High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/402/2020disposed of

Vikram Bedi v. Gurmeet Singh And ANR

2020-08-25Mr. Justice Manoj Bajaj4 pages

!"#"$%$%&'"(!)*#("+"((",$!"("-%*%&'#"$%$%&'.!)//"'0%'0 $!"##"//)$" &1($21,03"'$,)$",4 5#)**",67$!"/")('",,,/

"**%&'*1,0")8%/9):!"("67$!"21,03"'$&+.&'-%.$%&')',&(,"(&+ *"'$"'." ,)$", ; #)**", 67 $!" $(%)/ &1($ *"'$"'.%'0 $!"

#"$%$%&'"( $& 1',"(0& %0&(&1* 3#(%*&'3"'$ +&( 7")( )', $& #)7 .&3#"'*)$%&'&+ * ;<$&$!".&3#/)%')'$:)*1#!"/, !"#(&*".1$%&' .)*")(%*"*+(&3).&3#/)%'$ %'*$%$1$",67 1(3""$%'0!$&$!""++".$$!)$&'= > $!"#"$%$%&'"($&&9+(%"',/7 /&)'&+ * <+(&3!%3)',%'&(,"($&("$1('$!"*)%,)3&1'$%**1", ).!"?1"& ,)$", ;

,():'&')'9&+',%))$"!)6), @ !)',%0)(!A()'.!)$"!)6),$&$!".&3#/)%')'$ ';

$!"*)%, .!"?1":)*#("*"'$",67$!".&3#/)%')'$+&("'.)*!3"'$61$$!"*)3"0&$ ,%*!&'&(", )', ("$1('", 1'#)%, $& $!" .&3#/)%')'$ -%," 3"3& ,)$", ;

:%$!("3)(9*B'*1++%.%"'$1',*C !")..1*",:)*)##(%*",&+

$!"3)$$"(61$!",%,'&$#)7)'7!"", !"(")+$"()/"0)/'&$%.",)$", 4 :)*%**1",$&$!")..1*",$&#)7$!".!"?1")3&1'$61$$!" #"$%$%&'"(,%,'&$("$1('$!"*)%,)3&1'$ !"("+&("+""/%'0)00(%"-",$!"

#("*"'$.&3#/)%'$:)*+%/",

)9%'0.&0'%8)'."&+$!".&3#/)%'$$!"$(%)/ &1($*133&'", $!")..1*",$&+)."$(%)/1',"(".$%&'D=&+$!""0&$%)6/"'*$(13"'$* .$==@+&(*!&($E$!".$EA$&:!%.!!"#/"),",'&$01%/$7)',./)%3", $(%)/

!" $(%)/ &1($ )+$"( "F)3%'%'0 $!" 3)$"(%)/ &' (".&(, #(&."",",$&!&/,$!")..1*",01%/$7&+$!"&++"'."1',"(".$%&'D=&+$!" "0&$%)6/"'*$(13"'$*.$==)',%3#&*",$!"*"'$"'.")*'&$%.", )6&-"

%**)$%*+%", :%$! $!" 21,03"'$ &+ .&'-%.$%&' )', &(,"( &+ *"'$"'.",)$", ;#)**",671,%.%)/ )0%*$()$"*$ /)**)8%/9) )')##")/:)*.)((%",67$!".&'-%.$6")(%'0##")/& 4;,)$", =

!")##"//)$" &1($:!%/"!&/,%'0$!)$$!".&3#/)%')'$!)*#(&-",!%*.)*" 6"7&',(")*&')6/",&16$,%*3%**",$!")##")/+%/",67$!"#"$%$%&'"(

"'."$!"#("*"'$("-%*%&'#"$%$%&'

")('", .&1'*"/ )##")(%'0 &' 6"!)/+ &+$!"#"$%$%&'"( :)* !")(,)',)+$"()(01%'0+&(*&3"$%3"!",%,'&$#("**!%*.!)//"'0"$&$!" .&'-%.$%&'#)($%'$!"%3#10'", 21,03"'$)', .&'+%'",!%*#()7"(+&( (",1.$%&'&+*"'$"'.")/&'"

")('",.&1'*"/+&($!"#"$%$%&'"(.&'$"',*$!)$$!"#"$%$%&'"(%* +%(*$&++"',"()','"%$!"($!"("%*)'7.)*"#"',%'0)0)%'*$!%3'&(!":)*

D #("-%&1*/7.&'-%.$",%')'7&$!"(.)*"

$%*.&'$"',",$!)$)/"'%"'$-%":

3)76"$)9"')0)%'*$$!"#"$%$%&'"()*!"!)*)/("),71',"(0&'"3&("$!)'= 3&'$!*&1$&+$!"$&$)/):)(,",*"'$"'."&+7")($!"("+&("!"6"("/")*", &'#(&6)$%&'&(%'$!")/$"(')$%-"!%**"'$"'."3)76"(",1.",$&$!"#"(%&, )/("),71',"(0&'"67!%3

")('", .&1'*"/ +&( $!" $)$" !)* ("+"((", $& $!" .1*$&,7 ."($%+%.)$" ,)$", 4 +%/", 67 ?6)/ %'0! ()( "#1$7 1#"(%'$"',"'$ "'$()/)%/"(&8"#1($&.&'$"',$!)$$!"#"$%$%&'"(!)* 1',"(0&'")#"(%&,&+=3&'$!*)',4,)7*&1$&+$!"$&$)/*"'$"'."&+ 7")( #1(*1)'$ $& $!" %3#10'", 21,03"'$ &+ .&'-%.$%&' )', &(,"( &+ *"'$"'."

$%*'&$,%*#1$",$!)$$!"("%*'&&$!"(.)*")0)%'*$$!"#"$%$%&'"(

+$"(!")(%'0/")('",.&1'*"/+&($!"#)($%"* $!%* &1($+""/* $!)$*%'."$!"%'.%,"'$#"($)%'*$&$!"7")(;)',$!"#"$%$%&'"(%*+).%'0 $!")0&'7&+$(%)/)',)##")/+&($!"/)*$3&("$!)'G7")(*)',%*%' .1*$&,7+&($!"/)*$)/3&*$53&'$!*&1$&+$!"$&$)/*"'$"'."&+7")( $!"("+&("$!""',*&+21*$%.":&1/,6"3"$%+$!"*"'$"'."&+$!"#"$%$%&'"(%* (",1.",$&$!"#"(%&,)/("),71',"(0&'"67!%3

"*1/$)'$/7:!%/"3)%'$)%'%'0$!".&'-%.$%&'&+$!"#"$%$%&'"( )*):)(,",67$!"$(%)/ &1($)',)++%(3",67$!")##"//)$" &1($$!"

*"'$"'." &+ 7")((%0&(&1* %3#(%*&'3"'$ ):)(,", $& $!" #"$%$%&'"( %* 3&,%+%",)',(",1.",$&$!"&'")/("),71',"(0&'"67!%3 &:"-"($!"

.&3#"'*)$%&')*):)(,",67$!"$(%)/ &1($)',1#!"/,67$!")##"//)$"

&1($*!)//("3)%'%'$).$

4 !"#"$%$%&'"(%*%'.1*$&,7 "6"$*"$)$/%6"($7+&($!:%$!%+ !%*.1*$&,7%*'&$("?1%(",%'.&''".$%&':%$!)'7&$!"(.)*"

"-%*%&'#"$%$%&'%*,%*#&*",&++ 101*$

1/)$%

H!"$!"( "#&($)6/"

"*<& H!"$!"(#")9%'0< ")*&'", "*<&