High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2897/2009allowed

Ram Chander v. State Of Haryana

2015-01-27Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar7 pages

%#&'()*"+$,-

%%#*

'/% 0( 120

'%( 0'

3%%+/4&%'&)'&)/ 0 5'.6./3+/4&% #%.%

0 0)'.4 .+'''%% +*

7 8 93%. %. '% #/ :* &4&% ./+%.')%%/'%/''#

!;,

#$$!#/:*&4&% 9./

<!$

#$,$#/:*&4&% %/=/+'%.'

.4 ' )% # %. 5)/9% / / /%/ $>, ,, $$!

''/:*%.//% ''')/9+)9

/%&%)%%.#&%'#%.&'+%3)/: %.#%''#%.9'%#%#%.)9/5)/9%+3.&. '')/(

?##&%'#%.'%&''/)%#%. % )/ &% ,"@ # / #

&/)%.% $$;3.:.* 9.

93%.%.&##&'3''%%0+ 0' %. 0 )/ 9. & / /'&'/%.%#%.':&4/# %'%+0'%.%'&##&'

&4/ # 5)'

A. . &./ % '%+0'.&%B3%.%%.%%' .4 /* : #/ % )'.5 '%+ )9/3..4/% )'.5'%+ )9 . & % B3 %.% '%: '.

./ " 3'.'%'/%. ./&% 94%.%.%%.%%3'%#%#B9 '%%% 34+ 9./.'

'%%% % %. ##&% %.% $$; . 3'

'&% 9)/ / 3' &&/ :* '%:

'. ./ / %.% /*+ #% /)&9 &&)'//=%)%.)%'%6'.9. '+%.*3%)9 .*./ %B#%# 44.&/%3%.''':*%B#%%. '/44.& #%'%+#%.%/ %.%../%%B:.# &.9/ # %.% ' /4 # 4.& %)/ .' 4.& %3/')'/ .#%:%.%.#'/ ''%)%9)%./'%%/::)9 %. #%.#/%'%: '../ 3.&..%.'#% .''%'''.% @'

#/ ./4#4.&3''&*9'% /%.''%'%.3%.&##&'%./ /'/3*93%.&&)'//=%) %.:''#'/&%+&')/ &%'@@+ @-@+@$"+@@+<+-+@< '3' &%- # %. ' &% 3' 9'%/ 4'%9% 3'

)&.//&&)'/3'%/ ?

&%#%.4'%9%/'%%# %.&.+%.&'3'&%%/%%.)%# '''+3. &.9')/ &%@/3%. &%@< 3#/

9'% ./ / 5/ 9.+ %' / )/

&%' @$"+ @@@+ @-@+ - / 3%. &% @< 9'% % %/=//%.&&)'/+*6.)'. + /=%)/ %= )5=5* C/)9/5)/9% //%.%)%&D)%%/ %= )5=5*/6.)'.

#%.&.9'9'%%. % %/=//.'

& &4&%/=%)3&4&%//'%&/'#3'(

78 9)''%##4*'/%* ## '

-+$$$> &.)/ &%@$" / /#)% # *% # #+ % #)%. )/9 ' '% # / # %.%.'E 78 9)''%#%.*'/%* ## '

@+$$$> &.)/ &%@@@ / /#)% # *% # #+ % #)%. )/9''%#/# %.E 78 9)''%#%3*'/%* ## '

+$$$> &.)/ &%@-@ / /#)% # *% # #+ % #)%. )/9''%#/# %.E/ 748 9)''%#/#%3*' / % * # # '

+$$$> &. )/

&%- //#)%#*%# #+%#)%.)/9''%# /#%.

.'):'%%4'%&'#'% 3//% %.#%/%3&4&%'3//%)&&)%*

*+ ./ / 5/ 9. 3 &4&%/)/ &%@ /'%&/%)/9' '%#/#'F%.'/%*## '

,+$$$>

&. / /#)% # *% # #+ % #)%. )/9 '%#/#,-/*'

# &/9 * #)%.+ % * : %&/ %.%

%/=/ %.'/*'4/%.%'%& #'%'/). .''#&%/%.&)'%/* &%#&%/)&/:*%./ %%&)' 43#%.'+ %. #/ :* '/ %/ = / .' : // #)&%))'

+/'&)'+'''%/:*0 %

/0 5'.6./3+/4&%'+.''):%%/%.%

9.'3' ./&%:./99% %.'&#/=%)#%.&)'%/*/'')&.&%: ./9)%*)/ &%@ %.'9/+..''):%%/%.%

A< /. 9.%'%#/%.% '. 5+3.3'&.9 #%.'&%9)/+//%3%#%.##&4/./%B )/ %'4%4 ''):%%/%.%%.)9. 0)B.% 9..//'/%.%%. 9. ././&%%.)#%B93'''%'&% %.)/ %' *% A, :. 9./%%/.'&''

F%%.%:%.+ 9./ ./+:'/'

%.&##&'+./D)'%/#3'/&'%:'

# &2 ##&#/)&9%.&&)'/:)%%.D)'% 3'/&//')&.'%)%+%.'&%9)/+3.&.3')%

):/%%.%#%.&&)&+&%:./9)%*#:9 99%#9%./)%'

%'''):%%/%.%'%:

'../+3../&4/5)'%.&&)&+./ '%/%%.3%''

:F' A</'%%/%.%%3' %/ =/+3../#/%. 34+&''

F%+. %'%#/%.%%.)9.%.&&)&./%B& $$;

/.3'/'&.9/#%..'% ,, $$;*%%3'* !

< $$" %.% .' '%%% 3' &// :* %. 4'%9%9 ##& ''%%/%.%%.%9)%..%/% &%&%%.4'%9%9 ##&%.4'%9%9 ##&&%&%/ .#&/9.''%%% .#+%.'9/*# %.#4%.'&/9%.'%%%#'%: '.

./+3.3''/%.4:%.:)%#%%&B%%.%# %.&&)&+')F/ 2/ %%&)'.''):%%/%.%:%. 5/

9./ ./399%#9%./)%'' /%%B%.''#)9%6'.9.'+%.* 3')'/%%B'# A 0)B.% 9.:)%%.% /*%.*//%:#%.'/3%''#%B93' % .' ' : %/ %.% %. 5/ 9. .//*%%%%4%%.'&#/=%) #%.&)'%/* .*'//%'%%%.3%''

:F% &%/&%%.'&)%&'

;

49 ./ / &)' # %' 5/

9./ ./+%.')%#/'%.%%.&4&%#%. ##&)/ &%@ &%:')'%/ .*3%# %.'&%9)/3.&.3'/:* '. 5 / '. 5+ 4&&/9%%.'&)%+./%3%/#%./4#%. 43.&.3'%#%B9%.)/ %'#%.)%%%. 5 '%/+.3/%.%&/4%4.& / '. 53'/%%*&//9'%''&#%. %'%*#A2.//#/9.:#%.&%# /#)%&%%/:*.+)'.%#'%9#&% 3%.%*##&%3''/). )%.+%.)9.#%. '%%%# A 0)B.% 9.+%'/)%%.%#%. %3 #%/ %' ./ & # %B9 3' :)%

A, :. 9.&%9&*%'%#/.'&''

F% %.%:%.%.%'/%.&##&'./')9.% 3' ' 3 ' ' # #9 %. /)%* :)% %. D)'%3'%&&%/ ')&.'%)%+%.*&%:./ '':##&%%9%.'&#/=%)#%. &)'%/* .&/%D)'%./%B& $$;

,, $$;+'%: '../+3../&4/5)' %.&/%+3'/'&.9/#%..'% 34+'%'

3%B%.:*%.4'%9%9 ##&:*'%: '.

./.'#%9%.''%%%&// %3'*!

< $$"

%.%.''%%%3'&///)9%.4'%9%#%.&'

.F%##/9/9%./*&%:&&%/ 43#%.:4+%3%:'#%')'%%. &4&%# 9./ ./#%.##&)/

&%@

')%%*+%.+

<!$

#$,$#/:* %/=/'/''/#'.49: //#)&%))'

34+%.%3'+

!;,

#$$!#/:* 9./

#$$!#/:* ./&&%/ %.%.'%'

&D)%%/#%.&.9'9'%%. .*: .: :/'/')%*:/''.'%//'&.9/