High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1557/2015dismissed

Harjinder Singh @ Kala v. State Of Punjab

2019-03-19Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Kuldip Singh15 pages

!! " #" $

! !"# $%&'( )*+,-( !.,/01! "!

$%&'( )*+,-(2)'3,40,$51 # % & #" ' (

% "' ' !! % # ) ' & '#" $

!.,/01! "!6

) ! !! " "* + ,' $- ."' /' % ' 0 / 1

' $- !! ( ( !" $ " 2#0 ( " " *! * !- ,'34 "!-* '" " "*! * !5* ) !" " *

'( ! *$- 6% / /

7#89# ! * ! ) ':2( "

6 *54" ! ;(

" $ ! ) (! ( ) 4$-( !4**5* '( ( " $- #8, #*

#4** ! <5 #8,3 ) (*! (!""! *! * ) !" 5* +( "!! ) * "(" 0 *' (-*! :"( (5* ( '

$ ' ! !! = " !! $ !! * -" !" ! = " !! * -" !" !$- $"$ "!! "* 0"$( , 8 " ! "

"* -"- > #8 (**$! - / $"4,-'( & 0 " 4% ?

' (*" ( #8/

# 4$-/ * '<5 #8 3 '(

+ #8 2"6 ( !

' ( !# '& " ( 2;

( ! ( ! 0 (6 /

* $?;

(

( * * * * ( *! ;( ! ! ) 4$-/ & ( - ! (( (( "$ ?;

( !! @"! 6 $ *!* *! !" (! $5 #(* $5 ?

' (

( !(! ;"4 ' & " ( ;(

! & !"" # " ( " * " * '<5 #83' $( 6 - & " $" ( $ " ( " "*$*6 2 45* ' ! - !$"

, % * $" # % /!"*! "(! ! / ! ( 5!;( *-6 $ #8 /

( ! " *6 ( / '( ( * 4,- *

6 ;"4 & '( ! ( ! " / - $ ( ) ( "-*6 !(! $* / " * $"+-$6 ) *( $-/ 6 # = 0 ' =" 6 ( * ( *- ) - " / (*"$-*" 6 ( ! ( !

(! ! * !'<5 #83 ) 4 $-( $- * 2 45* ' ! ( 4,- * !$"1-'" *- $ ! /

#8 ;( ( ! *! !

* *

' ** *"/ ( 6 ( ! ;"4 '& '0 " 4 % 6 *( - ** *"/ ( *-( *'(

( "$-/ * ) - (6 / " * * " $" 4,-! ' &* # - " / * / 6 * * $ "

** *"/ !" "$ !;"4 '& " **'<5 #830'(!! *"* '<5 #83' $( 6 ( ( $ " 2 4 5* ' * !$"1-'" *- $ ! /

#8+2;

( !

' ( !?'# '& " ? -' ( 2 "6 ( !(! 0 (6 #8/

( ;( !

#8/

* '<5 #83 * * '<5 #8+3 ' $ ( * :2'

<5 #8+3;'( ) -( ! 4$-/ (- ! !! @"! 6$4 *! !" (!$5 ) ( ! ? !( $ 6(!" !$ #(* ?

' ( 2"6 ( !(! ;"4 & " (

;( ! !"" $4 6 ) *("- 2 45* ' ! ! ( ! $ # -' " / ' *- &*# -

"*' ?7-9': =$-'(45* ! (! ( $- *' ' - !6"! ! ! -(* ( $ *!$ ! $ - !

#4** 5* ( " $- #8, #*

!!4**!'<5 #8,3 $- ( " 4$- 2 (" ,5* *"

2 (" 5 * "!! 3 **! $(" 5 * -! "*!

"!! $(" 5 * "!!

3! "!" , $(" 5* (

3! "!"$ ) " (" 6 * " " ) "( 4** "'( (" " *" " ) !$$*$( !4**

# $$#%% #&'

#( ) * ! + , - "!

. ) /!

(#!+ , .)0 !'

1 !()+ 2 + ,

(##3#

#$!" / ( & * 4,- *

/ " * $"+-$6'( 6 '=" 6 ( * ( *- *- $ ! / " $" 4,-! ' &*# - " / *'( " 6 * * " $ " ** *"/

, " * 54"

$#8 ;(

;(

( ! 3

' ** *"/ ( 6 6( - ** *"' ( *-( *'( ( "$-/ * ) -(! / " /( &*# -( * / 6 * *'( " *"/ " *" * '<5 #83' $( 6 ( $ (

> :=!<5 #B ) 5 $ !C C'C;C'

CC'C<C C:C( ( "* $ ('$" $ 5 $ !C0C

+ ) *- !! ( $- / ! 54" ' ( "! / ! - / 6 *- !! !*# "

#$!#3

# 5% #(

*#!

#33 #( 3''

#3!

# $$#%% % 2#

# $%# % #! 2 , $$!

# #'# )/!

(#!+ , .)0 !'

1 !( )+ 2 + , 33!( ,

#'.33 #(6!7 (#!+ , -1% ( 8 3 % "

#33 #( (

$!# #!#%%#,#(%8!2 ,

#3 %.5

#'#

3 % 5###*#( 3%#(58#

#) "

#$$#%% %#( $!*#

#$%#% "

#$%#% ( 5%##(,#(#$ 93#

#33 #( % $!*#

#$%#% .

$!##3#

3 5#! %#(

9!(#! $!*#$%#% .

!;!(

$6<5%#

+ $!#'# !

+4.

*# #%(

#$!#3

33##( ( 3 !, ,

#5 !(#.

3 '5#

#33 #(. ($

#$%#% . $!*#

5% #3#!

8 #&3% (#

#$ %

$!##3#

$%3#33 !!#3# "

!;!(

$ *# #%( (#!= > )#' 5#! '

(

% #&3#$

$#3 %!,##!%#* ,#(

#9( ?#%(#!

#!% 9 %8! %##* (#3#!#3, #(

+#3

# @* (#3# 3

#3 #!#!#%#* 9%% !

, *# (#!

#$!* !

!#$!( 3 ,

3 #& =

: A"

#B #

#!3''

#(3!

'# %3

3#!

( #C

( #. ; !#

!#%#* A "

!(% '#A#%# #!#A(

!( #(!3*# #3# #33 #( 2#!#3 !# (##3#% #

#33 !!#3# 2$%3# # !8!'

#$%3#33 !!#3#

#& !#'#%8

'$!55%#

# %( *#$!

$ #(

#3!

'# 9 5 3%

%3#.

#33 #( %%#,#( *# % #($ 8 3% 7 !8

#!$#!.

#5 !(#

#$!#3

$!*#

#33 #( $!##

#3##( $!

$ #(

#3!

'# "

#5 !(# %( 5#%###(58

#'#!#3

33 #( ($ #(

#(##3#% "

#$%#

33 #( 3 3###(5#3 (#!#(%8 #

5 !(# 5##( 3 !,#(58

#$!#3

3 !

#$!#3

33##( ( 3 !, ,

#5 !(#

3 '5#

#33 #(. ($

#$%#% .

$!*#

5% #3#!

8 #&3% (#

$ %

$!##3#

#$%3#33 !!#3# )

#$!##3#

#33 #(

#3##33 !!#3# 5### 5% #(

3 !

%858

#$!#3

! ,

!#% 5%# #* (#3#. !'%%8

# 3 !

%( 5# % 5#% #*# 8 3 #!#* (#3#

# ##3

# #%# #!# #

# 33 !!#3# $$##(

#* (#3#(( 3#(58

#33 #( 3 B %

8( 3 (!(

#3 !

'8# #!

'#!#5%# ( 5 !#,!( ,

$!##3#

# 3## #

33 !!#3# 2$%3#.

#33 #( %(.( 5 .5#

%#(

#5##

!#5%#( 5 D!

$ !$#.

%(5# ($!$

5#% ((

. 3 3 !3 ' 3#.

#5 !(#

#33 #( !

#! #*8 9 %%.

#!#!#.

$! !#B !#(!# 5%

#$%#% "

5#!*#(#!% #!33 * (# (

?(#8* + #E ? :4 + C+ # !

!* ! ,!0,!'?

'$%#9 :4+ F "

##$#3#!#3*#!#(

# 3#

$$#%% "

#3 #(#

( # 32( #'!!

,#( #

7 !

# "

# 7 !

##!# #'!

#' !#.

#!# 3 #(#

!'%3 !# !# "

#$!55%#

'#5# ##(#

($ '!

! "

#$!#3

$!*#(

*#5#

(

#' !(#!. #!#

#$$#%% %#( $!*#

#$%# %

#!, '# %#!#(3 #%!

#$$#%%

#& !7 ( % 3# #2 8$# #* (#3# '#!#%8 5# 3 (#!#((!#7#3 #(!

#!#

#$!## 3#.

*# $!*#((

#3 3'$%# # %%

#3 !3 ' 3##&3% *#%8$

#, %

#$$#%% "

! ;!(

$ 6<5%#

# + $!#'# !

% *# #%(

57#3

##* (#3#

# !

,! #

# 3 # 3!#( %

##& !7 ( %3# 35#33#$ #((35#

5 3*

# # 3!#( %

8 "

!;!(

$ *#

#%( (#!= >

# '8 5# ( * (#(

3%# 7 ( %(#& !7 ( % G ( % 3# !#

!#'(#5#!#, ! #!3 !

#3 !# 7 ( %$!3##( , @& !7 ( %3# !#

!# '(# 58

# $!

8 #%# #!#

5#!# , ! #!3 !

@& !7 ( %3# !#,##!%%8

!# '(# 58 $!

8 ! 5#!# $!

( * ( %

3% (# #*# 7 ( % 3#!

* #3$3

8 9 % 3% (#, ! #

#$#3 %%8#'$#!#( !#3!(3# (#!+#3

#(#!

%?!3#( !#. :

! !

H(#<!, ! ##'$#!#(5 !#3# * ,

3# ,# # (#!+#3

#(# (# $$%8 #& !7 ( % 3# . B #

#= #!#

#8'(#*% !

%8I(

#8 ! #I

##3

#3 .3# '(#58 33 #($#! !!#%#* 3!

%$!3##( ,.

'2 ,

#3# $$#!

#3 !

*#5## 3 #(588 ( 3#'# .

!# !$!'

#. * , !##!#3#

# 3 !,# ,

# 33 #( $#!. $!3##( ,!'$#!

8.( .

#3 !

, *#

#33 #($#!,! (

%($$#!

'!#5%#! $$ ,

58 '2 ,

# %(, 8(* ,#!* (8#* % #'$!% !# !##!#3#

#$!3##( ,,

' 9 %%

3# %(5#*% !8

'(#58

#33 #(

(.(

3 #(588 ( 3#'# .

!# !$!'

!##!#3#

# 3 !,# ,

'. $!3##( , !' $#!

8 9 %( 5# *% !8.

( 3#'# . (# *# !##!#3#

# 3 !,# ,

#33 #($#!C!5

(# $!3##(!' $#!

8C!3

#3 !

, *#

#33 #($#!,! (

%( $$#!

'!#5%#! $$ ,

.58'2 ,

# %(, 8(* ,#!* (8#* % #'$!% !# !##!#3#

#$!3##( ,,

' )

#3# *% !8 %((#$#( $

3 (3 !3 ' 3##3 3#.7 (,#(

#% ,

+#3

# 9( @* (#3# 3 . !

<@* (#3#3 < "

#% 3%#!

3# 3 5#

#(, 33 #($#! %#

#3 !

*% !8(

#B #

! #!%#(# !

# 9

#3 (3 !3 ' 3# !! ( ,

#'2 ,3# $$#! 3 ( 5

#*#!3

8!*% !

#3# .

3 !

'8!# # 3 $

#3# .#*#

5%# #* (#3# # '$!

B #

. !#,!(

#3 !

#! #

33 #('(#

#3# . #!##'!

'*#'# #!# 3 !%%#( 58

# $% 3# #

#! 58

#'#%*#!

! , '#

#!,#38#'$%8#(58

#$ !$##3 !

, 3 3# "

#B #

#!3# *% !8! %8B #

3 %%

#3 !(%%

#3 !3 ' 3#

#3#.

3% ( ,

# '$!

3 !

'# , *# !

!#%#3

.3$#

#33 #(,#

,##% ,

!# .

( 3#'# !$!'

#.' 5#3 (#!#(5#!#(#3 ( ,

# 3 !

'$!# 3 #(58

# ( 3#'# .

!# !$!'

#. 8. 5## %%8 !#'*#( !## ( *% !8 3# (##!* ,

, # 3!#(

.5#3 #

$!# '#( %!'

, # ##, % +## * )!

32 %%9 5#33# *#(

' %(5#

( 3#( '2#!##(*% !83# , % . 3 !!8

###% ,($!

$%# ' !#.

#3 3##(#!# ! # #% 5#! #(*% !8 3# , % . 3%#!%8$!*#(.!#',

##3 %$! % *% !83# #

#!# %

#!## %%

#'2#!

+ #!#

# #'# '(#!# % !'# ( 3

#!!,

!#*#!% ! #!

#$#!

!# #(#(#!(33 #(. 3 #'# ' 5# !#,!(#( *% !8 "

# ( 3#'# '8 2#

#!'

$!'

# !

!# . ( #

# ( 3#'#

*%*#5

$!'

!# .$!'

#!, *## ( 3% !# '(#(

!# $!#3

+## )(!#< @* (#3#. :

@( . $ 4 $!'

# %8

3 #(

#3# % #!

3 #(

# %#3#% #!

*#C

. # 3#

#$!

#! '# !

## (* ,#

$!'

#. '

# ,##!% (# !5 %

8 %# 3# .,

#$!##

3 !8

#!3# # '# !

## (* ,#

# $!##

3 !8

. '

# ,##!% (# !5 %

#3# ,

!# ##( !'

' 5#5!# '

(

#*#!8 ( 3#'# .

!# !

$!'

#(# *

#3# + 3#

#57#3

! %# #&3% (# %8

# 3#

' %%8 ! !

# ( 3#'# .

!# !

$!'

#' 5# 3 3%3 % #( %#( ! # 3#

# !# ( %8

# 3 !

(# #!'

# 5#3# ! $!##3# ( 3#'# .

$!'

## 3 !

#38( ! '# !#

!2#(

(

#33 #( 9

# ( 3#'# .

$!'

#3 !

. , *#

#33 #($#!,! (

%($$#!

!#5%#! $$ ,

58'2 ,

# %(,

8(* ,#!* (8#* %.

# , #&3% (#

3# "

#!(A$$#!

#% $!

!##!

#'# %

#33 #(

#& !7 ( %3# . *% !8( ! #( '(#

(.35#!#% #( $58

#3 !

#3# %% *# 5#$!*#(% 2#8

#!3

#*% #

##* (#3# 3# .% 2#8

#* (#3#.(#$#( $

#*#!3

# '

5## '(# "

# *% #

# #* (#3#

3# (#$#(

#!#% 5 %

# , *#

##* (#3# 9 $# 83 !

$!# '$

#& !7 ( %3# #2 8$# #* (#3# 9 %( (#$#(

# !#

!3 ' 3#.

'# #

#3# '(#(

# 3!#( %

## $#2 3 3# + 3 3# 3 5# !#% #( $ ( 3*

35# (#(

#!#

##* (#3#5

3# 3'#!'

## $$#!

5# 5 #(. #*#!#' #%8

#33 #(.

( !#$#3 '

, 5! ,

#( ( 3 #

#'8 *#'

% #'#

#33 #(.

#!($2# 58

# !# 3%#!. '5 , ( '

25%8 3*#8

#33 #(

#$#!$# ! !

#3!

'#(

, '

#(58

'8'

#! 57#3

##* (#3#

# !

# 3 # 3!#( %

# #& !7 ( % 3# 3 5# 33#$ #( ( 3 5#

# 5 3*

# # 3!#( %

8 F + '

%!%8

!;!(

$6<5%#

#+ $!#'# !

%4 . *#

#%(

#!# 5% #! %#

#& !7 ( %3# 3#*#!

#5 3*

, !( !

%8#& !7 ( %3# %(5#3!!5! #(58'#

#!' #!

% "

!;!(

$ *# #%( (#!= > "

#!# 5% # ! %#

#& ! 7 ( % 3# 3#*#!5#

#5 3*

!( !

%8 #& ! 7 ( % 3# %( 5# 3!!5! #(58'#

#!' #!

%* (#"

''* "

+ #8!#9 :

. %27*"

#+ E ? 9 :

: + :. + *2 '! * + # 58 9$#3 !?% 3#9+ $! .+

* 1!'?8'

"#!* + # !

:+ :. ( J(* + #)# #,%9 : + 9

# $!## 3#.

# #& ! 7 ( % 3# 58 % 5##!##!!#(

#7 (,'#

#%#!#(, ! #(

#+$#3 %G (,#.(

5##3!!5! #(58

#!' #!

%!#3!( )#!#

#3# *% !8(

!# % ( 3#'# .

!# !$!'

#3 #'$% #(58 +#3

#@* (#3#3 F "

# $!#3

$!*#(

# 3# ,

# $$#%%

5#8(!#5%#( 5 "

#!# 33 !

#!#!#

#%%!##(7 (,'# (!(#!!#3!(#(58

#%#!#( !

% !

33!( ,%8.

#$$#% ( '

#( 7 *+ !' G (,#

7 "! ." !6 3 D3/ !$ D3/