High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1562/2015allowed

Tarsem Singh v. State Of Punjab

2019-02-08Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Anupinder Singh Grewal10 pages

!"" #

$%&"'()"&%"

**)) + & ,+-. * !"# $%&'( )*+,-( !.,/01! "!

$%&'( )*+,-($)2,$3( 0,$41 (5!'

, */)0! 0 (**)) & , & $"0" ")! 1)0,+-.

!.,/01! "!6 $(* **)"" " + '" (-+'%

0.2)&"3+'0 &'+0"&"$")

0"4("!(**)) $% &"'( )" &%"0 4( 4 !(' 4" ( " ( ! *+"(.)+&! "5

6,04!"! ! (+

5 6, 6%*"% )" *2" 07 6+) *2% "0 +'+ (6"8% (

6, "'+"%*"% (2 *2"

07 6+) *2% "0 +'+ (6 4% (

$(! (*!+ ""+ ())" ( !%*)" -4"&"'()' (!%*)" 098 ,0

0 (!

( (4" "))'( :)'4" (("% (:0 . (%"/&"'(4* " ((+ :"4"/(4!)"' (+ ")" (!+ 2 ((+ $(244 !("' )""" (% .+ 0$%&"'()"&%"&" &"'(!%."2!)!+)4" (("4"/( &(+( " ((+"'(.+)"% + (4!(.2 !!+$%&"'( :)!( ( ("' (!%% " :4!!+$%&"'(")"! "' (*''"!+) +) " +% +!+ "'.)4 ((/(4" (" " /"))( /(!))* : " **(!!+$%&"'(.+ ( ( ("% ")"! "-+2 !!+)42% (* )' 4" (4* :". (%"/&"'()!

( (* ".(" (%+4 ( .+ 5 % (') ! " /*)!. 4 ("%$%&"'(0+ 4("!($%&"'(")"! "-+" ( *("4"/( ;6098 ,7 04'" $(.24 * % % 8%" " $( .) " 4 ) ! 6 "' " 4 !%*) !()) 4 *+ +* !%*) ")) (!)%)" " $(*!+ "8%"+%.4" "+** (! $( % (!!+4)!+&! "5 , :" (! (*!+ " $(!!+4!"! !0 "!. :!0 (* **) < !+) **"' .() ( **)) (% )2'+ ( (*!+ "(") *" !

5 !+)**"' (& (% )2'+ ( (*!+ "( *" !.2.)+. +** (-+'% ()+ .)4 =(()!+) (* "' (+'( (-+'% !2!+))2 -4"&"'(* ( ()'4" ((". ( %"/&"'(% (:4* " ((+ !!+$% &"'(>&%" *" ("(+ :"4"/(4!)"' ( + ")" (!+ 2 !!+$%&"'(-+ "' ( !+ 2 ((+0 " !+)4" (("4" :4% 4" (&(" ()%!!+$%&"'(+( + %!+ 2((+ /() " ((+)4" %04("!(4" + " ("(+! () !!

+ ))4("4" ((+)4"%4" ( : 4!!+$%&"'(")"! "'.)4 ((("4" &( !))* : " ! !(()!!+$%&"'(0(40( ( ("% ")"! "-+2("*4" ($( 0!!+ $%&"'(!%+ ((+)4"% :!* ."2!) :" . ( %"/ &"'( ) ))4 ("% ( (+ )4"% :()4" (!!+! :"4"/(4 /.2 ( 4)""))')'4" ((" ( % :0 %'( $( !%*)" (" . ( %"/ &"'( 4 *!"' "% (*)"!4( (*)"!* 2% (% $," 0 (+4) +"'*" 04((" % 4!.2 (*)"!0 98 , 6 (" !

8%" "0 ( * ( ( !( -" :*" )0, ")0 .+ 5 , !

4" /( 4 % :0 %'(0 -" :*" )0 , ") (-4"("?4"")) /( ( (*" ) @ )4"% "" (

.+ 0(4* " ((+ :4/(4"-4"&"'( +"' ("(+ "'("!+ 2 :4!!+$% &"'(%4" ( :)!% (!+ 2 -4"&"'() ))4 (% !!+$%&"'( "'!+ 2("(+ ")"! .)44("!( +!/ (.!/"(( &(!))* (* $(2")% !!+$%&"'(+( 4 -4"&"'(4" ( $( 0(!* 6("!8%" "0 ( %" ( ( " !( !!+$% &"'( : " !!%*2/( :0%'( # ,=5 %** (

(4* 3+"" 0* % &+'20-":*" )0, ") : " "% ""*! (* "

, (*)"! %"/&"'(" (). (,= -4"&"'( : "" (

(4* "("(+ :". ( -4" &"'( % ( : 4 ) * /( 4" -4"&"'(4!)"' (+ ")" (!+ 2 ((+ .+ 0!!+$%&"'(!%."!2!) :*/ ( ."!2!)+ " ((+ : (""! *(2"!))2 +) "'/( &(" ()4 + " ((+ ((+)4"% $(2)))4 (% 6 ((+ )4"%0!!+$%&"'(' .)44" ( ( (/( &(!))* (* !!+$%&"'(42

% (* :" (6!((% //(4" ( (()* 4)" "))' ((*" ) :!!%*"-4"&"'( "% ( *)"! 6("!8%" "0(%" ( ( " (" (+4**8"% )2 @ # 4"

",)&"'(* ( ( 2'"' %""/(4%" ('" ((*" ) %'!2 @

''4) ( !+! ( * % % 8%" " (.2!/(4"-4" : "! ())4"'"-+" (*! ;""!"4+.!/(0.*

58 !%.!/) "( "!))2

!%) "( !%%" 4+

!%%") !%%" 4+ @8 !%) "("A ))2.)4" 4+ #8 !%"'( "(.!/.)"B+)2 :* (* % %8%" "* 098 ,: $(!+ ( 4("-+2 $("-+24 % %" ++"!" !+ (" ("2!+ + $"%. 4"-+2 ( 4+ .4" ("4(+. 4 (* % % 4" (""8(+ &61+)(&"'( "" ( ,= -4"&"'( ' (" % !"98 , :% (% 098 ,7

$( 0;6

098 ,7 04'" : !!%*" (!%*)" ,= -4"&"'((". (%"/ &"'( (* " "))'( &,1+% &"'()!( (* : /" *"% (* .) " ("

%))*) "!! " :! ( % (4" + &! "

, $(24 -":*" )0, ") :40 ( 420 (2 !" "% " ( /( 4 )2 $( "B+ * 4 ** $( .2 4 * % % 8%" " $(!!+4**(% (.+ ,) !( (!!+4!"+ :4 /+ % (*)"! )!/+*4" ' :%"!)+ % "98 ,C $( !!+' (.) "!% (."'!).2 ( "%./% !)%")"' "))'&) +'(/ !( ( 4** 6("!8%" "0(%" ( *+.)"4" (!%*)" 4!" +"' (!+ " ' " !!+ %/"!)+ % " ' ".+ ()(+7D(+0!!

+8*(" " %/"!)+ % $(*)!!24" + .2 ("*')"' (")!!".) *+.)" )' : " !)) ( !%*)" 2 ( "* 4" . ! "' (!2 (" ! (!!

:)."&"'()* ( 5

( !!+4" ' :%"!)+ % 098 ,C0 ( ."4("!(4!% (("*)! ;&<* "98 , $(8("." ! ""*!)EE EE4 "4" ((+%.) (+) '"'.)'+*4 "!!)+" $(*!+ """ ( (!!+( ( (+,= -4"&"'( : " !+)4" (("4" : 4%4" ( /(" ()+( 4 (

@ (+,= )4"%04("!(4" + " ("(+ ! () !!+!(( :'%+) "*).)4 (( /( /(!))* (* $(!!+42% (* ."!2!))'4" (4* $(4*" 4! (." ("!)+ % %.2 (!!+098 ,C !24 ! "!2%%098 ,F7 =(' (+'( (" *)098 ,< /EE" . (*)!4( (!4!)"'+ ")!+) / *)! /EE" (*)!%4(/(+( *" EE !(*" EE !"'*" EE ) " (4 )" %*" EG04("!(4 /" *)"!*" (+'(%%0 98 , " !. 4*" EEEE" (" *)" # " !. 4*" EE EE" # " !%EE EE" =" ( "

@ 6 " .)".) ( /(4+)+( ((+( "'(.+04(%%.(%")24* " ((+ &( !(%*" EE *" EE0 !"' ( * ( *!+ " $(" !. 4*" EE EE".+

&( (+)(+(""((+/4"'+))24)) ( (%")2 %%.4* (

# $(! (*!+ "") ( !+)( /*)! *" EE 6 *" EE0((" ()%0" 4+)( ! ( ",= -4"&"'(,= %"/&"'(( % (")4: &(!))*" ((+,= )4"% -4"&"'(,= %"/&"'(( /( ( (*" ) &(4 / ((*" ).2 4)"6!((% (

# ,= -4"&"'( $("" "! 4+)(. ()" /( $(2(+)( /( ((*" ) 6 (!%" ( % ,= -4" &"'( ( ( !(-" :*" )0 , ")0)2 5 , 04( (!!+! /*)! )4"%( (!!+'""'.)4 ((/(.+ " !(("% !!"' ("%0 (!!+( '")2.)4((04(* (",=

%"/&"'(0!!+$%&"'(' .)4(( : () !!%*"/( ((*" )

$(% " ".+ (!!+" ( .+ 5 % ( '!+) /*)!. 4,= -4"&"'(!!+$% &"'(0+ 4("!($%&"'(")"! "-+" /( 6!( 4."''+'.+ ( "!" 4" (,= -4"&"'(0("" ' 4+)(.,= -4"&"'( ("4"/( $( !2 ( . % ( ." "!)+ % %.2 (!!+098 ,C $(4* 4! " !2 %%0 98 ,F $( *)"! ( !" 2 "* 4" ( "%!2.) ",= &6 1+)( &"'( %" " (" !8%" " ( "* 4" (!%*)" 4!" +"' (!+" ' " ( 6 ()!

%" ( % ,= &61+)( &"'( ( *)!!24" + .2 ("*')"' (") 6 4!!".) ')*+.)" 6 ") .)".) ( (!!+4+) *" ( (+,= -4"&"'( ( /4"'+))24)) ( (%")2%%.4+).

$(!+! ,= -4"&"'(,= %"/&"'( 4+++) $(2(+)(* ! /(% (!)+ !( ( !!+ $(2(+)( /( ((*" )" '"' )' (* ,= )4"%(" ( //( ( (*" )0 ( !( ( !!+ ) !!%*" ,=

-4"&"'(,= %"/&"'( (*)"! " * (" "0(4)"4((4 / :0%'( $( 0 (4 -":*" )0, ")04((+!!+%. ( "-+" $(+'( (!!+4%4" (4*02 (2(+) ( !())' ( !!+ 6 ! +. ( *!+ " 2 $(0!"! " (." (""!0! .+ " $("<("*:E.) (&+*%+ "

555

&0(()+ H$(+ +)!+! -2, = 54("!((!% + "!% (!" ( (+'((4 * )'4" ( (! ( "%!!+!0 !( 0

@ 0 .+ # * % 0(% %* ("+!)% (+) :" ! "+ 2 (0 (+'(!+!!"' ("%0((")"."'".2(" +!) :4 +) (+'(. ((("+!) 4 +% 9 " ( 4 '' " +) "' (!0")04(4)))')2 %" (% %* +) -2, = 5 !(("% , = 5-2" ("%))' (; 6 G $("<("*:E.) (&+*%+ "

&0( ()+

I6 )** + ( (.("+, = 04" (!04 +)" ( ( ( %)2 .2"'4 (!(+. 4(4. ("'(") &(" 2 +("% ("%2 (()*4("!(4+)((4( *! ( "% ( ( (! ( " ("!" G 6"4 (""!+"!0 (*!+ " (") * (!'" (**)) .2.)+. !!"')20 (**)"))4 $(-+'% #

0 " $(**)) "!B+" )) (!(' %'" ("% :.) (4" (0" B+""2 ( ! -"&(% 3+' #

+*"&"'(14) 3+' =( (*/"'7 J7 =( (* .) J7