Kashmir Singh Etc. v. State Of Pb.
!"# # ''"
("
) *+ "& )" '
, '' - !"# '&.
+& /$"# 0.'1 &2 '' - *
'
&# 01 ) *+ 33333 $'.
"& "
"1
".
4" / # 5#$ & 42"$%$% $ 46
)'$ $ # '%
$%1 %$% 7&"
& !# &
''$%8 7# .
#& "% &$ +$&% 7$#$ 2 '$ $"
2$''% & !# &1
!"# *
7 "& "$$% 2 +% #2$%
"8 "$% .1 +#
$& "'$ 7.1 #721
!"# #&& .
7#"
#
'.
*
%& "
8 $&& 7$""
)9 4& *$& .
4 $ &
!"# " & % .
+% #$"
""""$
$ " $
7& "
$%# % "
&
& " " 0;& $ %$"1
!"# & % "
&
& " 0;& $ 8 4 &
%&8 #1 '"#& 7$'""
""% "
''
0;& $ "8
&$%'.1 # *$ $%#1 )1 & '%#1 0;& )'$ $ $2& " " $ 8 # *$ &$"
'"& #$"
$&$.
!"# ''$% #$
$%# % "
$& + #$
" # 0;& $ %$"8
!"# $%#1 #72 "& $# "$& )8
"
%& &8 # $"
$"
# *$ $%#1 )1 4 " #& +% """"$
&
$ .
"<8 4 < 7 '"
%
+%
$$% .
"< +$% 7$%#&1 "$& .
"< % .
+%
= <%
% 7 '"
% .
+%
$$% "$& .
"< 7
2& $ '"
"'& 4 #$"
"'
#2$% $"
$$ >/>8 & " "'
""$
#$1 #
.
'% " "'
#$ 7 < $ """"$1 2$& 2.
8 "'
" #&& 2 )9 4& $%#8 !"#
"&
'"
"".
&
"
%& 7 &
4 " , "$ +"$"
7#$ ?4 && / # $%#8 4 & %# "$ ' ' 2.1 && " "
7$"""8 "$1 4 <
.
"
"&.
7#"
!"#
' < @ &.
2.1 4 &
& &
& !"#
'%
.
+ 4'', %$"1 7# ""& "".
&"8 "$ "#% " &$ $'
'<#1 4 <
.
#$"
7
"&.
A
' '
+"$&"
" "'
""$
#$ ?
-
= 7 " ?"$
$ B+.1 ) *+1 #&$%# # %# "+' <#'
7# &"$&
"$1 #&& 2 $ $""
& B+.
48 +", '.1 $2&
?B1 #&$%# '."$"1 ' & .
"<8
*
"&
8
'$ $2"$%$ # '$$"1
#'' %$"
& $'& "$
#'' &%1 $'
1 "1
$"
&
"
'$&
#$ 7 '$&
""
2$&&
&
) 1 # $&$% $ $
"1
#%
&
- $
%"
)".
#$
+" "
1 =
"# ># > & %$"
"&1 7#$ #.
'&& % $'.
'$ & $'
$%
"
2$& 1
@ $&
7$"""
$ )9 4 $%#1 )9
"+' <#'
$%#1 )9 # *$ $%#1 )1 )9A 4" / # "$ $&1 )9
4 *$+
'$&
2$ &
"
'
&$%
?B E@ )FG #1
2$& %
'
&& "
7 &&
& ) 1 7#$ ''
$ $$%
" "
$%
2$& %$"
7
+ #.
&$& ''%$"
&$% #.
7 $ '"'.
'$ &
&$& '& 2$& & #$% %
"1 $'
2$& &% &&
D
2$ & +#
7#$ #.
7 +<& 2$& & 2 &1 " &
&% $% $"
."
.
$ "
G #8 & ' .
$1
&% # 4
#"
?'$% %%$2& &% #$
2$ & " 1 +#
$'& " '1 $ 7#$ %$2 1 7#$ '
<
D
7# $
$ $""
&1 2$& & && H
'
& $& % ' #$% '$ $
& = ) 1 #2$% $'& +# ''"G
"&1
& $$% " ''"
"&& & $% & .
'
#.
7 && '"& +$'
+* #$ $"#$% , $"$ +&"
"$" #$ &$ $'
%$"1 " "
1 '' - !"# @$&1 #1 2$& & &&
+"2& '
, #$
"& +& $ +"2& '' -
*
.$% '% &$%"
"$%
""$ ""$ " % +$'
#$
""$ 7$#&71 2$& & &&
#"
"$ "&
-7 '
#"
$'
#$% #2 #& '&
"'
''"G
"&1 '&
"'
+"$&"
%$% # %# & B&
"'
'' *
#"
&&
".1 *
7.
" $&$$& / #%7 ""1 #72 $# @ $&
$&$$ $ & %& G$2"$%$% % .
$ *
<7 # )9"
'$1 $&$.
*
"+'$"#&
$ $'
'$+$'$.
"'&
#$
9#"1 '&
"'
#"
&& $&$.
*
''.
"+'$"#& "$ *
2$ "'.
<7 / #%7 ""
7# *
7.
"$% .1
#"& / #%7 ""
"+' "# !
1 # %# *
%& "
+ # 7#
/ #%7 ""
"+' "# !
&1 / #%7 ""
'& " 7#
7.
*
" C%$ "$& & !'1 #1 & +
'& %& $&$.
*
#$% $2'
$"1 & $&
."' % '&
"'
''"
4 , $"'1
*
'% #$"
% #$"
"$&$'
&&""
$& #
$& '$ <7 / #%7 ""1 7# &$"
'"& $&$.
*
4 +$% "1 & + ' %& $&$.
&$& @ $ / #%7 ""
& $%
" $"
2$& &"
& + %& $&$.
*
I&
" "1 #'&$% $&$$ $ & $2"$%$% % .
&"
#2 = # %
7&
'&
"'
'' ".
*
$% 7.
++' "$ "2'
$ $'"
+$% #1 7 '& #2 +' "
%$ $& '$'
$ %
"
".1 "$% .1 *
7.1 # %#1
#"&
/ #%7 ""
"+' "# !
+
%& "
:# #$%
'
!$% 2$7 %''.
'7 "&& #."$ '
$""
$ $'"
) *+
.
#2$% %& #."$,
.
%& 7#$
$%# #2
%&"
$ $'"
#"$% #$
E 2.
$ $'
.
#2$% && #."$ '
$""
$.
" :#1
*
%& "
"$% .
&"
< ".
++'
# %
&2 & '&
"'
''
.
'<# $"& &$ $'
'<#1 #1
'& ""$+$'$.
$% 4 /721
$ '"
2$ $% 4 #"
&
$.
" &$ $'
'<# "1
.
' &
'<#8 &"
%$2 $" "$ $ %& 4 #2$% &
.1 "$
#"
+ %# $ $ '$< 2$& '
7''
&
.
"#7
.
$& "
"&.
$% "'"
< ' & $% $& $&
"&.
$ $'"
#& ?B1 ) *+1 #&$%#1 # %# "+' <#'
$ # '
E@ $ E@ )FG '" %"
"#7 ' '
#& "'"
$ #
$ '&
"'
''"
4& $%#1 $&& 7$""
"$& #2 *$& .
@ $&1 $% , "$
< 2
&$+$'$.
".
:#$"
$ '" 7$# '
$ :# #$% & "#7 7$"""
2.
'.
)9A 4" / # $%#1 )9 4 $%#1 )9
4 *$+ )9 # *$ $%#1 ) 2$ $.
& 7#$ #.
$%# #2 $2'2&
'"'.
&"& %$" #$
"
#$"
2$ ''
&"& '
2$ $%
%$2
$"$
$& '7 7''
"'& " "
$ $'
7$"""
$&& 7$"""
'""
7$"""
#2
$2 '" '$ $
7#$
&
B&
"'
''"
& 2$ &% "
#$"
$"
$
! "#$# %%&'(") 1
A $ $'
*"+, %
$# %%&'(
,-1
A $ $' A1 " +."$# %%&'(
,-1
$ $' DA1 %
$#%%&'(
,-1
$ $' %%&'(
,-$#/0"
) !$#%%&'(") 1
$ $' 1 '
$#%%&'(
,-1
A $ $'
"+- "$#%%&'(") 1
A $ $'
#" '$ +' & &$ "1
" "
@ 7#$
+"2$"
#2
& '%'
"$$ 2.
' $"
1
$#%%&'(
,-1
A '
$2$"$ 7#$' &'$% 2 '$.
7#
2.
+&1 $&& 7$""
*$& .
& $% " 2.
+ @ $&
7$""1 # & & 7$""
&.$% #$"
#2$% *$& 7$""
" 2.1 # "$% #$"
"$% "
7
& +'< "
7# 2$"$& "$ & <&
&$$ 4 #'&
+'$2&
"$% "
2$ "
#2$% &$ 7$$%
$'
'& "$%& 7$""
+'< "
7# 2.
+& #7$" "& 2&
"$" '$+' "$ $"
4 ) 7# 7 " "1 & 7$""
#'&
'$+' 7#" "$ .
$%#'.
&$"
&& 4 2.
&% 1 +"2& 7# ''%$ $.
%$" $ $'"
'"'.
'$ ''"1 #
'
"$ &7 $'
@ $$ $&& 7$""
" 2.
7# 7 2
&$& $" & +
4 2.
&% 1 &'.
"&$% ' $ # '
E@ $ &$"
""& #'&$%
2$
2$$&
A ?
# 1 $%' &% &%
*"
# * +"$#%%&'(
,-2345627 6"/78381 #"
+"2& "$ $"
$ $'
7$"""
.
2$&$.
2'
# 7$""
#$ " "
&$"
&& "$ '.
#$ $ $'
&"$%$ 4 # +"2& "+'$"#& '' """"$
+&1 #$
"#7
"
$ """"$ #1 "$
"
'%'
$ "
"
" """"$ $''$ $ ' #"
$& 1
$'"
""""$ 4 # +"2& """"$
'
" """"$ "+'$"#&1
"
&
#"
'+'
'
" #"
$& .
7 '7 7''
"'&
'$"
"'
" '.
%&1
& &% %%&'( +1 / "!&# $# 9 * +"1
$ $'
?
# &% * &%
$#
'
'( !
1
$ $' DD @ 1 +"2& 2 $ " & '
$''%'$.
&
$% " "$;
1 2$&
'' & #+.
7$''
$& $""$+' 7 '&
"$& ''
" "
$& 7## "$ * &$
4 # +"2& $ " "$;
' &$
'7 & ""$+$'$.
2$&
'' & '$<'.
#2 & $'& & $%
"
" "$;
1 #1
'& "$& 2$& '$+' & $""$+' 2$& 4 "
"1 &$"
""& &$'
+21
'% #$"
!"# #2$% & """"$
+& "&"
"+'$"#& &1 "$ *
$%# #"
$'&
#$"
""""$1 &7$% "
$
& $"
1 <
"
$ """"$
+& -
&.
2$"$ '7 "#7 #2 2$'&
:#1
"$& " "$;
' &$ '7 & ""$+$'$.
2$&
'' & '$<'.
#2 & $'& & $%
"
" "$;
H %& &%
2$ ""& $'
, $ &$'&1 7''
"&1 +"&
$"'
2$&
$$ '7 :# $''%'$.
$$ $.
#7$#1 7#$
$%# #2
''& $ 7#$' @ $"$% '' $"&$ $1 %&"
" 1
$'& & "+' ' "$+' @'$ #$"
''%& '" '$ $
/
'&
#$"
""""$
+& , "$ 7$# '$ " :#1 <
"
$ """"$
+& $
$.
+$ $& '%& & % &&'$%
$% '$2"
#'# 2$ ""
$"< 2$&$% ".
'.
& %"
'$ .
"#7 #$
" & " &"
''
$ '"
#'& '
& 7$#
$ #+.
&$"
$""& '' *
$%#1 7#
"&.
&
&% $$% " $" +"$&"
.$% $
.
$1
&% $" & ' &% ""& $'
!"
# %&"
#