High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1770/2011dismissed

Shehzad Alias Kanja v. State Of Haryana

2015-05-13Mr. Justice Satpal13 pages

#$!

% & "'

& "

&( ) *+ ,-./0 12)345

( +7+ (( - "

! "#$%! % &% $ (, "5 +189/ ):

( 6:

;/ / -

'( 1)

( +7+ (( - "

$ (, %+1 ) 1 )/ ):

( 6:

;/ / - ))) % &% *"

1+57)< (+1)+

12) 3 45 :

+7+ (( - ) "

=> 1):

+7+(( -+(1 -+

7( * 57)< ()( )0 ++ )9-(1 ))( ++ +%7)< /$? 6) 7< )57)< () ) /(1

(+1:

* :*( ))+ )( 7) < < 7+ + (

- + 9 +) + - /@ *1 ) 7(1 + ( (?

(1+) 7( 7+19

7) *( . )?(1 *( AB $C( 7) < < 7+ + ( - 7+19 7) *( .. )?(1 *( AB $) *( A=)+ ( 7) < < 7+ + ( +D (1+ (1 7+19

7) *( +.0./0> )?(1 *( AB $ $ ?+ + ( ( (1 +(( ( (&

1)D$E@ .>

) (1( %17/ 1)

(/ 1;

/ F9/ --79/ %:

)/ 1;7/

) 12)

( )* (+/?1 +) :<

)

+* (( ))* (-(1 (( + 75(/ 1+1(/ 4(;/ )1- $) +1 ) )1 $) +1 ) 1) +( (7*; * ( 1)

)<(1 + +7( ?1*1%17/ 1)/1;7/ 99/%+1 )) 7((1) )7

()1+9 (1 41 1) (?+9

( +*

?(1< ()*7(-(1 7<1+7+(<<7+1 ( 1+ <

1) )< )* ((1+ <)(1

+(( 97( (1 )?

(

))(1 -(1 ( )( ;(1

(

) ( .>(9 7(A (1((1 9 +)

7)9 +

1G+*17

1+ ( ?+* :

- )9-(1 (( (1

?(1 F7 +(( )(1 +) + +) +((1 ) :<(1+ ( /

(- *1 :< (9 7(

. (

)( (1 *17 ( F7 9 7((1

**7+ )E1 1 *1 ) (1 *17 /**7+ ) )7

1)* (1)1+ E1

(- *1

(/ %17/ +</

) 1) ) (1 <7 ) 7(-) +( 7

(- **7+ )+ (1 ?9*;+ )

)((*;7

(-?(1(1 +@+(*;+ - ?

D1 (<( ;(1 ($ )+1 (+(1 ) ** ) (1 *17 97( - **7+ )

) <?(11+<7(1 **7+ +*

) (1

(9-<)7<

+ 1 7+ +&7 ( </ (1

*+ ) - 7< < (1 :<

+7+( ) 57 + ) ( ( ?+ * ( ) 9- (1

**7+ )/?1 1)(1 ( ( -((*;

*+?1 -* ( +((1

/(17+/ - )(1( *( 9 (;

<+((1 (1 9++ (1++(( (/ # "

AA)( .>/D$EA@ ?+ <+( )7) *( +A=/AB/ ../.0./.)0> $)7) + *(($ ((

(1 :

+(<( ?+* 7("

7<1+( *

**7 ?+

) 7(-) +( .09 <?(1

*()< ?+ ) (1 )

( 1)?+ +( ) 12)?+ +( .> <?(1 1;

&+* +7 +(( (+D$@ )D$@.?

+7 )9-1)) 12)

*(:

-7(

+ )(1 # "/ 7A

+ -%17/ %:

)/ +<) --791:

(+*

+( )

( :

+(<( / *1@

( 7) *( .

$?++79(( )<+(:

+*7)<(1

(

(+ 7( :

**7+ )/ (1

(1 - 1;7/ F9)

) * * +

?+* )7*( )F7(1 (

(+ - 12)) 1)$ D )+-+B?( ++ +( 97(( ++ (+ *+ **7+ ) ?1 ) -< (1 *(< ( )

:) <+((1 7) *( ..$ ) )

)+ *(

/ :) ) ?+ ) )( 7( D<(1 :) )/ *(+)**7+(* + *+ *7) )(1((1 1)+7**

) :<(+*+ - ) + 9 ) 79(F7(1

(+ + F7 (-/ ( 7( 1+ * :*( ) (1 (1

+ 7+19 7) *( +A=/./../.0./0> ) ?(1 *( AB $ )+ + ( )9 << ) (1 (1 (

(+ 1:

) (1

+((

+ )* 7+ (1

(+:

(-<7 (1( (1 ( 7( 1+ < ++- ) * :*(< (1 **7+

+ (1+

9++ * 5 *(7 +)+7+ +

+() +(<7 ( )* 7+

(+ +(1((1 (1+ 1+ () ( ) ) ( +7

( (1 :

+ / * :*( (1

**7+ )+ (+7+(9 (+7(1 +79(( )(1(57 ++

*( )9-(1 : 7+

+ +7+

*(+

(+1:

)#7(1 + 57 ++1 ?

9*;

<)*(<<( 1:

) * < / ?1*1+ ((7 ?(1(1 *7:

( +() (*(

) ?+* )7*( ) /(* (9 +)(1() ((- (1 )?+ +(9+1 ): ? (1+ ( ) (-<(1 ) (++79(( )(1(: ? ( +?

+(1 57 )?( ++ + -$E 1/$E= / (+7

(<(1 *+ / ?+ (?(1 <+( +() $E/41 1)/9 (1 ( &

1)?++ ) * )1 +( +1 )) ( +7

((1

+ (+))( -<7 )(1(-*+

7+19 7) *( . $+) 7(+(1 ?+ ( ( ( ; (

+ )* 7+ (( ?1 7(<(1 9

+):

(+<7 +?(1 F7:

(1((1

19(7 +E1 <( ):()( )BA0 &

7(-7

( (/&+(*(%/#)9)/(++79(( )(1(

(1)+:

) (?

(-*+ +

1+9

)+*1< *F7(( )9 7(+

(( + <+( 7) *( +.B0/.B/.=/A/.B): 7+ (1 +

1+9

* :*( )(?

*+ +/ 7) *( .BB/A

$) (1 7) *( +./.A/.0./=>/A=/AB $ )0 + *(# 7 (1 *+ +

)<<+(1

*( ( (1

( H 12) 3 45/ ( + +79(( )(1(1 1)9

* :*( )*+ 7) *( .B

$) (1 (( 7) *( A> $+

)<<+( 1 (1 (( !(( $) +1 ( + +79(( ) (1( (1 +

?1 < ) +7* ( :) ) ( +1 ? (1

*(- (1 ) (1 ++

- ) 7 )<(1 :*( )+

(+/?1 +(( )( * ( *:2 )+ * (- 1:

1 ) )* 7+ ( +)<

(1 7<1(1 )?(1(1 9 +++(* $ 7+ (1 ) + (1( + - + +

57 )(1 *) (?1*1 **7 .> $E/ & "

;1/ )* * /

(/ $?/ )* <- D 9 +)

+) 7) ?<57 +

+, %+, - ./

- -.0 + 1 2/ - //2/ -/ ,1

8 ( ( +

*(.D.97() 797( 9+( )

?) +; *7 +1

(((

< +; ( 8* ( ) ?

7) . 79 &7( ?(1 1 7+ 95 *( ):+ )D- 8 (;

0*D0*9+ ?(11 7+ ) *(97( ):+ )D-9 * - 8"+ D$ (+

))+< )9- %+, - ./

- -.0 1 2/ - / 1 -/ ,1

"<1(7

@. 1:

A*D* ))+1 797+ ?(1)7+ +?

<)7( ?(1 7+) *(97()):+ )D- 8 (

+(+

*(()) 1:

*D* 9+ ?(1 ))+197+ &7( ?(11 7+ 7( *( ):+ )D- 9 * - 8"+D$?1*1+

)+< )9- %+, - ./

- -.0 0/ 32/-

/12/ -/ ,1

"<1( < ?

@.) ( -1:

0*D.* 97+ ))+1* 7?(1)7+ +?

<&7( ?(1 1 7+95 *(97()):+ )D- 9 * - 8"+D$&?1*1+

)+< )9- %+, - ./

- -.0 -/0 - /,1/ -/ ,1

<1(7

*1 +(9 ?*:*9 7(.*1*D 0* <1( )97()797(* ( )?

7) ?(1 9*;< ) ( ( ) ((

< ?(11 7+@ *( )):+ )D- )*( 57- *D** ( )97() 797( 9+(

?) +;( )((

<&7( ?(11 7+95 *( ):+ )D- . "<1( )-()) 1:

.D. **7 * ( ) ?

7) ?(1 97( ) 797(

?) +;)( )((

<&7( ?(11 7+)):+ )D- )-<1( 7

@.) 1:

.D. **7?(197()797(9+(*

?) )+; (((

<8* ( )?

7)&7( ?(11 7+ 95 *( ):+ )D- 0 "<1((( +

*( <1:

.D.**797( ) 797( +; 9*; ((

< &7( ?(1 7+ ):+ )D-95 *( ) (

(* (<+1() (;1;* 7 )?(1:

+ +)+< )9- ( * 9 * - 8"+D$

= %+, - ./

- - /%-/4 - / ,1

"<1(7

*1 +(.*19 ?)) *:*1:

.D.* ( )?(1( **7 (- 97()797(9+(*

?) (

< ( (

+- ?1

+- &7( ?(1 1 7+ 95 *( ):+ )D-9 * - 8"+ D$#/?1*1+

))+< )9- %+, - ./

- 1/2/- / 5 -/ ,1

8 ( ( +

*(1:

7( 97() 797(

?) +;*7+ (((

< (?1

**7* ( )?

7)9 7(.D.+2 &7( ?(11 7+95 *( )):+ )D - 8 (;

*D*97+ ))+1* 7?(1 )7+ +?

< ):+ ) D- ) ?(1 1 7+ 95 *(97(I$ +(1 *9 * - 8"?1*1 +

))+< )9- %+, - ./

- /1,2/.

/ -/ -/ ,1

"<1( )) ?

*1 +( 1:

. D . * ( ) ?

7) (- 97( ) 797(

?) 9+(*+;*7+ +(((

<?1*1+ (?1

&7( ?(11 7+95 *( )):+ )D - 8 ( (1:

.D.* ( (-97() 797( 9+(

?) +; ((

< ( ( ?1

&7( ?(11 7+ ):+ )D-

*( &"

;1/ )** /

(/$?1+

**-( +( )?1 +795 *( )( * ++ D( (1((1

57 +* 7) (9 *7+ (1 (19- + 7*1 +( ++ 1+ 9

) (1 *(7 (1

1) (+7

(<(1 :

7+ 1++(( ( +(1((1 *) (F7 +( 1+ (

) )9-1(1 7<1?1

<9 (1 ( 7(1

1+ - %17)

)1++(( )(1((1

(**7+ )1)) 12)?

( (((1 (

**7 -57 )?( ++ 1?1 ?+ ->@= - +((1 ( *) ()

>B9 (1 ( 7( (1(+1 ; ? (1<9 7((1+*+ (1 7<1+1 )(+ 1:< :

)57 +*) (?1*1(

; * 9 7( - +< 1 +(( )(1(+1 7) () (-(1 ++(+)7

( (1 * ?) (1 +

( ) 7(1 +(( ) (1( (1

(+)) (*7+ -57-( 1 ( - (1

$E/ 41 1)/ 9 (1 (1 * ( &

1)/)) (+7

((1 :

+ 9-)

?(11+9 (1 $E=/ /57 )?( ++)(( )(1(1 :

97 (57 + 1+*1 +( .>?1 <?+< < (?

)**7+

1 ?

/+(( )(1( 57 +?

)((1 1)+ +</

);

)(1(1 ?++1 ((9-(1

(1)

/(+( (* )(1((1 *?( ++ 1:

)7-+7

( :

+ ( +

*(+ $E/ :

47/ &$ 1+ )

) (1( .> 1

(*( )

)/ $ (( (-+?

+) $?/ (1/ + 7 7

+(<(1

**7+ ) # "

AA )( ) .> <+( ) ( $

(( (1

+( )+ +

*( (/$?

)(1(&

1)/ 1))41 1)( )(1((1

7)( (*17 <?(1

(-E1 - *1 ) (1

*17 / <1( (

+ (1

+*7)< (1

(+1)) 12)?

((1 *17 ) +(( )<(&

1)97(1 ?+ (17( ( /(1

(- ** :< *17 7

?1*1(1 + D1 ( +)((*;

(-?(1 +/

( (1 ?(1 +( + ) +(*;+ +(9 +19 / ")1/ 6 /5 / 91 -<1/ 1) :

)<7 +1 ( 57 + $ (- ) + ) (1 **7+ < )(

(**7+ )

/?1 ?+ +(

( <?(1.09

(1))7-) ( )9-1 7(+ )9-(1

(-?(19 ;((* 7(- ) ?

$ (

(+?

+79+ F7 (- +( )91 >

) ( )9 (1(1 )+1:< .> (1 1)9

+( ) (1 *+ 7) *( +.BB/A $)+ ) (1 (1 +) *+ $E./1(<1/?1 ?+

+( )+ @ $

((

)((1 :(( 1+)7-+7

( + 7+ $E0/

) +(9 ")1 <1 ?+

+( )+ +(9 ($ (( / (1 .>

1+ + <:

< 1*) ( (++(1 -7 ) )$E=/ +(9 6 <1/ ?1 1) :

) 57 + (1 +) *) (* ( -+7

( :

+ $E>/ +(9 +19 /?1 + :

)57 (1 *) (+?

+$EB/ 91 -<1/ 0. ( $?57 )?( ++1:

( :

+ * 7(+ $ 7+ ) +(1((1 *?( ++ 1:

)7- * ( ) (1 *7 :

+ )* :) ) + * + * ?(1 (1 *7 :

+ <:

9- (1

?( ++ +#*((1((1 () (1 :( ?( ++ -1:

: )7

9-(1

+* (9 < 7)( + (+) (1 :*(

(+ + (1<

)( +1 ?(1((1 *?( ++ +1)-D ( <) <+( (1 **7+ )

+ 1 ) - <7)< <+( (1 )(( )-/(1++*+ ?1 (1 + (1 )1) <7 ( (1 *) ( (+ (+(1 +

(+ ?

( )7* )(( +(< -:

-7*1<7 )((1 ( +(< (1 # "(+ <7 ((1((1 )?

+ ((< (+ <:

) (1 *+ +++* :

))* 7+ - (1(7 ( 1 )( +() (*( ) +(( (1 + *( )(1 *(+)**7+(* + (1+ *+ &+*

* + + + 7<1( ( 9 *( ) (1

+(( (+ + ?( ++ +

*(( +( (1

**7+ )((1 +

( -1)/ <)

+( ) 57+(

/+<7 ( (* -( *( )

( + (1 +

** *+ (1 (1( ( ?+

?1 ?+ +( +

( .>

(* ) :

) (1 +(( ( $E/ 1)( +7<< +((1(( ?+ **7+ ) 1)/ < )

?1 ?

+( ) * 7

7+ +(( ( +(1( 1)1+)

(1((1

(1( *1 +

( .>97((1 ( (7 )9*;9 *7+ (1

+1) )7

-/ * ( 9 1 (1

(+ (1( - (1 + ?+ *( ( *( ) (1

(+(1 (*+ /(1 /(1 -* (9 *( ?(1(1 F7 +( +7( 9 (1

*7*(+) **7+(* +

(1+9

)7- )9-(1 9++ * )* < ( :) (1((1

(+?

)

) ( < ?1*11) )7

(-)((*;

)?(1+( )(1 +?1*179

+*7)< 9 +

< 79*?

57 ) -1:

*(7- (* ( )(1

+)((*;$ 1++7**

) :<(+*+ - + 9 ) 79(F7(1

(+ ++*1< ) ((1++(< / )* 7+

(++79(+ (1((1 +

(++ D* ++:

)( +1 7)9 )7* )( (1( 1:< )-7) < ) < 7)?1(+

( ( (1 F7(7 +

(+ -1:

<1(-* :*( ))+

9-(1 )( 7(:) 7< )57)< () ) )( 0?1*1*+ ( + F7 (-/9 (1(1

+ )+++ ) * +

(H 12)1)

+7+

)9-(1+ 7(/1 %7)*<+(( /$?+ ) *( ) ( (;

( +(

+ (;< 1 *7+( )- :< +( + -& ",12

-./0 (+