # &", *  "  ,  "

 0   7





, ( 

:" ,, 

%&'& -&&(.



  /, , 00 "

# 1"2 3!#4 $ "1

/, , 00 056

$ "1